Press "Enter" to skip to content

#ManReBranded: Why modern masculinity is fundamentally flawed. | Rob Mitchell-James | TEDxNantwich


[Applause]
if today were an average day in the UK
thirteen men will kill themselves that’s
probably to people while you’re Sahara
this Tet event the harsh reality is that
modern day man is fundamentally flawed
and there’s not one person in this room
who isn’t directly affected by him so
just imagine for one moment if we could
take what man and masculinity represents
in its current format and rebrand it
completely would we make him think and
behave any differently would we change
anything at all well we need to because
it’s all just a little bit outdated
and it’s having a huge impact the
current perception of man and
masculinity has been developed through
sustained periods of hard labor of
conflict and industrialization and even
modern-day capitalism has had an impact
by encouraging and fueling our natural
competitive tendencies and so for years
through decades of gender stereotyping
man has learned to develop a thick skin
and build his walls and become stoic man
who never breaks down now stoicism is
defined as the endurance of pain and
hardship but without the display of
feelings or complaint it’s how we’ve
been conditioned for years and we still
live with that same mindset even now how
many times have you heard the phrase man
up or the more anatomically targeted
version of grow some balls but just
think about the impact that that has on
men on their relationships on their
professional development on their
children on you
this shallow emotionally disconnected
approach to masculinity is so outdated
and out of touch with the demands of
modern society and it affects every
single one of us up until 2016 I was
that guy who had absolutely perfected
the art of Manning up because that’s
what I believed was expected of me I was
working as a TV producer at the time and
so I had all the usual pressures of
budgets and deadlines and I experienced
stress on a daily basis so I developed
and perfectly honed the ability to
withdraw into myself to cut myself off
as a means of dealing with it and I
completely mastered the art of using
silence as a coping mechanism because I
thought that’s just the easiest way to
deal with stuff and sometimes I’ll be
gone for days not physically because I
was still there in the room but
emotionally I was completely detached to
what was happening right before my own
eyes and what was happening was I’d
started to fail I was so focused on
being that self-sufficient hero the
provider the hunter the protector the
stoic that I’d lost sight of all the
important things in life
I was conforming to expectations and as
a consequence all my work suffered my
relationship suffered and my health
suffered at 3:00 a.m. one morning as I
laid in my bed drenched in a cold sweat
and physically shivering from the breeze
that was coming in through the open
window and my heart rate going through
the roof I learned my lesson and I
learned that being that self-sufficient
here
isn’t in the slightest bit heroic at all
on the contrary stoicism the stiff
upper-lip the thousand-yard stare all of
those traditional masculine traits that
we used to define man are in fact the
fastest route to depression and
isolation and loneliness Newton’s third
law states that every action has an
equal and opposite reaction which
suggests that if we refuse to deal with
our pain and our hardship head arm it
will have an impact they might not be
immediate but it will happen and it hit
me really hard so on that morning in
2016 I slipped into the longest and most
crippling period of depression I’d ever
experienced now the first time I had
depression I didn’t have a clue what was
going on I had no energy and I was
confused and even the simplest of
decisions
I couldn’t make and It was as if all of
those vibrant sights and sounds and
colors and emotions that we experience
in a non depressive state just
completely drained away and at the time
I hid it because that’s what we do the
second time I had depression I was
looking because I understood and I
learned to not hide it you see
traditionally man has placed rational
goals ahead of his own emotional
development we conform to expectations
and so we embrace competition and we
seek out performance and profits and
efficiencies and results and while we’re
doing that because of the way that we’re
conditioned to think we are less focused
on those areas that develop our own
emotional intelligence it’s a
fundamental flaw of masculinity
and it drives what I call hollow success
hollow success is a material wealth and
it’s really short-lived and it’s
meaningless and hollow success is the
perfect contradiction because we can all
appear successful to the outside world
but how emotionally rich are we really
and how low success is a false castle
that we’re all living in and it’s built
on really flimsy foundations and all it
takes is a little breeze to come through
the window for all to come falling down
and here’s the evidence the biggest
killer of men under the age of 50 isn’t
cancer or smoking or road accidents or
alcohol
it’s themselves tragically suicide is
the biggest killer of men under 50 and
here’s something else for you to think
about why is it that when the gender
population split is give or take 50/50
male to female that 70% of the homeless
are men 96% of the prison population are
men and 76% of all suicides are men well
there are several contributing factors
but the biggest killer here literally is
cognitive conditioning and the way that
we are brought up that’s the biggest
killer here everything from what we
think to what we say to what we do to
our emotional responses to these are
repeating patterns of behavior based
upon the way that we’ve been conditioned
and it stems right back to early
childhood from a very early age girls
are conditioned to be caring and
sensitive and emotionally aware and that
grows right through into adulthood
but boys are conditioned down a
different route and you only need to
browse a toy store or a bookshelf to see
it and the differences are really stark
from pastel colored unicorns and
rainbows one moment to aggressive
weaponry and camouflage in masks next
all in the blink of an eye and yet we’re
all human what starting to see a shift
now in the way that females are
represented away from the traditional
Disney Princess to a much stronger more
independent character and that is
brilliant to see but I was seeing an
equivalent shift in the way that men are
represented absolutely not
man always has been and still is the
aggressor the stoic the mask wearer and
it’s always his problem to solve and his
problem alone for example when was the
last time you saw a guy stop and ask
someone for directions because I
guarantee that if you do see it he won’t
be listening to the answers because
despite having had the balls to ask
he’ll still be in his own head trying to
find his own solution so if we apply
that back to the statistics the
percentages are as they are because
women are conditioned to seek help and
support a men are conditioned not to
because it’s still seen as an admission
of weakness
up until that morning in 2016 I was
conditioned to think and act and behave
in a way that was expected of me and
I’ve continued to do that even though I
knew deep down in my core that what I
was doing wasn’t right for me and I
continue to do it right the way through
to the moment I realized it was having a
negative impact on my own health now I
didn’t want to become one of those
statistics that I just gave you so I
decided to make some changes I walked
out of what was
the best paid job that I ever had
without having a thing to go to and most
people put me on a scale somewhere
between boldness and absolute madness
admittedly most people slotted me on to
the madness end of the scale but I did
three things I reviewed I’ve refrained
and I rebranded I worked out what it was
that I wanted to be as opposed to what
it was I’d been conditioned to become
and I learn new skills and I
systematically said about making it
happen and so now I don’t drive the same
route to work every day and sit in the
same office with the same people doing
the same stuff now I’m a successful film
and TV actor I’m a public speaker and
I’m a coach so no matter how far away we
are from where we want to be change is
absolutely possible firstly by being
aware that we can be different and
secondly by having the confidence and
the courage and the commitment to change
to change our perspectives on man and
masculinity we need to face up to
traditional man and we need to sit him
down and question him and we need to
question his authority his choices his
decisions his wisdom or lack of and we
need to show him a compelling vision for
how his future can be as opposed to
basing it on outdated versions of his
own past and he’ll argue and you’ll no
doubt tell us that were mad and it’ll
absolutely tell us to man up that’s to
be expected but we shouldn’t be fearful
of that on the contrary we should
embrace it because if we’re rebranding
what we mean by a man and masculinity
surely by definition we’re also changing
what it means to man up and that is
where we need to start
because we live in an era of broken
families of absent or surrogate fathers
and where are the decent role models
that our children can look up to and
respect and admire for the right reasons
not because they earn millions from
kicking a ball or because they’ve run
some talent show but because they
exhibit the real values of emotional
intelligence and self-awareness and
compassion and because they are aware of
their own vulnerabilities and they have
the courage to deal with them so the
next time you’re told to man up I’ve
encouraged you really strongly to pause
and to really think about your responses
to that will you fall back into your old
conditioned behaviors and do what you’ve
always done or will you really man up
stand up and open up
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: