Press "Enter" to skip to content

I’m a Liar and So are You | Damon Routzh | TEDxEmory


hello how is everyone doing today how is
everyone doing today isn’t that magical
where I can ask the question twice and
you get louder right I’m just kidding I
hate it we’ve all had that before
funnily enough though the only question
I hate getting more than the dreaded so
Damon what are you gonna do with your
philosophy degree is the how are you
question I mean think about it how many
times a day are we asked this question
one two three dozens of times right and
even more interestingly is that this
question is being asked by everyone and
importantly everything right so friends
family strangers and even Facebook I
started asking me the question before I
post statuses so here I am trying to
post my which one was this eight status
of the day and I am thrown into
seemingly existential crisis I mean
seriously
sounds silly but the question how are
you has real impact on how we think of
ourselves think about when is the last
time we’ve actually taken this question
seriously you don’t go to a psychology
professional or a therapist it’s
probably been quite a while so that’s
why I’m here today I want to talk to you
all about how asking and answering the
question how are you can impact not only
our thinking of ourselves but it also
offers somebody else and ourselves the
ability to distort the reality of our
mental health and well-being so I’ve
broken this problem up into three
components and the first thing I want to
talk to you all today about is what I
call the problem of the asker so a Spurs
of the question how are you done to be
pretty in genuine right I mean you can
think about how many times it get asked
this question today if I had a dime for
every time I was asked a question well I
probably wouldn’t need to be justifying
my philosophy degree to anybody right
and so it has real impact and can you
imagine like every time getting asked
the question how are you to have to
disclose your your entire box of
feelings for the day right I mean try
making friends that way it’s not going
to work and assure you that and so this
has real impact on how we’re thinking of
ourselves right and but also how we’re
interacting with others so what we’re
doing is we’re creating a mutual
understanding between that person and
person that the answer should be no more
than one or two words which creates an
genuine conversation so who’s ever been
asked how are you by someone you’ve
never met before right probably almost
everyone I mean seriously imagine
telling them an hour of a story how am i
doing like that’s a huge question right
so what this does what the understanding
that the answer should be no more than
one or two words forces the answer into
a position of lying so think about how I
started the talk right how are you know
how are tea right I mean I got you
excited to lie look what is that right
so there’s real impact here and think
about this too like lying to ourselves
has real implications so think about the
example of like someone losing weight
right so so what happens that person
normally has a very hard time telling
they’ve lost weight this because the
brain takes into account with small
changes that we see on a daily basis and
forms a new self-image similarly in the
situation of lying to ourselves our
brain
takes into account our lies and thinks
differently of how we feel right so
we’re thinking how we’re feeling but
what is not happening is that we’re
changing the way in which we feel so
what this does is it creates the severe
form of cognitive dissonance between how
we think that we feel and what we’re
actually feeling right but the problem
doesn’t stop with just the asker so
answers has a question how are you also
tend to be pretty and genuine think of
how we normally responds the question
how are you
right I’m fine and you what does that
offer us zero insight but it convincing
100 percent deflection rate right but
what does this do
well it’s creating this weird sort of
misunderstanding between that person and
the person so what the question is
meaning right I mean imagine if I were
to respond how are you and I say hmmm
well you know I’m doing pretty well
actually yeah I had a really great day
an amazing lunch oh but let me let me
tell you what Rebecca said what would
you do you would probably be several
hundred feet in front of me because
let’s face that you probably didn’t care
to hear my answer and if you happen to
stay around you would probably have a
can this hurry up face right so what’s
happening then is that answer again is
forced into a position of lying forced
into a position of repeating the
practice of not understanding themselves
but the problem doesn’t stop here with
the answer so let’s think of another way
in which we answer the question how are
you fine
here’s a challenge for you next time
someone gives you the answer fine follow
up with them ask them hmm okay
why are you doing fine today get ready
for some confusion and maybe a little
bit of anger right but justifiably so
see the thing is fine is not an emotion
right so so getting so much explained
like why are you feeling fine it’s a
seemingly impossible task and insert any
active good add blue yellow right silly
when we think about it that way so what
this does is the creation of this new
weird emotion new weird word and
response is widening that gap again
between how we think that we feel and
how we actually feel so we’ve talked
about the problem of the asker talked
about the problem the answer but maybe
didn’t probably print problematize one
more thing alright maybe there’s
something else
maybe we can talk about the problem of
the question so maybe the question is
just a bad question right so here’s a
task for you find a little game
I’m activity when you leave after the
talk or since we all have smartphones
now if you want Google search how are
you responses there you can find 101
creative ways to answer the question how
are you and if you’re really curious how
to kill the job interview by nailing the
question how are you which the answer is
perfect so start using that apparently
right but but what does this tell us
right if neither the asker nor the
answer apparently nobody since google’s
try and ask this question knows how to
answer the question how are you then why
are we asked this question so many times
a day right I mean would we answer and
engage in conversation in a similar
fashion with any other question think
about this
what do you do for a living oh I’m a
doctor into you I mean I wish I could be
talked to and I think some of us wish
that we could be doctors and some of us
are doctors but the majority of us would
be lying right and we can laugh but we
can be like oh that’s funny so if we can
do that with something as extraneous and
small and as a profession why are we so
readily available to lie about something
is integral its mental health and
well-being you should probably do
something about this now what I want to
argue to you it’s not that fixing the
problem of this huge dissonance is going
to be easy by any means right but I do
want argue to you that’s starting to
make small steps for it’s changing the
problem and fixing the problem isn’t
necessarily going to take a psychology
professional or a therapist right we can
start doing it now so let’s start by
fixing the problem of the Oscar for some
reason I don’t know why we just parently
like the word fine or good or whatever
right
so if that’s what we want to hear let’s
start conversations off by saying hi
tell me you’re fine oh okay I’m fine now
you tell me right that’s very weird
right very strange but and it gets to
the point but but it’s not really what
we want to hear probably not so maybe we
can go deeper maybe we can go deeper
into our understanding and understand
the question for what it really is broad
confusing and misunderstood so what can
we do well how about we start asking
targeted questions so questions like
what did you do today what did you enjoy
about your day
have you thought about switching your
philosophy degree there we can start
engaging that person in conversation and
have real dialogue with them and learn
things or we can just say hello and move
on like we probably do anyways but we
can also go further we can ask things
like follow-up questions so why did you
enjoy that part of your day why did you
have a good day are you sure you haven’t
learn about switching your philosophy
degree and in that way not only show
that we’re interested but challenge that
person to understand how they feel why
they feel right I mean it’s gonna feel a
little strange I know but like that’s
what emotions are supposed to do to us
so so we talk about the problem the
Hangout asker now we can address the
problem of the answer so next time
someone gives you the answer of or next
time someone asks the question how are
you I would challenge you to respond do
really care to know or if you’re not
feeling as bold as I would like you to
I’m a huge fan of being bold if you’re
about to give the answer of fine stop
think to yourself what does it mean to
feel fine am I actually feeling fine is
the fact that I stayed up till 3:00 a.m.
thinking about what I’m gonna do with my
future making me feel fine and there we
can start beginning the process of
understanding ourselves so why am I here
today well it’s not to change the way in
which you think changed the way in which
you feel talk anything but what I do
want to try and do
and what I’ve attempted to do is to stop
the constant lying that we’re doing to
not only ourselves with other people
right fixing the problem of mental
health and well-being and understanding
ourselves is probably one of the hardest
things that we will ever have to tackle
in this generation and what I can assure
you is that lying about ourselves to
others and ourselves it’s not going to
be aiding in any kind of solution and I
also want to say you’re probably
thinking Damon this is a lot easier said
than done like I mean this is built in
and I agree if I see any of you during
lunch or if throughout the rest of ten
I’ll probably ask you how you’re doing
but what I will do is come back and say
no just kidding right or if you ask me I
might say tired but then I’ll come back
say no I’m not tired but let me tell you
about my day right it sound crazy but
that’s what we do when we’re trying to
change things but in that way we can
start dismantling this problem in
creating real change towards fixing
these huge huge problems such as mental
health well-being understanding
ourselves so I want to leave you with a
little deal if I have to stand up here
and in life and be proud about my
philosophy degree and not lie about it
then you all are certainly not allowed
to lie to me or anyone else about being
fine thank you
you
Please follow and like us: