Press "Enter" to skip to content

How the Internet and Copyright Fuel Creativity | Casey Fiesler | TEDxCU


I love the Internet you might love the
internet too you probably have your own
reasons maybe you like seeing pictures
of your friends cats on Facebook or
maybe you like laughing out loud at cats
who want cheeseburgers or like me are
particularly enamored of cats made of
pop-tarts who fly through space on
rainbows because of all the things I
love about the Internet the massive
amount of creativity that it has
unleashed is my favorite I first heard
about the Internet in the back of a
baby-sitters club book when I was 10 it
was an ad for The Prodigy internet
service and strangely enough my parents
did not want to pay 10 dollars a month
so that I could talk to strangers about
books but when I finally did get online
a few years later I discovered that one
of my favorite forms of creativity is
actually a kind of remix and lots of
people were already doing it I was
writing my own stories about
baby-sitters club characters and it
turns out this is called fanfiction and
people have been writing stories about
other people’s characters for decades
but with the internet they suddenly had
a much easier way to share them with
each other so I stopped writing stories
about baby-sitters club and started
writing stories about Star Trek and now
20 years later I am basically a
professor of people doing cool things on
the Internet
but when I was in high school in the mid
90s it didn’t occur to me that my Star
Trek stories might be copyright
infringement this was pre Napster we
didn’t even think copying a song was
copyright infringement at this point no
one really cared about copyright except
lawyers and corporations and
professional content creators but now we
care because now all of us are content
creators Facebook status updates tweets
image means you
two videos stories about Star Trek now
we’re all creating new things often
using existing media because this cat
isn’t popular just because of the first
cat it’s all the cats that came after it
remixed cats new versions of cats all of
these creative cats as Lawrence Lessig
says we don’t live in a read-only
culture anymore
it’s a readwrite culture we can comment
with media as much as we can comment on
media and we do this was why I started
writing stories about Star Trek in the
first place
I wanted to give the female characters
more to do I thought that Ahura had it
in her to be more than a telephone
operator and so I wrote stories where
she and Christine chapel the nurse saved
the day over and over again and then I
shared these stories with other people
online and I felt like it really said
something because this is one of the
amazing things the combination of this
democratized creativity and saying
something because now we don’t need a
publisher to share a novel with the rest
of the world we don’t need a distributor
to create a film before the Internet
even sharing Star Trek stories required
staplers and stamps and if you wanted to
say something important you had to
convince a newspaper to publish an op-ed
but YouTube videos these days have more
views than op-eds
and we can use this readwrite culture to
say important things maybe you want to
comment about the portrayal of women in
video games so use clips from those
video games to show patterns or maybe
you want to make political commentary
using politicians own words and a little
bit of humor so you make a political
remix video everyone these days has
something to say and we have the ability
to say it to a lot of people let me tell
you a story about a time when I had
something important to say
in 2014 there was a controversy around
Barbie and sexism now this was 20 years
after Barbie said math is hard this time
the message was girls can’t code let me
briefly recap the plot of the published
book Barbie I can be a computer engineer
Barbie is sitting at the kitchen table
with her laptop and skipper asked her
what she’s doing
Barbie says she’s creating a video game
which is pretty cool and so skipper
asked if she can play the game and
Barbie says laughing I’m only creating
the design ideas I need Stephan and
Brian to turn it into a real game after
this Barbie realizes that her computer
is infected with a virus and in trying
to fix it she infects skippers computer
with a virus luckily there’s a happy
ending Stephan and Brian fix both the
computers and finished the video game
boys to the rescue I probably don’t have
to tell you what’s wrong with this story
I could have done an entire talk about
the representation of women in
technology fields how today young girls
are often still told that it’s okay if
they’re not as good at math as boys
girls are good at design ideas and boys
are good at building things the good
that can be done from suggesting that a
girl like Barbie could be a computer
engineer can be undone by a narrative
like this of course we had the typical
internet outrage over this after a
blogger brought this book to the world’s
attention at the time I was finishing up
my dissertation so procrastinating and
therefore completely on board with this
outrage and I thought at the time
at least this is going to be a meme
because it’s so bad I thought this is
the kind of thing that our readwrite
culture is built to tear to pieces and
then I thought well I could do that
and again I was procrastinating from my
dissertation so I thought it was a
really good idea so I took a night and I
rewrote the entire book I learned what
everyone was outraged about I got some
feedback from my roommate I’ve blanked
all the pages in Photoshop and created a
brand new narrative in my story barbi
and Stephan and Brian are still creating
a game together but Barbie happens to be
the one doing the coding and the drama
is not Barbie’s utter incompetence when
it comes to computer security but
instead internet trolls suggesting that
she can’t be the one doing the coding on
this videogame because she’s a girl my
story also has a happy ending
Barbie ignores the trolls she and Steven
and Brian make a great game and at the
end she realizes that yeah she can be a
computer engineer so I posted Barbie
remix now with less sexism on my blog
and the next day it had 50,000 hits and
there was a story about it in Cosmo I
didn’t expect this to go viral I doubt
you ever do but the response was
overwhelmingly positive and it wasn’t
just the commentary about the original
book the bloggers who’d written about it
the first time had done a great job of
that already but the way that I
critiqued it using the original people
got it it said something new in fact the
piece of criticism that I did get was
isn’t this copyright infringement Mattel
is going to sue you I have a law degree
my area of expertise is copyright law
and internet law
and actually this critique did not
surprise me at all that dissertation I
was finishing was in part about
confusion in the law around remix and
how it impacts the way that people are
creative online after all haven’t you
ever wondered why Saturday Night Live
can parody television shows or songs why
you can quote a book in a book review or
this massive amount of creativity the
image memes you’re sharing on Facebook
over and over if every thing that is
ever a copy of anything was always
copyright infringement then our entire
creative production would look really
different the point of copyright law in
the Constitution is to promote
creativity and innovation the idea is
that if you spend ten years writing a
novel and then as soon as you publish it
someone else can copy it word-for-word
and publish it again and then reap all
of the financial rewards you might not
want to spend so much time writing that
novel this bit of control over your
creative production is intended as an
incentive but most of our current
copyright laws were penned in the 70s
before the internet when the idea that
so many people would create so many
things and have no expectation of being
paid for it seemed a little crazy so if
our current copyright laws seems
slightly broken when it comes to the
internet it’s because they weren’t built
to deal with the ways that we’re being
creative now and sometimes copyright law
isn’t used quite as intended anyway if
it’s meant to be a shield to protect
yourself from other people exploiting
your work or profiting off of your work
consider if it’s used as a sword instead
to hack away a criticism or free speech
luckily the law accounts for this
in the United States there’s something
called fair use which is an exception to
copyright law it’s intended as a safety
valve between copyright and free speech
after all imagine if you always had to
ask permission for everything dear book
publisher may I please quote a paragraph
from your book so that I can trash it in
my review or can I use the images from
your book so that I can convey to the
world how sexist it is again copyright
law is intended to promote creativity
not to kill criticism and this is why
criticism and commentary are a big part
of this exception to copyright law you
might think well it usually works out
okay after all Mattel did not sue me but
not all copyright holders are so
reasonable
for example I’ve spoken to many people
over the course of my research who have
gotten cease and desist letters over
remix videos on YouTube or fanfiction
it’s a lot easier for a copyright holder
to have something taken down than it is
to fight it what if copyright isn’t a
sword but a grenade you just throw it
out there for anything that might be a
possible threat but without a lot of
concern for potentially innocent
casualties one example of this with
someone else who had something to say
about sexism if we concede that a
reasonable critique of a twilight film
series is that the female protagonist
does not have a lot of agency a lot of
people have written about this issue and
scholarly articles and blog posts and
this video says the same thing
it takes scenes from Twilight and Buffy
the Vampire Slayer and splices them
together to create a new narrative in
Buffy vs. Edward Edward Cullen meets a
strong female protagonist who takes no
crap from vampires spoiler she stakes
him at the end
and this video was flagged for copyright
infringement not once but twice by
Lionsgate the film studio behind
Twilight in this case the Creator
happens to be someone who knows his
rights very well and was willing to
fight for them but over the course of my
research I’ve talked to many content
creators and I looked at the chilling
effects of copyright law an online
creative production I can tell you with
some confidence that for most people if
they get a cease and desist letter about
a remix then that remix will be gone
from the internet forever because along
with this massive amount of creativity
and these new forms of creativity comes
uncertainty around the law and people
afraid of getting into trouble and who
can blame them when even YouTube’s
official video about their copyright
policy presents fair use as something
scary confusing and it will literally
crush you and before you create your
silly remix video and put it on YouTube
maybe you should consult a qualified
copyright attorney and if you do get
your video flagged for copyright
infringement and you want to fight it
well in that case you need to be really
sure you’re right because if you’re
wrong you could get in a lot of trouble
that’s how the law works so could people
have gotten in trouble for nyan cat
remixes can we have gotten in trouble
for the Star Trek stories could I have
gotten in trouble for remix seeing this
Barbie book if I didn’t know as much
about copyright as I do I might have
been very concerned by the first two or
three or four people suggesting that I
was going to be sued maybe I would have
taken down the remix out of fear but
what good is that kind of creative
suppression do for anyone after all
Barbie remix actually had a really good
brief taste of internet fame I have a
really good example for doing talks like
this one but most importantly Mattel
really took all of the criticism to
heart
last year they released game developer
Barbie not only is she wearing sensible
shoes but she does all of her own coding
and the messaging around her involved
things like teamwork and creativity and
things that I really tried to emphasize
in the narrative that I created this is
why it’s so important for us to protect
creative criticism and for us to protect
cool things that aren’t harming
copyright owners like stories about
baby-sitters club and Star Trek because
the internet is for cats the internet is
for saying important things sometimes at
the same time and copyright law allows
us this kind of creative expression the
internet and all of its awesomeness
along with copyright provide fuel for us
to be creative and for us to say
important things so it’s our job to take
that fuel and to make the internet a little more awesome
Please follow and like us: