
human rights lawyer in full-time legal
practice in London and the highest court
in the land still convened some would
say by an accident of history in this
building here I met a young man who had
just quit his job in the British Foreign
Office when I asked him why did you
leave he told me this story he had gone
to his boss one morning and said let’s
do something about human rights abuses
in China and his boss had replied we
can’t do anything about human rights
abuses in China because we have trade
relations with China so my friend went
away with his tail between his legs and
six months later he returned again to
his boss and he said this time let’s do
something about human rights in Burma as
it was then called his boss once again
paused and said oh but we can’t do
anything about human rights in Burma
because we don’t have any trade
relations with Burma this was the moment
he knew he had to leave it wasn’t just
the hypocrisy that got to him it was the
unwillingness of his government to
engage in conflict with other
governments intense discussions all the
while innocent people were being harmed
we are constantly told that conflict is
bad that compromise is good that
conflict is bad but a consensus is good
that conflict is bad and collaboration
is good but in my view that’s far too
simple a vision of the world we cannot
know with our conflict is bad unless we
know who is fighting why they are
fighting and how they are fighting and
compromises can be thoroughly rotten
if they harm people who are not at the
table people who are vulnerable
disempowered people whom we have an
obligation to protect now you might be
somewhat skeptical of a lawyer arguing
about the benefits of conflict and
creating problems for compromise but I
did also qualify as a mediator and these
days I spend my time giving talks about
ethics for free so as my bank manager
likes to remind me I’m downwardly mobile
but if you accept my argument it should
change not just the way we lead our
personal lives which I wish to put to
one side for the moment but it will
change the way we think about major
problems of public health and the
environment
let me explain every middle schooler in
the United States my 12 year old
daughter included learns that there are
three branches of government the
legislative the executive and the
judicial branch James Madison wrote if
there is any principle more sacred in
our Constitution and indeed in any free
Constitution than any other it is that
which separates the legislative the
executive and the judicial powers now
the framers were not just concerned
about the concentration and exercise of
power they also understood the perils of
influence judges cannot determine the
constitutionality of laws if they
participate in making those laws nor can
they hold the other branches of
government accountable if they
collaborate with them or enter into
close relationships with them the
Constitution is as one famous scholar
put it an invitation to struck to
struggle and We the People are served
when those branches do indeed struggle
with each other now we recognize the
importance of struggle
not just in the public sector between
our branches of government we also know
it too in the private sector in
relationships among corporations let’s
imagine that two American Airlines get
together and agree that they will not
drop the price of their economy class
air fares below 250 dollars a ticket
that is collaboration some would say
collusion not competition and we the
people are harmed because we pay more
for our tickets
imagine simulate two airlines were to
say look airline a will take the route
from LA to Chicago an airline B says
will take the route from Chicago to DC
and we won’t compete once again that’s
collaboration or collusion instead of
competition and we the people are harmed
so we understand the importance of
struggle when it comes to relationships
between branches of government the
public sector we also understand the
importance of conflict when it comes to
relationships among corporations the
private sector but where we have
forgotten it is in the relationships
between the public and the private and
governments all over the world are
collaborating with industry to solve
problems of public health and the
environment often collaborating with the
very corporations that are creating or
exacerbating the problems they are
trying to solve we are told that these
relationships are a win-win but what if
someone is losing out let me give you
some examples a United Nations agency
decided to address a serious problem
poor sanitation in schools in rural
India they did so not just in
collaboration with national and local
governments but also with a television
company
and with a major multinational soda
company in exchange for less than 1
million dollars that corporation
received the benefits of a month-long
promotional campaign including a 12-hour
telethon all using the company’s logo
and color scheme this was an arrangement
which was totally understandable from
the corporation’s point of view it
enhances the reputation of the company
and it creates brand loyalty for its
products but in my view this is
profoundly problematic for the
intergovernmental agency an agency that
has a mission to promote sustainable
living by increasing consumption of
sugar-sweetened beverages made from
scarce local water supplies and drunk
out of plastic bottles in a country that
is already grappling with obesity this
is neither sustainable from a public
health nor an environmental point of
view and in order to solve one public
health problem the agency is sowing the
seeds of another this is just one
example of dozens I discovered in
researching a book on the relationships
between government and industry I could
also have told you about the initiatives
in parks in London and throughout
Britain involving the same company
promoting exercise or indeed of the
British government creating voluntary
pledges in partnership with industry
instead of regulating industry these
collaborations or partnerships have
become the paradigm in public health and
once again they make sense from the
point of view of industry it allows them
to frame public health problems and
their solutions in ways that are least
threatening to most consonant with their
commercial interests so obesity becomes
a problem of individual decision making
of personal behavior personal
responsibility and lack of physical
activity it is not a problem when framed
this way
of a multinational food system involving
major corporations and again I don’t
blame industry industry naturally
engages in strategies of influence to
promote its commercial interests but
governments have a responsibility to
develop counter strategies to protect us
and the common good I want to give you
another example moving from high-profile
collaborations to something that is
below ground both literally and
figuratively
and I just before I do I should mention
the mistake that governments are making
when they collaborate in this way with
industry is that they conflate the
common good with common ground when you
collaborate with industry you
necessarily put off the table things
that might promote the common good to
which industry will not agree industry
will not agree to increased regulation
unless it believes this will stave off
even more regulation or perhaps knock
some competitors out of the market nor
can companies agree to do certain things
for example raise the prices of their
unhealthy products because that would
violate competition law as we’ve
established so our government should not
confound the common good and common
ground especially when common ground
means reaching agreement with industry
so again to the example below ground the
hydraulic fracturing of natural gas
imagine that you purchase a plot of land
not knowing the mineral rights have been
sold this is before the fracking boom
you build your dream home on that plot
and shortly afterwards you discover that
a gas company is building a well pad on
your land that was the plight of the
halowatcher family within a very short
period of time they began to complain of
headaches of so
throats of itchy eyes in addition to the
interference from the noise vibration
and the bright lights from the flaring
of natural gas
they were very vocal in their criticisms
and then they fell silent and thanks to
the Pittsburgh post-gazette where this
image appeared and one other newspaper
we discovered why they fell silent the
newspapers went to the court and said
what happened to the halowatcher x’ and
it turned out the halowatcher x’ had
made a secret settlement with the gas
operators and it was a
take-it-or-leave-it settlement the gas
company said you can have a six-figure
sum to move elsewhere and start your
lives again but in return you must
promise not to speak of your experience
with our company not to speak of your
experience with fracking not to speak
about the health consequences that might
have been revealed by a medical
examination now I do not blame the
halowatcher x’ for accepting a ticket or
leave it settlement and starting their
lives elsewhere and one can understand
why the company would wish to silence a
squeaky wheel what I want to point the
finger at is a legal and regulatory
system a system in which there are
networks of agreements just like this
one which serve to silence people and
seal off data points from public health
tech experts and epidemiologists a
system in which regulators will even
refrain from issuing a violation notice
in the event of pollution if the
landowner and the gas company agreed to
settle this is a system which isn’t just
bad from a public health point of view
it exposes hazards to local families who
remain in the dark now I have given you
two examples not because they are
isolated examples there are examples of
a systemic problem I could share some
counter examples the case for example of
the public official who sues the
pharmaceutical company for concealing
the fact that its antidepressant
increases suicidal thoughts in
adolescence I can tell you about the
regulator who went after the food
company for exaggerating the purported
health benefits of its yogurts
and I can tell you about the legislator
who despite heavy lobbying directed at
both sides of the aisle pushes for
environmental protections these are
isolated examples but they are beacons
of light in the darkness and they can
show us the way I began by suggesting
that sometimes we need to engage in
conflict
governments should tussle with struggle
with at times engage in direct conflict
with corporations this is not because
governments are inherently good and
corporations are inherently evil
each is capable of good or ill but
corporations understandably act to
promote their commercial interests and
they do so either sometimes undermining
or promoting the common good but it is
the responsibility of governments to
protect and promote the common good and
we should insist that they fight to do
so this is because governments are the
guardians of public health governments
are the guardians of the environment and
it is government’s that are guardians of
these essential parts of our common good
thank you [Applause]