Press "Enter" to skip to content

Identity Politics | Sigurd Brekke | TEDxSOAS


I distrust identity politics our cities
causing a tribal divisive and polarizing
political environment which is ripping
us apart and if you’re going to succeed
in this touristic societies we need
people with different identities to
agree but how we’re going to do this
with the use of identity politics how
we’re going to fight discrimination with
discrimination and how we’re going to be
able to speak our truth and one is
afraid of having an opinion based on
your identity unfortunately I see this
current use of identity politics causing
damage to our society right now I don’t
know if you heard about the Robin Hood
scandal in UK but basically from late
1980s to 2010 or 1400 rape and sexual
assault cases happened in this period
the charla victims tried to report these
cases to over hundred local police
authorities but the fair or potentially
being labeled racist may the police look
the other way
so the perpetrators ethnicity most
little Asia made the police local
authorities nor dare to address these
situations when I heard about this a
struggle to grasp with the fact that
this fear was really the reason but in
most cases it was so if we cannot call
out child sexual abuse in this current
political environment is a potential
risk or be labeled racist well then we
have a problem we need to be able to
discuss sensitive issues such as racism
police brutality inequality
globalization migration and gender for
example without being afraid of having
an opinion based on an arbitrary
identity regardless of his skin color
class or gender you should be able to
participate in discussing these
sensitive issues unfortunately it’s not
what I see in this current political
environment let’s me if you look at some
examples so when observing debates
around gender differences and what I
noticed was that people who argued but
certain biological differences between a
man and a woman was then automatically
categorized as AI discriminating as
women supporting the patriarchy or being
gender biased
why not because of their opinion
arguments but there are den today I
struggle with this as the ethical and
political answer is clear everyone
should have the same opportunities of
course but shouldn’t stop us to be able
to discuss biology soberly and or
politicize the issue with the use of
identity politics also been observing
the debates around accurate the use of
gender pronoun I think first of all we
can all agree that discrimination based
on gender identity is all and
wrong but what I saw was that people who
agreed on the issue but I’ll get against
a specific proposed solution was then
judged based on their identity so people
who agreed on the issue argued against a
specific solution from the most
oppressed identity then your identity
was being used against you as an
argument and with this argumentation
how can people different identities be
able to gather around certain social
facts which is essential for our society
to function together if we use our
identity differences against each other
I do not understand also in terms of
discussing police brutality in our
society as a whole I noticed a certain
identities of your less credible to have
an opinion but no questions like how
many people got shot
who shot them what was the color on
their skin how many people died
what was the color on their skin it’s
the only way to understand this to have
a specific identity can one say me as a
white man or me as a black man I know X
Y is set on this topic I say no and if
you think so to be a problem when
discussing something like violence in
our society as a whole
identity or your identity aren’t often
relevant but this is not to say that a
person’s like life experience it’s never
relevant it clearly is
affecting us all for example it can be
used to falsify certain claims like if
someone say Catholics don’t believe in
hell
and you could say no my mom is a
Catholic and she believes in hell
so someone make a statement about a
group which happened to be part of you
might very well be in a position to
falsify this claim based on your
experience but in most cases discussing
facts and data identity aren’t really
relevant we need to be able to gather on
certain social facts which goes beyond
gender beyond skin colour and beyond
cloths and these needs to be challenged
discussed and argued and potentially
improved if you use or view everything
through the lenses of identity we will
not be able to solve any of this issues
sensitive issues together so if you’re
going to use out enter politics how does
it work well it’s all based about even
group realities and each identity group
has his own reality which nobody else
can understand this one we hear so often
you can’t understand X because they have
a specific skin color or it cannot
understand why because you’re not the
woman or you’re not a man but if you
fragment a population in this in-group
this fragmentation could go all the way
down to the individual which is why I
say we should judge people individually
not what is constructed in group
unfortunately I see this ideology
manifest in the millennial generation
for example here at the universities it
should be a safe space for thought
or the safe space from thought
University should be placed where
contradictory views to current views
they’re actually the only people who can
teach you something you don’t already
know which is why we should appreciate
this over s’ti of thought not limited it
when we start to use strong words like
supporting the patriarchy discriminating
against women gender biased I might add
racist white supremacist llama phobic
and Nazi which got a shadow a doubt or
real big issues in our society the
by throwing these strong words around to
people to slightly disagree with you
these words will lose meaning we’ve got
to be able to use them accurately and
precisely for example against the
identitarian movement in Europe and
North America I would argue they are
throwing them around to anyone who slide
to disagree with you these words will
lose meaning we start on today in this
parent political environment two public
intellectuals Jordan Pederson a Ben
Shapiro are labeled white supremacists
and even nasty tendencies I found this
interesting as Spencer Perry’s Orthodox
Jew I’m not heard of any Orthodox Jews
being Nazi as well but hey in this
political environment everything seems
possible and it’s important for me to
clarify that its current use of identity
politics it’s being used on both
political sides for example the rhetoric
being used on the All Tribes with a
Muslim band by Trump or the Home Affairs
Minister in Australia said by only
accepting white farmers what type of
suggestion is this what the intolerant
left particularly strong in universities
for something evergreen college forcing
white people not to be in school in a
specific day or having dorms just for
specific skin color or having places we
know white people this doesn’t seem to
be the solution either so what is the
solution
well we need to be able to try to find
places we can build cross-cultural
bridges which goes beyond gender beyond
skin colour and beyond clothes this is
the only way our interconnected and
globalized generation will be able to
solve any of these difficult issues
together to limit people’s view through
their identity do not hold people
hostage or they Bourne Identity judge
people’s character and content not the
color of their skin but I know these are
all very difficult and sensitive issues
with strong historical luggage which is
important to understand and acknowledge
but if you go back
new identity differences we will not
bring progress it will only further fuel
is polarizing environment which we see
hurting our political discourse today
this is why I urge you not to play this
identity politics game when the on the
Left all right thank you
[Applause] [Music]

Please follow and like us: