
enjoying sustained calm and consensus a
general sense that our institutions are
just an efficient and serving the common
good okay now come back to reality
because that is not the society that we
live in here in now America 2018 we’re
actually pretty angry about a lot of our
institutions so think about the criminal
justice system do we celebrate it as a
stable pillar of our just society hardly
we’re pretty worried about things like
police violence and mass incarceration
and racial disparities and sentencing so
forth right or how about our election
system do we think of this as a
well-oiled mechanism of democracy that
it’s supposed to be
we’re troubled Frank we’re troubled over
things like the way that campaigns are
funded by corporate interests and by
gerrymandered district and by trench
Mynt of party loyalty and so on right
and how about the the news media so
everybody seems to think that everybody
else is getting fed fake news but we
don’t know we can’t agree on who the
arbiter is right so we we feel really
ambivalent about our institutions you
could probably add to that list of those
I’d mentioned some institution that you
feel personally distressed by right what
do we do with our distress well what
most people do is complain about
institutions on social media right which
hardly ever leads to anything good but
what we need are not complainers but
reformers we need those who love their
institutions enough in order to work
toward making them healthier
but how do we reform our institutions
how’s that how’s that possible
is it even possible where do we begin
and and and and where can we find some
sort of guide or template to show us how
to do it well I’m here to deliver some
good news
reform is possible and the reason I know
it’s possible is that it’s been done
before five hundred years ago last
October marked it was the 500th
anniversary of a monumentally successful
reform movement and I mean the one that
Martin Luther spearheaded so my claim
today is that a little bit of
familiarity with the way that Luther
went about reforming can go a long way
in helping guide us as we try to reform
our institutions today so what I’m gonna
do i I’m going to talk through what I
take to be the four stages of Luther’s
reform movement do we do we have the
slides we have the slides I would have
them up there okay great
okay so the first stage is protesting a
Martin Luther there is great okay so so
it’s 1517 and Luther is a monk and a
theologian the little German town of
Vinton burg and he hears that Johann
Tetzel a traveling indulgent salesman is
coming to the area indulgences have long
been a part of medieval Catholic piety
so the idea is in exchange for some act
of penitence like giving alms or going
on a pilgrimage you would be given by
your father confessor this document
called an indulgence there’s one that
confirmed that your act of penitence was
meritorious that the punishment for your
sin had been lifted now this practice
had degenerated to the point where
European peasants were simply being told
give us money and your relatives will be
ushered through purgatory to paradise so
we’ve become just a way of making money
by exploiting the faithful basically and
this made Luther furious so what he did
was he protested and he did this by
nailing his famous 95 theses to the
Vidhan burg church door this is a
professor’s protest a way of stating
grievances declaring that this practice
was degenerate and his protest was
really successful so Johann Tetzel
campaign failed and Luther got all of
Europe talking about indulgences and
whether they were appropriate
so so what is Luther do next the next
stage is rediscovering the foundations
Luther digs into the theological
foundations of the institutional church
he’s trying to reform he wants to
identify the theological beating heart
that that’s underneath all of the
corruption and he succeeds in finding
its grace okay so the idea is salvation
is not a matter of doing good works to
to meet God’s approval rather it’s a
matter of receiving while we’re sinners
God’s gift of salvation so this core
insight about grace is the thing that
animates everything that follows for
Luther and this is really important
because it allows Luther to move beyond
a negative vision and a sense for what’s
wrong with the church to a positive
vision a sense for what’s possible for
the church and and this with this
positive vision as his Polestar he is
able to navigate between two errors one
error would be not going far enough with
his reform for example just declaring
indulgences
not permitting indulgences but not then
dealing with any of the underlying
corruption the other error would be
going too far
say rejecting the Christian tradition
altogether as Luther articulates his
central insight about grace and the
positive vision that follows from it
conflict with Rome increases until by
1521 four years later it becomes clear
that no reconciliation with Rome is
going to be possible and this takes us
to the third stage implementing local
changes so Luther gets together with the
some other leaders in Vidhan burg to try
out some new ways of doing Church so he
the the mass is conducted in German
rather than in land and both the bread
and the wine are given to parishioners
Luther translates the Bible into German
confession is not required for for the
forgiveness of sins the the number of
sacraments is reduced from seven to two
and so on what all these things have in
common is that they’re out workings of
Luther’s core insight about grace but
they’re implemented locally on a small
scale as a sort of pilot program in
Vinton burg and Luther oversees their
implementation with the eye of a realist
so he knows he’s got to keep this team
together he’s got to keep him from
fighting among themselves
he’s got to admonish the overzealous and
he’s got to encourage the timid and he’s
got to constantly remind them about that
that grace is the is the the the central
idea here and it almost doesn’t work his
team almost falls apart it’s only
because of his meticulous
this patient attentive leadership that
this that this goes gradually reform in
the Vinton Berg mold spreads to other
towns in Germany and a movement really
begins in earnest and takes us to the
fourth stage restructuring for a
sustainable future so Luther recognizes
that he’s not going to live forever so
he collaborates with some civil leaders
and some church leaders to try to make
this a long-term thing
he writes catechisms which are teaching
manuals for both clergy and laity he
writes the Augsburg confession which is
a succinct statement of his doctrine and
he helps establish schools and
seminaries so that the next generation
can be educated I think it’s here that
Luther really demonstrates his wisdom
because this is the boring and tedious
part right this is where Luther he’s
taking up the unglamorous
task of establishing new institutional
systems that can outlive him and they do
I’ll live him the Lutheran movement is
vibrant to this day okay so four stages
protesting a harm rediscovering the
foundations implementing local changes
and restructuring for a sustainable
future
I submit that successful reform is
always going to involve all four stages
so let’s think about what it would be
like to stop at an earlier stage so
suppose you identify some problem in an
institution and you vigorously protest
it and then you stop so I call this the
the lazy reformer now I’m not saying
that protesters are lazy far from it
protest requires an enormous amount of
courage and tireless perseverance
however if you protest and then stop you
are avoiding a hard intellectual work
it’s the work of studying the history
and the mechanics of the institution
that you’re trying to reform to
understand what its core values are and
why the way it’s currently structured
stifles rather than expressing those
core values that’s really complicated
stuff that’s hard work
so let’s say you do that hard work you
gain some insight you have some ideas
and then you stop okay I call this the
the timid reformer so I look reform is
risky you might actually make the
institution worse this does happen
well-meaning reformers make institutions
worse sometimes you certainly will get
some pushback you’ll make some new
enemies right but if you got an idea
you’ve done your homework you’ve got an
idea put it on the table take a risk at
your hands dirty okay so let’s say you’d
do that and that some of your ideas are
implemented and this is going and you
stop I call that the self-absorbed
reformer so at this point the the
reformer still has all of the power the
reformer this is that the reforms are
the reformers brainchild right so the
process is only complete once the
reformer can hand off the reins to the
next generation and can bow out and to
go that far
five hundred years ago the church needed
reforming and Luther stepped up and
today our institutions need reforming
maybe you are called to be a reformer to
love an institution that you’re part of
enough to work to make it healthier but
just make sure you’re in it for the long
haul so don’t be a lazy reformer don’t
be a timid reformer don’t be a
self-absorbed performer be like Luther
be studious be a risk-taker be
self-transcending and who knows what’s
possible if you see this process through
to its end so are you ready let’s get
reforming thank you [Applause]