Press "Enter" to skip to content

Imagine a power station. Now imagine something better. | Alice Bell | TEDxImperialCollege


hello yeah I’m Alice and ever since as a
teenager I’ve worked in things to do
public engagement with science and
technology because I’ve been really
aware and really inspired by the fact
that there are big gaps between
scientists and engineers and medics and
everybody else and we could all gain
from being a bit more connected to them
I think as members of the public those
of us who aren’t part of those
communities there’s a lot we can learn
from them but also they could probably
learn a bit from talking to some other
people too and in for the last few years
I’ve been specced really focusing on
climate change in energy because that’s
the thing that I kind of wake up in the
morning most scared about most
passionate about and for the last two
years I’ve worked for a charity called
10/10 and what we do at 10:10 is we we
try and create opportunities for people
to take action on climate change because
I think this is probably something that
a lot of you feel I have wanna take
action on climate change think that’s
maybe something you should do but not
really sure how and maybe you’ve got
phone DS like oh if you just whip up a
little meat it’ll all be fine we’ve all
met the people who’ve watched too many
watch Kasper ECT many times this year
but you might be thinking well you know
that sounds like a good idea but I’m a
bit skeptical of this and you probably
will be right because you know what yes
you should if you want to take action of
climate change one big way you can do
that as an individual is thinking about
what you eat and that might lead to at
least decreasing animal products I’ll
let you go away and think about that but
it’s not even if you took a really
radical impact on your own diet and
convinced loads of other people to do
that that’s still not going to test
they’re not going to do it there’s so
many other multiple different things and
multiple different places we need to
take action so you look like one of
those today we talk about power stations
and I’m going to invite us to think
about what we might do when we build a
power station and what other things we
might do when we build a power station
then just create power and how that
might collectively lead to a slightly
better relationship with electricity
which will help us ultimately take the
kind of action on climate change that we
need and that we want so we all need to
think of that think of a power station
it might look a bit like this which is
the emoji for power bytes and this is
not the emoji but the emoji for power
station is a lot like this the cooling
towers possibly loads of steam coming
out of them probably something quite far
way that you might just see from a train
it’s kept really far away from towns
away little keeping all the noise and
pollution understandably away from us
but also keeping it away from our kind
of consciousness you might think about
hazards and like terrifying scares or
for a Simpsons farm you might think
about three-eyed fish and evil owners if
a nuclear power family might be an or
eat that are posted are images of
nuclear power and popular culture a full
of three-eyed fish and evil owners but
we can we can it’s okay to demand
something better than not to want
something better than that and we as
humans are creative and powerful enough
to do something better than that so you
might have heard quite a lot in the news
about a tidal lagoon idea that’s planned
for Swansea if you haven’t maybe that’s
probably a lucky escape from you having
to go through all the political rhetoric
around but it’s quite interesting
project I would suggest to go and google
it later because it’s pretty interesting
and a lot of discussion about whether
they build this this tidal lagoon in
Swansea has centered around how much
money or cost and it’s like something
around 1.3 billion so it is
understandable that people are thinking
about how much money will cost or
they’re thinking about how many jobs it
might create latest big arrests I heard
last week was that there will be 30,000
total jobs in Wales but we are in an
election period so we probably should
take any rhetorics about jobs with quite
a big pinch of salt but still
potentially will create a lot of jobs in
the area and in areas where some jobs
and good jobs would be really well
really needed but one of the things
that’s important about that and the
other thing is that you see the
economics first and then the climate
change comes second and I think that’s
that’s dangerous we need to start
thinking about climate change right up
there with the economics or potentially
thinking about it before because there
is no economics in a dead planet and the
the climate change is part of the
economics there’s lots of ways in which
we allow our economics to kind of be
separated from the climate change
question but climate change is key to
and again there’s a lot of figures that
go around it kind of depends on whether
we think that a swansea tidal lagoon if
it happens it’s just a one-off or if
it’s the start of a fleet of them and
how fast that we have this fleets but
one figure suggests that if we have ten
built by 2030 we could decrease carbon
emissions in the UK by a third this is
potentially incredibly powerful in terms
of UK tackling climate change but
there’s something even more important
about what there something that goes
alongside of Bo
those important things for economics and
climate change that totally gets missed
out and most of the conversations about
sponsee but I want to think about today
and that’s that they don’t just want to
build something that generates
electricity they want to create a space
that people would go to so in this
artist’s impression we have all these
people like playing in these water pools
and you can see it’s very beautiful
architectural design what’s not in there
is a bit of art that they’ve already
commissioned that will be part of it and
if you go on the website you can read
their really intricate plans for
wildlife so one of the controversies
around tidal goons are some of the ways
in which they’ve been done in the past
have not been good for wildlife and it’s
certainly something you really need to
think about when you go to any big bit
of energy infrastructure is the impact
on the local environment but the people
behind this plan they don’t just want to
think about how they can minimize impact
they have a whole programme of habitat
protection and recreation and actual
creation that will not only create
spaces for wildlife which are important
in themselves but also critically create
flood defences which because although
this will help us tackle climate change
is we’re already locked into quite a lot
already as the gate becoming more and
more important and will create an
opportunity for the people who will
visit this area because they want it to
be a visitor center with our and culture
and spaces people to hang out actually
an opportunity for people to connect
more with nature we don’t think about
power stations as as being somewhere
that would actually help improve our
relationship with nature but the people
behind this feel that they can do that
and I think that I find this quite
inspiring that’s really easy to dismiss
these like wildlife plans and art
projects to go around projects like this
as a bit of like PR fluff on top and I
think that that’s dangerous though
because if we dismiss our social and
cultural relationship with energy then
we lose all sorts of things that we need
in order to get the economic plans and
the climate change plans in the
engineering projects and the jobs and
everything off the ground in fact I’d
argue that one of the reasons were in
such a mess in terms of our relationship
with energy which is leading to all
sorts of economic problems and worries
about climate change and habitat problem
this destruction of wildlife habitats
and us motion a feeling that we don’t
get to see birds so often and all sorts
of other problems it’s because we have
such a bad social and cultural
relationship with energy now these
people have Swansea aren’t just the only
people are dreaming like that this is
project at this amazing organization
called land art generator initiative or
lucky base in the States but they work
around the world and every two years
they run a competition where they invite
people to imagine renewable energy as if
it could be beautiful and their archives
are if you want somewhere to just
procrastinate on the internet for a
couple of hours their website is amazing
they have these archive of weird and
wacky designs and a lot of them are
design fiction so this one is meant to
be these balloons are actually meant to
be solar PV cells that kind of open and
move up and down I think the description
was slightly confusing but well it the
thing is I think this is fiction I
really can’t imagine an engineer begin
to do this now although if someone in
the room is a PV engineering wants to
tell me that I’m wrong I’d love to hear
it because I’d love to build this but
what’s important about this is not just
that it’s it’s not so much that it could
happen it’s more than it’s a challenge
to the way that we think about what
energy would be so this isn’t meant to
be met just somewhere that people would
hang out in a park and jump for joy with
me that they have in their weird
architectural model pictures that
they’ve cut and pasted in but it’ll be
playable so it’s not just beautiful but
playable but it’s not just people who
are magining stuff it’s not just
blueprints it’s not just a swansea and
laggy there are people who are already
thinking about this and doing it already
so this is if you’ve got Iceland the
country not versiv market they have
loads of geothermal power they’re really
into it it’s amazing and one of the
things they have is by one of the big
jerk geothermal plants not far from
Reykjavik is a spa and this is a spa
next to a power station it’s incredible
if you ever act near that totally go and
the Eden Project in Cornwall is trying
to do a geothermal project the moment
which they hope will also power heat
Earth’s moon poles so someone was
telling me that in Iceland they have
there’s lots of really really good
swimmers and one of the reasons for that
is that they have loads of sort of more
every day level than a spa a lot of
their sleep they have loads of dream
pools that are very cheap and easy to
use because they’re powered from the
geothermal
people are literally you know swimming
in the heat of the thing you know their
electricity generation
there’s also acid it if any of you’ve
ever been to the Redditch in the
Midlands there is a swimming pool in the
Midlands that is power at the heat is
for the swimming pool to keep the water
warm comes from reusing the heat that is
created from a crematorium next door
that’s probably the most genius those
slightly disturbing versions there’s a
people big guy wrote hey this is cool
it’s a wind turbine turbine in Norfolk
that you can climb up so but like you
can climb up the monument in London you
can climb up this and there’s an amazing
view so cool
if there is a school that has solar
panels that are kind of fused with
stained-glass windows and this churches
that have things like that too which I
just think is incredibly beautiful too
about imagining renewable energies if it
could be beautiful how beautiful is that
this is one of my favorites this is a
solar tree in Bristol there are two
cemeteries in Bristol this is one on
some allotments and the one in the
centre of Bristol I suppose in the main
square you can charge your phone off it
so there like a statue actually and it I
think it’s quite important that this is
Bristol that it’s out because Bristol
has a lot of controversies around
particularly one statue they have of a
slave trade owner slave trader called
Edward Coulston it’s been in the news
recently cuz they finally renamed in
Colston Hall that used to be named after
him it’s decided this just really
inappropriate to have it named after him
this leather statue outside there’s all
sorts of controversies regular in
Bristol about taking this statue down I
think what what a great alternative to a
statue of a slave trader they’re gonna
have stuff on our streets as meant to
sort of make us think and talk about
stuff to do with our culture when that
statute Ledger Coulson was partners
because people thought he was you know
some people thought he was great and he
contributed loads to the area well we
take that down why not replace it with
something like something that relates to
electricity because so much of our lives
rely on electricity why not create
beautiful pieces of public art that the
make us think about that make us talk
about that and that are usable we can
charge our phone on one of the other
things I really love about the solitaire
is that the panels on the solar tree
were actually made in workshops DIY
solar panel making workshops so you get
off cuts of solar panels I’ve actually
my necklace if it weren’t interfere as a
microphone my necklace is just a little
off part of a solar panel that’s just
been put into a piece of jewelry but
there’s a group called demand energy
equality that run workshops when they
get a load of off cuts and they’re
little bits of solar cells are really
brittle so one of the first things I do
need is workshop as they get you to like
just break them and it feels really
naughty because you’re like baking a
solar panel but we never get to have
that kind of interaction with
electricity generation just to break
this little bit of a spare solar panel
but then to get there the bits that they
think are more usable and they wouldn’t
let you break and you’ve put them
together in sequence it’s just like
really simple electronic
so the kind of stuff you might under
school with a soldiering iron and it’s
great because adults do it and they do a
spread shop and it gets to talk about
what the electricity stuff that we let a
school that we’ve forgotten what’s the
what I mean have to remember it and
think about and I think but when you
learned about in school it was still
quite abstract but when you think about
it in your twenties or thirties or
fifties or sixties
you’re thinking that’s the stuff I’ve
been using and the edits used to build
that I pay and the concerns I have about
my future and my children’s future and
all that sort of tied up it becomes
different when you learn this stuff is
that we learn this stuff as an adult and
so what some beautiful about these
workshops is they they give a chance for
people to reconnect a very physical
level and also they give an opportunity
over the course of an afternoon for
people to talk to each other about
electricity so this photograph is
actually taken in Barton Moss which is
mr. Alford and there’s a community
that’s been heavily affected by the
controversies and Load protests
and I think it was summer 2014 and after
the protest erupted died down
some of the people who live locally who
were anti-fracking got together and said
well we don’t want fracking what do we
want and this solar panel making
workshop was part of the process of them
just sitting and sitting and talking to
each other about what they wanted and in
the end they decided they actually got
together and they did a fundraise and
they brought some solar panels and
installed them in a local school and if
the solar carts haven’t come in a couple
years ago they would be building much
bigger projects than that that would be
you know kind of completing with the
kind of fracking project that were that
they were being though being told that
they should accept in their local
environment and so in that one workshop
though it’s going to make a mobile phone
charger like the solar tree is that’s
not going to solve the energy problems
of a city that’s not these little phone
charges are not gonna in themselves
solve the problems of that community
that are being faced with fracking but
what they can do is they can help create
opportunities for people to talk about
energy which themselves can then unlock
larger conversations really important
ones this is also key not far from
Barton mosses is great in Manchester the
Old Trafford area this church they’ve
turned their church into a Power Station
look at the acquitting faces they love
their solar panels and they used the
money that they make of the solar panels
to create something called a sunshine
grants fund which has funded things like
Food Bank food parcels for asylum
seekers and beehives the local
allotments those
beautiful so they brought the solar
panels by doing a by offering shares in
the solar panels so people is sort of
giving their savings to a bank which at
the moment face it they’re not going to
get much interest back off anyway and
the bank they will invest in oil and gas
and coal and armors and stuff like that
they can put it in these solar panels
and they’ll get a good rate of interest
back they’ll be investing in their local
community I mean the other prophets of
it sort of lining bankers pockets or
energy companies pockets it helps fund
things like be hires and allotments and
support for asylum seekers I just think
that’s a beautiful way of thinking about
energy and again those solar panels and
themselves I’m not going to stop energy
problems a great immense stir but they
also help unlock further conversations
an important work that we all need to be
engaging I think a bit more in there’s
another one my favorites this little
girl sleeping snow if her solar panels
which was still generating electricity
even in the snow she lives in Balkan
which is another community that’s been
affected by fracking in fact they were
the site of the first protest in
the UK in 2013 and if you’ve ever been
to welcome you might well have been
thoroughly on the train to Brighton and
it’s this tiny tiny little village you’d
probably never been because it is really
small and it’s really friendly and it’s
really lovely it’s a sort of
quintessential English village everybody
goes about quiet everyone knows their
neighbors and then when the
protest came everything changed and I
like bottom offs where basically most
people in the area hated fracking they
really were angry about these companies
coming in with their drills it’s
a bit different it probably was a
similar pattern to the nation as a whole
which is that a good chunk of people
hate sucking another chunk of people
quite liked it and then there’s a big
chunk of people in the middle who don’t
really know and in Bochum because you
had this big fight everyone kind of
starts to take sides and for the first
time in years people stopped talking to
each other it’s really horrible
so even after all the wackos went
because in the end they didn’t frack and
the protesters left and the press had
left and the politicians who were trying
to make political capital out of
everybody left this poor little village
was left quite bruised and so a group of
them got together and thought well what
are we going to do if we aren’t going to
be faxed and also what they were made to
face questions that most of us don’t
have to face which is where what is our
energy future where is it going to come
from whose lives are going to be
inconvenienced by it but I’ll talk about
that they wanted some it’s going to
bring the community together and
realize that although kind of
divided everyone everyone really quite
like solar and they also like the idea
of community owned solar so again with a
share issue that was worked from the
local community and so they first
brought a share they built this first
small share offer to put some solar
panels on a counter temperature this one
then they did see local schools and I
recently heard that one of the schools
just bought a battery so they’re doing
solar and storage as well which is like
amazing to see a state school doing like
that something that innovative normally
you know we don’t it’s sort of seen as
like just rich tech enthusiasts gets do
it but anyway they did in the school and
then ultimately they developed a solar
farm nearby which would match the
electricity demand of the whole village
and the village next door so this isn’t
just playing around with little trees
that you can you know charge your mobile
phone and they were really thinking big
and this is a picture of a solar farm
it’s not the one that they built but
it’s one that they visited this
photograph was taken on a trip where
they went to a lot of local solar fire
weather works particular one is oXXO
farm to learn a lot about it and think
about what kind of said a farm they
wanted and they wanted one because they
had the opportunity to build their own
one they could think and the first two
actually they weren’t going to do a
solar farm at all they wanted to just do
rooftop solar on the village which is
what a lot of people say I often get
this like when are you post up at work
on on Facebook we get people go I hate
solar farms where I can’t you put it on
roofs well you can’t put them on roofs
but so in France can also have a lot
done well can be really important and
that was a kind of journey that the
people of Balkan went through because
they started off thinking oh so much
should be on roofs and then they started
thinking about what impact it was having
on their village if it was covered in
solar panels and like putting them up
and also just where they’d be positioned
and what the opportunities of a solar
farm town wall could be and then they
changed and they were like no we really
want a solar farm but we’re going to do
it really well so they went to this one
because it’s um it’s almost like a it’s
almost like a nature reserve as well as
a solar farm which if you do them well
can be and their space for the sheep to
graze so it doesn’t necessarily disturb
doesn’t take land from farm crop
production or food production and they
thought about where the hedges would be
positioned so it wouldn’t affect the
views but also could create habitats for
badgers and hedgehogs and they could
have wild flowers and it’s a really
beautiful thing that they made really
really beautiful just take it back to
the cities this is a massive power
station well I mean
and power stations farms it’s not huge
but as a solar estate is pretty cool its
4,400 solar panels across Blackfriars
Bridge if you ever go through black fry
station we’ll get off it my only is it a
really cool station that’s on a bridge
so you can think is it north or south
and reverb it’s it is a power station
because it’s covered in solar panels
that apparently generates half of the
energy that the station uses the trains
going through is a whole other issue but
my charity 10/10 is working with
Imperial on that at the moment so watch
that space next door to that is actually
a place where we used to generate
electricity in cities we used to
generate power in cities this is one of
our old power stations this is what it’s
now take modern the old backside power
station well beautiful things about that
is if you go up to the chimney now all
the way up top the new viewing platform
that opened last year and let down you
can see that they’ve installed some
solar and it is becoming a power station
yet again this is a school that’s got
solar and this is what I really love the
schools that one solar really take their
educational opportunity there’s loads of
schools that just rent their roofs out
to Sony developers and the kids don’t
even know the solar panels on there but
the best schools really take it as an
educational opportunity and the
important thing I think about that it’s
not just that the school is gentlemen
that school is quite a major solar
installation they’ll be generating a
fair bit of their electricity and I’m a
good solar generator and a really sunny
day the kids will see it and yeah we’ll
call it your super generating but on a
day like today where they’re only
generating a bit that opens up questions
for the kids to think about where else
is our energy coming from where’s our
heating coming from this gas power
that’s not even coming from the solar
panels and they start up other questions
about electricity and heat and other
power generation that they wouldn’t
otherwise be talking about so these
solar panels are not just powerful
because they generate electricity but
they open up opportunities for us to
discuss where the rest of our
electricity is going to come from and
that I think is a pet most powerful
thing for these things so yeah these
solar there are all sorts of things that
we could do with other kinds of power
generation in fact the guy who installed
those solar trees has got a really good
idea about some wind trees that he wants
to do in Liverpool and if anyone knows
anywhere we can get funding for that
tell me but we need more more
opportunities for us to engage socially
and culturally with energy all these
little solar panels around the country
are totting up to a huge amount of
electricity but in themselves it is not
going to be enough every little bit
counts yes and it’s great that they’re
doing that but what is especially
important is also that they open up
opportunities for us to talk about where
the rest is going to come from so we
dismissed our social and cultural
relationships with energy out our peril
and less imagine some power stations
unless imagine something different as
imagine this as well as big cooling
towers even if we also still have the
cooling towers let’s imagine kids
playing with solar panels like that –
thank you
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: