Press "Enter" to skip to content

I’m Proud of Lying to Your Doctor | Andrew Roblyer | TEDxTAMU


two years ago I was sitting in a

hospital room waiting for doctors and

nurses to come in my attention was foken

s focused on a bassinet beside me my

mother was bent over that bassinets

because inside of it was my

three-month-old daughter Hannah 24 hours

earlier Hannah had been brought to the

ER by her nanny because she had drowned

in the bath when I arrived at the ER a

couple hours later after I found out

they informed me that they actually

suspected the nanny of shaking her and

drowning her to try and cover it up but

none of that mattered in the moment

because the end result was the same

Hannah had no brain function at least

that’s what they told me then because of

how young she was they had to wait 24

hours and perform the same brain

function tests again to ensure that she

was actually dead so we waited my wife

was in the Navy and was deployed on a

ship at the time so she wasn’t going to

make it back in time despite her best

efforts so my mom was there with me

about 20 hours later the doctors and the

nurses came back into the room performed

their tests again and told us the news

Hannah was gone

anguish is the best word that I can

think of to describe the emotion that I

felt right then but I also remember a

lot about the nurses in the room I

remember that they didn’t really know

how to handle me or this situation a

couple of them were standing over in the

corner they were quiet seemed frozen in

place not sure what to do or say one of

them came over and tried to comfort me

by putting her hand on my shoulder and I

remember yelling at her and pushing her

away and she kind of responded like I’d

burned her and then a couple of them I

remember giggled and looking back on it

I’m sure it was that giggle that

sometimes happens when we don’t know

what else to say or do but at the time

that’s not what it felt like it felt

like they were laughing at me at us in

general I didn’t feel particularly well

cared for in that moment but that was

the point of this simulation

because yes it was a simulation he

gigantic lie if you will I was an actor

Hannah was mannequin in a bassinet my

mother was played by another actor who’s

not actually related to me even the

hospital chaplain that was in the room

with us was played by yet another actor

but before we talk about this simulation

this lie let’s exercise our imaginations

for a minute imagine that you’re a

nursing student or medical student and

this is your first encounter with loss

and trauma and it’s the real world with

real people and real feelings what if

you didn’t know that that’s how you

would respond to those situations if you

didn’t know that you were one of those

people that shuts down and doesn’t know

what to say or do what about if you’re

one of those people that gets upset when

someone rejects an offer of help that

you give them or what about if you’re

one of those people that giggles

nervously when you don’t know what else

to do

if those nurses had been experiencing

this in the real world for the first

time they would have learned the hard

way that involuntary reactions and

behaviors can still have very real

impacts on their patients and their

patients families but because they were

in a simulated environment because they

were essentially being lied to they were

safe to learn and to grow so back to the

simulation like I said there were three

of us in that room that were actors and

acting is and kind of at strictest sense

a lie right after all I’m pretending to

be someone that I’m not when I’m acting

but it’s a lie that the audience agrees

to and is part of right and that’s why

artists and actors specifically in this

instance can tell us important truths

about ourselves and about the people

around us that we may not otherwise

realize so that’s why I’m proud of lying

to your doctor because I’m proud of

being an artist who works in the

healthcare field in the healthcare field

actors like myself are known as what are

called standardized patients or SPS for

short you know SPS were first used by a

man named dr. Howard barrows in 1963 so

relatively recently when he hired an

actor to portray a patient for medical

students who was paraplegic and had

multiple sclerosis now if you know

anything about paraplegia or MS then you

know that both of these things involve

physical manifestations or physical

symptom ology of these conditions so you

have to have a lot of control over your

body to mimic those symptoms if you

don’t actually have them additionally

this actor was responsible for learning

basically the life story of this patient

so that if the students asked them

questions about the care they’d received

or what their experience was like they

could answer those questions

realistically but dr. Howard barrows

used this actor in another way as well

in addition to being someone that the

students could evaluate he was

evaluating the students he could give

these students feedback about what it

was like to be their patient about what

it was like to receive care from them

before they ever interacted with a

patient like the person he was

pretending to be in the real world

since that time standardized patients

have become much more widespread across

the world they’re very common in medical

school training now to varying degrees

depending on which medical school you’re

talking about and they’ve expanded

nursing program to use standardized

patients including the one here at Texas

A&M University

even veterinary medicine programs

sometimes use standardized patients like

the one here at Texas A&M after all

that’s happened communicate with the

human companions of their animal

patients right so standardized patients

have become so important to medical care

that in the United States one of the

tests that medical students have to take

on their way to receiving their medical

license

involves what I call the SP gauntlet or

twelve standardized patient encounters

over the course of eight hours which

means that they’re evaluating twelve

patients but they’re also being

evaluated by twelve patients on the

level of care they receive their

communication their rapport building

skills etc so who are these standardized

patients who are these people that are

so important to medical training well

the short answer is that they could be

anyone right some of them are like me

and have a lot of formal training and

acting and theater and acting teaching

some of them are former or current

educators or former

current healthcare professionals future

educators future healthcare

professionals and some of them are none

of the above some of them are people

that are passionate about the work that

we do to help prepare the next

generation of healthcare professionals

but they don’t necessarily have a

history of artistic training like I said

I have a lot of formal training I

graduated from a and I’m with the Duke

in theatre arts and I actually got into

work being as a standard being a

standardized patient by googling the

phrase day jobs that use acting skills

because I knew as most artists do that I

probably wasn’t gonna make a living as

an actor at least not right away and so

I needed a day job to pay the bills but

I wanted to find a job that would

complement and build on the skills that

I was already developing as an artist

and I stumbled across a blog from this

Google search that I can’t find anymore

otherwise I tell you which one it was

written by a woman who lived in the San

Francisco Bay Area talking about this

really cool job she had where she

basically pretended to be sick all day

and medical students came in and

evaluated her so I looked into it more

and found out that we had a program here

at A&M and got involved because of my

background and because of my training I

now all trained standardized patients as

well as trained people who trained and

standardized patients so I’ve moved

beyond simply just performing as a

standardized patient but anyone can be a

standardized patient it takes work it

takes dedication and the skill set that

it requires is more artistic than

technical in nature but just because

it’s artistic doesn’t necessarily mean

it’s easy so to demonstrate this you’re

all going to become standardized

patients for just a moment okay so I

want you to imagine that you are going

to portray a patient who has a really

really bad headache and when I say

really really bad headache I mean a

headache that if you were to rate it on

a scale from zero to ten with zero being

no pain and ten being the worst pain of

your life it is a 10 out of 10 headache

okay

maybe you’ve had a headache like this

before maybe you’ve had a migraine maybe

you have experienced a really bad

tension headache or maybe you’ve woken

up one morning after having a little too

much fun the night before right so I

want you to imagine

okay close your eyes if you need to you

don’t have to but I want you to imagine

that kind of tension that pounding that

you feel in the center of your head when

you have a really bad headache maybe as

you start to imagine this you’ll notice

your face kind of starting to tense up a

little bit right because it just that’s

what happens when you feel pain as your

body kind of tenses up so as you imagine

that pain that tension moving down into

the back of your neck right maybe you

start to imagine those muscles tensing

maybe you even start to actually feel

them tensing okay and then I want you to

think about the fact that light is going

to hurt your eyes right it’s going to

make the headache worse you don’t want

to move too quickly or too much in any

part of your body because that jostles

your head and hurts you right so you’re

going to keep everything tense right and

maybe you notice your breathing start to

change because when we’re in pain we try

to hold everything still and keep

everything from hurting right and maybe

as I’m talking and as these loud sounds

are coming in that’s hurting your head

even more so you got to talk a little

bit more quietly right oh okay now I

want you to imagine holding that level

of pain for 20 minutes at a time up to

10 times per day because that’s how many

students we can see in a given day it’s

not easy right it takes skill it takes

practice it takes training to be able to

use our bodies in this way right but not

only that you have to maintain that

level of pain for that long and you have

to be able to listen to this entire talk

and give me feedback on it afterwards so

you have to be paying attention to it

well enough that you can give me

feedback about how I can improve after

I’m done talking so like I said not an

easy skill but that realism is really

really important and that’s where the

term is standardized in standardized

patient comes into play here at Texas

A&M University we have five campuses of

our Health Science Center we have

medical students on all five of those

campuses and nursing students on two on

all of the campuses the students should

be receiving and are receiving the same

education right they should be going

through the same curriculum learning the

same material taking the same tests we

don’t want one campus to

have more educational opportunity it’s

been another campus so we have to

standardize it which means that let’s

say we’ll use this headache example we

have campus a where we have standardized

patient a and student a and campus B

where we have standardized patient B and

student B and on campus a student a

walks into C standardized patient egg

like this and as soon as they walk in

without even talking is the student can

see that this patient is in a lot of

pain right think about how you would

want this position this young medical

student to interact with a patient like

that especially if you were that patient

you want a sense of urgency you’d want

them to engage with you you want them to

keep their voice down you want them to

acknowledge your pain as quickly as

possible right all of these skills that

we may be evaluating as a standardized

patient that we may be wanting to

examine whether these students have

developed these skills now imagine that

on another campus we have a student

that’s seeing the exact same case with

all of the same information a 10 out of

10 headache right all of the same things

except that when they walk in the room

they walk in and they see a patient that

right extremely different experience

especially because if you saw a patient

like that who said that they were in ten

out of ten pain you might think that

they were lying in order to get pain

medications right and so the skills that

this student is going to be tested on

are going to vary very drastically from

the skills that this student is going to

be tested on so we have to make sure

that we’re standardized but not only

that not only do we have to be

standardized across all of our campuses

which means that everyone has to be able

to all of these performers these actors

these artists who work as standardized

patients they have to be able to be at

the same level as each other

we also have to be at the same level

with ourselves which means that of those

ten encounters that we may see

throughout the day we don’t want our

first one to look like this and our last

one to look like this right because we

want every student to get the same

experience which means that we have to

maintain that level of realism for the

entire day now it’s not to say that

students can’t learn from less realistic

simulations we use mannequins in the

simulation center we use

computer programs and video that virtual

reality virtual reality is becoming a

bigger thing in the simulation world but

I like to think of those simulations as

living textbook simulations right there

taking a textbook and kind of bringing

it to life but a human being is not a

textbook we’re not even close to a

textbook right and so even though we

have to be standardized there’s

something incredibly important about the

realism that artists can bring to this

process as an example of this one of the

people that I work with now at the

clinical Learning Resource Center at the

Health Science Center used to be a

nursing student and she went through a

simulation identical to the one that I

told you about at the beginning of this

talk with me and my daughter Hannah and

she talks about the fact that not long

after she went through that simulation

she actually experienced something

almost identical to that in the real

world and she says that had she not

experienced something that felt so real

in a safe space she never would have

been prepared for that situation when it

happened in front of her but because

she’d been through it once in a very

real way with a real emotions and a real

experience a very well told lie if you

will she was able to maintain her cool

under pressure

respond to the family in a way that was

meaningful and engaged with them and

cared for them in a way that they could

appreciate and receive in that moment so

this is the importance of art in

medicine a field that we don’t

necessarily think of as being in any way

artistic right we think of it as being

clinical as being scientific you might

think you might have heard the acronym

stem right science technology

engineering and math but I think it’s

incredibly important that we don’t

forget to add the a right because steam

right steam powers our medical field

it’s what broadens the horizon of

medical care it’s what what improves the

future of the care that we will receive

as patients because none of us want to

be cogs in a machine right so how do you

as a nurse who has a lot of patients to

see in a given day on a hospital floor

make every single one of them feel like

they matter and that they’re not just a

number on your clip

bored standardized patients artists can

help you teach help you learn that but

if you’re a medical student are a doctor

and you have to explain a really

complicated diagnosis and a complicated

plan of care to a patient and you want

to make sure they actually understand

you and that they’re not just saying

they understand because they’re

intimidated by you as a physician right

standardized patients artists can help

you learn that what if you’re trying to

deal with an angry patient and you need

to learn how to get at the core of that

anger right rather than just treating

the symptoms of the anger but really

truly help that person feel understood

about the thing that is causing them

pain and frustration and anger

standardized patients and artists can

help you learn how to do that right so

this is the point of using artists in

healthcare we bring a truth to these

students and your future doctors by

telling lies by pretending to be someone

that we’re not and by doing it

extraordinarily well so that’s why I’m

proud of lying to your doctor that’s why

I’m proud of teaching other people to

lie to your doctors extraordinarily well

we lie because you shouldn’t have to thank

Please follow and like us: