
[Music]
thank you so much good afternoon
everyone my name is John Shaw I’m a
psychology professor here at Lafayette
College and I’m honored to be part of
this exciting event today now as you
know the theme of today’s conference is
solving for y the y that I’m going to
talk about is the Y that represents the
essence of each one of us as individuals
that is who we are every day we
constantly try to solve for y you try to
figure out who are you who am I
who’s that person over there when you
meet someone for the first time you try
to solve for y when someone applies for
a job
both the interviewer and the job
applicant are trying to solve for y when
college admissions committees review
those thousands of files they get every
year they’re trying to solve for y
they’re trying to find the essence of
the people that are buried beneath those
grades and SATs and extracurricular
activities when two people are sizing
each other up as potential long-term
mates they’re definitely trying to solve
for y and that process can take months
or sometimes even years now as you’ve
probably figured out solving for y is
really hard work and can take a lot of
time ah we have a shortcut to instead of
doing all that work we can use labels
and that’s what my talk is about today
now I’ve got a word cloud that’s
floating above me on the screen here and
these are labels of different groups of
people I in creating this word cloud I
made a list and I was able to come up
with over 100 labels in just a few
minutes time I’ve just included about 20
or 30 for readability up here I’d like
everybody to take a moment and look at
the word cloud and see what labels mean
something to you so just take a couple
seconds and take a look and as you as
you scan through it you’ll see some
labels you’re familiar with maybe some
you’re not familiar with what you will
notice is that many of these labels can
evoke strong emotions some of these
labels might make you proud some of them
might make you happy some of the labels
might make you sad some might even make
you angry
another thing about labels is they
affect people in different ways my
reaction to the label old might be
different than your reaction my reaction
to the labels gay American tall
Democrat liberal blonde disabled maybe
different than your reactions but we all
have strong reactions to these labels as
we’re going to see today
the labels can affect both the people
being labeled as well as the labelers
themselves and one thing to keep in mind
is the effects of these labels occur
even if we don’t save them or use them
all we have to do is think about them
now the use of label starts really early
it starts at the very beginning when a
child is about to be born or even before
everybody wants to know is it a boy or
is it a girl and so they asked that
question aunts uncles friends relatives
even strangers will ask is it a boy or
is it a girl now the answer to that
seemingly simple question can have a
lifetime of consequences it could affect
whether that child plays with trucks or
dolls it could affect what color crayons
that child uses it could affect when
that child gets to high school whether
the child plays football or field hockey
it might even affect whether the child
wants to be a nurse or a doctor all of
the results of this simple kind of the
question if you don’t believe me take a
look at these pictures of girls and boys
toys here and if you can get past the
pinkness and the blueness of the
pictures you will see that on the left
and the girls toys most of the toys are
domestic toys cooking there’s a lot of
apparel there’s dolls on the right there
are boys toys that are action toys
they’re building toys their sports kinds
of toys simply because the toys have
gender labels just like the children do
so there’s girls toys and there’s boys
toys so I would suggest then the next
time somebody asks the question is it a
boy or is it a girl the best answer to
give is that it’s simply a baby
and as an aside here this is I have two
children a boy and a girl and this is a
picture of one of them and I’m not
really sure which one because it’s just
a baby okay all right so people are
really really really good at using
labels unfortunately solar institutions
I’ve listed some of the institutions up
here schools hospitals employers
businesses the government media
politicians they’re all really really
good at using labels think of the labels
they put on us they label us by our
gender by our age by our country of
origin by our race by our ethnicity by
our religion by all sorts of things
and so they treat us this way and
categorize us and put us into groups the
first time you go to a doctor’s office
you fill out an information form think
of what you think of the labels you put
on that form they ask you your age they
ask you your gender they ask you your
race they will often ask you whether
you’re married they will ask you whether
you’re a smoker whether you’re a drinker
these are all labels and those labels
can affect how the doctor sees you and
it might even affect how she treats you
here’s a map most of us are familiar
with this is a map that I took from just
before the election in the fall and this
is the traditional map that the media
uses to characterize voting patterns in
the States so the red states are
Republican the deep blue states are
Democrat then we have light blue states
that are leaning Democrat we have purple
states that are kind of a mixture we
have some peach States I assume those
are supposed to be light red but they
appear peach and those are supposed to
be leaning Republican now we’re in
Pennsylvania here they’re about thirteen
million of us who live in Pennsylvania
and think how absurd it is to label all
Pennsylvanians as like blue we’re a very
diverse group in Pennsylvania we can’t
all be covered by one label but these
labels affected the way the media
covered the election it certainly
affected the way that the candidates ran
their campaigns and it also affected
voted voter behavior if you’re a
Democrat in a state that’s bright red up
on this screen behind me you might be
less likely to vote because you think
your vote might not matter so laborers
are incredibly powerful
so labels are powerful there they come
automatically and they’re resistant to
change and again we don’t actually have
to even use the labels all we have to do
is think about the labels now labels can
affect both the people being labeled and
the label or let’s talk about the people
being labeled first I’ve got some fairly
technical terms up here self-fulfilling
prophesy stereotype threat decrease in
self esteem etc and so labels can affect
the people being labeled I’m going to
talk about one of these and just walk
you through it stereotype threat so
stereotype threat is the way that
stereotypes can affect people’s
performance in real world situations
I’ve chosen a common stereotype and
that’s girls are bad at math of course
it’s not true but most people have heard
that stereotype girls are bad at math so
here’s what happens I’ve got a couple of
girls here they look like they’re in
junior high they’re taking a
standardized test and
so at the top of the form they put their
name and maybe even sometimes they put
their gender at the top but they don’t
have to as soon as they put their name
or their gender that activates the label
that they are female and along with that
label comes the stereotype that girls
are bad at math and then the girls can
start to get nervous and anxious and it
can actually affect their performance on
the task there have been dozens and
dozens of studies that have shown this
they’ve shown this with gender they’ve
shown it with race they saw it with
other characteristics as well and so the
girls perform poorly on the test
confirming the stereotype that’s not
true in the first place ok so that’s the
real danger or something like stereotype
threat but one thing we don’t often
think about is the effect of labels on
the people who are doing the labeling so
when we use labels we become lazy
perceivers we oversimplify the world and
we succumb to prejudice and
discrimination what I mean by that is we
start looking at people as members of
categories rather than as individuals ok
and so let me give you a couple of
examples so here’s Luke Skywalker he
almost always is depicted in white and
is arch-nemesis Darth Vader who’s almost
always depicted in black so we have the
labels white and black it’s fairly easy
in people’s minds to have those morph
into good and evil so white becomes good
and black becomes evil here we have
Glinda the Good Witch of the south from
The Wizard of Oz she’s always depicted
as being beautiful we have the Wicked
Witch of the West who’s usually depicted
as being ugly so we have two labels here
beautiful and ugly and they also can
morph into good or evil
so we have words like white and black
that become good and evil we have words
like beautiful and ugly that become good
and evil so one of the real dangers of
labels is the fact that they can morph
into even additional labels now a set of
labels that’s particularly damaging our
mental health labels and these are
labels that society places on people
with certain psychological disorders and
conditions let’s take a look and look at
this at this some word cloud and I want
to let you know I couldn’t possibly
include all the labels here I just
included a few so that they would be
readable some of these labels might jump
out at you
not because of the size of the font or
the size of the word but because maybe
of a personal experience or someone you
know but these are labels that in almost
all cases have neg
negative effects on the people being
labeled okay but they can also have
effects on the labelers and this is
really important because when people use
these labels or even think about them we
might treat people with these
psychological disorders differently than
we would if we didn’t have the label and
another thing that’s interesting is
these are not actually labels of people
the first word cloud were labels of
groups of people this is not these are
labels of disorders and conditions but
what happens is when we use these labels
the research shows that the people
become the labels both in their own eyes
and in the eyes of the people who are
doing the labeling so you can see
there’s really really damaging long-term
effects for both groups of people for
these kinds of labels so what can we do
okay we’ve identity much all agree that
having labels can affect both the people
being labeled and the people that are
doing the labeling well we can try
looking beyond the labels okay so
instead of seeing more people and humans
we could say King Triton and Ariel
instead of seeing beasts in humans we
could see Prince Adam and Belle but most
of you didn’t know that his name was
Prince Adam and I had to actually look
it up before preparing the talk and
instead of ogres we could see Shrek and
Fiona so we can try looking beyond the
labels but you know what it’s really
hard once the labels are out there and
when you look at these pictures I see
ogres and beasts and more people so it’s
really hard to not use the labels once
they’re out there because they’re
powerful they’re automatic and they’re
resistant to change so even better we
might try not using the labels at all
so my example here is I’ve chosen weeds
and weed is a chose it because I think
it’s a universally negative label we
don’t like weeds they’re unsightly we
try to get rid of them in the United
States we’d spend tens of millions of
dollars every single year trying to
banish weeds from our gardens from our
lawns they’re just a big nuisance okay
however if you look at weeds
individually you will see that they’re
not so bad at all weeds are just a our
plants and this one for instance is
white Dutch clover it’s a rather
beautiful plant the next one these are
all classified as weeds this is violet
clearly a beautiful plant and if we look
at these individuals we can see the
individualism and the beauty in each one
of them
this one is creeping Charlie and my
favorite the last one is the dandelion
and if we get beyond the labels and look
at these as individual plants we will
see that they’re unique and they’re
beautiful now I think this approach to
weeds was summed up really nicely by a
Milne the author of Winnie the Pooh and
he said weeds or flowers too once you
get to know them so maybe that’s the
approach we should take when we solve
for y instead of using labels as we’re
trying to figure out who people are
maybe we should simply try to get to
know them because after all why doesn’t
equal X we know that Y does not equal W
and it certainly doesn’t equal Z now
instead y equals a really complex
beautiful set of factors that make each
one of us who we are as individuals so
as we go about the world and try to
solve for y let’s all see if we can
avoid using labels as we’re solving for
y thank you very much
[Applause]
thank you so much good afternoon
everyone my name is John Shaw I’m a
psychology professor here at Lafayette
College and I’m honored to be part of
this exciting event today now as you
know the theme of today’s conference is
solving for y the y that I’m going to
talk about is the Y that represents the
essence of each one of us as individuals
that is who we are every day we
constantly try to solve for y you try to
figure out who are you who am I
who’s that person over there when you
meet someone for the first time you try
to solve for y when someone applies for
a job
both the interviewer and the job
applicant are trying to solve for y when
college admissions committees review
those thousands of files they get every
year they’re trying to solve for y
they’re trying to find the essence of
the people that are buried beneath those
grades and SATs and extracurricular
activities when two people are sizing
each other up as potential long-term
mates they’re definitely trying to solve
for y and that process can take months
or sometimes even years now as you’ve
probably figured out solving for y is
really hard work and can take a lot of
time ah we have a shortcut to instead of
doing all that work we can use labels
and that’s what my talk is about today
now I’ve got a word cloud that’s
floating above me on the screen here and
these are labels of different groups of
people I in creating this word cloud I
made a list and I was able to come up
with over 100 labels in just a few
minutes time I’ve just included about 20
or 30 for readability up here I’d like
everybody to take a moment and look at
the word cloud and see what labels mean
something to you so just take a couple
seconds and take a look and as you as
you scan through it you’ll see some
labels you’re familiar with maybe some
you’re not familiar with what you will
notice is that many of these labels can
evoke strong emotions some of these
labels might make you proud some of them
might make you happy some of the labels
might make you sad some might even make
you angry
another thing about labels is they
affect people in different ways my
reaction to the label old might be
different than your reaction my reaction
to the labels gay American tall
Democrat liberal blonde disabled maybe
different than your reactions but we all
have strong reactions to these labels as
we’re going to see today
the labels can affect both the people
being labeled as well as the labelers
themselves and one thing to keep in mind
is the effects of these labels occur
even if we don’t save them or use them
all we have to do is think about them
now the use of label starts really early
it starts at the very beginning when a
child is about to be born or even before
everybody wants to know is it a boy or
is it a girl and so they asked that
question aunts uncles friends relatives
even strangers will ask is it a boy or
is it a girl now the answer to that
seemingly simple question can have a
lifetime of consequences it could affect
whether that child plays with trucks or
dolls it could affect what color crayons
that child uses it could affect when
that child gets to high school whether
the child plays football or field hockey
it might even affect whether the child
wants to be a nurse or a doctor all of
the results of this simple kind of the
question if you don’t believe me take a
look at these pictures of girls and boys
toys here and if you can get past the
pinkness and the blueness of the
pictures you will see that on the left
and the girls toys most of the toys are
domestic toys cooking there’s a lot of
apparel there’s dolls on the right there
are boys toys that are action toys
they’re building toys their sports kinds
of toys simply because the toys have
gender labels just like the children do
so there’s girls toys and there’s boys
toys so I would suggest then the next
time somebody asks the question is it a
boy or is it a girl the best answer to
give is that it’s simply a baby
and as an aside here this is I have two
children a boy and a girl and this is a
picture of one of them and I’m not
really sure which one because it’s just
a baby okay all right so people are
really really really good at using
labels unfortunately solar institutions
I’ve listed some of the institutions up
here schools hospitals employers
businesses the government media
politicians they’re all really really
good at using labels think of the labels
they put on us they label us by our
gender by our age by our country of
origin by our race by our ethnicity by
our religion by all sorts of things
and so they treat us this way and
categorize us and put us into groups the
first time you go to a doctor’s office
you fill out an information form think
of what you think of the labels you put
on that form they ask you your age they
ask you your gender they ask you your
race they will often ask you whether
you’re married they will ask you whether
you’re a smoker whether you’re a drinker
these are all labels and those labels
can affect how the doctor sees you and
it might even affect how she treats you
here’s a map most of us are familiar
with this is a map that I took from just
before the election in the fall and this
is the traditional map that the media
uses to characterize voting patterns in
the States so the red states are
Republican the deep blue states are
Democrat then we have light blue states
that are leaning Democrat we have purple
states that are kind of a mixture we
have some peach States I assume those
are supposed to be light red but they
appear peach and those are supposed to
be leaning Republican now we’re in
Pennsylvania here they’re about thirteen
million of us who live in Pennsylvania
and think how absurd it is to label all
Pennsylvanians as like blue we’re a very
diverse group in Pennsylvania we can’t
all be covered by one label but these
labels affected the way the media
covered the election it certainly
affected the way that the candidates ran
their campaigns and it also affected
voted voter behavior if you’re a
Democrat in a state that’s bright red up
on this screen behind me you might be
less likely to vote because you think
your vote might not matter so laborers
are incredibly powerful
so labels are powerful there they come
automatically and they’re resistant to
change and again we don’t actually have
to even use the labels all we have to do
is think about the labels now labels can
affect both the people being labeled and
the label or let’s talk about the people
being labeled first I’ve got some fairly
technical terms up here self-fulfilling
prophesy stereotype threat decrease in
self esteem etc and so labels can affect
the people being labeled I’m going to
talk about one of these and just walk
you through it stereotype threat so
stereotype threat is the way that
stereotypes can affect people’s
performance in real world situations
I’ve chosen a common stereotype and
that’s girls are bad at math of course
it’s not true but most people have heard
that stereotype girls are bad at math so
here’s what happens I’ve got a couple of
girls here they look like they’re in
junior high they’re taking a
standardized test and
so at the top of the form they put their
name and maybe even sometimes they put
their gender at the top but they don’t
have to as soon as they put their name
or their gender that activates the label
that they are female and along with that
label comes the stereotype that girls
are bad at math and then the girls can
start to get nervous and anxious and it
can actually affect their performance on
the task there have been dozens and
dozens of studies that have shown this
they’ve shown this with gender they’ve
shown it with race they saw it with
other characteristics as well and so the
girls perform poorly on the test
confirming the stereotype that’s not
true in the first place ok so that’s the
real danger or something like stereotype
threat but one thing we don’t often
think about is the effect of labels on
the people who are doing the labeling so
when we use labels we become lazy
perceivers we oversimplify the world and
we succumb to prejudice and
discrimination what I mean by that is we
start looking at people as members of
categories rather than as individuals ok
and so let me give you a couple of
examples so here’s Luke Skywalker he
almost always is depicted in white and
is arch-nemesis Darth Vader who’s almost
always depicted in black so we have the
labels white and black it’s fairly easy
in people’s minds to have those morph
into good and evil so white becomes good
and black becomes evil here we have
Glinda the Good Witch of the south from
The Wizard of Oz she’s always depicted
as being beautiful we have the Wicked
Witch of the West who’s usually depicted
as being ugly so we have two labels here
beautiful and ugly and they also can
morph into good or evil
so we have words like white and black
that become good and evil we have words
like beautiful and ugly that become good
and evil so one of the real dangers of
labels is the fact that they can morph
into even additional labels now a set of
labels that’s particularly damaging our
mental health labels and these are
labels that society places on people
with certain psychological disorders and
conditions let’s take a look and look at
this at this some word cloud and I want
to let you know I couldn’t possibly
include all the labels here I just
included a few so that they would be
readable some of these labels might jump
out at you
not because of the size of the font or
the size of the word but because maybe
of a personal experience or someone you
know but these are labels that in almost
all cases have neg
negative effects on the people being
labeled okay but they can also have
effects on the labelers and this is
really important because when people use
these labels or even think about them we
might treat people with these
psychological disorders differently than
we would if we didn’t have the label and
another thing that’s interesting is
these are not actually labels of people
the first word cloud were labels of
groups of people this is not these are
labels of disorders and conditions but
what happens is when we use these labels
the research shows that the people
become the labels both in their own eyes
and in the eyes of the people who are
doing the labeling so you can see
there’s really really damaging long-term
effects for both groups of people for
these kinds of labels so what can we do
okay we’ve identity much all agree that
having labels can affect both the people
being labeled and the people that are
doing the labeling well we can try
looking beyond the labels okay so
instead of seeing more people and humans
we could say King Triton and Ariel
instead of seeing beasts in humans we
could see Prince Adam and Belle but most
of you didn’t know that his name was
Prince Adam and I had to actually look
it up before preparing the talk and
instead of ogres we could see Shrek and
Fiona so we can try looking beyond the
labels but you know what it’s really
hard once the labels are out there and
when you look at these pictures I see
ogres and beasts and more people so it’s
really hard to not use the labels once
they’re out there because they’re
powerful they’re automatic and they’re
resistant to change so even better we
might try not using the labels at all
so my example here is I’ve chosen weeds
and weed is a chose it because I think
it’s a universally negative label we
don’t like weeds they’re unsightly we
try to get rid of them in the United
States we’d spend tens of millions of
dollars every single year trying to
banish weeds from our gardens from our
lawns they’re just a big nuisance okay
however if you look at weeds
individually you will see that they’re
not so bad at all weeds are just a our
plants and this one for instance is
white Dutch clover it’s a rather
beautiful plant the next one these are
all classified as weeds this is violet
clearly a beautiful plant and if we look
at these individuals we can see the
individualism and the beauty in each one
of them
this one is creeping Charlie and my
favorite the last one is the dandelion
and if we get beyond the labels and look
at these as individual plants we will
see that they’re unique and they’re
beautiful now I think this approach to
weeds was summed up really nicely by a
Milne the author of Winnie the Pooh and
he said weeds or flowers too once you
get to know them so maybe that’s the
approach we should take when we solve
for y instead of using labels as we’re
trying to figure out who people are
maybe we should simply try to get to
know them because after all why doesn’t
equal X we know that Y does not equal W
and it certainly doesn’t equal Z now
instead y equals a really complex
beautiful set of factors that make each
one of us who we are as individuals so
as we go about the world and try to
solve for y let’s all see if we can
avoid using labels as we’re solving for
y thank you very much
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: