
modern technology has ushered in a new
cultural citizenship test that needs to
be passed in order to be accepted in the
21st century world the participation in
social media I remember the first time I
logged in and created my Facebook
account it was the day after I graduated
high school and by the end of the week
my feeling of acceptance skyrocketed as
I already had 50 friends and over the
course of the next few years I started
to discover the dark side of social
media the social media argument now
whether or not we have seen this or
participated in it we have all felt the
emotion that goes along with it that the
anger the rage the jealousy all aimed at
somebody on the computer screen the
nature of social media itself openly
drives its users to conflict because as
Facebook says users can express what
matters to them now there will be ideas
that come into conflict with one another
and human history that’s nothing new
differences of ideas usually drive to
conflict but what’s different about the
social media online presence is a
significant degree of anonymity let’s
take a look at how this works in a
social media argument probably the most
crucial one we’re going to deal with
today most crucial debate ever is Harry
Potter greater than Voldemort
now these two individuals they’re going
at it and they have multiple posts
eventually they do come to the degree to
be this discussion they don’t solve the
issue for us however they do come to the
conclusion that Death Eaters are better
than Hagrid because they have tattoos
now when it comes to the social media
argument the goal is not to come to an
agreeable conclusion but rather to have
your voice be heard let’s look at him
one more serious in nature this was a
history article post on Facebook by the
History Channel
celebrating the anniversary of the USS
Maine explosion in 1898 although in 1898
it was believed to be sabotage by Spain
an investigation in 1976 discovered that
it was most likely an internal fire that
caused the ammunition to explode now
let’s look at some of the comments
our original poster of Jason here he’s
not upset over the History Channel
article but rather their use of likely
in their description and so thus ensues
the debate Mallory comes on the scene
here and she very clearly denotes that
likely does not mean definitive and she
also backs it up with a personal attack
against Jason a tactic that is very
commonly used in Facebook and other
social media arguments Brennan joins
Mallory’s team in attacking Jason and
calling on him to quote swim with the
crocodiles furthermore the argument goes
on and Mallory helps us out by giving us
some definition something that is always
helpful in a social media argument and
eventually we reach the breaking point
of every online argument as our original
poster Jason and Mallory devolved into
personal attacks eventually leading to
Mallory telling Jason and giving him
advice of how to be promoted from being
a fry cook at McDonald’s now where did
these and so many other social media
arguments go wrong well there’s three
main reasons why often online your
disagreements do not come to an
agreeable conclusion but rather
developing as these cases did with
name-calling
the first main reason why your online
arguments fail is the first beast
difficut use of logical fallacies we’ve
already seen how this works with our
example the first one was ad hominem
which essentially means of reverting to
attacking your opponent the established
rules of rhetoric do not apply to the
online world the second main reason is
you can’t see your person’s faith you
can’t see your opponent’s face the chief
contributor to negative online
interactions studies have shown is the
lack of eye contact when you’re talking
face-to-face with a person you see those
nonverbal cues and you naturally pick up
on them in real life online that just
doesn’t happen the last reason is online
arguments are in the public’s view now
we don’t have to think about this but
your conversation on Facebook or other
social media outlets is not in person it
the world can see it
other people can can see what you’re
saying and so when it comes to your
social media argument you’re more apt to
defend yourself and you’re more apt to
show to yourself and to those around you
that you’re intelligent and so you’ll
try harder to prove your point so with
all these problems what do social media
arguments actually accomplish well
according to multiple studies not very
much when it comes to studies we have a
Cornell University study which they use
the the subreddit changed my mind and
over the course of the next two and a
half years they had over 18,000 threads
in which users would post on any
particular topic and the internet would
try and change their mind what they
concluded they gathered the data and
they concluded that in only 30 percent
of the conversations online was the
original poster only slightly persuaded
this artificial environment
you only have a 30 percent persuasion
rate chances are in a real life online
Congress a
on topics that people actually actually
care about this number is going to be
significantly less furthermore what they
concluded is that your online argument
after five posts only a after five post
your online argument your chances of
persuasion are virtually impossible so
what this means best-case scenario you
have a one in three chance to persuade
your opponent and you have to do it in
less than five posts and so when it
comes to your online argument chances
are it’s going to be unsuccessful now
there has been one thing that online
arguments have been known to be a
successful in emotional stress and
fatigue multiple psychologists have come
and said including John Sewell ur an art
Markman of the University of Texas
Austin have come and they have said that
those nonverbal cues that we pick up on
in everyday life we can’t do that online
because we’re looking at a computer
screen and so what this does is it
enables the online argument to become
emotionally charged faster than
face-to-face John’s really would go on
to note that online you have the chance
to research your article your argument
you have the chance to rewrite it
possibly find a picture of your opponent
and to face it and thus because of those
reasons your arguments become
emotionally charged faster online than
in face-to-face and so when it comes to
the internet it is an amazing tool we
have had more social interaction with
those we know and those we don’t than
ever before the Internet is amazing tool
we have a massive amount of information
however when it comes to online
arguments and quarrels we have a better
tool face-to-face interaction sitting
with a person getting a cup of coffee
sitting across the table and having a
real conversation
that’s where arguments will be concluded
in an agreeable fashion and so when I
joined social media all those years ago
I entered into a brand new world that in
which I could be a part of but what I
did see where its limits online
argumentation is unsuccessful and so
let’s return to civility let’s return to
personhood in our arguments not by
looking to the computer screen to make a
change but rather looking to the face of
a human person thank you [Applause]