Press "Enter" to skip to content

How we know | Andreas Wahl | TEDxOslo


two years ago in the middle of the night

I stood like I’m standing out but in a

swimming pool with a submerged rifle in

front of me

aimed at my chest in my hand I held the

cord leading to the trigger this is not

how I normally spend my Thursday nights

I was shooting a TV series for the

national broadcaster here in Norway

called life on the line in which I test

the laws of physics with my life on the

line in this episode I would entrust my

life to the concept of drag or fluid

resistance the retarding force acting

upon a body moving in the fluid in the

pool I was not supposed to be the body

moving the bullet was the theory is

straightforward a bullet fired in or

into water will not travel very far

because of all the water molecules it

has to push out of its way and we have

done numerous tests in the water without

me in the water tracking every bullets

position with a high-speed camera

we had weighed all the cartridges with

the most exact paper weight that we

could find to make sure one of them did

not surprisingly contain more gunpowder

than the others now it was 6:00 in the

morning we had worked all night trying

to get control of all the variables

discussing all possible outcomes there

should I stand in front of the gun and

pull the trigger should I fire a bullet

at myself my rational part told me it

will turn out exactly as in in theory

and tests the other part of me law the

irrational part was scared shitless

it only has to fail once and I’m dead

and to me just the idea of standing in

front of a gun loaded made to kill it

yeah you can have a look for yourself it

still makes my hair stand talking about

it too to help you understand how I

ended up in the pool that night I should

tell you my background is in physics I’m

a physicist and I’ve spent the last

eight years communicating science for a

living writing giving talks hosting TV

shows and this morning as the Sun was

about thrice sitting there on the edge

of the pool my rational reasoning was

pulling my irrational fear to the edge I

remember asking myself how do I take the

decision whether to to pull the trigger

and fire a bullet at myself or go home

on what basis do I take that decision

like how can I know for sure how do you

know stuff to be true I can tell you

that when your life is on the line these

and this is how I think we know stuff it

all starts with an idea a leap of

imagination scientists they have this

immense privilege of standing on the

edge of what we know and scoping

outwards so you have an idea of how

something might be you kind of make it

guess really and then you form this into

our hypothesis a prediction and a

testable one and after may after making

sure no one has done exactly what you’re

planning to do you start the trial and

error you you design a procedure that

will hopefully answer your hypothesis in

the end and then you start testing and

in the Natural Sciences we have

something truly unique we have something

you won’t find in in politics or

economics or art we have this

universally agreed-upon blueprint to

test against will not one that everyone

accepts its nature if your hypothesis

does not agree with nature you need to

toss it out if your hypothesis cannot

successfully predict how nature works

it’s not worth much and then there is

publication telling people about your

work you might remember this a few years

ago headlines all over the world being

neutrinos traveling faster than light

okay you might have to be a physicist to

remember

[Music]

this children anyway a few weeks later

the same news channels reported

something like haha scientists were

wrong neutrinos do not travel faster

than light this was how it was seen

through the media lens this is what

actually happened a few scientists in

Switzerland found something odd their

data seemed to implicate these

fundamental particles neutrinos travel

faster than light which is not possible

according to the current laws of physics

nothing travels faster the night so they

naturally assume they must have made a

mistake somewhere

so they went looking for the mistakes

for years they couldn’t find any so they

published their findings in an academic

journal saying hey this is strange we

think we must have made a mistake but we

can find it can you guys help us and the

scientific world did help them it turned

out there was an fiber optic cable

improperly installed and an oscillating

clock ticking too fast but I love this

this story because it shows a crucial

element of the scientific method to seek

criticism in what other part of society

do people go hey please come pull my

work apart tell me what I’ve done wrong

I don’t think that’s intuitive it

certainly isn’t to me I’ve had to learn

it but it’s part of what makes

publishing so important in the

scientific method and then there’s my

willingness to change your mind in

science if presented with better

knowledge you should change your mind it

doesn’t always happen

scientists are humans too but it happens

let me give you an example a life saving

110 years ago in hospitals all over the

world

premature children were given pure

oxygen to help them cope with life

outside the womb

now imagine in one of these hospitals

and an experienced and highly regarded

pediatrician who has given 100% oxygen –

tiny premature babies her whole career

and taught her students to do the same

one day reading a scientific paper or

attending a scientific conference and

learning all these new studies showing

it’s not to the child’s best in fact

giving them a gas makes closer to what

we breathe here today like starting out

with 30-40 percent oxygen it decreases

the chance of brain damage and increases

survival rate now please

imagine her with all of these tiny

babies that she has tried to help in

their mind both the ones that survived

and the ones that did not and with all

her students looking up to her imagine

her saying to herself and to her

colleagues

okay then that’s what we’re going to do

it happens and this discovery alone and

has since then saved an estimated

200,000 lives and I think this is

something we can all learn from the

scientific method to be willing to

change your mind if presented with with

new and solid information it’s a

fundamental thing I mean I trust you

more if you are open to changing your

mind I think we will have a more

fruitful discussion if we are all open

to this idea it’s hard I know because we

intuitively do the opposite but I think

it’s worth trying science might be this

cold logical process but it’s always

performed by humans and we like to think

of ourselves as as rational beings we

certainly are not

and sometimes our irrationality stands

in the way of scientific progress but at

the same time the human capacity of

wonder and curiosity is crucial to the

process as for me I felt that duality of

the human mind that night in the pool we

had done lots of tests we had weighed

all the bullets

the only variable changed would be me

standing in front of the gun it should

perform exactly as in tests there should

be no fear my rational personality told

me but then science cannot state facts

with a hundred percent certainty it can

only say something is very

very likely what if just this one time

my irrationality spoke and this is what

it’s gone today

[Applause] thank you

Please follow and like us: