Press "Enter" to skip to content

‘How Stress Makes Us Sharper’ | Ian Robertson | TEDxTrinityCollegeDublin


how to lobsters grow if a hard fixed

shell

a soft growing lobster good to have to

think about that I’ll come back to later

now I need your help

about ten days ago my heart was racing

my stomach was churning my mouth was dry

my skin was sweaty what emotion was I

no no Ireland Ireland had just beat

England a rugby so how is it the two

such different emotions anxiety and

stress and excitement can have the same

bodily symptoms well

these symptoms are the sympathetic

autonomic nervous system in

fight-or-flight mode these are symptoms

of arousal and that arousal is general

and is common to many different emotions

anxiety excitement anger indeed

sexual attraction as well so how do I

know what emotion I’m experiencing well

I knew I was excited in that pub in

Sligo with people shouting about me I

knew I was excited because of the

context had I been down a dark Lynn with

someone coming at me with a knife I

would have known that I was frightened

that I was anxious but arousal which is

the common energy of emotions is like

all energy something that can be

Ernest in a number of different ways

there was a very clever psychologist

called Allison Brooks Pittsburgh who

used this principle practical effect

she took a group of people like you and

she took them one by one to come down

here like me and do mental arithmetic

and sing karaoke in front of a critical

audience like you and their actual

objective performance was measured

they were also wired up to a heart

monitor and they could see on a screen

the pounding of their heart represented

there but she made one other small

adjustment one group of people had to

say three words before they performed

three words out loud they had to say I

feel anxious a fairly accurate

representation of a state of affairs

other group had to say three different

words they had to say

I feel excited and remarkably that group

performed significantly better at the

karaoke under the mental arithmetic in

objective terms they performed better

why was that well the human brain is the

most complex entity in the known

universe and it has the capacity to

create its own context in this case by

language by saying three words I feel

excited was like an alchemy transforming

one emotion anxiety and the sense of

threat

into another one excitement and a sense

of challenge and possibility how did

that work

scientifically well to explain that I

have to show you one of the most famous

curves and all of psychology it’s called

the yerkes-dodson curve from 1908 which

showed that for any performance exam

speech musical performance there’s an

optimal level of arousal below that

optimal level the performance is poor

and above that optimal level performance

is poor and in order to get yourself to

that optimal level that sweet spot you

need to be able to engineer your own

arousal and stress the stress of

performance can actually push you up to

that peak but it can also push you over

the other side such that you have too

much arousal which actually interferes

with how your brain is functioning and

so what Allison Brooks did was by

changing the context with these three

words she pulled the people back from

the left side of that curve up to the

top up to their sweet spot so that

actually they could perform

significantly better and they performed

significantly better because of a

natural chemical in the brain called

norepinephrine or as is called in Europe

noradrenaline which anytime we

experience this arousal of the

fight-or-flight system our brain

generates increasing levels of

norepinephrine and that’s generated in a

part of the brain a tiny sliver of

tissue called the locus coeruleus deep

and when the norepinephrine is this

optimal level your brain performs like

an orchestra the different parts of your

brain are sweetly synchronized to little

and it doesn’t work so well too much and

it doesn’t work so well so I’m going to

give you a little tip now I’d like you

to close your eyes for a moment I’ll do

this too and we’re going to to your own

count of five can breathe in slowly to

the count of five and then out to the

how many of you felt a tiny bit

different after doing that compared to

before up your hand if you did that’s

because you changed your brain chemistry

because the remarkable thing about the

locus coeruleus the brain’s only source

of norepinephrine nor adrenaline is

chemo sensitive it responds to how much

carbon dioxide is in your blood and you

control moment to moment how much carbon

dioxide is in your blood by the way you

breathe and so you have a second method

to bring yourself to the sweet spot of

performance you have a second method by

using your breath to either pull your

back from the over stimulated over those

of norepinephrine right hand side of

this curve but you can also sometimes if

you’re in the left side of the curve you

can use your breathing by breathing in a

different way to bring yourself up to

that sweet spot but that’s another sweet

spot I want to tell you about is even

more important and that’s called the

adversity sweet spot and a sportsman

like Tiger Woods he knows all about this

for him the day he is not nervous as

there he quits he feels the right of

that anxiety he uses that arousal of

performance to get himself to the sweet

spot and all the great sports men and

women of the world implicitly or

explicitly know that to perform at their

best they have to manage the energy this

nonspecific arousal that’s common to all

emotions and use it to get their brain

to that orchestrated symphonic

performance of coordinated firing of the

different parts of the brain

by using the arousal and by titrating

and modifying how much nor epinephrine

or adrenaline is in their brain and if

you can do that then you can also manage

the second sweet spot that I’m going to

talk about which is the adversity sweet

spot it turns out the people who in

their youth or childhood and childhood

had very little adversity or very little

stress end up being more emotionally

vulnerable as young adults they’re more

likely to be depressed and anxious be

having difficulties in life experience

of moderate stressors inoculates you to

some extent vaccinates you against

subsequent greater stresses severe

stress is another matter

because what we have here is another

sweet spot another inverted u-shaped

curve where two little adversity in life

leaves you exposed and vulnerable in the

similar way to too much adversity but

there’s a sweet spot in the middle that

leaves you more emotionally tough it is

not just emotions if you in middle age

experience low back pain and you’ve had

no or little adversity in your previous

life you’re significantly more likely to

be taking severe pain killing

medications to be disabled and to be

chronically off work so it affects your

pain tolerance your physical pain

tolerance as well again this sweet spot

of moderate adversity but even more

remarkably some people in their 70s and

80s show memory decline a minority but

once you have

fragile memory at that age your

likelihood of that progressing is

greatly increased so in one study in

Holland sure enough they measured

people’s cognitive function over a

two-year period and found indeed there

was a decline in cognitive function

among these people who had fragile

memory except except for people who had

moderate levels of stress during that

two-year period what do I mean by

moderate levels of stress I mean not

death of a spouse that’s too stressful

but serious illness of a spouse stroke

or cancer conflict with family or

neighbors these kind of moderate

stresses not-nice stress or by any means

bizarrely seem to Montaine cognitive

function in older people who otherwise

were going to decline in fact if they

had three such stressors of the two-year

period they showed no cognitive decline

whatsoever why is that

well if you are 70 or 80 and not working

perhaps you’re maybe living a very

pleasant life maybe very predictable

your brain is probably not going to be

being challenged when our brain is

challenged it generates norepinephrine

noradrenaline by switching on the locus

coeruleus and norepinephrine is a

remarkable drug because what it does is

it helps grow new brain cells and new

brain connections and it may even reduce

the toxicity of the amyloid plaques that

are associated with Alzheimer’s disease

and so if you’re a person who suddenly

is faced with having to cope with a

seriously ill spouse or cope with family

conflict it may not be nice but actually

forces your brain to produce a natural

and incredibly positive drug

norepinephrine noradrenaline

as long as it doesn’t push you over the

other side of the curve which is why

severe adversity can be as bad as new

adversity so I’d like to go back to mr.

lobster

how does he grow an ambitious hungry

growing soft lobster and a hard

unyielding shell what happens what

happens is starts to hurt the sharp

interior of the shell is rubbing against

this pain the stress there is adversity

what does he do he looks around and

finds a big rock he crawls under the

rock and he painfully squeezes out of

the old shell and he lies there

vulnerable until a new bigger shell

grows he does that several times in a

lobster life I think that’s not a bad

analogy about stress and how if we

approach stress properly and use the

energy of stress we can have benefits

not only for our emotional state for a

physical body and indeed that precious

resource our mental function thank you

you [Applause]

Please follow and like us: