Press "Enter" to skip to content

Learning to Speak Up! | Melissa Shuman Zarin, Ph.D. | TEDxStevensInstituteofTechnology


I want to start by having you close your
eyes and I want you to think about a
time when you were in college and I want
you to think about all the things you
really liked about being at college
maybe it was the freedom you experienced
being away from home maybe it was the
new things you got to study the new
classes you were taking maybe it was the
new friends you were making the clubs
you were joining maybe it was even the
parties you were going to and really
take that in and now I want you to
imagine for a minute that something has
changed and maybe the workload starts to
feel too hard so you start missing some
assignments and maybe in the morning you
feel too tired to get out of bed and so
you stopped going to a class or two and
maybe you begin to be so anxious about
that that you start to not sleep at all
and you’re up all night worrying and
maybe that Club you joined you quit
because you’re just not that interested
but you tell people you don’t have time
or that sport you like to play you to
stop and maybe eating doesn’t interest
you so much so you stop going to the
dining hall and you stop seeing your
friends and maybe drugs and alcohol are
the only thing that start to make you
feel better and maybe you even begin to
think about suicide as an option now
open your eyes and think about all the
people while you were in college that
you interacted with whether it was your
friends or your roommate your RA
professors staff faculty would any of
them notice those changes in you and
would you even wanted them to with
someone intervene and speak up for you
so here’s the thing there’s no question
that college is a really complex time in
a young adults life we’re asking them to
make a lot of transitions in their life
the transition to adulthood right
being on their own for the first time
making choices for themselves the
transition to a career path what’s my
major do I like what I’m studying
is it the right choice and the
transition to self-identity who am i who
do I want to be who do I want in my life
and all of these transitions come with a
lot of social and emotional and academic
challenges and changes and for many
students they’ll go through these
changes with very few bumps and work
towards graduation and moving on in
their lives but for others things get
really complicated and daily tasks
become extremely difficult they feel
extreme pressure to succeed they feel
they struggle maybe academically with
their work because perhaps it’s not the
right choice
socialization becomes hard they don’t
either know how to make friends or
they’ll withdraw from the friends that
they have we’ve seen that for many
pre-existing mental health issues get
exacerbated and daily tasks and things
become difficult there’s no question
that mental health on college campuses
is growing and that it’s documented
everyday in literature and newspaper
articles magazines and popular culture
on a regular basis and College
counseling centers are struggling daily
to meet the demands and needs and so I
want to just draw your attention to some
recent trends and let you know kind of
fill in the pieces of what’s going on so
I’ve given you some numbers to look at
50% is the number of mental health cases
that begin before the age of 14 and 75%
are the number of cases of mental health
that begin before the age of 24 so
already we begin to see that College is
going to be a prime time for the onset
of mental health struggles right off the
bat in recent studies we learned that
40% of students indicated that they
suffered from severe depression that it
made it hard to function and 60 percent
reported overwhelming anxiety 11.1 is
the percentage of students who seriously
considered suicide and it’s important to
know that at this point in time suicide
is the second leading cause of death in
college students and the suicide rate in
15 to 24 year olds has tripled in the
last 50 years and so what that tells me
is not only do we have to continue to
provide robust mental health services we
have to it’s not an option the need is
there but it’s the two-thirds number I
really want to draw your attention to
2/3 is the number of students with
depression and anxiety who don’t seek
help right so I want you to think about
that two-thirds of students who reported
suffering from depression and anxiety
do not seek help that’s really
troublesome for me and has really
motivated a lot of the work that I do
because what it tells me is that every
day when I walk around and I pass young
people I’m a bystander to someone in
distress and that’s just sort of where
we start we’re all bystanders right and
it’s a hard thing to hear we’re all
bystanders but when you consider what a
bystander is right a bystander is
someone who is witnesses an event a
passive bystander or someone who
witnesses that event and doesn’t take
action we’re an active bystander or
someone who can witness event and take
an action and if we consider a student
in distress to be that event then if two
thirds of students aren’t seeking help
were all bystanders to someone in
distress on any given day and that was
the starting point from my conversations
with many of my colleagues and many
other mental health providers across the
country about how do we find those
students and how do we get them to seek
help and get them into the Counseling
Center or get them the resources they
need and in having those conversations
once you begin to realize that we’re
bystanders it means that we’re all
seeing different things on a daily basis
and we knew and I knew in those
conversations that students and faculty
and staff were probably all seeing signs
but not being sure what they were seeing
and if they did what to do with the
information and as this was growing at
the same time bystander work was growing
in sexual assault awareness and we were
talking about could we apply the same
idea to mental health could we change
how we talk about mental health and
begin to educate our staff and our
faculty and our students about seeing
those signs knowing what to do when they
saw it and then knowing the resources
they had to be able to get students
health once we started having those
conversations right it became clear we
could start to do this and it became
important to do it to find those
students now part of the conversation is
understanding why we don’t intervene and
this becomes important because the goal
is to create a community of care and is
to create individuals
want to step in and do things so this is
a really well-documented part of mental
health studies it’s something I studied
way back when I was an undergrad in
social psychology classes but it becomes
important because it lends itself to why
we don’t intervene on college campuses
and what we can use to change that the
first is the bystander effect and what
this says is that the more people around
the less likely someone’s going to step
in and intervene right so why is that
because the more people around it’s easy
to assume someone else is going to do it
right and that’s called the diffusion of
responsibility and where else will you
find a million people but a college
campus so if you were involved in
something and you’re watching you may
say someone else has it right someone
else probably noticed the student not
handing in a paper someone else probably
noticed the student who was sitting on
the bench beings you know not looking so
great I’m sure someone else has it so it
becomes easy to see why we might act in
that way and again it’s very popular
it’s in a lot of media about bystander
effect
another reason is conformity right the
idea behind conformity is that we don’t
want to stand out we kind of want to fit
into the crowd right and so if we’re all
looking around and everybody’s sleeping
late and sometimes missing classes we
might assume that’s okay and I don’t
really want to say anything to my friend
because I don’t want to seem different
it seems normal it seems part of the
culture and I hear that a lot it’s
really normal in college to do X it’s
really normal
to do college and Y and so we tend to
want to stay and fit into that picture
the last one is probably the one that
affects mental health the most which is
the unknown the ambiguous situation
right what am I really looking at is it
really a big deal and do I really need
to take action right and that’s where we
sometimes have to refocus our lens and
that’s where some of bystander
intervention begins which is can we
refocus our lens we can is the answer
and so what we talk about when we talk
about being working on bystander
behaviors isn’t not being a bystander
it’s moving from passive to active
behaviors and the way we do that is
through three steps and the first one we
like to talk about is recognizing the
problem now in a lot of ways that seems
really simple right we should all
recognize problems but if you remember I
said the ambiguous situation is the most
difficult to figure out what happens is
to really recognize a problem you have
to begin to refocus your lens that’s the
language I like to use when I work with
students is refocusing the lens and
moving away from normalizing things to
asking yourself is this really normal is
this really not a problem and so once
you begin to do that you might look at a
situation and take your friend for
example JJ and let’s say I haven’t seen
JJ in a while and I send JJ a text and I
haven’t heard back
I might not really worry about it for a
while but if I begin to refocus my lens
I might realize that that’s not normal
for my relationship with JJ and I
haven’t actually seen them in class and
they’re actually not been coming to that
club we joined and so when I begin to
put those pieces together I’m gonna say
in my gut I think something might
actually be wrong here as opposed to
normalizing and saying everybody does
that or I haven’t heard it’s okay but
I’m putting those pieces together and
I’m beginning to recognize that in fact
there may be a problem the next part
once you recognize there’s a problem is
assuming personal responsibility now
this is where it kind of throws people
off because they assume that if I assume
personal responsibility for my friend
then I have to step in directly and do
something and in fact that might be true
and that may be an approach I’ll take
but what assuming responsibility really
means is that I’ve now recognized
there’s a problem and I’m gonna take an
action I don’t know the action yet but
I’m going to do something and what that
action is is determined by a variety of
factors it could be time it could be the
situation it could be where I am in my
own life but I’m going to take an action
and that action is the speaking out part
and that’s what the goal is is to get
people to speak up right so we have
recognizing a problem by refocusing our
lens assuming personal responsibility to
take the action and then taking the
action and what about taking the action
well we teach three tools and those
tools are the three DS and those are the
way we choose to speak up depending on
the circumstance so the first is direct
so if I take my friend JJ again who I
haven’t heard from in a while and I’m
noticing there’s something going on and
I see they’re missing some classes and
we’re in the same class and there’s
assignments that aren’t getting hand in
I may go directly to JJ and try to
find JJ and say hey I’m worried about
you I’m really concerned this is what I
see going on and that would be direct
that would me be me
Melissa’s stepping into the situation
and directly trying to talk to my friend
the second one is distract and basically
what distract says is that a direct
approach may not be the best at that
time but there may be another way to
reach out to that person and try to
figure out what’s going on so what I may
do is try to go to JJ again but instead
of saying I’m worried about you I may
say instead hey I need to go for a walk
do you want to come with me I’m starving
I need some food so it gets them out of
their dorm room or wherever they are
taking a walk and beginning that process
where in fact we may never talk about
what’s going on but we may have that
moment and I may be able to lay some
foundation or I may share what’s going
on with me and getting that dialogue
started and creating a way for the
conversation to happen and that’s often
a really good place to start when you’re
concerned about someone because right
off the bat they may not realize until
you give them all the pieces that
something’s going on the last one is one
of my favorites but it’s also the one I
think we forget about a lot which is the
delegate because we often think if we
give someone else the task then I’m not
moving into being an active bystander
but in fact delegating to the
appropriate place is being an active
bystander because sometimes I’m not the
appropriate person to do the action I
know there’s a problem right so a really
simple example would be I was walking
home a few weeks ago there’s wires
hanging on my street I knew it was a
problem but I also knew I wasn’t going
to be the one to hang the wires back up
so I delegated it to my police
department who called and the fire
department came right so I was not being
passive I was being active but I got the
right people well it’s the same with our
students in distress so if I take my
friend JJ who at this point may be being
direct hasn’t worked
distracting hasn’t worked and now things
are escalating maybe to the point that
I’m really concerned because I haven’t
seen them in a while and when I do they
seem very sad and they’re saying a lot
of things about quitting classes and
quitting school I’m a delegate at this
point to an RA or even to our care team
which is a place where students can
report and faculty can report students
of concern and they have the ability
then to network or in fact if I’m really
concerned about their safety we
there’s some other escalating things
going on about they’re talking about
death and giving up
I’m gonna call campus police because
that’s the best resource to use if
you’re concerned about safety and again
I’m being a active bystander I’m not
directly getting involved but I’m
delegating to the proprietary learn
three steps for intervening and we learn
tools we create a community of care and
that’s what we want is a community of
care we want students and faculty and
staff not just learn academic things but
we want them to learn emotional things
and skills they can use and when we give
people tools I know as a psychologist
they use them I also know it works and
because of that what I’ve seen here and
the more we’ve done this kind of work
and we’ve taught signs of distress our
care reports have grown by double and
for some people that might seem alarming
but in fact that’s what we want if you
consider that two-thirds of students
suffering from anxiety and depression
don’t seek help right we need to find
ways to speak up for them and so we want
those reports to grow because that means
we’re finding those students and we’re
speaking up for them and no longer being
a passive bystander but an active
bystander in their life and the best
part about all of this is that these are
tools right and they’re not limited to
college and the goal of college right is
to educate students to take tools out
into their own communities and so these
are tools that you never forget and can
take with you and when our students
graduate we hope they take them out as
all of you take them out into your own
communities and use them in your daily life the way I’ve learned to do as well
Please follow and like us: