
[Music]
meet Salima Salima is living in a
village her family is struggling to get
by and one day her on came over to say I
will be able to get you a job in a
factory in Dhaka several weeks later the
on came again by the house with an
individual that she introduced as the
factory recruiter and encouraged Salima
to go to Dhaka with this guy she trusted
her and and why wouldn’t she and she
leaves the village to go to Dhaka
unfortunately when she arrives in Dhaka
she is being sold in a brothel in Mira
meet an hour
Munir and puto they were really keen to
find a job to work overseas so they
discussed with the Dalal in the village
and he arranged for them to go to Qatar
using his connections what happened when
they arrived in the destination country
in Qatar in Doha they were taking to a
labor camp their passports were taken
away they were forced to to work over 12
hours a day with very little food this
went on for over a year so what is human
trafficking I am pretty sure that all of
you came across this term either
trafficking in persons either human
trafficking or either modern slavery it
can take many forms forced labor sexual
exploitation but also domestic servitude
the bondage child marriage
world’s marriage and removal of organs
it was firstly defined in the
international legislation under the
protocol to suppress to prevent suppress
and punish trafficking in persons
especially women in children better
known as the Palermo protocol today I
choose to focus on prosecution to talk
about prosecution in human trafficking
cases the reason I choose this topic is
because it seems to me that lately the
prosecution have taken a seat back in
the anti trafficking intervention
prevention protection even social
economical intervention seems to be more
central to the combating human
trafficking
while prosecution is something that is
left to the state but what I want to
tell you today that the prevention and
protection are very closely entwined
with prosecution and without the
prosecution they are being mean
meaningless before I move forward to
make my point let me give you an idea
about what are we facing and let me
start with the trafficking myth or
misconception most of the people when
they talk about human trafficking they
have several ideas one of them is that
only women and children are being
trafficked this is not the case over 60%
of the people being trafficked are male
human trafficking its sex trafficking
this is not the case again only 20% of
the people trafficked are actually
sexually exploit exploited although we
agree that they deserve our attention
there are 68 percent which are traffic
for forced labor human trafficking the
same thing as human smuggling no human
smuggling it’s a crime committed against
the border of a country human
trafficking always a crime committed
against a person so I’ll let you read
this part and I would just conclude in
this no victim can consent to his or her
own exploitation so let me talk about
how big the business of human
trafficking is 150 billions yearly is
the profit according to ILO by contrast
the funding for the organization finding
fighting to combat human trafficking is
350 million I think that it’s 0.2
percent of something again forty five
point million people are being
trafficked and 58 percent of those are
in five Asian countries this morning we
all hurt faisal presentation about how
good and how well the population held
the growth of bangladesh i will show you
the other side 1 percent of the
Bangladeshi are in our traffic either in
within the country or outside of the
country
to combat human trafficking in 2012 a
new law was adopted
it’s called prevention and suppression
of human trafficking and let me tell you
it is a very good law I’ve been working
International and I’ve seen several laws
in lots of countries and this is one of
the best as I have seen it
not only has provision about the
investigation prosecution trial but it’s
also very important looks at the victim
protection and support however there is
a problem the rules of implementation
were adopted only in January 2017 that
means that there was a gap of five years
where the law was left to the individual
interpretation of criminal justice
sector which went to be quite a problems
in terms of the prosecution’s and I will
show you why here we have the victims
identified number of personal rests and
number of person convicted 2015 2016
2017 look at the difference between the
numbers we have thousands of people
arrested and only for three and one
convicted so why is this happening based
on my experience as a police officer
working specifically in trafficking
investigation but also considering that
within the last three years I have been
working very closely with the criminal
justice sector in Bangladesh I’ve
learned the following the police do not
recognize the crime of trafficking and
thus note that do not identify the
victim as such or when they do they keep
on taking statements over longer periods
of time and they create a secondary
victimization of the person which were
trafficked another reason is the lack of
access to evidence because the crime was
committed on the air on the destination
countries
I am pretty sure that you are familiar
with a dictum hold justice a delay
justice denied lots of trials take a
such a long amount of time that victims
are settling out with traffickers
outside of the court in this example I
have we were following closely over 100
81 cases and out of this 100 were
settled outside of court most important
reason was the length of the trial
procedure
another reason a lack of police
prosecution cooperation family pressure
not to press accusations against the
trafficking traffickers if they are part
of your family also you know they are
really concerned about the stigma and of
course corruption in the criminal
justice system meet Salima again
Salima wanted to file a case against her
and her family pressure her not to
because they did not want to lose face
and they were also very concerned about
the perspective of marriage of the other
girls in the family if the community
will find out what happened to Salomon
what happened they managed to break free
of the camp and they found a Bangladeshi
embassy they requested to be repatriated
and they were sent back to Bangladesh
after one year of hard work with nothing
they file a case against the doll the
doll was arrested and later on releasing
bail he’s continuing what he’s doing
before and he reminds them all the time
that they cannot do anything against him
so this is what I want to talk about the
connection between process
and Prevention it doesn’t matter how
many times we send out prevention
messages if the victims if the community
keep on seeing traffickers doing
whatever they are doing with impunity
and there were no consequences for their
actions and let me talk about the
protection side there is no protection
for the victims if it’s no justice it
doesn’t matter that we help the victim
you know to get access to support to
shelter to food to medical but if they
don’t get justice I will tell you what
one victim said to me I want him to go
to jail for what he did to me he
deserved to be in jail for what I got
true there is no protection for victim
if there is no justice so you might
wonder what is the solution they are
very easy action that they can be taking
like for example you speedy trial
Bangladesh has a very clear procedure of
how to use pretty a speedy trial
use it for human trafficking cases
create an anti trafficking task force
which brings together prosecutors and
police they will work together also
ensure that the victims have not only
access to support but also when a
conviction is being finalized
there is also financial compensation for
the victims and one of the most
important things
protect them from intimidation allowed
me to finish this talk by telling you
the trafficking is everywhere around us
it’s also based on demand demand for
cheap labor demand for prodigy
prodigy-man
for organs for sexual services you and
you and you myself included we are all
complicit to this look around you and
I’m pretty sure that if we look even
around this building 500 meters we will
be able to find people which are being
enslaved on in trafficking situation
what I will hope that you live here with
a new vision and you will be able to
look around you and recognize the cases
maybe this is happening even in your
house or even into your friend’s house
if you notice report it go to the police
go to the NGOs do not deny someone’s
tomorrow while you are sitting there and
contemplate yours
thank you very much
you
meet Salima Salima is living in a
village her family is struggling to get
by and one day her on came over to say I
will be able to get you a job in a
factory in Dhaka several weeks later the
on came again by the house with an
individual that she introduced as the
factory recruiter and encouraged Salima
to go to Dhaka with this guy she trusted
her and and why wouldn’t she and she
leaves the village to go to Dhaka
unfortunately when she arrives in Dhaka
she is being sold in a brothel in Mira
meet an hour
Munir and puto they were really keen to
find a job to work overseas so they
discussed with the Dalal in the village
and he arranged for them to go to Qatar
using his connections what happened when
they arrived in the destination country
in Qatar in Doha they were taking to a
labor camp their passports were taken
away they were forced to to work over 12
hours a day with very little food this
went on for over a year so what is human
trafficking I am pretty sure that all of
you came across this term either
trafficking in persons either human
trafficking or either modern slavery it
can take many forms forced labor sexual
exploitation but also domestic servitude
the bondage child marriage
world’s marriage and removal of organs
it was firstly defined in the
international legislation under the
protocol to suppress to prevent suppress
and punish trafficking in persons
especially women in children better
known as the Palermo protocol today I
choose to focus on prosecution to talk
about prosecution in human trafficking
cases the reason I choose this topic is
because it seems to me that lately the
prosecution have taken a seat back in
the anti trafficking intervention
prevention protection even social
economical intervention seems to be more
central to the combating human
trafficking
while prosecution is something that is
left to the state but what I want to
tell you today that the prevention and
protection are very closely entwined
with prosecution and without the
prosecution they are being mean
meaningless before I move forward to
make my point let me give you an idea
about what are we facing and let me
start with the trafficking myth or
misconception most of the people when
they talk about human trafficking they
have several ideas one of them is that
only women and children are being
trafficked this is not the case over 60%
of the people being trafficked are male
human trafficking its sex trafficking
this is not the case again only 20% of
the people trafficked are actually
sexually exploit exploited although we
agree that they deserve our attention
there are 68 percent which are traffic
for forced labor human trafficking the
same thing as human smuggling no human
smuggling it’s a crime committed against
the border of a country human
trafficking always a crime committed
against a person so I’ll let you read
this part and I would just conclude in
this no victim can consent to his or her
own exploitation so let me talk about
how big the business of human
trafficking is 150 billions yearly is
the profit according to ILO by contrast
the funding for the organization finding
fighting to combat human trafficking is
350 million I think that it’s 0.2
percent of something again forty five
point million people are being
trafficked and 58 percent of those are
in five Asian countries this morning we
all hurt faisal presentation about how
good and how well the population held
the growth of bangladesh i will show you
the other side 1 percent of the
Bangladeshi are in our traffic either in
within the country or outside of the
country
to combat human trafficking in 2012 a
new law was adopted
it’s called prevention and suppression
of human trafficking and let me tell you
it is a very good law I’ve been working
International and I’ve seen several laws
in lots of countries and this is one of
the best as I have seen it
not only has provision about the
investigation prosecution trial but it’s
also very important looks at the victim
protection and support however there is
a problem the rules of implementation
were adopted only in January 2017 that
means that there was a gap of five years
where the law was left to the individual
interpretation of criminal justice
sector which went to be quite a problems
in terms of the prosecution’s and I will
show you why here we have the victims
identified number of personal rests and
number of person convicted 2015 2016
2017 look at the difference between the
numbers we have thousands of people
arrested and only for three and one
convicted so why is this happening based
on my experience as a police officer
working specifically in trafficking
investigation but also considering that
within the last three years I have been
working very closely with the criminal
justice sector in Bangladesh I’ve
learned the following the police do not
recognize the crime of trafficking and
thus note that do not identify the
victim as such or when they do they keep
on taking statements over longer periods
of time and they create a secondary
victimization of the person which were
trafficked another reason is the lack of
access to evidence because the crime was
committed on the air on the destination
countries
I am pretty sure that you are familiar
with a dictum hold justice a delay
justice denied lots of trials take a
such a long amount of time that victims
are settling out with traffickers
outside of the court in this example I
have we were following closely over 100
81 cases and out of this 100 were
settled outside of court most important
reason was the length of the trial
procedure
another reason a lack of police
prosecution cooperation family pressure
not to press accusations against the
trafficking traffickers if they are part
of your family also you know they are
really concerned about the stigma and of
course corruption in the criminal
justice system meet Salima again
Salima wanted to file a case against her
and her family pressure her not to
because they did not want to lose face
and they were also very concerned about
the perspective of marriage of the other
girls in the family if the community
will find out what happened to Salomon
what happened they managed to break free
of the camp and they found a Bangladeshi
embassy they requested to be repatriated
and they were sent back to Bangladesh
after one year of hard work with nothing
they file a case against the doll the
doll was arrested and later on releasing
bail he’s continuing what he’s doing
before and he reminds them all the time
that they cannot do anything against him
so this is what I want to talk about the
connection between process
and Prevention it doesn’t matter how
many times we send out prevention
messages if the victims if the community
keep on seeing traffickers doing
whatever they are doing with impunity
and there were no consequences for their
actions and let me talk about the
protection side there is no protection
for the victims if it’s no justice it
doesn’t matter that we help the victim
you know to get access to support to
shelter to food to medical but if they
don’t get justice I will tell you what
one victim said to me I want him to go
to jail for what he did to me he
deserved to be in jail for what I got
true there is no protection for victim
if there is no justice so you might
wonder what is the solution they are
very easy action that they can be taking
like for example you speedy trial
Bangladesh has a very clear procedure of
how to use pretty a speedy trial
use it for human trafficking cases
create an anti trafficking task force
which brings together prosecutors and
police they will work together also
ensure that the victims have not only
access to support but also when a
conviction is being finalized
there is also financial compensation for
the victims and one of the most
important things
protect them from intimidation allowed
me to finish this talk by telling you
the trafficking is everywhere around us
it’s also based on demand demand for
cheap labor demand for prodigy
prodigy-man
for organs for sexual services you and
you and you myself included we are all
complicit to this look around you and
I’m pretty sure that if we look even
around this building 500 meters we will
be able to find people which are being
enslaved on in trafficking situation
what I will hope that you live here with
a new vision and you will be able to
look around you and recognize the cases
maybe this is happening even in your
house or even into your friend’s house
if you notice report it go to the police
go to the NGOs do not deny someone’s
tomorrow while you are sitting there and
contemplate yours
thank you very much
you
Please follow and like us: