Press "Enter" to skip to content

In the Age of “Fake News”, What’s Real? | Kaylee Laakso | TEDxNMU


now this evening we’re gonna be talking
about fake news in crafting the delivery
of this talk I wait at least 10
different ways for how to frame it I
wanted to make it entertaining or even
story like perhaps and then I thought
about politics do I include them do I
throw them out what do I do with them
because I know that this is a
potentially contentious topic and it has
largely been filled with polarizing
political banter and then what I
realized I really wanted to do was drive
home its importance no not the
importance of my talk nor the importance
even of fake news in a general sense but
the importance of breaking through the
effects of fake news in all senses to
reopen dialogue because that’s what this
is really all about dialogue and now the
type of discourse I’m talking about is
that which is often disregarded or
rejected dialectic I want to see people
with different backgrounds viewpoints
and beliefs on subjects come together to
establish the truth because only through
the exchange of ideas large small
conflicting complimentary and everything
in between will be grower understanding
and knowledge but doing this as a
challenge we are naturally predisposed
to have a greater liking for those we
have more likeness with so to
deliberately go out of our way and
secret others with whom we may have
drastically different opinions from is
out of the ordinary
and just as we often socializing groups
of like-minded people we tend also to
consume news media from like-minded
sources and this is we would like to
spend a bit of time exploring a few
concepts starting with what is fake news
now we’ve heard allegations that the
entirety of mainstream media news
networks as being fake news providers
CNN ABC CBS NBC The Washington Post in
The New York Times
have each been vilified by select
politicians over the past 18 months for
being fake news and relatedly a threat
to our country now these are
exceptionally strong words
so begs to question the veracity of
these accusations to start to answer
this let’s look at my working definition
of fake news fake news is deliberately
false information or misinformation that
is guised as being truthful and deceives
the consumer into believing the story
and as you may have noticed I said that
this is my working definition of fake
news as a term has become popularized in
association with politics and image
attempts at defining it are also
constantly shifting some now are looking
at sensationalistic terms or image based
terms to define it but really where we
stand right now is with no universally
accepted definition of fake news the
perhaps was more important than defining
it narrowly is understanding it broadly
and even beyond that being aware of it
holistically now with that said let’s
get back to our investigation into these
news networks so are these mainstream
media news networks they’re being
accused of being fake news really
promoting fake news stories know by and
large of course they’re not but what
they are all inherently doing within
their reporting is incorporating their
biases their opinions and their agendas
to one extent or another and while
American journalists are ethically bound
to seek the truth and to provide a fair
account within the reporting this does
not mean they do not make mistakes or
that they always succeed in eliminating
their biases byesies exist in all of us
and each of us here today we hold
something called an implicit bias this
sits within the subconscious of who we
are it’s tailored to each of us uniquely
and will last and more for lifetime
within us but outside of this something
known as explicit bias may also exist
and this is when we on a conscious level
hold a prejudice or preference for a
group portion or thing
over another and because the entirety of
news is sourced written released and
promoted by people there’s a natural
inability to strictly report the facts
then when media networks tend to sway
too heavily to one side or another
something known as media bias may emerge
however media bias does not equal fake
news media bias may take many forms and
in many ways is what separates American
news networks into leftist conservative
sensationalist and so forth actually
perceived media bias may arise from the
networks or the journalists use of tools
and techniques such as framing and
agendas now the media does largely look
to set public and political priorities
while also shaping opinions through
their reporting one element that they do
this with is agenda setting an agenda
building this comes from communication
social science theory to explain the
media’s use of building up importance or
on certain subjects or topics within
that reporting and it’s heightened level
of importance within these news cycles
is intended to translate to an
importance within our minds they build
up what we should be consciously
thinking about so be kind of summarizes
and saying that the media uses
agenda-setting to tell us what to think
about and then once we have this
established hierarchy of what to think
about the media employs a concept of
priming and this helps us build and
really recall our knowledge around a
subject now priming incorporates aspects
of triggers or benchmarks or these
mental cues and the more that we see
different bits of information all
pertaining to one subject we start to
build an understanding around it as well
as our sentiment and perception of it so
priming is something that’s particularly
used with building up a favorable
unfavorable or otherwise opinion of
politicians
among other things then outside of this
one key aspect that is used within all
media is framing now framing is when we
are able to develop a broader
understanding of material within certain
subjects this is accomplished through
selecting specific information and then
presenting it in a story like fashion
and these stories are great because they
allow us to more personally connect with
a material and through this personal
connection we’re then able to have our
status are then able to satisfy or
cognitive and emotional demands okay
with all this said let me just touch on
this one more time just summarize it
really briefly I’ll release news media
as part of an agenda whether it be
corporate political issue specific or
another it is deliberately framed and to
highlight issues and information that
someone wishes to make important to us
and our biases beliefs and ideals are
targeted so that the news we consume
made me our cognitive and emotional
demands and thereby satisfy our needs
for information and leave us with no
need to search further so this in large
part may explain why we tend to seek and
consume news information from sources
that largely already fit our point of
view emphasizing this we are
frighteningly more likely to believe a
legitimately fake news story that suits
our predispositions than we are one that
is truthful but challenges them if
everything that’s routinely targeted by
politicians as fake news really is
nothing more than skillfully crafted
truthful information why do they spend
all this time with these accusations I
suppose there could be a number of
reasons let’s think about the term fake
news for a moment what thoughts come to
mind what images fill your head how do
you feel when you hear the term fake
news and now let’s take a moment to
consider term we’ve briefly discussed
how does that one sit comparatively a
bit lackluster isn’t it
and so while politicians are really just
attacking media bias they opted instead
for the flashy or crass or term of fake
news for the impact of it and for its
implied finality bias is known to exist
in everyone in everything so it’s
accepted and tolerated to an extent
fakeness on the other hand is not when
something is deemed to be actually fake
it’s written off and discarded and once
something has been discredited and
disregarded there exists no need to
discuss it further so politicians wield
their potentially damaging allegations
of fake news in an effort to cut
discourse between their supporters and
those who prescribe to beliefs and
viewpoints that are generally more in
line with the network’s they wish to
smear in essence they use these
allegations to discredit anyone who
holds opposing viewpoints to theirs or
may make arguments that are unfavorable
to their agendas and to put even more
plainly and with a touch of hyperbole
they’re seeking to silence the
opposition for the idea of an opposition
to exist and to be targeted the first
has to be an accepted belief in their
being teams or lines of Allegiance
in-groups and out-groups
and as we’ve all seen from the run-up to
the last presidential election through
today politicians are particularly quick
in defending their camps their ardent
supporters at about any cost
conversely there was a forceful and
their demonizing shaming and
discrediting of those who do not support
them the concept of if you’re not with
me you’re against me has seemingly
pervaded all aspects of our society now
news media is being targeted by
politicians in this effort while
simultaneously being exploited by them
to the point of question leading our
society the polarization in America is
at a high and it continues to be stoked
by politicians at the highest of levels
concerning Li this threatens notions of
understanding and compromise which in
turn threatens ideals of cohesion and
collective progress and when we are not
together we are weaker and when we allow
ourselves to view those with opposing
political viewpoints to ours as the
enemy we close ourselves off from
opportunity the opportunity to learn to
grow to accept and to formulate a better
solution for all of us now we cannot
allow ourselves to be either on a
winning team or on a losing team life in
society simply cannot work this way
we’re a nation of many people from all
backgrounds and all walks of life so
this requires us to account for all
viewpoints not only those were
comfortable with but also those we’re
extremely uncomfortable with and we can
do this but to do so we have to start
with a desire to connect to connect to
the issues and to connect to the people
on all sides of those issues this means
we need to see through the tools and
techniques that are employed by the
media and the politicians that continue
to drive us apart we need to recognize
that flashy headlines that we often look
at and think that we’re building up some
level of knowledge with but they’re
really just that they’re flashy
headlines they’re catchy words they’re
lacking in content in context so we need
to read beyond them we need to see
through the provocative language that’s
used within media as well as some of the
big-name experts and all those neatly
packaged stories to really get to the
core of the issues because at the core
of every news story are the facts in
every article and report that is
properly sourced meaning not verifiably
fake they’re in there now it may take a
bit of time and a little bit of digging
but we can find them we can canvas a
wide variety of credible news we can
consult international
national liberal conservative moderate
an independent programming and across
this broad canvas of media will find
these consistent bits of information
that will come out and he’s consistent
bits we can say are likely the facts and
even better we can add to this pile
facts would we know that something’s
referencing a meeting or a hearing or
legislature we can get to the source
documents we can find transcripts and
recordings and actually understand the
words behind all the reporting that we
see this flash of language in we can
dive a bit deeper even and look at who
the experts are what the polls are where
the statistics are coming from we can
really start to build our understanding
of the issue or issues at hand and
collectively use all of this to build up
our independent knowledge of these
issues and subjects whether or not
they’re in line with those that are
promoted by the media now this will our
us with an ability to not only
independently process the news
differently but it will enable us to
create actual dialogue on the topic with
people from all backgrounds we can come
together from varied points of belief
and political affiliation to discuss
what’s central to the topic and to all
of us the facts we get to establish the
truth we seek together rather than
adopting it from someone else’s agenda
so pick a topic and let’s start talking
thank you [Applause]
Please follow and like us: