Press "Enter" to skip to content

I Thought We All Had Free Will … | Alex Gilbert | TEDxYouth@DPL


Niro said life is like a game of cards
the hand you’re dealt is determinism the
way you play it
is free will I thought free will was
matter perspective and the paradox
imagine take a family out to a really
fancy restaurant there’s everything on
the menu that they could choose from but
each of them chooses the same expensive
steak was this their free choice but
it’s all predestined by fate God the
Stars or anything else pioneering
scientists Benjamin Libet came up with
the theory that free will was just an
illusion according to him brain activity
proceeded every conscious decision but
this was more to do with how our bodies
moved than whether we can make decisions
with reasons behind them his theory
never really took off organized
religions set out a structure for a way
of life and belief the perception is
that the more organized the religion and
the more rules there are to follow the
less choice there is for the people many
writings are full of rules and they have
situations where curses outweigh the
positives
the curses are warnings of the
consequences of choosing to disobey God
this is where the paradox comes in it
seems that God is taking away our free
will by making us act in a particular
way but on the other hand he is giving
us the free will to choose what we want
by showing off the consequences if we
disobey the important word here is
choose we do get the choice but we are
guided towards the better path free will
is very precious and people treasure and
fight for it people of all ages should
be able to think for themselves when
children get into arguments with their
parents it is usually because the child
wants more freedom and the parent is
willing to give and the parent wants to
keep control over the child without
freedom to disobey we become just like
robots
to feel human we need to be in a
position where we can choose to accept
or to reject the choices we’re offered
rather they’re just blindly following
without questioning parents warn us
about the dangers of taking drugs they
tell us about all the terrible things
that can happen but we still have the
freedom to make that choice they trust
us to make the correct choice knowing
the consequences of our actions
there are times though that we don’t
always listen and we have to learn from
the consequences why’d the religious
books threaten such fire and brimstone
just to get people to follow the rules
while else encourage people to take the
right path it’s a bit like parenting
sometimes it doesn’t seem kind at first
imagine a child leg football by the road
and chases the ball into path of a car
that narrowly misses him a passerby
would freeze in shock
once realizing no harm had happened
would carry on tossing onto their breath
on the other hand the mother watching
her child would have the same initial
reaction a freezing in shock but would
then run over and grab and shout at the
child for not following her rules this
is because the mother cares and she will
shock the child into a bang for the
child’s own good this is exactly what
God is doing in these curses so if we
follow the rules and choose the right
path good things should happen to us and
it follows that bad things will happen
to bad people but in the real world bad
things happen to good people why is this
and if there is a God why doesn’t he
step in and help the people who are
following his rules the reason is
because he’d be expected to step in for
any situation in the world no matter how
big or how small where would he draw the
line if we were allowing our belief
saving the day every time something bad
happened we would have no incentive to
develop and do things for ourselves a
perfect world is something to aspire to
but would be boring life is about
striving for improvement but if there is
nothing left
to improve what would we do they’ll
always be conflict it is a part of
humanity whether we are adults or
children as I said at the beginning free
will is a matter of perspective and the
paradox different people have different
views on the same subject
it depends on people’s beliefs
upbringing and the society in which they
live a person North Korea might believe
that they have all the free will in the
world but it would appear differently to
us in the West the paradox is that the
more we think that we have no free will
because there are so many rules we
actually have the freedom to accept also
reject those choices with knowledge and
understanding on the other hand if we
think we have complete free will or we
can make every choice we like but if our
lives are predetermined then all those
choices have already been made in
advance as Isaac Bashevis singer said we
must believe in free will we have no
choice thank you for listening [Applause]
Please follow and like us: