
[Music]
yesterday was my very first day without
a job since 1993 I’ve been working at
the national nonprofit managing several
teams that I’d grown from the ground up
but now each of those teams was filled
with very very talented people and so
the only thing left to do was to just
get out of their way in the nonprofit
world we often wear many hats I’ve built
or managed web IT government affairs
editorial and PR teams given that
background I figured that my chances in
the job market we’re gonna be pretty
okay now the last time I had to apply
for a job the process was very
straightforward you see a job
announcement you write up a cover letter
submit it with your resume and then you
just wait to hear back from the company
and so I did just that now I’ve always
been excited and passionate about
technology so I started applying to the
dreamiest companies like Google and
Facebook and slack but as the the
applications piled up I found that
almost no matter what job I applied to I
was being met with a resounding silence
it’s easy to get lost to feel lost when
you’re in a period of transition like
this I’d had a perfectly good job and
I’ve voluntarily walked away from it but
now I couldn’t seem to convince anyone
in these companies that a career
nonprofit ear had something to offer
them I spoke with some folks in HR who
told me that in all likelihood I was
probably being filtered out by applicant
tracking systems we call him an 80s and
80s is simply a database of jobs and
applicants and the more sophisticated
versions have automated filters that
search through resumes and cover letters
for keywords specific educational
background specific work experience it’s
like a robot so sometimes I was being
filtered out because I simply wasn’t the
best candidate for the job but sometimes
I thought despite having the kind of
experience that made me a very
interesting candidate maybe I was being
filtered out because I simply didn’t
have the specific pedigree that these
companies and these algorithms are
looking for unless you have a lot of
dot-coms on your resume it’s very very
difficult to get into the most
well-known internet companies these days
so my chance is to make this transition
many people told me we’re nearly
impossible I had two things working
against me one I was up against leaders
in their field so my resume doesn’t
always jump to the top of the pile and
two robots read every application now of
course that’s not true for all companies
but it’s certainly true for many of the
big ones and in fairness I was an
unconventional candidate for many of
these companies but unconventional can
be a very good thing right so I did the
only reasonable thing that a person
faced with this challenge can do I
decided that if they were going to use a
robot to filter me out I was going to
use a robot to force my way in now of
course that’s not actually a reasonable
thing to do but I was lost and I was
determined to be found so I together
this Rube Goldberg ian’s contraption of
web crawlers and spreadsheets and
scripts in order to automate my job
application process it would search the
web for jobs that I’d be interested in
and then it built out a cover letter
that was customized to the job and
personalized to the hiring manager it
sent these applications in batches with
tracking mechanisms built in so that I
could see when emails were opened who
read my resume and who went and looked
at my LinkedIn profile
it was in no way elegant but it was
ruthlessly efficient the very first time
I spun it up I stepped away to get a cup
of coffee and when I came back I found
that I had inadvertently applied to more
than 1300 jobs in the Midwest now I live
in New York City and I had no intention
whatsoever of moving halfway across the
country for these jobs so I did a little
bit of refining until the robot was
working with a little bit more precision
now surely this bot would be massively
more efficient than I could ever be
working just by myself so therefore my
chances of it overcoming the odds that
were stacked up against me I thought
they were pretty good but an interesting
thing happened after thousands of
applications had gone out
I saw no better results in the large and
well-known Internet companies then I had
when I was applying to jobs manually
virtually no success just a whole lot
more of it so you may be thinking of
course you’re getting rejected you can’t
just send out a form letter and expect
to get a response well I didn’t I had
built and designed this robot to
optimize and adjust to lots of different
variables using a/b testing the idea was
I wanted this to act just like an
individual would each application one
job at a time now as a side note I’ve
since learned that rejection and
disappointment can temporarily reduce
dopamine levels in your brain and reduce
dopamine in the brain is associated with
all sorts of things but one really
important one which is depression so if
you think that it’s sad when you apply
for a job and it doesn’t come through
imagine not getting 3,000 jobs
we’ve been told for a very long time
that robots would eventually take over
our jobs but nobody ever told us that
they would be able to bum us out on such
an epic level so I continued to run
these a B tests using subtle and not so
subtle changes in email subject lines
and cover letters and so forth but while
I saw some variation River in response
it really wasn’t much it seemed like
nothing made a difference the
old-fashioned way of applying to jobs
with a thoughtful cover letter and a
resume just seemed tilted against
someone like me someone who didn’t have
the exact pedigree that those algorithms
were looking for and I realized early on
that this just was not going to be the
way that I get my next job but now I was
really interested I wanted to see just
how badly this system was tilted against
someone like me eventually I decided to
just throw the game I ran an a/b test
using a perfectly normal-looking cover
letter and I contrasted that with a
letter that admits right in the second
line that it’s being sent by a robot now
that second letter should either perform
much much better than the first or a
whole lot worse someone shy to be saying
hey I like the cut of this guy’s jib we
should hire him or they should be saying
who the heck does he think he is
and for my purposes I didn’t care which
I just wanted to see that someone anyone
was paying attention and as far as I
could tell from this experiment and
others like it the answer is that nobody
reads cover letters not even it seems
the robots now this was confirmed by a
number of HR people that I’ve been
speaking to a recruiter at Spotify told
me that they get between three hundred
and three hundred and fifty thousand
applications per year is it any wonder
that they have to rely on automation to
deal with that kind of volume and how do
you stand out from a crowd that’s that
big another recruiter told me that in
his experience roughly 80 to 90 percent
of the most senior level jobs are never
even advertised so how do you get into
that crowd still others told me that
their companies posted jobs on all of
the websites but they only considered
referrals and a number of them were
paying their own employees thousands and
thousands of dollars for referrals who
went on to get the job now in many
companies in the United States as many
as 30 to 50 percent of hires come from
referrals and referred candidates are
more than four times as likely to be
hired than non referred candidates so
maybe those companies should just tell
people if you don’t know someone at this
company don’t bother applying go outside
get some exercise play with your kids or
try and find someone who works at this
company and meet them because all of
those things are going to be infinitely
more effective than applying for a job
even on our own website in fact some
people began telling me these dirty
little secrets things like I don’t even
look at people that apply to jobs
anymore I only consider people that I
find on my own while hunting on LinkedIn
now this person is openly admitting that
they don’t consider people who’ve
actively self-selected
as interested in that company and
interested in that position and instead
they go out searching for other people
who already have jobs and have shown no
interest in their company so that seems
like a store clerk who leaves a line
full of customers waiting to checkout
and instead is running around the
parking lot asking does anybody want to
buy something another person told me
that a colleague routinely posted
non-existent senior-level jobs on all of
the websites this is strictly to get a
pipeline of information about applicants
that were available for poaching they
posted the same jobs over and over and
over again racking up hundreds if not
thousands of applicants information
despite not actually having a job to
offer I’d been applying to jobs that
don’t exist trying to squeeze my way
through filters that were built to keep
people like me out and competing against
people who had worked at their
competitors and who are friends with
their employees and let’s not forget now
I’m sad at the same time I heard stories
from people who are incredibly
passionate about their careers and
compassionate for people who are
searching for careers one told me I wish
that I could sit down over coffee with
every single applicant that we get but I
just can’t do that and so instead I
never stopped clicking on their profiles
just in case the next one is like you I
learned about companies that are
creating content management systems for
job applicants sort of like an
application tracking system to match the
applicant tracking system that the the
recruiters use others are creating
entire referral networks and some of
them are focusing exclusively on
underrepresented populations I’m still
on the lookout for my next job but I can
say that I’ve had roughly the same
number of interviews from networking
with just a small handful of very
helpful contacts as I did when I had a
bot that
to thousands and thousands of jobs so it
turns out that simple networking has
been hundreds of times more effective
than submitting an unsolicited
application or hitting a click here to
apply now button so what did I learn by
robotically applying to thousands of
jobs well it’s not how you apply it’s
who you know
and if you don’t know someone don’t
bother and also the number of
applications that you put in has no
correlation to whether or not you’ll be
considered for a job and you definitely
won’t be considered for the jobs that
you don’t even get a chance to apply to
but what’s in this for companies what
can they learn from from this experience
well first the sheer volume of
applicants that recruiters have to go
through coupled with measures like time
to fill or cost of acquisition I think
that this forces them into an efficiency
mode that forecloses opportunities on
some very interesting candidates also
transparency is critical
if you’re a company the hire is almost
exclusively by referral just say that
you’ll save your recruiters a whole lot
of time and you’ll do job applicants the
favor of not wasting their time if they
don’t already know someone on the inside
now I mentioned earlier that I’m in my
very first days on the job market and
whether I was applying the old-fashioned
way or by brute force I couldn’t seem to
get my foot in the door
however after telling my story a
peculiar thing happened more than 200
other job candidates reached out to
share similar experiences
dozens of HR tech companies reached out
to me I’ve met with CEOs I’ve spoken at
All Hands meetings and now I’m advising
a number of companies with HR and
recruiting products
overall the robot was a complete and
total failure but in a strange way it
may actually accomplish its task this
project was incredibly fun it gave me
the chance to to be inquisitive and to
break up complicated processes into
achievable steps and to learn new
approaches to old problems but it was in
telling my story that the companies that
I had spent so much time trying to
impress actually became more aware of
what I’m capable of and they came to me
now not everybody has the opportunity to
build a bot that helps them turn the
odds in their favor and that’s why the
most important lesson that I’ve learned
from job seekers and recruiters and a
robot is that the job search process is
incredibly personal and recruiting is
filled with people who are committed to
other people
but we still need to strive to make this
more human and more humane
[Applause]
[Music]
yesterday was my very first day without
a job since 1993 I’ve been working at
the national nonprofit managing several
teams that I’d grown from the ground up
but now each of those teams was filled
with very very talented people and so
the only thing left to do was to just
get out of their way in the nonprofit
world we often wear many hats I’ve built
or managed web IT government affairs
editorial and PR teams given that
background I figured that my chances in
the job market we’re gonna be pretty
okay now the last time I had to apply
for a job the process was very
straightforward you see a job
announcement you write up a cover letter
submit it with your resume and then you
just wait to hear back from the company
and so I did just that now I’ve always
been excited and passionate about
technology so I started applying to the
dreamiest companies like Google and
Facebook and slack but as the the
applications piled up I found that
almost no matter what job I applied to I
was being met with a resounding silence
it’s easy to get lost to feel lost when
you’re in a period of transition like
this I’d had a perfectly good job and
I’ve voluntarily walked away from it but
now I couldn’t seem to convince anyone
in these companies that a career
nonprofit ear had something to offer
them I spoke with some folks in HR who
told me that in all likelihood I was
probably being filtered out by applicant
tracking systems we call him an 80s and
80s is simply a database of jobs and
applicants and the more sophisticated
versions have automated filters that
search through resumes and cover letters
for keywords specific educational
background specific work experience it’s
like a robot so sometimes I was being
filtered out because I simply wasn’t the
best candidate for the job but sometimes
I thought despite having the kind of
experience that made me a very
interesting candidate maybe I was being
filtered out because I simply didn’t
have the specific pedigree that these
companies and these algorithms are
looking for unless you have a lot of
dot-coms on your resume it’s very very
difficult to get into the most
well-known internet companies these days
so my chance is to make this transition
many people told me we’re nearly
impossible I had two things working
against me one I was up against leaders
in their field so my resume doesn’t
always jump to the top of the pile and
two robots read every application now of
course that’s not true for all companies
but it’s certainly true for many of the
big ones and in fairness I was an
unconventional candidate for many of
these companies but unconventional can
be a very good thing right so I did the
only reasonable thing that a person
faced with this challenge can do I
decided that if they were going to use a
robot to filter me out I was going to
use a robot to force my way in now of
course that’s not actually a reasonable
thing to do but I was lost and I was
determined to be found so I together
this Rube Goldberg ian’s contraption of
web crawlers and spreadsheets and
scripts in order to automate my job
application process it would search the
web for jobs that I’d be interested in
and then it built out a cover letter
that was customized to the job and
personalized to the hiring manager it
sent these applications in batches with
tracking mechanisms built in so that I
could see when emails were opened who
read my resume and who went and looked
at my LinkedIn profile
it was in no way elegant but it was
ruthlessly efficient the very first time
I spun it up I stepped away to get a cup
of coffee and when I came back I found
that I had inadvertently applied to more
than 1300 jobs in the Midwest now I live
in New York City and I had no intention
whatsoever of moving halfway across the
country for these jobs so I did a little
bit of refining until the robot was
working with a little bit more precision
now surely this bot would be massively
more efficient than I could ever be
working just by myself so therefore my
chances of it overcoming the odds that
were stacked up against me I thought
they were pretty good but an interesting
thing happened after thousands of
applications had gone out
I saw no better results in the large and
well-known Internet companies then I had
when I was applying to jobs manually
virtually no success just a whole lot
more of it so you may be thinking of
course you’re getting rejected you can’t
just send out a form letter and expect
to get a response well I didn’t I had
built and designed this robot to
optimize and adjust to lots of different
variables using a/b testing the idea was
I wanted this to act just like an
individual would each application one
job at a time now as a side note I’ve
since learned that rejection and
disappointment can temporarily reduce
dopamine levels in your brain and reduce
dopamine in the brain is associated with
all sorts of things but one really
important one which is depression so if
you think that it’s sad when you apply
for a job and it doesn’t come through
imagine not getting 3,000 jobs
we’ve been told for a very long time
that robots would eventually take over
our jobs but nobody ever told us that
they would be able to bum us out on such
an epic level so I continued to run
these a B tests using subtle and not so
subtle changes in email subject lines
and cover letters and so forth but while
I saw some variation River in response
it really wasn’t much it seemed like
nothing made a difference the
old-fashioned way of applying to jobs
with a thoughtful cover letter and a
resume just seemed tilted against
someone like me someone who didn’t have
the exact pedigree that those algorithms
were looking for and I realized early on
that this just was not going to be the
way that I get my next job but now I was
really interested I wanted to see just
how badly this system was tilted against
someone like me eventually I decided to
just throw the game I ran an a/b test
using a perfectly normal-looking cover
letter and I contrasted that with a
letter that admits right in the second
line that it’s being sent by a robot now
that second letter should either perform
much much better than the first or a
whole lot worse someone shy to be saying
hey I like the cut of this guy’s jib we
should hire him or they should be saying
who the heck does he think he is
and for my purposes I didn’t care which
I just wanted to see that someone anyone
was paying attention and as far as I
could tell from this experiment and
others like it the answer is that nobody
reads cover letters not even it seems
the robots now this was confirmed by a
number of HR people that I’ve been
speaking to a recruiter at Spotify told
me that they get between three hundred
and three hundred and fifty thousand
applications per year is it any wonder
that they have to rely on automation to
deal with that kind of volume and how do
you stand out from a crowd that’s that
big another recruiter told me that in
his experience roughly 80 to 90 percent
of the most senior level jobs are never
even advertised so how do you get into
that crowd still others told me that
their companies posted jobs on all of
the websites but they only considered
referrals and a number of them were
paying their own employees thousands and
thousands of dollars for referrals who
went on to get the job now in many
companies in the United States as many
as 30 to 50 percent of hires come from
referrals and referred candidates are
more than four times as likely to be
hired than non referred candidates so
maybe those companies should just tell
people if you don’t know someone at this
company don’t bother applying go outside
get some exercise play with your kids or
try and find someone who works at this
company and meet them because all of
those things are going to be infinitely
more effective than applying for a job
even on our own website in fact some
people began telling me these dirty
little secrets things like I don’t even
look at people that apply to jobs
anymore I only consider people that I
find on my own while hunting on LinkedIn
now this person is openly admitting that
they don’t consider people who’ve
actively self-selected
as interested in that company and
interested in that position and instead
they go out searching for other people
who already have jobs and have shown no
interest in their company so that seems
like a store clerk who leaves a line
full of customers waiting to checkout
and instead is running around the
parking lot asking does anybody want to
buy something another person told me
that a colleague routinely posted
non-existent senior-level jobs on all of
the websites this is strictly to get a
pipeline of information about applicants
that were available for poaching they
posted the same jobs over and over and
over again racking up hundreds if not
thousands of applicants information
despite not actually having a job to
offer I’d been applying to jobs that
don’t exist trying to squeeze my way
through filters that were built to keep
people like me out and competing against
people who had worked at their
competitors and who are friends with
their employees and let’s not forget now
I’m sad at the same time I heard stories
from people who are incredibly
passionate about their careers and
compassionate for people who are
searching for careers one told me I wish
that I could sit down over coffee with
every single applicant that we get but I
just can’t do that and so instead I
never stopped clicking on their profiles
just in case the next one is like you I
learned about companies that are
creating content management systems for
job applicants sort of like an
application tracking system to match the
applicant tracking system that the the
recruiters use others are creating
entire referral networks and some of
them are focusing exclusively on
underrepresented populations I’m still
on the lookout for my next job but I can
say that I’ve had roughly the same
number of interviews from networking
with just a small handful of very
helpful contacts as I did when I had a
bot that
to thousands and thousands of jobs so it
turns out that simple networking has
been hundreds of times more effective
than submitting an unsolicited
application or hitting a click here to
apply now button so what did I learn by
robotically applying to thousands of
jobs well it’s not how you apply it’s
who you know
and if you don’t know someone don’t
bother and also the number of
applications that you put in has no
correlation to whether or not you’ll be
considered for a job and you definitely
won’t be considered for the jobs that
you don’t even get a chance to apply to
but what’s in this for companies what
can they learn from from this experience
well first the sheer volume of
applicants that recruiters have to go
through coupled with measures like time
to fill or cost of acquisition I think
that this forces them into an efficiency
mode that forecloses opportunities on
some very interesting candidates also
transparency is critical
if you’re a company the hire is almost
exclusively by referral just say that
you’ll save your recruiters a whole lot
of time and you’ll do job applicants the
favor of not wasting their time if they
don’t already know someone on the inside
now I mentioned earlier that I’m in my
very first days on the job market and
whether I was applying the old-fashioned
way or by brute force I couldn’t seem to
get my foot in the door
however after telling my story a
peculiar thing happened more than 200
other job candidates reached out to
share similar experiences
dozens of HR tech companies reached out
to me I’ve met with CEOs I’ve spoken at
All Hands meetings and now I’m advising
a number of companies with HR and
recruiting products
overall the robot was a complete and
total failure but in a strange way it
may actually accomplish its task this
project was incredibly fun it gave me
the chance to to be inquisitive and to
break up complicated processes into
achievable steps and to learn new
approaches to old problems but it was in
telling my story that the companies that
I had spent so much time trying to
impress actually became more aware of
what I’m capable of and they came to me
now not everybody has the opportunity to
build a bot that helps them turn the
odds in their favor and that’s why the
most important lesson that I’ve learned
from job seekers and recruiters and a
robot is that the job search process is
incredibly personal and recruiting is
filled with people who are committed to
other people
but we still need to strive to make this
more human and more humane
[Applause]
[Music]
Please follow and like us: