
[Music]
good afternoon because it is humans
robots and business so in any order you
particularly one first I’m going to talk
about some signs of the times
first productivity it’s an issue it’s a
worry for government because it’s
remained stuck at 2008 levels not
showing any signs of moving that’s not
true in other countries so we’re
actually falling behind then link to
that is possibly is employee engagement
businesses naturally want their
employees to feel committed to the
things that they’re trying to do in the
belief that they will work more
effectively the trouble is the
statistics there aren’t particularly
encouraging either Gallup which reviews
this globally in its most recent survey
suggested that some 68 percent of US
workers do not feel engaged in their
work well the figure globally is even
worse it’s 87 percent feel disengaged in
their work and then linked all of this
to is the notion of trust the bigger
issue of trust in business now we used
to trust business much more readily than
we did government or media but again in
recent years that figure has been
plummeting so that if you look at the
Adelman barometer which has been
measuring this thing in recent years
Trust has plummeted in business in this
country and it’s now a negative
territory that’s clearly a problem for
business but I want to argue that it’s a
problem for all of us too because it
suggests the weakening of the
relationship between business and the
communities it needs to link to there
are many reasons for this I’m sure you
can think of reasons why you might no
longer trust business I want to look at
something which is perhaps less obvious
but it’s a problem which is in the way
that businesses think about identity
about their identities and because
there’s a muddle in their heads about
identity that’s affecting the way that
they can relate to other people and it’s
being expressed
test in the language that they use I’m
not talking about jargon the kind of
specialized or technical vocabulary that
businesses sometimes use when they’re
not thinking properly about who they’re
talking or to about what they know I’m
talking about something altogether
stranger which once noticed you will see
everywhere it might look like a detail
but I think it’s the tip of a much
bigger iceberg to illustrate what I’m
talking about here’s a recent apology
from Nivea after a gaffe we are deeply
sorry to anyone who may take offense to
this specific post diversity and equal
opportunity are crucial values of Nivea
now if you’re beginning to fill them
maybe there’s something a little bit
awkward about that I think you’re right
and the awkwardness lies well it starts
off promising ly enough we are deeply
sorry that’s straightforward is what
you’d expect but why does it then move
on to talking about diversity and equal
opportunity what’s this value stuff got
to do with Nivea and what’s that got to
do with my apology we’re losing a sense
of what responsibility is being taken
here in any case it’s a very strange way
of talking about values it would have
been much more natural to say diversity
and equal opportunity are really
important to us because then you’re in
the same kind of space we and us
responsibilities being taken but instead
we have this depersonalization this
shift to a kind of abstraction it’s
worth saying that values are always
difficult things to talk about
because values stand in need of
embodiment they are a behavioural
feature so that if there’s something
which you need to show rather than to
tell so that is someone start speaking
of values it leaves room for incredulity
for doubt because you think well I’d
rather see it than hear you talk about
this to illustrate that a little bit
further
think about the difference between these
three statements which on the face of it
seem to be dealing with the same thing I
try to be honest
then I value honesty and an even worse
honesty is one of my key values now I
try to be honest this a reasonable
statement to make by the time you’ve got
to I value honesty you’re already
leaving room for you to value that
honesty in other people but not yourself
there’s no commitment there
and again I think you can see as it were
an abstraction are pushing away which
leaves room room for this thing to
become less than real something more
optional and if you put it in a kind of
more obvious work context again the
difference between someone who says I
value team work and team work is one of
our corporate values if a manager says
to you I value team work you’ll
understand pretty immediately that she
means that she wants you to work in a
cooperative way if she says team work is
one of our corporate values I think
you’d be forgiven for thinking well
that’s very nice for you what am I
supposed to do about it across all these
examples as I say there’s a deep
personalization going on a reliance upon
the stated rather than the performed are
speaking when you should be showing
showing not telling why is it happening
well it’s becoming pervasive in business
it has become pervasive in business if
any of you’ve got any anywhere ever near
a corporate entity there’s a good chance
you’ll have encountered the Holy Trinity
of mission vision and values now this is
a trilogy which has been constructed by
brand consultants by brand thinkers to
help businesses create a corporate
personality and identity which is there
to help define them now there’s a whole
lot wrong with that but I’m not going to
go into it now what I do want to talk
about initially is a couple of reasons
why it might seem like a good idea
the first is that we actually relate
better to people than we do to things
that’s kind of understandable so there’s
a logic in trying to create as it were a
corporate personality which then in
theory should strengthen the allegiance
we might feel as customers or as
employees to that corporate thing and it
then follows from that
that’s the having created this
constructed identity this thing that
you’d want to embed it in the other in
the organization that you’d want it to
become Express through the behaviors so
you need to make that real that’s
understandable so the mission and the
vision are there to set the door
action of the company what it’s all
about the values are developed in order
to characterize the kind of qualities
that the business should have in pursuit
of those goals the first thing that
happens if you have actually if you’ve
looked at any sets of corporate values
is that they are relentlessly anodyne
they are no more than hiding factors
things like respect for others integrity
diversity nothing wrong with any of
those things in themselves but they are
the kind of basic elements of human
decency the kinds of things that anybody
would want to achieve and they won’t get
you very far if actually your ambition
in this is to create a distinctive
identity but I want to argue that it’s
actually worse than this because in the
ways that business is set about trying
to make these things real to embed them
in their organizations they actually do
the opposite of what they’re trying to
do which is to draw people closer to
make firmer connections but they
actually end up alienating now the
reason for that is the way that business
communication is handled there’s a kind
of received opinion in business
communication received wisdom that the
way you take something like a value a
concept and embed it in the organization
is to repeat it ad nauseam wherever you
possibly can then somehow by a
mysterious process of osmosis as
employees we’re going to take that thing
into ourselves so will suddenly become
more empathetic people because the
company said it’s an empathetic
organization or as customers because the
company is always speaking about it so
yeah that’s the business if she does but
about that thing and again you’ll
recognize it for being that doesn’t
sound so unreasonable in theory but if
you look at what actually happens in
practice um a while ago I received an
email from Kevin Turner who’s a chief
operating officer it’s Microsoft me and
a few million others no doubt and this
is what Kevin had to say listening to
customers and partners is a top priority
in every activity we do by taking this
5-minute personalized survey you help us
to better understand the needs of our
customers
and partners in our ongoing efforts to
improve experiences across all products
and services I think we can all agree
this a pretty terrible piece of writing
but we so used to this kind of core for
a garbage that we actually just file it
under corporate garbage and think no
more I think you should if you step back
though and ask why it feels like garbage
it becomes a little bit more interesting
remember this is a piece of Direct Mail
what it’s asking me to do is complete a
questionnaire so why does it start off
talking about Microsoft’s management
priorities wine earth do I want to know
about that well the reason is because
our Kevin is towing a corporate line and
he’s been told that what Microsoft wants
to do is be known for listening so he’s
going to talk about listening and how
good Microsoft is adhered and how
concerned it is to do it regardless of
the fact was of whether I actually want
to be listening to that at all at the
moment then if you look at the second
sentence and particularly the second
half of the second sentence
I think it’s self-evident why a company
would want to understand my needs as a
customer better you don’t need to say
much more but Kevin wants to say a bit
more he wants to talk about improving
experiences or where’s that come from
it’s quite a strange phrase and it’s
come from the fact that at the time
Microsoft wanted to be known for
improving experiences it thought that
that was what it was all about so again
it’s going to tell us about it at every
possible opportunity whether or not this
is an appropriate moment to be talking
about that and the net effect I would
argue is that although this is being
done in the name of creating an identity
a personality which we can identify with
the net effect is actually to push this
or pushes away to end up sounding so
strange and so alien that we just think
it’s part of corporate business as usual
and not much to do with me it is quite
possible that Kevin Turner goes home and
talks to his family in this kind of a
way
but I somehow doubt it and the sad thing
is that the alternative the way to
create a engaging human conversation is
actually just to sound human and not
robotic and those human voices are
readily available in the company every
type of company is full of human voices
but they are suppressed because of a
different management imperative which
has decided to take on this notion of
identity and the reason they are
oppressed is because there’s also a
confusion between consistency and
uniformity consistency is value it is
some valuable it’s something you want
over time because it will promote
recognition over time and you know
consistent good behavior is a good thing
uniformity isn’t the same thing at all
if you think about our human identity
that’s because identity actually isn’t a
monolithic quality we are complex
creatures we’re multifaceted creatures
and it is quite possible that we can
sustain a whole load of different
characteristics and still be
recognizable likewise a business can be
recognizable for whole load of
characteristics without needing to
channel them down into a kind of verbal
battering ram or series of battering
rams which is launched against us
whenever we might not be thinking we
wanted to listen and the trouble with
being battered is where we don’t really
like that very much and the consequence
is that it does sound alien now I want
to name this way of talking this tone of
voice management robotic that is the
insistence on repeating a concept or
idea regardless of whether it’s relevant
at every possible opportunity whether
it’s in line with what that expected
audience should be expecting and it’s
worth snap to it’s actually the
insistence I’m talking about the company
about itself when you should be talking
about something else just bad
communication practice and the saddest
thing of all is that having pushed
itself to management robotic well we’ve
reached the stage where artificial
intelligence where real robots have got
to the level where they’re quite close
to being able to pass what’s called the
Turing test which is the point where
they will be so capable of understanding
human speech so capable of responding
flexibly and intelligently that we won’t
be able to tell them apart from human
intelligence
the irony is a business has been moving
in the opposite direction businesses
would not pass the Turing test now it’s
not just a problem for business
communication it’s a problem I would
suggest for business behavior too
because although the intention is to
turn these ideas into behavior – as it
will make it real because of the way
it’s being done it’s actually just
emphasizing how artificial this identity
is how alien it is and if it is pushed
into an artificial theoretical space
that creates space for the business to
say well that’s where the ethical stuff
happens but we’ve got real stuff to be
getting on with
in a way it’s exempting business from
the ordinary ethical concerns which
drive our behavior outside business the
unintended consequence of mission vision
and values is to perpetuate the license
business gives itself to be different it
helps the people in the organization to
say well I live by these things out here
but here in work I’ve got different
priorities I need to respect it allows
the possibility of just saying well it’s
just business as if that’s something
different from responsibilities you have
in the real world and if you think that
and good luck with the hope that you’re
going to become more engaging that
you’re going to start building trust
because people will see through it there
is a pretty devastating consequence for
business communicators people like me
because it means that everything that
we’ve been told and worked on for
decades now about
corporate identity and how it works is
wrong it’s a waste of time a waste of
effort and energy effort and energy and
money which could be much better applied
to changing the things which need to be
changed in an organization and that’s
much harder work but it’s not just a
waste it’s actually as I say undermining
the reasons the things why you actually
took on identity in the first place it
is stopping you forged the connections
the closer links that made you want to
construct this identity I’m not
suggesting that there is no point in
thinking about mission vision and values
there’s a lot of point about it
especially at senior levels of the
organization it’s a very good idea I
think to set out a series of clear
values which you use as the yardstick to
charge management decisions by
especially if you actually stick to that
but if you want to be engaging then you
need to get away from management robotic
you need to find a way a space for human
voices to make themselves heard for
people to be able to speak for
themselves in the organization again
that’s especially critical if you want
to start working in social media or
trying to do so already because social
media is essentially a human
conversation which is happening out
there in the cloud but I want to say
it’s true for every context broader
business space because if you adopt
management robotic you’re going to end
up sounding weird and when did you last
want to sound weird thank you very much
[Applause]
you
good afternoon because it is humans
robots and business so in any order you
particularly one first I’m going to talk
about some signs of the times
first productivity it’s an issue it’s a
worry for government because it’s
remained stuck at 2008 levels not
showing any signs of moving that’s not
true in other countries so we’re
actually falling behind then link to
that is possibly is employee engagement
businesses naturally want their
employees to feel committed to the
things that they’re trying to do in the
belief that they will work more
effectively the trouble is the
statistics there aren’t particularly
encouraging either Gallup which reviews
this globally in its most recent survey
suggested that some 68 percent of US
workers do not feel engaged in their
work well the figure globally is even
worse it’s 87 percent feel disengaged in
their work and then linked all of this
to is the notion of trust the bigger
issue of trust in business now we used
to trust business much more readily than
we did government or media but again in
recent years that figure has been
plummeting so that if you look at the
Adelman barometer which has been
measuring this thing in recent years
Trust has plummeted in business in this
country and it’s now a negative
territory that’s clearly a problem for
business but I want to argue that it’s a
problem for all of us too because it
suggests the weakening of the
relationship between business and the
communities it needs to link to there
are many reasons for this I’m sure you
can think of reasons why you might no
longer trust business I want to look at
something which is perhaps less obvious
but it’s a problem which is in the way
that businesses think about identity
about their identities and because
there’s a muddle in their heads about
identity that’s affecting the way that
they can relate to other people and it’s
being expressed
test in the language that they use I’m
not talking about jargon the kind of
specialized or technical vocabulary that
businesses sometimes use when they’re
not thinking properly about who they’re
talking or to about what they know I’m
talking about something altogether
stranger which once noticed you will see
everywhere it might look like a detail
but I think it’s the tip of a much
bigger iceberg to illustrate what I’m
talking about here’s a recent apology
from Nivea after a gaffe we are deeply
sorry to anyone who may take offense to
this specific post diversity and equal
opportunity are crucial values of Nivea
now if you’re beginning to fill them
maybe there’s something a little bit
awkward about that I think you’re right
and the awkwardness lies well it starts
off promising ly enough we are deeply
sorry that’s straightforward is what
you’d expect but why does it then move
on to talking about diversity and equal
opportunity what’s this value stuff got
to do with Nivea and what’s that got to
do with my apology we’re losing a sense
of what responsibility is being taken
here in any case it’s a very strange way
of talking about values it would have
been much more natural to say diversity
and equal opportunity are really
important to us because then you’re in
the same kind of space we and us
responsibilities being taken but instead
we have this depersonalization this
shift to a kind of abstraction it’s
worth saying that values are always
difficult things to talk about
because values stand in need of
embodiment they are a behavioural
feature so that if there’s something
which you need to show rather than to
tell so that is someone start speaking
of values it leaves room for incredulity
for doubt because you think well I’d
rather see it than hear you talk about
this to illustrate that a little bit
further
think about the difference between these
three statements which on the face of it
seem to be dealing with the same thing I
try to be honest
then I value honesty and an even worse
honesty is one of my key values now I
try to be honest this a reasonable
statement to make by the time you’ve got
to I value honesty you’re already
leaving room for you to value that
honesty in other people but not yourself
there’s no commitment there
and again I think you can see as it were
an abstraction are pushing away which
leaves room room for this thing to
become less than real something more
optional and if you put it in a kind of
more obvious work context again the
difference between someone who says I
value team work and team work is one of
our corporate values if a manager says
to you I value team work you’ll
understand pretty immediately that she
means that she wants you to work in a
cooperative way if she says team work is
one of our corporate values I think
you’d be forgiven for thinking well
that’s very nice for you what am I
supposed to do about it across all these
examples as I say there’s a deep
personalization going on a reliance upon
the stated rather than the performed are
speaking when you should be showing
showing not telling why is it happening
well it’s becoming pervasive in business
it has become pervasive in business if
any of you’ve got any anywhere ever near
a corporate entity there’s a good chance
you’ll have encountered the Holy Trinity
of mission vision and values now this is
a trilogy which has been constructed by
brand consultants by brand thinkers to
help businesses create a corporate
personality and identity which is there
to help define them now there’s a whole
lot wrong with that but I’m not going to
go into it now what I do want to talk
about initially is a couple of reasons
why it might seem like a good idea
the first is that we actually relate
better to people than we do to things
that’s kind of understandable so there’s
a logic in trying to create as it were a
corporate personality which then in
theory should strengthen the allegiance
we might feel as customers or as
employees to that corporate thing and it
then follows from that
that’s the having created this
constructed identity this thing that
you’d want to embed it in the other in
the organization that you’d want it to
become Express through the behaviors so
you need to make that real that’s
understandable so the mission and the
vision are there to set the door
action of the company what it’s all
about the values are developed in order
to characterize the kind of qualities
that the business should have in pursuit
of those goals the first thing that
happens if you have actually if you’ve
looked at any sets of corporate values
is that they are relentlessly anodyne
they are no more than hiding factors
things like respect for others integrity
diversity nothing wrong with any of
those things in themselves but they are
the kind of basic elements of human
decency the kinds of things that anybody
would want to achieve and they won’t get
you very far if actually your ambition
in this is to create a distinctive
identity but I want to argue that it’s
actually worse than this because in the
ways that business is set about trying
to make these things real to embed them
in their organizations they actually do
the opposite of what they’re trying to
do which is to draw people closer to
make firmer connections but they
actually end up alienating now the
reason for that is the way that business
communication is handled there’s a kind
of received opinion in business
communication received wisdom that the
way you take something like a value a
concept and embed it in the organization
is to repeat it ad nauseam wherever you
possibly can then somehow by a
mysterious process of osmosis as
employees we’re going to take that thing
into ourselves so will suddenly become
more empathetic people because the
company said it’s an empathetic
organization or as customers because the
company is always speaking about it so
yeah that’s the business if she does but
about that thing and again you’ll
recognize it for being that doesn’t
sound so unreasonable in theory but if
you look at what actually happens in
practice um a while ago I received an
email from Kevin Turner who’s a chief
operating officer it’s Microsoft me and
a few million others no doubt and this
is what Kevin had to say listening to
customers and partners is a top priority
in every activity we do by taking this
5-minute personalized survey you help us
to better understand the needs of our
customers
and partners in our ongoing efforts to
improve experiences across all products
and services I think we can all agree
this a pretty terrible piece of writing
but we so used to this kind of core for
a garbage that we actually just file it
under corporate garbage and think no
more I think you should if you step back
though and ask why it feels like garbage
it becomes a little bit more interesting
remember this is a piece of Direct Mail
what it’s asking me to do is complete a
questionnaire so why does it start off
talking about Microsoft’s management
priorities wine earth do I want to know
about that well the reason is because
our Kevin is towing a corporate line and
he’s been told that what Microsoft wants
to do is be known for listening so he’s
going to talk about listening and how
good Microsoft is adhered and how
concerned it is to do it regardless of
the fact was of whether I actually want
to be listening to that at all at the
moment then if you look at the second
sentence and particularly the second
half of the second sentence
I think it’s self-evident why a company
would want to understand my needs as a
customer better you don’t need to say
much more but Kevin wants to say a bit
more he wants to talk about improving
experiences or where’s that come from
it’s quite a strange phrase and it’s
come from the fact that at the time
Microsoft wanted to be known for
improving experiences it thought that
that was what it was all about so again
it’s going to tell us about it at every
possible opportunity whether or not this
is an appropriate moment to be talking
about that and the net effect I would
argue is that although this is being
done in the name of creating an identity
a personality which we can identify with
the net effect is actually to push this
or pushes away to end up sounding so
strange and so alien that we just think
it’s part of corporate business as usual
and not much to do with me it is quite
possible that Kevin Turner goes home and
talks to his family in this kind of a
way
but I somehow doubt it and the sad thing
is that the alternative the way to
create a engaging human conversation is
actually just to sound human and not
robotic and those human voices are
readily available in the company every
type of company is full of human voices
but they are suppressed because of a
different management imperative which
has decided to take on this notion of
identity and the reason they are
oppressed is because there’s also a
confusion between consistency and
uniformity consistency is value it is
some valuable it’s something you want
over time because it will promote
recognition over time and you know
consistent good behavior is a good thing
uniformity isn’t the same thing at all
if you think about our human identity
that’s because identity actually isn’t a
monolithic quality we are complex
creatures we’re multifaceted creatures
and it is quite possible that we can
sustain a whole load of different
characteristics and still be
recognizable likewise a business can be
recognizable for whole load of
characteristics without needing to
channel them down into a kind of verbal
battering ram or series of battering
rams which is launched against us
whenever we might not be thinking we
wanted to listen and the trouble with
being battered is where we don’t really
like that very much and the consequence
is that it does sound alien now I want
to name this way of talking this tone of
voice management robotic that is the
insistence on repeating a concept or
idea regardless of whether it’s relevant
at every possible opportunity whether
it’s in line with what that expected
audience should be expecting and it’s
worth snap to it’s actually the
insistence I’m talking about the company
about itself when you should be talking
about something else just bad
communication practice and the saddest
thing of all is that having pushed
itself to management robotic well we’ve
reached the stage where artificial
intelligence where real robots have got
to the level where they’re quite close
to being able to pass what’s called the
Turing test which is the point where
they will be so capable of understanding
human speech so capable of responding
flexibly and intelligently that we won’t
be able to tell them apart from human
intelligence
the irony is a business has been moving
in the opposite direction businesses
would not pass the Turing test now it’s
not just a problem for business
communication it’s a problem I would
suggest for business behavior too
because although the intention is to
turn these ideas into behavior – as it
will make it real because of the way
it’s being done it’s actually just
emphasizing how artificial this identity
is how alien it is and if it is pushed
into an artificial theoretical space
that creates space for the business to
say well that’s where the ethical stuff
happens but we’ve got real stuff to be
getting on with
in a way it’s exempting business from
the ordinary ethical concerns which
drive our behavior outside business the
unintended consequence of mission vision
and values is to perpetuate the license
business gives itself to be different it
helps the people in the organization to
say well I live by these things out here
but here in work I’ve got different
priorities I need to respect it allows
the possibility of just saying well it’s
just business as if that’s something
different from responsibilities you have
in the real world and if you think that
and good luck with the hope that you’re
going to become more engaging that
you’re going to start building trust
because people will see through it there
is a pretty devastating consequence for
business communicators people like me
because it means that everything that
we’ve been told and worked on for
decades now about
corporate identity and how it works is
wrong it’s a waste of time a waste of
effort and energy effort and energy and
money which could be much better applied
to changing the things which need to be
changed in an organization and that’s
much harder work but it’s not just a
waste it’s actually as I say undermining
the reasons the things why you actually
took on identity in the first place it
is stopping you forged the connections
the closer links that made you want to
construct this identity I’m not
suggesting that there is no point in
thinking about mission vision and values
there’s a lot of point about it
especially at senior levels of the
organization it’s a very good idea I
think to set out a series of clear
values which you use as the yardstick to
charge management decisions by
especially if you actually stick to that
but if you want to be engaging then you
need to get away from management robotic
you need to find a way a space for human
voices to make themselves heard for
people to be able to speak for
themselves in the organization again
that’s especially critical if you want
to start working in social media or
trying to do so already because social
media is essentially a human
conversation which is happening out
there in the cloud but I want to say
it’s true for every context broader
business space because if you adopt
management robotic you’re going to end
up sounding weird and when did you last
want to sound weird thank you very much
[Applause]
you
Please follow and like us: