Press "Enter" to skip to content

Humor of the Middle Ages. You would ban it today. | Mikhail Maizuls | TEDxMoscow


at
eighth year in Weimar Germany
the trial began on charges
expressionist artist georg gross in
insulting churches and in fact in
sacrilege
his crime was that
for the play on the soldier he is
depicted the crucifixion only christ on it
was wearing soldier’s boots and in
gas mask first world war with her
gas attacks ended wrong
long
gross claimed that this image
means suffering humanity which
hypocrites are driving to a new slaughterhouse
his accusers polished by presenting
christa
so strange appearance he is thereby
outraged the sacred symbol for
all Christians one of the main rules
games that exist almost in
any society is the rules for dealing with
sacral
sacral images sacral
objects that really
for everyone is surrounded by a halo of reverence or
those who have already lost essentially this
status but someone is keen to get them back on
pedestal and reinstate from doubt
All the more here is ridicule us in Russia
both are very familiar today
in 2016 in French satirical
weekly charlie ebdo came out
caricature of which was captured
Holy Trinity Cathedral entered into
complex
Russian spiritual and cultural center
shortly before, solemnly opened in
Paris in this picture as we see
whose drawings and the article where he appeared
mocked the church use scheme
as a policy tool dome cathedral
introduce themselves as President Putin’s
quality of response
outraged committee chairman
State Duma on science and
The formation of Cheslav Nikonov stated that
if it were in Russia, then this
blasphemous drawing would obviously
banned under insults
believers
passes two years vanikova sloth
on carnival
artist Nikolai Polissky does not burn 11
comrades 30-meter wooden ok
construction resembling in form
gothic cathedral
the fire action itself is called
flaming gothic by the name of that
style which is good to see right away
voices rise, why burn church
a representative of the Moscow Patriarchate
emphasizes that with Christian imagery
must be protected from this kind
police shares
to justify explaining that the church is
not at all a church that he does not have an altar and
that no anti-clerical promise
this promotion is not
and the crucifixion which georg gross turned
in anti-war sermon and gothic
cathedral with spiers aspiring to heaven
even if they are burning send us to
western medieval and middle ages
remembers extremely often generally in
any debate about how you can
how can not be treated sacred
characters someone seeking to protect
shrines from desecration appeals to
most canon law
which were formulated in the mean
century
someone on the contrary defending freedom
creativity or secular values ​​in
different measurements on the contrary complain about
the return of the new middle ages
but if we look at the very
the middle ages we will see what is there in the era
almost total religiosity
sacred in its various manifestations
much more often than we can afford
imagine met with low
ridiculous bodily obscene and this
the meeting was not always a conflict
laughter over the clergy
and sometimes over some church
establishments sounded not only from the outside
churches for example from what
political movements but from the inside out
mustache in clerics
one of the most striking evidence of such
interactions
serves marginals small often
comic drawings decorating fields
many manuscripts be it even
the psaltery chorus and bible prayer books
or something else on these images
extremely often sacred scenes in
how is the image of the last evening
meet side by side with figures or
scenes that if they make fun
and at least parody the clergy
from ordinary priests and monks
yes popes how here we see
a donkey dressed in papal tiara or here
on top of the foot the bishop explains something
exhortation in something a rose something scolds
monk lowering gases
Moreover marginals sometimes raise
hand not only on the clergy hierarchy
but also on the church rituals themselves
and sometimes even the sacraments here are monkeys
the bishop behind her back is the deacon monkey
I light the church and here the monkey bishop
serves the mass but instead of the guests that is
unleavened bread which is provided in
body of christ
Above the monkey head skull
of course we can assume that such
sort of images appear in some kind
critical manuscripts or manuscripts
created by some artisans
anticlericals but in general it is not
similar or similar images
found in huge numbers
luxury rare few available
manuscripts ordered in
including the princes of the church of the abbot and the bishop
cardinals
and in many ways although not always it was
kinda laugh for their own but because
security if you go ahead and move away
already from these manuscripts which
really few people have seen it
few people were afraid then we will see that
middle parishioner
to the temple often could see images that
by their naturalness in general by
plots that did not affect on
present day
hardly imagine the sacred
space is one example
occurring regularly in romance
temples from spain to ireland call
exhibitionists image
male or female figures who
flaunt their genitals
phalluses or vulva historians of course
argue about where they came from what they
meant
were they required to
expose the vices of the flesh or
how many suppose served their
kind of amulets protecting the congregation and
the building itself from the forces of darkness
demons and the evil eye will make it for
brackets it is important that such images
they are extremely numerous and
extremely diverse not found
only outside the temples most often and
inside in the sacred space
near the choir near the altar as
let’s say this figure from the holy church
water gandhi in city dress in france
let’s stop for a second when we
imagine medieval
artist or sculptor who took
visualization of some sacral
plot we immediately see cleric
alcohol or cleric which is more important
censor standing behind him of course
it is so but not quite
in an era when Christianity remains
the most important frame of interpretation is the church
is despite everything
heretical movements criticism chief
moderated sacred to masters
there remains a fairly wide field of freedom
exactly how to visualize the truth
about which the church preaches yes of course
in some 13th century
can argue whether it is possible or not
depict christ nailed to the cross not
four as it happened from time immemorial and
three nails and whether it is heresy or in
late 14th century
University of Paris as a concert
angers he criticizes the image of the maiden
mary with baby such three-dimensional
fold open and inside the trinity
whether he is asking questions
Someone from forgiveness think that
through maiden mary not only came into the world
god son christ
but also god father and holy spirit that is
heresy but despite this such doubts
even if they were spoken by the theologians
and church hierarchs were ducks
most often their opinions and we almost never
let’s find some examples
images are centralized and engaged
were going to put on carts somewhere
taken from burned and in general such
sort of centralized campaigns against
visual
before the church medieval clerics actively
burned the writing of heretics and sometimes writing
infidels such as in a talmud
france 13th century but control over
the word was much tougher than
control over the way when this situation
begins to change again contrary to that
what we can imagine is already
going on outside the middle ages in
the early 16th century is happening
a few words firstly of course then
along with a huge next to a huge
continent of christian sacral
art of christian iconography
small islands appear first
and then a whole secular archipelago
arts of secular genres for which
the church is required to give some kind of answer yet
more important is that at this time
there is a church schism
for the first time after the separation of the Catholic and
Orthodox Church in the eleventh
century
according to the unity of the Christian world is applied
such a blow with the advent of Protestantism
Protestants and Lutherans Calvinists angry
to her and others not only subject
radical criticism of the papacy church as
institute
but also cast doubt on the whole system
rescue techniques
from the cult of images and the cult of saints to
the sacraments themselves and more importantly that in contrast
from earlier critical groups
Protestants in the sixteenth century
can bring down on the catholic church
although she also reciprocates us
all the power of modern for that time
media
printing press and wood engraving then
there is technology that allows you to quickly
mean cheap and socially available
replicate the image and
unfolding this caricature
war between protestants and catholics 1
slander the evidence that we see
here it is a protestant engraving of
the netherlands 1566 where
the catholic mass appears as
through hypocritical act here is
fox priests here are on the altar and
on which instead of Christ the Virgin Mary
or whom any saints depicted judas
the iscariot apostle to the traitor
Catholics supposedly worship in response to
put this total attack under
doubt the legitimacy of the whole national
church and its institutions
Catholic clerics are becoming
hypersensitive compared even
medieval to not only critics on and
ridicule in your address
if in the Middle Ages it is easy to imagine
they themselves were full of terrible image
ships where the underworld next to others
estates fried cook and every
clergy and priests are erased and
the monks are the bishops of the pope because they too
people because they sin too
naturally in hell also occur in
an era
ideological clash with
protestant when expose
authority click click opinion already
much more dangerous in new images
doomsday 16 18 centuries they
gradually dissolve it old them
often cover up and clean catholic
theologians such as Lugansk
professor ivan little nose or archbishop
cities of bolonia in italy
Dobreli flight begin to ask again
unthinkable middle ages thick
folios
in the works in which a small comb
pass by
almost all plot church
iconography to separate the true from
doubtful doubtful from dangerous and
formulate what measures should
to accept
and their gaze is drawn not only to
the images opened heretic as let’s say
some kind of protestant picture on
who would the devil have bore the pope
well, the image is only potentially dangerous
with misinterpretation as say
if someone portrays a demon in
priestly robes who baptizes
babes someone can decide what a demon
the priest is a bad priest
which means baptism done by evil
the priest she really is and it puts
threatened again and authority
clergy and general salvation masses
believers appeared in the early new
time censorship is addressed not only to new
depicting but also to the ancients in the 13th century in
Strasbourg Cathedral
depicted drives skits from
most popular in the middle ages
epic most popular drink whether siri nari
Where
beasts coming from the clergy are buried
his fellows carry crosses carry candles and
even serves the mass in the 17th century when
Strasbourg joins France and
comes back from Protestantism back to
catholicism these images churn and they
preserved only in engraving that degree
laughing with his anticlerical minutes
which was quite the thoughts in the temple in
Middle Ages in the early new time in
conditions couples total standoff with
Protestantism
no longer relevant and even dangerous from this
stories can be learned a few lessons
but I only touched upon one for many
centuries Christian images have found the second
measurement of course they belong
sacred history of church doctrine
are objects of worship but at the same time
they are so tightly incorporated into
our common cultural dictionaries are what
already belong to everyone and you can see it well
like here in these angels from advertising anyone
deodorant released low years ago in
yuar she was completely forbidden
and in Russia it is equipped with such caution
the inscription that the angel is not quite
angel-fantasy image of the ideal
girl just in case
the task and the task really is at all
not unambiguous uneasy is
to find a compromise between respect for
sacred way which for many
meaningful and the right to have them perry
interpret look at them
differently so sometimes they ground them
and above them including irony
because no faith you can not
to be outside criticism on sacred images
no one has a copyright
thank you very much
[applause]
Please follow and like us: