
close your eyes and for a moment
best imagine would you exchange your
space for Damocles you would have heard
about the story of Damocles number CLIs
was the guy just close your eyes think
about it whether you exchange your space
with demo please you’re sitting on this
big blown there is this banquet table in
front of you it has everything on that
plate you have all your fantasies your
all your fancies everything you love you
want it to have ever in your life is
right in front of you there is only one
small discomfort there is this big heavy
shining sharp sward which is hanging on
top of your head which is hanging by a
thin air and at any point of time this
thin hair is getting stretched and at
some point of time one thing is certain
that that hair would break the SWAT
would come swooshing down and there
would be blood on the floor would you
like to switch places with demo please
would you I don’t know there could be
some of you who might still want to who
yeah yeah so I have a good news and a
bad news for you the good news first you
don’t need to exchange your space with
them uh please the bad news next because
you are sitting on the space of Damocles
there is a sword which is hanging on top
of your head the hair is getting
stretched it’s only a matter of time
when that SWAT would come down and you
would see the blood splattered on the
floor every guy in this auditorium every
guy who’s guys or girl who’s in the
auditorium and outside the auditorium is
today sitting at the same place where
that Greek guy or he would call Damocles
was sitting at some point of time we’ve
we were such a long way we have this
insatiable desire for
energy that we have plundered our earth
we have destroyed our ecosystem we have
reached a stage where we have ourselves
started that doomsday clock and this
Doomsday Clock has already started
picking we need to find solutions for it
we are running against time and we need
to find a way by which we can get energy
in mortality we are I would
lots of biologists are still trying to
work out mankind immortality I think
mankind immortality would also come one
at one point of time but that’s for
another subject but clearly energy
immortality would come far before
mankind immortality comes but today what
I will do is I’ll take you to this
fascinating journey of what is happening
all the events which are happening
around you which are shaping this world
yeah eight minutes eight minutes it
takes for the rays of the Sun to start
off from the surface of the Sun and to
reach the earth and the earth has always
been thirsty always been hungry for
these rays of Sun for our food as well
as health I’ll come to health later on
and food later on but today Sun also
feeds all our energy needs Sun
increasingly is feeding energy needs
across the world yep in less than two
hours the amount of energy which earth
receives is equivalent to the energy
requirement of the whole of the world
for the full one year
just imagine the the scale is too high
typically a year has eight seven six
zero hours it’s a simple calculation of
24 in 50 65 so a year has eight seven
six zero hours and I’m only talking
about two hours from those eight seven
six zero hours yes within those two
hours we would get the sort of energy
that we require to a
energize all the factories in this world
all the houses in this world to work
your smartphone’s your music system your
cars your mobile phones your
telecommunication equipment everything
let’s assume that we we’ve got a magic
wand by which we can do that even if we
can’t do it in 2 2 hours if we are able
to do it in 4 hours if you are able to
do it in six ten fifty hundred well the
ratios are so big that clearly the
consequences are something that we just
can’t imagine we’ve just scraped the
surface of this brilliant phenomena me
if the Sun is pretty far off so at times
it looks very tiny but actually it is
very big the diameter of the Sun is
practically hundred times the diameter
of the earth you can imagine the scale
that I am talking about if you see the
Sun and if I were to consider the Sun as
a hollow sphere there would be one
million earth which can be dropped into
the hollow sphere one million earth we
can calculate 1 million is n lakhs so n
lakh earths we can drop into a big
sphere of Sun so the consequences are
immense
because need to figure out how to how to
how to exploit the potential we’ve still
not we’ve still not scratch the surface
as I said yeah have you ever tried to
take out the ketchup from the bottle
at first the ketchup refuses to come out
you tap a little maybe some drops of the
ketchup would come out you give the same
amount of intensity the same amount of
tap to the neck of the bottle and some
globules would come out maybe after six
or seven or eight taps the whole of the
ketchup comes out this is something
which in if you would have the Malcolm
Gladwell book it is called the tipping
point the tipping point means that while
you are doing the same amount of effort
suddenly the consequences are nonlinear
the consequences are not proportional
the amount of effort that you are
putting in we are similarly doing the
same thing in solar in solar you keep on
putting the same effort and there would
come a time when the ketchup would start
flowing out of the bottle we’ve still
not reached the place when the catcher
this is disruptive we are we are very
comfortable when we talk of linear
progressions you very comfortable when
we talk of arithmetic progressions the
trouble starts off when we talk of
geometric progressions when we talk of 1
2 4 8 16 32 64 128 that’s the trouble
what happens our mind is not tuned to
thinking visualizing what happens when
geometric progressions takes place and
we are as we talk we are sitting in a
space we are sitting in a world where
geometric progressions are taking off so
we just learned visualize we just can’t
visualize what the world would be in the
next two years in the next four years
because the geometric progression would
take it to those boundaries with our
beyond our imagination we would have
never expected it so we have a lot of
technology which is happening around us
which we clearly call it disruptive and
not only I would not call it disruptive
I would also call it a game changer
because whatever assumptions that we’ve
taken so far in life one by one those
assumptions would get broken as we move
forward I I started off my talk saying
that with respect to health and food we
always owe it to the Sun we actually
never knew how to convert one type of
energy into another type of energy there
see around 200 years back or 400 years
back or even now what’s happening is
that you typically have a human body
like mine there is a juicer inside my
body
we call it metabolism and through the
metabolism we take in organic compounds
which we call it food our body’s the
engine the food gets converted into
energy
and we use that energy for using our
muscle and then there is a movement of
hand and feet which takes place where –
where do we get these organic compounds
from if you go through the food chain at
the end of the bay at the bottom of the
food chain you have plants and what do
plants do plants have chlorophyll plants
take energy from the Sun and they
convert to again a juicer called
photosynthesis and they convert the
solar energy into organic compounds so
it was a complicated process sometime
around 100 years back so you had the
plants which were taking in solar energy
using photosynthesis converting solar
into organic compounds and then the
human beings used to eat them and then
we used to convert the same thing from
carbohydrates to energy it was a long
process it was from solar on one hand to
the energy on the other one we just
needed something that by which we can
convert solar directly into energy we
have done this now one thing which solar
has done is that solar today has
democratized energy earlier on energy
was only accessible was only available
to few who could afford it it was very
difficult to haul all that electricity
to the remote parts of the world to
where no transmission lines can go and
actually if you if you see Sun is free
to all there is there is no there is no
permit which is required there is no you
don’t need to pay any toll tax or you
don’t need to pay any attached to any
government to exercise your control over
the Sun it is the most it is I would say
it is the most democratic institution of
all you want to have sunlight there is
nothing no government in this world can
sort of inhibit you from using the
sunlight so Sun in some way has
democratized the whole of energy you
would have seen nations have gone to war
nations have gone to war or because
somebody wanted to capture
fields which belong to another nation we
have seen nations quarreling over water
water distribution that the people
construct huge amount of dams so that
they don’t want to share water but with
respect to Sun it is free for all so in
a way in a way we are moving towards the
space we are moving towards time when
clearly democratization of energy would
happen and Sun would be responsible for
it in a way Sun would be responsible for
removing violence from this earth
because much of the violence has
happened in the past so many years
because of the need to have the sources
of energy as energy security of number
of Nations once you eliminate it then
part of the problem gets resolved we
have we have all of these all of these
spectrum of possibilities and as far as
solar is concerned it is at just one end
of the spectrum of possibilities on the
other end of the spectrum of
possibilities you have you have this
coal oil and gas all of this the coal
oil and the gas we have only a limited
quantity of back on earth we are we are
losing out on coal oil and gas it is
available in the finite quantity at some
point of time we would run out of all of
these three and that time would come
sooner than later and typically what
happens is so whenever you want to base
your future you want to base your future
on something which is optimistic
something which is certain you can’t
base your future on something which is
uncertain because only when the future
is certain if you see the history of
mankind only when the future is
optimistic only when we have belief in
your future that the progress has
happened if you were to see around 400
years back human mankind used to think
that the pie is limited the pie that we
need to share and you would see that the
only thing
we used to do was fight wars against
each other because they knew that if I
want to become bigger I want to eat the
other guys pie but with respect to
energy when it came in the pie suddenly
become bigger and now the mankind was
able to comprehend that the pie can also
become bigger and in order to mean to
prosper it’s not necessarily that I
would eat the pie of other because the
pie is getting bigger and I can make my
pie bigger so in a way if you see all of
these all of this coal oil and gas they
are not as bad as it looks on the face
of it in the last 200 years huge amount
of prosperity has happened huge amount
of progress have happened the progress
that we have received in the last 200
years is far more than what mankind has
done in the last 70 thousand years and
when I talk of 70 thousand years if you
see the history of mankind
its it was around 70,000 years back like
the cognitive development of human being
took place when we started thinking
around twelve thousand years back we
started agriculture so the Agricultural
Revolution came in but the huge amount
of prosperity and the growth and the
advancement in advancement in technology
in industrial growth came in when all of
these fossil fuel came in the steam
engine changed at all
the steam engine gave a complete
different definition to the efficiency
which was heathrow unknown to mankind we
could do the work which he used to do in
months we could convert it into days so
in a way the steam engine completely
changed the narrative and we need to
thank all the fossil fuel for changing
that narrative we have we have done so
much advancement in the past so many
years only because fossil fuel was there
yeah but at the same time once the
fossil fuel came in we all know what
happens we all know that
you burn fossil fuel you have carbon
dioxide which is coming out
you have sulfur dioxide which is coming
out your nitrous oxide which are coming
out and I don’t need to sort of talk
about the whole effects of global
warming the polar ice cap melting the
rise in the sea levels the low-lying
areas getting drowned it is a sort of an
epilepsy scenario that apocalypse is
coming sooner than later fossil fuel is
the new sugar yeah if you see the sugar
would not kill so many people the sugar
would kill huge amount of people and the
same amount of people would be killed by
the fossil fuel itself it is addictive
we’ve become so much addicted to fossil
fuel for a simple reason that we want
huge amount of energy and we never need
seem to be satisfied from the quantity
of energy that we required it’s like
it’s like it’s like diabetes you know it
is bad for you but still you can’t move
away from the sugar the pills would not
do any longer we have reached the stage
when we need to explore several other
things before we find a solution for
energy immortality we owe it to our
future generations as I said we cannot
give something which is uncertain we
cannot give something which is of short
supply to our future generations our
future generations required something
which is sustainable they required
something which is which would last then
it
they require something which would last
generations after generations we have we
have spectrum of possibilities I think
within within the fossil fuel on one
side and the solar on one side solar can
only give you energy as long as the Sun
is there but what happens and the Sun is
not there wind can only give you energy
when wind is there what happens when
wind is was there so you would have you
would have alternative narratives
sometimes
when Sun is there you would have
alternative narrative coming into play
and sometimes when the Sun is not there
yeah so so it’s not that the Sun is the
ultimate solution Sun also has an
Achilles heel as I said if the Sun is
not shining you would not get solar
energy if wind is not blowing you would
not get wind energy ah hydropower is
there you can combine hydro with wind
with solar
if you if you have studied hydro power
hydropower is something which is similar
to storage but why it happens that
whenever there are conflicting
narratives which are there which are in
either end of the spectrum we get into
polarization we polarize ourselves the
guys I’ve been on the other side of the
table
the people who feel that fossil fuel are
the only solution to this world they
would say that all the renewable guys
are romantic guys they would never be
able to satisfy the energy needs of the
world and they are just going around
propagating their theory whereas the
solar guys the evangelistic zeal would
always keep around and start saying that
all these fossil fuel are just making
the Doomsday Clock picked longer why
can’t we why can’t we sit why can’t we
figure out that it’s not necessary that
we need to bind ourselves ground
ourselves in the opposing narrative
there is always a chance of a compromise
there is always a chance of something
which is in between and this is
something which is in between is that
what we are talking about today so you
have coal on one end of the spectrum you
have oil on one end of the spectrum and
you have solar on the other end of the
spectrum are these the two only two
alternatives of course not you have to
walk through the whole spectrum to
figure out which is the possibility that
suits me in the best as as the topic of
today’s discussion says grey matters
this
Dre is the bridge gray is the bridge
Gray’s the cooperation and gray is
handing giving a hand of cooperation
from the black to the white whenever
there is a conflicting narrative which
is there this grey comes into play we
don’t know the solutions there are many
solutions which are there in this gray
zone we would talk about biofuels we
would talk about hydropower we would
talk about tidal power we would talk
about fusion fission so there are lots
of things which are there in this gray
zone I would like to bring a concept of
fragility and antifragility I think all
of you who’ve not read
massives book he talks about fragility
and I’m an MP fragility it typically
talks about concept of rules principles
and values and he talks about that rules
are always very fragile you can make
thousand and one rules but they are
always exposed to manipulation and you
can always break them so as far as the
new non-renewables are concerned they
are on one end of the spectrum they are
fragile we can keep making rules that we
will have better technology we would
reduce the consumption we would have
less pollution but rules are rules they
can easily be broken on the other end of
the spectrum are virtues it’s something
like honesty is a virtue you can make
rules that I would not steal I would not
I would not tell a lie but those rules
can always be broken but with respect to
virtues once we say honesty is the best
policy that’s a virtue which is embedded
then you can’t move around that’s
antifragile there is no other narrative
than bang the virtue so I would say that
renewable is a virtue a non-renewable is
a fragile and renewable is a antifragile
as I said Solar is a virtue it used to
it used to happen quite a sometime back
that number of people used to consider
solar as a just a hobby but in the last
five six years solar from being a
technology which was ex
answer suddenly has become very
competitive renewables were always
expensive non-renewables were always
cheap
they were always affordable but you had
an issue with them the issue that you
had with them was that they created
pollution which destroyed our
environment whereas when you talk about
solar solar was renewable solar didn’t
destroy the environment but the problem
with solar was that it was very
expensive over a period of time the
solar prices have come down from around
four years back it was around eighteen
rupees per kilowatt hour now it is near
about four rupees so this is what I call
geometric progression this is what I
call disruption this is what I call sort
of moving towards the tipping point we
don’t come around for something which
cost you only seen prices going up
you’ve never seen prices coming down but
you have suddenly have a situation that
for years but somebody would never have
imagined that somebody did something
which cost a peon rupees today would
cost for rupees please think about it
tell me even a single item that you use
in your daily life where the price has
come down from 80 into four if the price
comes down by half then it comes from 80
into nine then again it comes down by
half then it becomes nine to two and a
four and a half so we have travelled
from eighteen to four and a half or four
and now less than four in just four
years time so that’s the that’s the
scale which I am talking about and I
think we are moving towards we are
moving towards the path of energy
immortality and whenever we go towards
that path of energy immortality there
would always be shades of gray and if
you actually see on a lighter note what
is the day today Saturday what’s the day
tomorrow and you just slowly spell
Sunday what does it mean have you ever
ever thought that thunder is actually
sunbae
what’s the what’s the Hindi word for son
any some other word Ravi and what is
tomorrow
and what does de Vivar and Sunday
connote to you it’s a day off and what
what does Sunday mean to you and what
else you feel happy you feel relaxed you
feel that you all your bodies have gone
off so Sunday and Ravi were it’s been
it’s been going on for centuries you
always knew that Sunday is a day when
you can relax when you can leave
everything to the Sun and you can relax
and have all your worries away so thanks
a lot thank you [Applause]