Press "Enter" to skip to content

Let’s get hyper | George Mellick | TEDxYouth@BGS


well good morning everyone it’s really
exciting to be here this morning now my
name is Jorge and I am a neuroscientist
and I’ve spent the last 20 years of my
life studying an enigmatic disease at
the brain known as Parkinson’s disease
I’ll tell you a little bit more about
that later but as a scientist I’m
engaged in thinking about complex
problems and in training next generation
of scientists to do just the same and
it’s from this that I got the idea for
my talk today we must get high five what
do I mean you may have heard of the
terms multidisciplinary learning or even
interdisciplinary learning in order to
solve a problem well my idea is that we
need a new way of learning which I call
hyper disciplinary learning this
reconciles the explosion of data that
exists in our current age with the idea
that we still need a very broad and
comprehensive knowledge base to give us
the scope for innovative solutions to
complex problems let me explain a little
more
we humans are unique this is because we
have a capacity for abstract thought and
ability to analyze past events this
enables us to set and test scenarios and
to think about what might happen in the
future as a result of our actions no
other animal on earth does this we’re
also unique and that humans have an urge
in fact it’s even a evolutionary
compulsion to network with other humans
to join our collective minds together in
order to share our human experiences now
this has allowed us to develop society
and culture and to build a corpus of
knowledge even allowing us to redirect
the course of nature the extended human
life the human lifespan and it’s enabled
us to exploit the world’s resources for
around own purposes
but there’s a downside to this human
uniqueness humans are the only animals
other than our closest living relatives
the chimpanzees that will work together
in order to kill other members of our
own species and say this is a terrible
thing and it’s also true that while we
can exploit the
resources for alone ends we also have
the capacity to destroy everything
that’s near and dear to us consider the
number of extinctions that are result of
human activity and it’s an interesting
irony that our successes of species has
also led us to many of the complex
challenges we face in the 21st century
consider the expansion of human
populations which has led to a
limitation in resources human induced
climate change and the aging of our
population we just seen the emergence of
new diseases like dementia and
parkinsonism becoming prominent many
cancers and also complex health mental
health conditions like depression all
really important first world problems
well my idea contends that these sort of
complex issues requires us to have
collective thought and in order to do
this better we need to move away from
single single individual ways of looking
at things into more collective ways of
looking at things we need to pursue the
intersection of ideas using my concept
of hyper disciplinary learning now the
idea of bringing a whole heap of
information together to Network new
knowledge it’s not a new thing
in fact in third century China the way
dynasty emperor chap I actually did this
when he commissioned his chief Confucian
scholar and I call Manchu to go out and
get a book of all the knowledge that
existed at the time from all the way no
texts and philosophical works to tell a
single anthology this is called the
Huang Lang or Imperial Mirror contained
over a thousand different chapters from
40 different sections and the Roman
world also had its ability network
information plenty the elders Naturalis
historia is an example this is a
compilation of facts about Roman life
when over 2,000 authors all put together
in the single book and other
civilizations had similar compendium but
most of these works were works at a
single person bringing information
together a huge undertaking consider
John Harris’s Universal English
dictionary of Arts and Sciences public
first in 1704 this was a compilation of
all aspects of art science and
technology nice and neatly listed in
alphabetical order for ease of reference
and historically it was important for
scholars to be proficient at all of the
liberal arts and sciences but as we’re
all aware the explosion of information
in recent times has made this very
difficult in fact how much information
exists we’ve already heard the last
speaker talking about this but when
google corporation in 20th 2010 decided
that they wanted to digitize every known
publication that ever existed every name
bought a estimated that the number of
book-like objects was in the order of a
hundred and thirty million books and
from 2010 to 2015
there was an addition in excess of five
million more book like objects published
a massive amount of information and this
is just the old-fashioned book these
days our information in our knowledge is
not published in all fashion books the
put this into perspective Cisco Systems
estimated that across the internet in
2016 the amount of data that was
transmitted was in excess of 1.2
zettabyte
and that seven orders of magnitude than
the amount of information if all
published books ever existed in him to
to humans but it’s important to
recognize as we’ve been reminded by
Clifford Stoll but data is not
information information is not knowledge
knowledge is not understanding and
importantly understanding is not wisdom
so how might we best bring these
zettabytes of data together to build our
collective understanding it perhaps even
our wisdom to solve the complex problems
we face in the 21st century
well I contend that to do this we need a
realignment in the way we train a next
generation of scientists we need to move
away from single disciplinary
specialties and culturally restricted
scientific and technological subject
areas and move towards more holistic
models of thinking and synthesizing
information
this is the hyper disciplinary learning
that I speak of many something above or
beyond disciplines well in the history
it would have been expected that the
fort leaders of the day would actually
have a fairly good grasp of a
significant quantum of the then-known
knowledge but as we’ve been discussing
this is no longer possible and indeed in
the 20th century and now exacerbated in
our age of big data we’ve started to
learn more and more about narrowing
areas of interest and our university to
degree degree programs and even our high
school curricula reflect this this is
the reductionist aspect of science where
we asked specific questions and
simplified idealized and controlled
experimental settings to get a concrete
an answer in absolute terms and while
reductionist science has helped us to
learn a lot and it’s been one of the
reasons we’ve been able to solve many
problems
I’m afraid that complex problems require
thinking that’s outside of this
disciplinary box and outside you have to
be looked at from a large number of
angles so to reiterate what I’m talking
about I want to go back to that complex
enigma that I think about every day and
that’s Parkinson’s disease this year we
celebrate the 200th anniversary of the
1817 publication of a small treatise in
Thailand and essay on the shaking palsy
by James Parkinson this is the first
description in our Western medical
literature for the disease that now
bears James Parkinson’s names
Parkinson’s disease affects over 70
thousand Australians and more than five
million people worldwide it is an
age-related illness and it sets its
prevalence is set to double in the next
50 years as the world’s population gets
older this has huge economic
implications as in Australia alone the
burden of Parkinson’s disease is in the
order of ten billion dollars every year
now we know a lot about Parkinson’s but
we still can’t predict who would get
Parkinson’s disease and once they’re
diagnosed we can’t actually predict what
their prop what a person’s
prognosis knees and more most
importantly though for Parkinson’s we
can’t stop slow or reverse the
degeneration of the brain it occurs of
the disease but the human development of
understanding into Parkinson’s disease
provides us with a very good template my
argument about the changing nature of
knowledge James Parkinson himself is the
archetypal 18th and 19th century scholar
born in 1755 in the Shoreditch region of
North East London like his father James
Parkinson was an apothecary and surgeon
and he was a member of the Royal College
of Surgeons but he had an extensive
education and very broad interests in
effect in his lifetime it was probably
more prominently known for his prolific
writings in geology and paleontology
it’s social welfare in and in political
activism there’s no doubt that his
extensive education helped him to hone
his skills of observation and his
ability to synthesize information these
are all attributes that were
particularly important in his ability to
discover a new disease and it was in the
20th century that disciplinary knowledge
and reductionist science and help them
understand much more about Parkinson’s
in the second decade of the 20th century
it was pathologists who identified that
the pigment in the brain was missing in
the brains of people who have died
Parkinson’s in an area of the brain
called the black substance or
substantial nigra it was until the 1950s
that was chemists that identified that
this region of the brain was very high
in a chemical called dopamine and this
allowed pharmacologists or drug
scientists to observe their seemingly
miraculous effect of replacing this
chemical in the brains of people with
Parkinson’s this was the topic of a
wonderful book by Oliver Sacks
published in 1973 awakenings which was
later turned into a movie starring Robin
Williams who ironically in 2014 died
suffering from a form of Parkinson’s
disease
these pharmacological advances caused a
revolution in our
understanding of Parkinson’s and also
provided for the first time treatments
for individuals with the disease
I think parallel zero surgeons and
neurophysiologists were able to show
largely by some trial and error in
humans actually and then by some close
and controlled experiments and animals
that if you damaged parts of the brain
can actually improve the motor symptoms
of Parkinson’s disease and this went on
to be developed into very highly
technical neuro you know surgical
interventions for Parkinson’s like deep
brain stimulation well replace small
electrodes deep into the brain regions
into which electrical stimulation causes
pseudo lesions that control or modulate
the abnormal brain functions that occur
in the parkinsonian brain this would
have been possible without a large
number of other technical advances take
the imaging of the brain for instance
this requires important and disciplinary
knowledge in physics for the magnetic
resonance imaging and high-powered data
processing techniques did you know that
the same algorithms that are used for
stealth bombers to find their military
targets a neurosurgeon used upon the
targets in the brain that are the
targets for this delicate neurosurgery
and I’m just talking now about the
treatments for Parkinson’s you can
imagine the amount of data that’s being
generated in experiments that are set
out to try and understand the cause the
disease we can our sequence entire human
genomes we can interrogate the way a
single cell can read and transcribe the
genetic information we can use the so
called omics technologies to get an idea
of globally things like the metabolome
the proteome the epigenome and so on
stem cell technologies enable us to
culture brain cells from skin cells and
to study the inner workings of these
cells with high content microscopic
imaging that can be automated to produce
terabytes of information that can be
analyzed by a computer algorithm we can
monitor a patient’s symptoms their
movements and even their actual brain
activity in real-time with things
simple as an iPhone you can imagine the
amount of information that we might be
able to generate using these experiments
but to me it can be frustrating as a
practitioner of science sir a lot of the
experiments that are being done are
being driven by the technology rather
than the quality of the question itself
there’s an old adage that to someone who
owns a Hammer Every Problem looks like a
nail
and so it is to disciplinary scientists
for example to a geneticist Parkinson’s
is considered a genetic disease to a
toxicologist it may be caused by an
environmental exposure to a cell
biologist I will explain it by a change
in a cellular process and to a
neurophysiologist it might all be
explained by changes in the connections
between areas in the brain but in
reality Parkinson’s disease may be all
of these things and it may be none of
these things in order to solve the
Enigma of Parkinson’s and many of the
other complex challenges we face we
don’t just need to train more
geneticists or toxicologists
pharmacologists neurophysiologists or
even by informaticians in fact we don’t
just need to train any disciplinary
scientists but what we do need to do is
train more students in the science of
how to bring ideas and information
together and how to look for the
intersections in that knowledge in many
respects this goes beyond the single
discipline beyond multiple disciplines
and actually transcends the gaps between
and across disciplines this is the hyper
disciplinary north learning that I’m
talking about
unlike the olden days polymath whose
encyclopedic knowledge could provide the
genius to solve the problems
individually today’s hyper disciplinary
problem solvers need to work
collectively and in teams and they need
to use multiple levels of data and
multifaceted approaches of course in
doing this we can’t ignore the
importance of disciplinary knowledge
this still remains critical also
critical is our need to adhere to the
scientific principles of evidence-based
hypothesis test
without these things we will not get far
but we need to go beyond this using the
reductionist mindset will only get us
part of the way when it comes to complex
challenges so any of you out there who
are budding scientists and any of you
interesting is interested in solving the
complex challenges of our age let me
conclude by saying this we need to
embrace complexity cannot be afraid of
it we need to look broadly for solutions
we need to take as much of the available
information as we can and we need to
work socially and collectively to put
that knowledge together in meaningful
ways we need to keep asking difficult
questions and we need to work together
and we need to work collegiately now if
carefully practiced and perfected hyper
disciplinary learning will maximize our
evolution our evolutionary propensity to
network information and will help us as
humans to save our planet to protect our
fellow species and to avoid disaster and
Oblivion thank you
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: