
recall a time when you gave someone a
really good gift that time you got the
gift just right if you were to think
about that memory and try to explain
what made your gift a good one what
would you say was it something about
what you gave something about the way
you gave it even though we all have
practice doing the kinds of actions we
call giving a gift we have a hard time
explaining what makes some of these go
well what makes some of them good ones
while others of them just fall flat or
are in some other way bad I think we can
make some progress understanding our
gift giving actions we might start by
noticing that there’s a rather natural
way of breaking up the gift action into
three moments the first moment of the
gift begins with the givers thinking
about what to give we might call this
the givers intentions the second moment
of the gift is the gift object the thing
the giver decides to give and past the
receiver the third moment of giving is
the effect the gift has on the receiver
we can approach these three moments in a
couple of different ways we might treat
them as three separate pieces of action
or we could alternatively approach them
as a unified action one single action in
our common sense everyday way of talking
about gifts I think we go with the
separate as opposed to the unified
approach to see this I want to take us
through a few familiar examples of
gift-giving to focus on the three
moments intention object and effect one
moment at a time suppose for example I
have a friend Sarah her birthday’s
coming up and I’d like to get her a gift
I asked another friend Kate for her
advice about what to give Cara Sarah
Kate says to me just give her that
something that shows you’re thinking
of her it’s the thought that counts it’s
the thought that counts as a way of
saying that giving a good gift depends
upon the first of the three moments of
giving on the givers intention this
advice that insists that if the giver
means well if she’s thoughtful then
we’ll have a good gift this advice works
sometimes but it doesn’t always work
good intentions don’t guarantee that the
gift will be good for example suppose
Sarah and I are longtime friends I
searched my memory and find a hilarious
but scandalous trip that she and I took
to New Orleans and I think of just the
thing to reference that trip in all its
glory now if I give this gift the
scandalous gift I will have from a
certain point of view been very
thoughtful I thought about our
relationship and I intended my gift is a
unique way to speak to us but if I give
this gift to Sarah at her birthday party
in front of say her grandmother this is
not a good gift it’s the wrong object to
give on that occasion and the effect on
the receiver the look of horror on
Sarah’s face when she opens that gift is
not the desired effect so with this
example we’ve done right with by one
moment of the gift the intention has
gone pretty well but we failed with
object and effect and overall this is a
bad gift so Kate and I go back to the
drawing board
this time Kate tries on a different kind
of advice focusing on the object to give
Sarah for her birthday she says just
give her something nice it’ll be great
now I know Sarah is a busy woman under a
lot of pressure and so I decide to get
her a pampering sort of gift a spa day
booked with relaxing treatments it
sounds like a nice gift we might agree
and there’s an added bonus this is a
gift it’s appropriate to give at a
birthday party in front of Grandma but
we have a problem
even though Kate’s advice picks out
something that sounds like a good gift
we aren’t safe and expecting to give a
good gift of this object to Sara why
because Sara’s just one of those people
who doesn’t like being touched by
strangers she doesn’t enjoy massages
pedicures or anything like that
she must have mentioned this to me a
thousand times so as her friend I should
know this so this time I’ve done
something right with the second moment
of giving but I failed with the first I
haven’t been particularly thoughtful and
I failed with the third this is not a
gift that Sara will enjoy again a bad
gift we’ve got one more to try out if we
can’t secure the good gift with only the
good intentions of the giver and we
can’t secure it with only the good gift
object can we guarantee that the gift
will be good by focusing only on the
third moment of giving on having the
right effect on the receiver kate says
to me forget the advice I gave you
before just give Sara something she’ll
like I think this sounds really
promising to me and now I’ve really got
it
give this gift and her face lights up I
can tell that holding that puppy is just
making her happy the desired effect on
the receiver is achieved but here again
we have a problem with Sara’s busy work
and travel schedule everyone knows she’s
in no position to take good care of a
dog we might imagine the puppies
entrance at the birthday party prompting
a collective look of what was she
thinking directed right at me this lets
me know that I failed to be thoughtful
in the right way and I’ve failed to
select a good gift object for Sara so
here again we have success at one of the
three moments but failure at the other
two and overall a bad gift it turns out
that none of the three moments of giving
can all by itself secure the good gift
that is neither the good intentions of
the giver nor the good gift object nor
the
good effect on the receiver can alone
guarantee that the gift will be good
what we need to do is change our way of
approaching the three moments of giving
instead of treating the three is three
separate pieces of action we need to
bring the three together and think of
them as a single unified action giving a
good gift is a unity among intention
object and effect making the shift to
the unified approach has two
consequences for how we think about good
giving first the unified approach
insists that giving a good gift depends
on not just one moment of the gift or
even two but on all three a second
consequence is this the unified approach
insists that if we’re thinking in the
right way about any one of the three
moments of giving will be immediately
pulled to thinking about the other two
that is giving a good gift is the kind
of action in which each of its moments
already includes the other to consider
this example Sarah and I have often met
for tea at her place or mine to catch up
over a good conversation last week her
teapot broke I decide that a new teapot
is just the thing to give Sarah for her
birthday
just a thing to let her know that I hope
our friendly tradition continues I give
the gift and she’s touched by it here
finally I’ve got it right this is a good
gift I’ve hit all three marks intention
object effect and importantly I haven’t
hit these as three separate marks it
isn’t that I had some thought about what
to give and separately a teapot would be
a good gift and separately something’s
happened to my friend who was happy
rather the intention that I had already
had a sense of what object would mark it
and already aimed at the effect on my
friend the object I gave Sarah is
already an object flowing from my
intention as that intention aims at
Sarah’s enjoyment and the effect that I
hope to have on my friend is already
from the start
effect I’m aiming at with my intention
and with the object I give we can make
progress and understanding are giving
actions and what makes some of them good
simply by bringing these three moments
together giving a gift is a unified
action so it turns out that giving a
good gift isn’t especially difficult to
do if we’ve been getting it wrong up to
now
that’s mostly because we’ve been
thinking about it in the wrong way using
what we know in fragments we can steer
toward new and fond moments of giving if
we can only bring those fragments
together into a unity we can do better
we can give good gifts simply by
approaching giving as a unity among
intention object and effect thank you [Applause]
really good gift that time you got the
gift just right if you were to think
about that memory and try to explain
what made your gift a good one what
would you say was it something about
what you gave something about the way
you gave it even though we all have
practice doing the kinds of actions we
call giving a gift we have a hard time
explaining what makes some of these go
well what makes some of them good ones
while others of them just fall flat or
are in some other way bad I think we can
make some progress understanding our
gift giving actions we might start by
noticing that there’s a rather natural
way of breaking up the gift action into
three moments the first moment of the
gift begins with the givers thinking
about what to give we might call this
the givers intentions the second moment
of the gift is the gift object the thing
the giver decides to give and past the
receiver the third moment of giving is
the effect the gift has on the receiver
we can approach these three moments in a
couple of different ways we might treat
them as three separate pieces of action
or we could alternatively approach them
as a unified action one single action in
our common sense everyday way of talking
about gifts I think we go with the
separate as opposed to the unified
approach to see this I want to take us
through a few familiar examples of
gift-giving to focus on the three
moments intention object and effect one
moment at a time suppose for example I
have a friend Sarah her birthday’s
coming up and I’d like to get her a gift
I asked another friend Kate for her
advice about what to give Cara Sarah
Kate says to me just give her that
something that shows you’re thinking
of her it’s the thought that counts it’s
the thought that counts as a way of
saying that giving a good gift depends
upon the first of the three moments of
giving on the givers intention this
advice that insists that if the giver
means well if she’s thoughtful then
we’ll have a good gift this advice works
sometimes but it doesn’t always work
good intentions don’t guarantee that the
gift will be good for example suppose
Sarah and I are longtime friends I
searched my memory and find a hilarious
but scandalous trip that she and I took
to New Orleans and I think of just the
thing to reference that trip in all its
glory now if I give this gift the
scandalous gift I will have from a
certain point of view been very
thoughtful I thought about our
relationship and I intended my gift is a
unique way to speak to us but if I give
this gift to Sarah at her birthday party
in front of say her grandmother this is
not a good gift it’s the wrong object to
give on that occasion and the effect on
the receiver the look of horror on
Sarah’s face when she opens that gift is
not the desired effect so with this
example we’ve done right with by one
moment of the gift the intention has
gone pretty well but we failed with
object and effect and overall this is a
bad gift so Kate and I go back to the
drawing board
this time Kate tries on a different kind
of advice focusing on the object to give
Sarah for her birthday she says just
give her something nice it’ll be great
now I know Sarah is a busy woman under a
lot of pressure and so I decide to get
her a pampering sort of gift a spa day
booked with relaxing treatments it
sounds like a nice gift we might agree
and there’s an added bonus this is a
gift it’s appropriate to give at a
birthday party in front of Grandma but
we have a problem
even though Kate’s advice picks out
something that sounds like a good gift
we aren’t safe and expecting to give a
good gift of this object to Sara why
because Sara’s just one of those people
who doesn’t like being touched by
strangers she doesn’t enjoy massages
pedicures or anything like that
she must have mentioned this to me a
thousand times so as her friend I should
know this so this time I’ve done
something right with the second moment
of giving but I failed with the first I
haven’t been particularly thoughtful and
I failed with the third this is not a
gift that Sara will enjoy again a bad
gift we’ve got one more to try out if we
can’t secure the good gift with only the
good intentions of the giver and we
can’t secure it with only the good gift
object can we guarantee that the gift
will be good by focusing only on the
third moment of giving on having the
right effect on the receiver kate says
to me forget the advice I gave you
before just give Sara something she’ll
like I think this sounds really
promising to me and now I’ve really got
it
give this gift and her face lights up I
can tell that holding that puppy is just
making her happy the desired effect on
the receiver is achieved but here again
we have a problem with Sara’s busy work
and travel schedule everyone knows she’s
in no position to take good care of a
dog we might imagine the puppies
entrance at the birthday party prompting
a collective look of what was she
thinking directed right at me this lets
me know that I failed to be thoughtful
in the right way and I’ve failed to
select a good gift object for Sara so
here again we have success at one of the
three moments but failure at the other
two and overall a bad gift it turns out
that none of the three moments of giving
can all by itself secure the good gift
that is neither the good intentions of
the giver nor the good gift object nor
the
good effect on the receiver can alone
guarantee that the gift will be good
what we need to do is change our way of
approaching the three moments of giving
instead of treating the three is three
separate pieces of action we need to
bring the three together and think of
them as a single unified action giving a
good gift is a unity among intention
object and effect making the shift to
the unified approach has two
consequences for how we think about good
giving first the unified approach
insists that giving a good gift depends
on not just one moment of the gift or
even two but on all three a second
consequence is this the unified approach
insists that if we’re thinking in the
right way about any one of the three
moments of giving will be immediately
pulled to thinking about the other two
that is giving a good gift is the kind
of action in which each of its moments
already includes the other to consider
this example Sarah and I have often met
for tea at her place or mine to catch up
over a good conversation last week her
teapot broke I decide that a new teapot
is just the thing to give Sarah for her
birthday
just a thing to let her know that I hope
our friendly tradition continues I give
the gift and she’s touched by it here
finally I’ve got it right this is a good
gift I’ve hit all three marks intention
object effect and importantly I haven’t
hit these as three separate marks it
isn’t that I had some thought about what
to give and separately a teapot would be
a good gift and separately something’s
happened to my friend who was happy
rather the intention that I had already
had a sense of what object would mark it
and already aimed at the effect on my
friend the object I gave Sarah is
already an object flowing from my
intention as that intention aims at
Sarah’s enjoyment and the effect that I
hope to have on my friend is already
from the start
effect I’m aiming at with my intention
and with the object I give we can make
progress and understanding are giving
actions and what makes some of them good
simply by bringing these three moments
together giving a gift is a unified
action so it turns out that giving a
good gift isn’t especially difficult to
do if we’ve been getting it wrong up to
now
that’s mostly because we’ve been
thinking about it in the wrong way using
what we know in fragments we can steer
toward new and fond moments of giving if
we can only bring those fragments
together into a unity we can do better
we can give good gifts simply by
approaching giving as a unity among
intention object and effect thank you [Applause]
Please follow and like us: