Press "Enter" to skip to content

Identity as Becoming not Being: Unlearning to Learn from the Margin | Arjuna Parakrama | TEDxKandy


okay so I’m going to talk about us and
about the crisis that we’re in ethnic
identity and I would like to start with
the pre ethnic national identity the man
who finds his homeland sweet is still
attend a beginner he’d whom every soil
is as his native one is already strong
but he is perfect to whom the entire
world is a foreign land this is the
trick we need to learn to have our own
world ours as well as a foreign land I’m
going to look at the ways in which we
identify this identify where our
ethnicity and somehow is the precursor
to a kind of narrow nationalism that is
destructive it’s interesting that
identity leads to nationalism it is
actually nationalism that that creates
the nation not the other way around
so we have in this a sense of a sense of
nationalists you know thinking which
then leads to form of involving of the
nation but as I’ll keep referring this
again there’s another group outside of
us they’re not us the as hugely not as
as possible the furthest away from us
and we’ll call them the subaltern for
the time being this group for them the
arguments of nationalism do not clinch
because the space the discourse is so
far removed from their lived experience
it does not make sense often I’m told by
them when I’m working in battle or some
places are you going back to Sri Lanka
is that’s what it is it Nepal when you
go out they say I going back to Nepal
you know the thing is this is outside
what they have is the love of their
first language the love of their home
and its environment but that’s not
naturalism let’s keep that in mind as we
move to the issue of identity now we
need to recognize that is usual for us
to think of identity especially ethnic
as an essential part of our being we see
identities are determined by birth by
ancestry we recognize that they are
reinforced by religion by culture by
language we associate our belonging to
each of these identities as natural and
strong and overriding everything else we
may be upper class middle class working
class we still treasure this thing and
in fact these are what we call our roots
those who don’t react to the threat
either its perceived or real against our
identities these are seen as weak people
in authentic even cowardly ultimately
what happens is their very identity is
what is questioned not their arguments
so you know and I will I will explain
this further now what happens in the
manipulation of identities and I’m
mischievously used a quote from worrying
who says you know people don’t want war
this is how during the Nuremberg trials
he said people don’t go but we can
manipulate them how do you manipulate
them voice or no voice the people can be
always brought to the bidding of the
leaders that is easy all you have to do
is tell them they are being attacked and
denounced the pacifists for lack of
patriotism and exposing the country to
danger it works the same way in every
country he says you just gotta tell them
you know we’re being attacked and then
[Music]
here’s a progressive agency and I think
I can’t do any better than then take the
paradigmatic case of Sangakkara in his
Cowdrey lecture 2011 he says I will keep
paramount in my mind my Sri Lankan
identity fans of different races costs
ethnicities and religions who together
celebrate their diversity by uniting for
a common national cause they are my
foundation they are my family I will
play my cricket for them their spirit is
the true spirit of cricket with me are
all my people
tamil singer Lee’s Muslim and burger I’m
Buddhist Hindu a follow Islam and
Christianity I am today and always
proudly Sri Lankan there is no question
a Sangha car is bona fides and as guru
parent states in an article he doesn’t
preach at all but that’s about all we
can give him you know the shared
ethnicity he posits his based on
commonality and a firmly cherished
accepted worldview what happens if this
initial premise is broken Sangakkara
doesn’t present the negative scenario
but the dominant nationalist paradigm
does there is no place in the Lankan
identity for those who do not support a
cricket so his fans eyes his country but
what about those who don’t one may ask
legitimately what happens to that group
and the answer is invariably to splutter
in disbelief that you actually asked
such a foolish question right here’s the
dominant idea so let’s lean this is that
important and worth spending a little
time this is the classic model of the
dominant ideology or which Sagar Kairos
is the progressive version the only
person should not feel it in their very
flesh and bones that they must fight to
defend their country are not only
traitors and cowards but we should check
whether they are really Sri Lankans
because no true Lankan no genuine son of
the soil can actually feel this way
perhaps they’re Outsiders mistakes of
nature it is unthinkable that any real
single ease can feel any other way in
their hearts and souls people can lie
and cheat for money and power but how
can anyone betray their own country how
can they forsake their own blood being
single is must be more than having a
second his name and here it is people
who support another country over Sri
Lanka even at a cricket match just as
those who want our war heroes to be
humiliated to suit a foreign agenda do
not deserve
live here and most importantly they
cannot be genuinely Sri Lanka
nationalist so it’s there
I didn’t that questioned not their
argument this because his team is the
team that supports it so the
common-sense understanding of our ethnic
I disease that we are born into an
identity into an ethnicity we are
singular or Tamil a burger or Muslim or
Adivasi because our parents are the same
we have no choice in that sense as our
ethnic identity is fixed predetermined
and beyond that control it follows that
this natural authentic identity shapes
our world and behavior we become human
through our ethnicities and of course as
an aside we will say fortunately for us
our ethnicity is the best in the world
yes
so what happens we have a known thing of
this identity and we say identity is
that which is given to us what we call
and the others give us but of course
others a sign an identity when we are
marginalized when we are discriminated
that’s the classic form we identify
others negatively right
obviously we say is controlled by
rationality it’s not in fact it is the
suppressor it is the pre rational we
also talk about multiple dot single
affiliations but I must say it’s
important to recognize that you know no
one in their right mind will think that
the the terrible attacks of the of the
Muslim ring yes by the Myanmar and state
for example would be because there are
Sanskrit is economists
you know accountants it’s because of
their ethnicity and ideally that’s the
classic thing that’s the only one that
you would attack somebody on that’s the
only one that you can chase them but of
course again there is another point
about identity that’s important we
cherish identity because we see that as
the as the hallmark of resisting this
intrusive capitalism capitalism invades
our
space but our ethnicity is something
that is part of our family roots and so
on it’s outside of this capital
ironically so that’s why we have a
resurgence of various forms of
identities particularly I think ones in
sri lanka today and also in other parts
of the world but if we think a minute
it’s also the same case it’s also the
case that there is a trend now for
precisely the commodification and the
branding of identity which is then
exported in terms of tokens and symbols
and slogans so we have a corporate
identity as well there’s a corporate
identity of being single over London and
we show it in terms of you know
something that we wear or something that
we don’t wear so I think that tension is
important to recognize as well so we are
ready to fight on behalf of identity we
will defend our earthly group in many
ways and artists in our discourse
identities pre rational its foundational
it’s inherited
it’s the wellspring of our subject would
we this invokes the highest loyalty it
invokes the sort of most important
things the thing that is prior to
everything right so I think ideas are
based as we have seen on birth naming
language religion but these day if
things taken together still do not
sufficiently explain the stranglehold
and obsession that ethnicity occupies in
our lives
ethnicity cuts across or appears to cut
across the crucial categories of class
gender religion age region it is for us
an undeniable proud essence we sort of
self depraved applique ting me
don’t push it but we know we are the
best and we know that’s our essence it’s
the co of our being on the other hand we
become teachers for its students monks
activists these are matters of choice in
circumstance but we cannot undo our
density which
essential for happy ethnicity owns us
and we are its product now this is true
for foremost Sri Lankans in fact working
on the atrocities committed against
Muslims in the diggin area in recent
past we spoke to an our key interlocutor
told us that that this is not
justifiable yes why because the violence
was not spontaneous that is based on the
information of natural feelings if that
that will be explainable
it’s not even produced by sensitivity to
the injustice committed against a fellow
cyclist that was also natural he says
the trouble here is this was planned and
artificial not authentic and natural
hence wrong inexcusable can you see so
the kind of will identity you expect it
to be emotional you expected to have
that that anger and so on if it’s not
there then it can’t be genuine identity
right so we’re looking at listen is this
then completely uncontested terrain and
I’m saying no I’m saying while this
course discourse is dominant there is a
group who cannot challenge this as a
monic wheel they cannot even appear on
our radar screen but with everyday lives
and understated practices completely and
utterly refute most cherished
understanding of identity and identity
politics this group I call them
subalterns we can call them whatever we
want and I said I refer to that these
people who on the margins of society
whom we call whom we say they accept
wretchedness as normality they they
can’t think of anything else they have
no access to the lines of upward
mobility they adorn its borders they
create his exceptions they represent his
edges as I said nationalism doesn’t
Harbor the same thing same demand for
them as it does for the
lower and even the middle and lower
classes and we’re from nationalism from
which many of the middle and upper
classes profit so what I’m going to do
now here is as I pointed up I’m going to
show you three videos that I’ve taken
it’s like me taking me about 20 years to
do this
it’s really difficult stuff when we
first showed this I remember showing it
in Washington and the embassy called me
they said we need the names of these
people because they’re all potential
suicide bombers because they can move
from one ethnicity to the other right
but of course so here we have then
ethnicity is becoming earning the right
[Music]
[Applause]
now family originated from the vadik
ability of our devices and one of its
members say she she believes equally in
Buddhism and Hinduism they have two
first languages or mother tongues
singular and some of the drama that is
contained in this duality can be seen
from the novice Buddhist monk of this
family says he can’t remember how many
siblings he has he’s also embarrassed
and unsure about his first language he
remains as it were in the wider world
the person are non grata between both of
ours whereas in his village his mother
is comfortable with her do a religion or
multiple religion and her dual languages
single or undo a single attorney MLM a
verdict so yeah I’m there me me me Nico
he’s an artist who’s here in the
audience who sort of tried to present
this in a different way these are three
that’s the progressive art and here is a
radical practice we have my monk who we
spoke about another novice so there’s no
visible difference here as in the
paintings but that is the important
thing of becoming so what you would have
noticed in the in the videos is the
mistakes they make
they say signalize my religion Buddhism
is my race or my ethnicity but when you
think about it singer has become a
religion for us we operate as so these
mistakes their ability to make the
mistake means that they haven’t learnt
the the rules are not learning the rules
means they’re able to critique all of
this stuff very clearly it’s like the
child to recognize the emperor had no
clothes so I think we need to understand
and that’s very important what we have
here with if we take this mistake
seriously then we will learn the the
problems that we have entrenched and
internalized in terms of our valuing of
identity and ethnicity so what happens
here if we are ready to learn these
quiet understated practices about
becoming not being the monks have become
Buddhist we are Buddhist just by birth
how does that work so the thing is we
the one becoming in the sense that one
repeated he earns the right and corrects
oneself as one goes on one learns by
doing one does by learning it is as
alien to the patronizing hierarchy of
Tolerance as it is to the hegemonic
exclusion of radical difference both
within and without dominant identities
I’m I’m saying see they mistake
ethnicity for religion religion
ethnicity the the woman says I was born
to one group and now I’m mixed and we’d
laugh and say that
wrong but what a wonderful notion of a
degree that is idly that is fluid that’s
related to practice to becoming not
being ok so I would say that this rule
breaking subjects upwards and challenges
the hierarchies and the values that we
have are we up to accepting this
challenge or are we going to reproduce
precisely these these old notions of
ethnicity and an identity and then keep
re-enacting the tragedies of our times again and again thank
Please follow and like us: