Press "Enter" to skip to content

How We Got It All Wrong | Dalia Danish | TEDxUSTZC


morning today i’ll talk about how we got

it all wrong why we got it all wrong and

how we can possibly get it right

hopefully and i’ll be talking from a

neuroscientific perspective because

that’s what I’m specialized in but first

let me share a few photos of things that

are very precious to me if you like

that’s really my dog and you understand

why she’s important that an i use my

niece and you’ll understand why she is

important as well and that dr. mohammed

habla was a famous egyptian visual

artist and you’ll understand how the

three are related before i explain any

of that stuff let me talk a bit about

the boring neuroscientific stuff when we

learn we learn through different ways

and the first one is possibly imitation

so when you see a little baby and you

stick your tongue out at the baby the

baby will imitate that melts often more

back in the day looked at newborn

infants and they realized that yes if

you do stay cute on out the baby will

imitate that you can try this at home

and the babies will imitate the various

visual effect that you’re making an

imitation involves a human agent and a

salient effect now another way of

learning is through stimulus enhancement

and emulation and that doesn’t

necessarily involve an agent but it

involves maybe trial and error so a good

example is a baby monkey and a mommy

monkey and maybe there’s a log and

there’s food underneath the log now

mommy monkey doesn’t have to show baby

monkey how to do it the monkey

understands somehow that the log affords

to be tired

and that there’s food underneath so in

that case you have a salient goal which

is the food and you have the trial and

error and that’s a Malaysian now the

finally you have something called

mimicking and that’s basically repeating

a behavior it doesn’t really involve a

goal or anything so I won’t really be

talking about mimicking again imitation

human agent salient effect emulations

stimulus enhancements trial and error

salient effect no human agent now back

in the day at the Max Planck what we did

is that we had little babies in what was

called the baby lab and what is still

called the wavy lab and we presented

those babies with two buttons a red

button and a blue button and we saw that

we realized that if I were to press the

blue button for example and you had a

salient effect ie it glows and it makes

a nice sound the kid were more likely to

repeat that and do it over and over

again so the frequency is higher in the

latency is higher as well meanwhile

somewhere in Italy guys came up with an

extremely extremely interesting

observation and I’ll since I don’t have

any props I’m going to ask you to try

and imagine me picking up a glass of

water and drinking that now as you

imagine or you see me do that action the

neurons in your brain are firing as if

you were performing that action itself

and it’s in the cortex of your brain and

there they did an experiment with a

macaque monkey and it was rizzolatti and

his team and they realized what we call

now called mirror neurons now here’s the

monkey observing someone pick up a

peanut the same neurons are firing in

the monkeys brain as the monkey itself

was picking up the peanut now that when

that was done by mechanical claw

or tweezers in this case the neurons

didn’t fire interestingly enough

somewhere else in the world someone

decided to do that with a human baby and

the interesting thing was when the toy

was picked up ie the salient effect was

picked up by a mechanical claw the

neurons fired which is quite amazing it

shows that maybe there’s something else

going on and maybe we imitate for the

sake of imitation and maybe as Wolfgang

prints in the max planck assumed that we

have something called the common coding

theory ie actions are coded in their

outcomes so imitation is coded for the

sake of imitation and then I decided

back in the day also to do another

experiment what if my action was a

counterintuitive action so what it what

and in that case I recall back then a

touch screen was this big and I was

walking around with a huge test touch

screen in a in a at University and back

in the in the marketplace trying to

recruit subjects and those subjects were

toddlers and I used white a lot of

toddlers for my experiment and it was

quite sometimes quite freaky for the

parents to see a young student walk

around with the suitcase asking the

parents well can I use your baby for an

experiment you’ll get eight pounds and

free video so it quite freaky however

they participated and I decided to do

the following now most of you don’t know

who would you woodpecker is it’s that

thing over there and it goes ahead so it

creates a salient effect and it looks

kind of cool and I decided to do the

following i decided to what if i press

on a certain button on the screen and

the salient effect happens somewhere

else so on a different but

on that screen will the child repeat

that yes or no what if in a second

condition I press the button and nothing

happens will the child do that yes or no

and also I wanted to look at emulations

stimulus enhancement what if I did

absolutely nothing and an arrow

descended on the button will that be

repeated if there was a goal would you

woodpecker coming out finally the final

condition and arrow the sense nothing

happened now I’ll take you somewhere

else in the world because meanwhile as I

was doing that the guy called Muhammad

habla was somewhere in Switzerland he

had students and he realized that people

actually enjoyed using this weird

different method and it was them tracing

one another so he would put a blank

screen a transparent screen and half

people trace one another and people

actually enjoyed that kind of strange

but I’ll explain why going back to my

experiment I realized the following when

I press the button woody woodpecker

comes out the frequency was really high

now so that’s hand without come when you

had the hand meet pressing the button no

outcome frequency extremely high as well

and that’s the latency in brackets when

there was an arrow emulation nothing

going on then frequencies really low so

it we didn’t get any results there when

there was an arrow and the salient

effect kids repeated that over and over

again so what does this really tell us

about us it’s quite amazing so bill mas

Arriba Larabee ephaea goo goo ga enak

faceless demon a lottery pool on Doc

professor x 0 dis rough lucky guy who

good akmahad dr. tabbouleh ill machine

mumkin to Talam

terminal in the Nesbitt well a ibis

tomorrow Selena ana meet or neuroscience

Allison o’clock mechanics Tara will make

a Libra you monkey no inner to mutate

with a bastard menina the ananda and

then a haggis my social construction and

then Hagar is Maha Maha wallet and then

a Hagar is Maha a little makina well

Lily well I had the 10 hi I’m Ella in my

family in hospital in Harlem aguada

Alison had the bible study rolla i doubt

the machine will do the same thing i

doubt the machine will be stuck in

social construction I doubt the machine

will think about whether it said the

right thing at the wrong time or the

wrong thing at the right time it just

moves on however we are stuck in in our

own way because you’re not really

letting your brain do the action for you

you’re not really letting your brain

fire for you and then you become someone

who’s just standing in their own way

when the idea for example of a nuclear

family was invented maybe in the 60s

that the perfect family the perfect

coexistence is a father and mother two

kids they work and this is the family

this is a social construction and you’re

being stuck in that thou as said before

I in five six years ago Egypt was in a

chaotic state and given that chaotic

state I observed something really weird

I observe people who would wear head

canizal killa killa hiya who dial with

saguaro gambas are alpha color is our

home game The Hague a puteri ok now a

machine out Lily will not do that and

the amazing thing about us humans is

that we imitate for the sake of

imitation we exist

with the sake of existence and we

communicate for the sake of

communication so we don’t really need

that Woody Woodpecker that glowing light

or that salient goal just communicating

or being around one another is good

enough so in some and I’ll make it short

but sweet all those experiments we done

ages ago and that by that I mean

possibly in the late nineteen hundreds

early 2000s now we’re in 2017 and I

would like to ask you not to use your

brain but to let your brain use you to

let your brain function well because

it’s functioning perfectly and my being

here is just to communicate that now as

a final point I recall when I came back

from France I met with an old friend and

that friend was trying to learn French

and they asked me if I recommended any

book and I said well Albert Camus is a

good book you can read about mythology

or whatever and that friend from Egypt

told me lo haga host mojito tell are

smoking jajaja fish haga telephone

oaxaca fish hey girl joseph MO Hawk

intellect odd that Cayenne Africa with

host of mosca kenton African state

muchacho esta sib mocha Costa girl and

you’ll be just fine thank you very much [Applause]

Please follow and like us: