Press "Enter" to skip to content

Insect Metamorphosis: Success through Reinvention | Martha Weiss | TEDxFoggyBottom


[Music]
the dramatic transformation from
caterpillar to butterfly familiar to all
of us from elementary school is quite
simply amazing and the process provides
a tremendously powerful metaphor for all
kinds of change witness the theme of
today’s TEDx event but what is it about
the process of metamorphosis that
inspires such wonder after all every
sexually reproducing multicellular
organism begins life as a single
fertilized egg develops complexity and
emerges into the world as an independent
organism the Acorn develops into a
mighty oak a human fetus spends about
nine months in a warm dark pond before
it emerges as an independent little
human being so why is metamorphosis so
special
metamorphic insects are unique because
they do the whole development thing not
just once but twice first a single
fertilized egg develops into a
caterpillar and then in a second change
that organism transforms into another
self-sufficient independent organism for
us then the process of metamorphosis can
represent a major transition or a second
chance a message that it’s not too late
to change in my research at Georgetown
I’ve been studying insect behavior and
insect learning for a long time and
these questions have led me to the study
of metamorphosis I look at metamorphosis
on a biological level and I’m interested
in what changes and what if anything
persists between one stage and the next
originally caterpillars and butterflies
were classified as two completely
separate organisms and why wouldn’t they
be after all they’re totally different
inside and out because they’re a dad
did for entirely different jobs the
caterpillar is a feeding specialist it’s
job is to eat leaves and get fat that’s
it the butterfly on the other hand is in
charge of reproduction and dispersal it
uses its long tongue to feed on
high-energy nectar to power its flight
and it’s beautiful wings are used to
attract mates and then also to fly long
distances to deposit their eggs in new
places
these big differences between larvae and
adults are in fact the key to what makes
a lifecycle of complete metamorphosis so
tremendously efficient the division of
labor means that the two stages don’t
need to compromise in function and can
evolve the traits best suited to their
particular tasks in fact once this
strategy of a division of labour evolved
280 million years ago it gave rise to
the most successful groups of insects
and indeed of animals on earth it’s not
just caterpillars and butterflies that
undergo complete metamorphosis also
beetles flies and bees ants and wasps
undergo this complete transformation
life cycle along with their associated
grubs maggots and larvae so what’s going
on inside that chrysalis many people
assume that the caterpillar turns
entirely to goo and that the butterfly
is made from scratch but that’s not what
happens although some of the caterpillar
is in fact broken down and an amino acid
rich soup is used to build the butterfly
not everything dissolves some structures
are retained and remodeled and the goo
Goo’s is around some important
scaffolding little structures called
imaginal discs which contain the starter
cells of antennae when
and other adult features were already in
place when the tiny caterpillar first
crawled out of its egg these cells start
dividing when the larva is close to few
patient when the caterpillar is big
enough a hormonal cue lets it know to
shed its last larval skin revealing the
chrysalis beneath recently scientists
have been able to use new technology to
look inside a living chrysalis during
the actual transition from caterpillar
to butterfly and what we see is really
startling in this slide the blue lines
are the tracheal tubes or breathing
tubes which provide air to the tissues
and you can see that from day one the
tracheal tubes are in place and they
don’t really change the gut shown in red
shrinks and gets narrower to accommodate
a different diet but it’s present the
whole time it’s remodeled it’s not
reinvented so clearly some things change
and some things stay the same but what
happens in the area of brains and memory
I study insect behavior in my lab and as
I was and as I studied caterpillars
learning odors and butterflies learning
colors shapes and patterns I started to
wonder would it be possible to train a
caterpillar to something that the
butterfly could still remember so my
student Doug Blackistone and I examined
this question using the tobacco hornworm
we exposed the caterpillars to a mild
electric shock in association with the
odor and then we tested the caterpillars
in this y-shaped maze we put the
caterpillars in the front and gave them
a choice of that same odor and fresh air
and the caterpillars that had been
exposed to the odor
with the shock avoided the odor other
caterpillars that had not had that
aversive association didn’t care and
visited both arms equally okay so the
caterpillars learned but what about the
butterflies what were the moths rather
what would happen after metamorphosis so
we let the caterpillars pupate waited a
month and then tested the moths in the
same y tube apparatus with the same
odors what we found was that the moths
that had come from the caterpillars that
had learned to avoid the odor also
avoided the odor so the memory did in
fact transfer across metamorphosis we’re
not entirely sure exactly what the
mechanism is but clearly memory can
persist from one stage to the next
providing a kind of a mental bridge
between larvae and adults which brings
us back to the question of why
metamorphosis is such a resonant
metaphor for us in addition to the
reassuring idea that change is possible
and that a second chance awaits us the
fact that the dramatic transformation
unfolds in private means that only the
changer needs to know what’s happening
and can wait until they’re good and
ready for the big reveal the little bits
of adult structures that are present in
the hatchling caterpillar suggests that
the potential for change is contained
within us and the retention of Metamora
of memory across metamorphosis reassures
us that changes not withstanding we
remain the same individual before and
after not a bad crop of lessons from a
crawling caterpillar thank you
you
[Music]
Please follow and like us: