Press "Enter" to skip to content

Innovation through Diversity | Rocío Lorenzo | TEDxMünchen


fifteen years ago I thought that the
diversity stuff the women’s stuff was
not something I had to worry about it
was something an older generation had to
fight for in my university we were 50/50
male-female and we women tended to have
the better grades so well not everything
was perfect diversity in leadership
positions was something that would
happen naturally over time right not
quite
while moving up the ladder BC making it
to partner I started to realize how
often I was the only women in the room
and how am a genius leadership still is
many leaders I met sort of diversity has
something to comply with out of
political correctness or in this case
the right thing to do but not as a
business priority they just did not have
a reason to believe that diversity would
help them achieve their most immediate
pressing goals hitting the numbers
delivering the new product the real
goals they get measured by my personal
experience had been working and stuffing
diverse teams that while requiring a
little bit more effort at the beginning
diverse teams tended to bring fresher
more creative ideas so I wanted to know
are more diverse organizations really
more innovative and can diversity be
something more than political
correctness and really become a real
competitive advantage for organizations
so to find out we set up a study with
the Technical University of Munich we
surveyed I hope this works
oh it works great we surveyed 171
companies in Germany Austria and
Switzerland and as we speak were
expanding the study to five additional
countries and an additional thousand 500
companies we asked those companies
basically two things
how innovative they are and how diverse
they are to measure the first one to
measure innovation we asked for
innovation revenues innovation revenues
are the share of revenues they’ve made
from new products and services in the
last three years so we did not ask the
companies how many creative ideas they
have or how much they spend in
creativity but rather if all of that
translates into products and services
that make the company more successful
today and tomorrow to measure the second
one to mention diversity we hadn’t
looked at six factors migration
background age education and gender as
well amongst others and we asked which
percent of the management including
middle management possess such
characteristics while preparing to go in
the field with with those questions I am
with the team to discuss well what do
respect us our resolved and we were not
optimistic to put it mildly the most
skeptics on the team they saw a real
possibility that nothing would come out
of this and most of the team was rather
on the cautious side so we landed all
together at only if meaning that we
probably will not find any kind of
relationship between diversity and
innovation across the board
but rather only if certain criteria are
met for example a very open leadership
style that allows leaders to contribute
and speak up freely
a couple of months later the data came
in and the results convinced the most
skeptical amongst us the answer was a
clear yes no ifs no buts
companies that are more diverse are in
our sample clearly more innovative
period now a fair question to ask is the
chicken or the egg question meaning our
company’s really more innovative because
they are more diverse or the other way
around which way is it
now we do not know how much is pure
correlation versus causation but what we
do know is that in our data clearly
companies that are more diverse are more
innovative and if we take the companies
that are higher on the innovation side
they are more diverse – so it’s fair to
assume that it works both ways
diversity drive an innovation and
innovation driving diversity once that
we publish the results we were surprised
at the reaction in the medium we got
quite some attention and it went from
quite factual as you can see higher
female share boost innovation to more
sensationalist titles like estate at
home women cost trillions and my
personal favorite housewives kill
innovation
now there’s no such thing as bad
publicity right so as you can see that I
mentioned generating the most
controversy was gender and on the back
of that coverage we started to get calls
from senior executives wanting to
understand more surprise surprise about
gender diversity I tend to start those
discussions asking those senior
executives well what do you think at the
situation in your organization today and
a frequent reaction I got was well we’re
not yet there but we’re not that bad
so one executive told me for example oh
we’re not that bad at all one of the
members in our board is a woman now and
that might sounds weird to you but he
had a point in being proud about that
because in Germany if you have one women
in your board you’re part of a select
group of thirty out of the hundred
largest publicly listed companies in
Germany the other seventy have an
all-male board and not even one of this
100 largest publicly listed companies in
Germany have a single female CEOs of
today but here’s what really matters all
those few single female board members
alone they won’t make a difference our
data shows that for gender diversity to
have an impact on innovation you need to
have more than 20% women’s in management
to see a difference let’s have a look at
the data we divided in our study our
sample in three groups and as you can
see the results are quite dramatic only
in the group where you have more than
20% women and leadership only there we
see a clear jump in innovation revenue
to above-average levels which basically
means that you do need critical mass to
move the needles and companies like JP
Morgan Alibaba or even Apple are already
above that threshold as of today another
reaction I got quite a lot was
let’s not be too impatient this this
will get solved by itself over time and
and I have all the sympathy in the world
for this point of view because I used to
think like that too now let’s have a
look at the facts now and first let me
give you the good news so the share of
women that are college graduates and
have ten years of professional
experience has grown very nicely over
time as you can see which is great and
which means the pond the pool in which
to fish for five men for female leaders
has increased nicely now according to my
old theory
the share of women in leadership would
have increased more or less in parallel
right now let’s have a look at what
happened in reality and these are the
German numbers it’s not even close so as
you can see the share of women in
management in Germany has remained more
or less constant over the last twenty
years which means I was completely wrong
and which means as well that my
generation the best female educated
generation in history we just have not
made it we have failed to achieve
leadership in significant numbers and
education has just not magically
translated into leadership now that was
a painful realization for me personally
and it made me realise that if we want
to change this we need to engage and we
need to do better now the question is of
course what to do
achieving 20% women in leadership or
even more seems like a daunting task to
many understandably given the track
record but they’re companies that are
making progress that are doing it
successfully if we take for example is
ApS an example the software company they
were in 2011 and 19% women in leadership
yet they decided to do better and so
they did what you do in any other area
of business where you want to improve
they said measurable target and they put
measures behind it now these
self-imposed calls made them think more
creatively about recruiting pools about
new recruiting pools and especially
about developing new leaders and as we
speak they have set himself a target of
30% women in leadership for 2022 so
experience shows it’s doable and at the
end of the day it all burns down to two
decisions that are taken every day in
every organization by many of us who to
hire and who to develop and promote now
nothing against women’s networks
trainings mentoring programs it’s all
good but at the end of the day it’s two
decisions hiring and promotion that sent
the most powerful change signal in any
organization now I never set out to be a
diversity advocates but here I am I’m
actually a management consultant but now
my goal is to change the face of
leadership to make it more diverse and
not so that leaders can check a box and
feel like they’ve been political correct
or complied with something but because
they understand they understand the
diversity not only gender diversity but
all of their mentions of diversity make
the organization more innovative better
and by embracing diversity by embracing
diverse talent we are providing true
opportunity for all thank you
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: