
minute
two men John and Bob both are forty-five
both married both have two kids living
at home both attend church send their
kids to public schools and root for the
Atlanta Falcons despite their many
similarities John and Bob are different
in one very important way John earns
$200,000 a year
and Bob earns $30,000 a year this
difference in their income is likely to
have important implications for many
aspects of their lives as a high earner
John probably sleeps better at night
he’s less likely to have high blood
pressure or to suffer from clinical
depression
quite simply John is likely to have a
longer and healthier life
it’s no secret that it’s nice to have
money money allows us to buy a
comfortable home in a safe neighborhood
to expose our kids to things like piano
lessons summer camps and trips to
but what if despite all the obvious
advantages of having more money money
actually had negative implications for
our social lives what if having higher
incomes could actually isolate us from
other people there are at least two
reasons to expect that money might make
us more solitary and less social the
first is that when we don’t have money
the world feels more uncertain more
unpredictable and one way that we manage
this stress is through social support
imagine for a moment that you hold a
low-wage job say you are a cashier at a
school cafeteria and you earn $10 an
hour or $400 a week now after you’ve
covered your rent paid your taxes
utilities food car payments everything
else there’s almost nothing left now
consider all the threats that come with
this way of life what if the timing belt
on your car breaks
how will you afford to fix it how will
you get to work
if you can’t
what if your hours are reduced and now
instead of bringing home $400 a week you
bring home 350 or 300 page event where
will you live if you can’t this type of
uncertainty is stressful and one of the
ways that we manage the stress
associated with with this is through
social support when we feel scared
threatened or uncertain we come together
when there’s a death
we mourn with others when there’s a
national tragedy we gather with others
other people provide comfort they help
ease our stress they help us make sense
of what has happened so for higher
earners those people who are lucky
enough to inhabit worlds that have fewer
of these uncertainties and threats this
driver of social connection may be
diminished there’s another central
reason we affiliate and one we are often
more hesitant to acknowledge other
people help us solve problems they help
us manage threats and we in turn give
this aid to others
so imagine again that you work at that
school cafeteria and now you’ve just
given birth to a baby girl now there
wasn’t any money before at the end of
the month so how are you going to give
this child what she needs to survive to
hopefully thrive chances are you will
mother may agree to watch the child
while you work in the mornings you may
trade childcare with another co-worker
in a similar position you may borrow a
crib from your aunt hand-me-down clothes
from your sisters older children toys
from a neighbor this is instrumental
support the help we give and receive
from other people and if you don’t have
money this kind of support is crucial
money however reduces our need for
instrumental support instead of leaning
on our social networks to help raise
this child we can pay for childcare we
can buy a crib we can buy toys we can
buy clothes money reduces our needs for
all kinds of instrumental support
instead of asking a neighbor to watch
over our house while we’re out of town
we can install an alarm system instead
of asking our parents for help with the
down payment for our first home we can
cover it ourselves
money makes us less reliant on other
people and as a result it may make us
less focused on nurturing and fostering
these relationships so for these reasons
as a social scientist I wondered would
people in higher earning households
spend less time socializing with other
people would they spend more time alone
I tested this possibility along with my
co-author Kathleen vos from the
University of Minnesota and we published
our findings in a social science journal
earlier this year we analyzed data from
two large surveys of American adults in
the first study we analyzed data from
the General Social Survey and here
nearly 30,000 Americans were asked to
document how often they spend an evening
socializing with family with neighbors
and with friends and we wanted to know
would people in higher earning
households spend less time socializing
with other people now of course there
are likely to be other factors
associated with time spent socializing
things like how much you work how large
your family is your age your gender and
many others so we accounted for these
factors so that we could look at the
unique effect of income
and here’s what we found income was
strongly predictive of the number of
evenings spent socializing people in
higher earning households spent
significantly fewer evenings in total
socializing with other people
now you may wonder as we did is this the
only or even the best way of measuring
social time so next we looked at data
from the American time use survey and in
this survey over 88,000 Americans were
asked to document how they spent each
minute of the previous day and again we
wanted to know would higher earners
spend fewer minutes of the day with
other people would they spend more
minutes alone and again we adjusted for
many other factors that are likely to be
related to time spent with others how
much you worked how large your family is
and again we found that income seemed to
dampen our interest in spending time
with others people in higher earning
households spent significantly fewer
minutes of the day socializing with
other people they spent significantly
more minutes of the day by themselves
now so far I painted a pretty bleak
picture of how income affects our social
lives that with more money we seem to
become more solitary and less relational
but as we progressed in this research we
began to wonder does income reduce our
interest in all types of social
relationships or just some now earlier I
talked about how one function of social
relationships is instrumental support
the help we give and receive from other
people well relationships differ in the
extent to which instrumental support is
expected and received we tend to give
the most instrumental support to our
family members to our relatives we are
much less likely to give instrumental
support to another relational partner
our friends consider for a moment if you
had a two-week housing gap you had sold
one house and then but it was two weeks
before you could move into your new
house and you and your very rambunctious
two-year-old twins needed somewhere to
stay
whom would you ask to put you up Nana or
friends
most Americans if they had the choice
would choose Nana we are much less
likely to ask for this kind of support
from friends friendships tend to revolve
around emotional and social support
they’re associated with camaraderie and
fun not substantial aid this is a
picture I took about 25 years ago of my
dad and some of his close friends like
many friends they are similar in a lot
of ways similar in terms of age gender
interests most of them have spent their
lives in schools as educators all of
them enjoy gathering around the piano
drinking cheap alcohol and loudly
singing songs like Hey Jude and Alice’s
this is typical of friendships we tend
to choose friends who are like us who
have common goals and interests and
values and these friends tend to give us
considerable emotional and social
support but not considerable aid so we
wondered would higher earners spend more
of their limited social time with
friends given that they don’t need
substantial instrumental aid that they
can solve many of their challenges with
their own resources would they focus on
friends that relationship type that is
rooted in social and emotional support
not substantial aid so going back to the
first study where Americans were asked
how often they spent a social evening
with family with neighbors and with
friends whereas before we looked at the
total amount of time spent socializing
next we looked at socializing patterns
by the type of relationship
and here’s what we found as you probably
would expect by now high earners spent
fewer evenings with their family members
with their relatives but we found the
opposite pattern for friends relative to
low earners high earners spent more
evenings socializing with friends and
the same pattern emerged in the second
study where we looked at the number of
minutes Americans spent with others
during the day and again we found high
earners spend more time with friends and
less time with family compared to lower
earners so this suggests that money
doesn’t completely dampen our interest
in affiliating rather it seems to shape
how we affiliate and with whom
but even though higher nurse spent
considerably more time with friends and
their lower earning counterparts overall
they still spent considerably less time
with other people and so did other
members of their household
so what does this all mean
for how we make sense of and nurture our
social worlds well let me tell you what
I hope it means for my children
like many parents I hope that as adults
my children are relatively financially
comfortable that they don’t spend a
considerable amount of time worrying
about credit card debt foreclosure how
they might afford to fix a timing belt
on their car but I also hope that they
have rich social lives that they give
and receive considerable social and
instrumental support from each other to
their cousins to their aunts and uncles
to their parents to their friends to
their communities and neighbors like
money social relationships improve the
quality and quantity of our lives
they make us happier and healthier but
if you think about it a lot of what we
use discretionary money for pushes us
away from other people
we buy a bigger house so that each
member of the family can have more
individual space we put a swing set in
the backyard and then spend less time at
the neighborhood park but perhaps if we
recognize this tendency and if it
bothers us there are things we can do to
counteract it maybe we can use some of
that discretionary money to nurture our
social worlds to foster connections to
bring us closer together that is what I
hope for my children thank you [Applause]