
arguably most important currencies in
our lives money and happiness and the
question that I want to focus on more
specifically is whether we can use one
of them to get more of the other so can
money buy happiness okay so let’s start
by looking at me at the age of three you
can see I’ve barely changed at all since
now my grandma had bought me this
beautiful garden gnome and I loved them
so much that I just wouldn’t stop
hugging it even though you probably
agree that it’s not exactly the greatest
targeting material so in this case the
money my grandma had invested really did
buy the happiness it was expected to buy
that they I was pretty much the happiest
personal life now before we draw any
overly hasting conclusions from this
story let’s look at me again this time
on Christmas Eve at the age of seven so
my parents had scraped together all
their savings to buy me this badass bike
here and they have been excited for
weeks to give it to me now as you can
probably tell from the somewhat fake and
forced smile on my face it didn’t quite
turn out the way they had expected it
was basically a Christmas tragedy and
that involves a lot of crying on my end
and a lot of general unhappiness on
Christmas Eve now why because what I had
asked my parents for was not a badass
bike but actually this really really
girly Bobby caravan here now imagine how
disappointed I was and when I found out
that not only had I not got the Barbie
Caravan but my younger sister had
actually got it instead yes and you can
probably tell that I still haven’t fully
recovered from that childhood trauma
it’ll probably take years so in this
case I like in the previous story the
money my parents had invested clearly
failed to buy the happiness they had
hoped for and what can we learn from
these two stories well first of all I
was a pretty weird kid
um but obviously I wouldn’t have
embarrassed myself so badly here if
there wasn’t to be a great educational
lesson to be learned from this because
what these two stories actually show is
that the answer to the question of
whether or not money can buy happiness
isn’t really obvious and isn’t really
straightforward so the only conclusion
we can really draw so far is that it
depends now if you’re like me you’re
probably not very satisfied with that
conclusion at the very least it would be
good to know what it depends on and this
is exactly what I want to talk about
today so want to discuss both ways in
which money can and ways in which money
cannot buy you greater happiness so when
I’m done talking I really want you to
have a better idea of how you can make
your money work for you network for your
happiness rather than having it the
other way around ok so let’s start by
looking at ways in which money cannot
buy happiness so what you see here is
the annual household income in the US on
the horizontal axis increasing from left
to right and you get the percentage of
people experiencing positive effect
which is basically a measure of
happiness on the horizontal axis so
let’s look at what the relationship
between these two variables looks like
the first thing you see is that people
with very low income so people on the
left-hand side
they experience substantially lower
levels of positive effect of happiness
and that makes sense because when you
think about it and having very little
money available simply makes many
aspects of life much harder however what
you also see is that the curve flattens
very quickly so above a threshold of
around $75,000 and a year money doesn’t
really do much for our happiness anymore
now you might be thinking well this
scale only goes up to 180,000 clearly
millionaires with all the money in the
world and absolutely nothing to worry
about
we’ll be happier right it turns out that
this is not the case so even when
look at the very end of the income scale
money doesn’t seem to affect happiness
anymore so this tells a very clear story
right and that is that money in and by
itself doesn’t really do anything for a
happiness don’t despair and because
there’s more to the story
because what researchers have suggested
recently is that money can indeed buy
happiness if we’re spending it right so
the question is not how much money we
have or how much money we make but what
we do with the money that’s available to
us so what this research shows for
example is that people are happier if
they spend money on others rather than
themselves or if they spend money on
experiences rather than material goods
and this is great because those are two
very simple but very powerful ways in
which you can actually make your money
work for you and your happiness
however this research is based on an
assumption and that for me as a
personality psychologist who basically
studies and how people differ from one
another
seems a bit overly simplistic and that’s
the assumption that what makes you happy
makes me happy so the idea that the same
types of spending increase happiness for
everybody I’m just going to show you an
example of why I think this is a bit too
simplistic so let’s take this young lady
here and assume that she has a choice to
either spend her money on going to a
rock concert on buying this fancy new
handbag here now if you think back
previous research would suggest that
people are generally happier if they
spend money on experiences rather than
material goods but I’m pretty sure that
most of you here would agree with me
that in her case it’s fairly
questionable whether she would enjoy
going to the rock concert more than
buying her selves a new handbag now if
we take a different person this can
actually shift immediately so again I’m
sure that you would probably all agree
that in her case going to the rock
concert is probably a better idea in
terms of increasing her em happiness
than buying the handbag so once you
assume that people have their unique
interests and preferences
is the question that we need to answer
shifts from what is the right type of
spending to what is the right type of
spending for this particular individual
and luckily and there’s a
well-established theory in psychology
that actually helps us to answer that
question and that’s the theory of
psychological fit now what does theory
suggests is that people who experience
fit in the lives are happier for example
and this research showing that people
are happier if they have partners who
are similar to them psychologically if
they work in an environment that
reflects their psychological needs or
even if they just live in a residential
area that is in line with their
psychological motivations now what I
have suggested and in collaboration with
my co-authors Joe Gladstone and David
Stillwell is that we can take the
concept of psychological fit and apply
it to the context of consumption so the
hypothesis that we’re putting forward is
really that money can indeed buy
happiness if we spend it in line with
our personality so if we spend it in a
way that money matches our most
fundamental needs and preferences ok so
because we obviously had to test this
hypothesis
what we did is we conducted a study with
students at the University of Cambridge
and what we did is we gave students a
personality questionnaire and we invited
the students who scored among the top
30% and those who scored among the
bottom 30% of extraversion to come to us
into the lab and before so basically the
extroverted group with worst was a group
of students like highly sociable highly
outgoing when the interpreter group was
kind of made up of rather reserved and
quiet students before we told them
anything about the study we actually
gave them a Happiness questionnaire to
measure their baseline happiness just
just how happy were students in general
without participating in our study at
all we then randomly assigned students
in both groups to receive either a
seven-pound
and voucher for the student bar
which in our case was a proxy for an
extroverted product or a 7-pound voucher
for a bookstore as a proxy for an
introverted product we then told
students well go about your lives and
spend a voucher within the next two days
and then please stay in the bar or read
the book for at least 30 minutes and the
longest consumption experience we
measured students happiness at three
time points first once they had received
the voucher second when they cashed a
voucher and third right after they had
it and consume the product for 30
minutes that they had stayed in the bar
for thirty minutes or they had read the
book for thirty minutes and just to make
to simplify the analyses we took these
three measures and we calculated an
overall measure of consumption happiness
that we could then compare back to
students baseline level happiness okay
so now let’s look at what we found so
what you can see here and is student is
the change in happiness in comparison to
students baseline so how did the
consumption experience affect students
happiness in comparison to how happy
they were before everything that’s above
the line means that got happier
everything below the line means they got
less happy so if we start with the book
condition we have introverts and blue
extroverts and green and the little
puzzle icon just marks the matching
condition so in the case of the book
voucher the matching condition there was
a group of introverted students and the
first thing you can see is they’re
basically getting the the book voucher
increased happiness in both groups so
Cambridge students generally seem to
appreciate getting a free book what you
also see is as expected like the level
of happiness increased more strongly in
the matching condition so the blue bar
is higher than the green bar now when we
look at the bar condition again here we
have extroverts in green that’s the
matching condition and what we see here
is a somewhat more divergent pattern
because while happiness increased for
extroverted students it decreased for
introverted students which means that
sending there’s poor
in turds to the bar to have fun with
their friends not only failed to
increase their happiness but it actually
made them miserable so next time you
think about dragging your introverted
friend to the bar well think twice
you might traumatize them for life just
like my parents did and with the Barbie
Caravan okay so but this was generally
good news so these results seem to
support our general idea that spending
money in a way that matches your
personality can actually increase
happiness and those studies perfect and
there were three limitations and to our
little experiment here first one is we
only looked at one personality train so
we only looked at extraversion second
one is that we only study two products
so we only looked at the bar voucher and
a book voucher and the third one is that
it’s highly questionable whether
Cambridge students are actually
representative of the general population
now having spent three and a half years
there and looking at myself today I have
to say I highly highly doubted so what
we did is we followed up with a second
study in which we collaborated with an
international bank and together with a
bank we recruited 625 UK citizens to
take part in a survey that measured
their life satisfaction and it also
measured their personality on five
distinct personality traits now at the
end of the survey we asked participants
whether they would be willing to share
with us their bank transaction data for
the six months preceding the survey so
we could look at participant spending in
59 categories to get an idea of what day
and how they spend their money on as
they went about their everyday lives so
we knew for example how much money they
had spent on music how often they had
gone to the pub or whether or not they
were paying off a mortgage at that time
now what did we find so again the
hypothesis was that the better the fit
between a person’s personality and their
overall spending so their spending
across these 59 categories would
increase life satisfaction and happiness
and this is exactly what we found
so better for the better the fit the
higher the self-reported life
satisfaction of participants after these
six months and what’s interesting and
also in line with what I discussed
earlier is that neither income nor the
total amount that participants had spent
over these six months actually was
related to life satisfaction so it
really doesn’t matter how much money you
have or how much money you spend what
matters is that you spend the money
that’s available to you in the right way
now you might be thinking well how can I
use these insights to really maximize
the happiness that I gained from my own
consumption experience and the way that
I see there’s basically two things you
have to do first one is I’ll let you lay
down and die as this image here might
suggest but actually to know yourself so
just take a few minutes sit down and
think about what really motivates and
drives you so do you like to be
constantly surrounded by other people or
would you rather spend most of the time
by yourself
or do you like to go out and explore or
would you rather go back to the same
place again and again and if you want to
do that in a slightly more systematic
way and learn about your personality the
way that psychologists think about him
we have developed a website that’s
called discover my profile where you can
take free psychological tests
personality tests and then get immediate
feedback on your responses so check it
out if you want why is this step
important it’s important because the
more you know about yourself the better
you understand yourself the easier it’ll
be for you to then identify the types of
spending that are in line or let’s speak
to these motivations in the second step
so once you have a clear idea of your
personal needs and preferences this will
be pretty easy and you won’t find it too
difficult to really find suitable ways
of spending your money okay so the the
message that I want you to take away
from this talk is really that it doesn’t
depend it doesn’t matter how much money
you have it doesn’t matter how much
money you spend what really matters is
is that you spend what you have
available in the right way so money
alone won’t buy you happiness but if you
manage to spend it in a way that really
speaks to your needs and fulfills your
motivations then there’s a pretty good
chance that your money will actually
help you to buy happiness
thank you [Applause]