Press "Enter" to skip to content

How Journalism Became One Of The Most Dangerous Jobs In The World | Peter Greste | TEDxSydney


[Music]
thank you very much that you guys have
got stamina a few months ago an
organization called Freedom House
released the results of its annual
survey the state of press freedom around
the world and its startling conclusion
was that it’s now at the worst that it’s
been in 13 years so what does that mean
in practical terms well last year 79
journalists were murdered on the job
that wasn’t a record we hit that mark
back in 2007 when about a hundred and
twenty journalists died because of their
work but it is broadly in line with
historical trends in which about a
hundred journalists have killed each
year simply for doing their jobs what
about those under arrest well last year
was a record so what is it that’s major
kn’l isn’t one of the most dangerous
jobs in the world well there are plenty
of reasons why you might not want to
journalists around think of perhaps
Latin American drugs lords for example
or anybody who picks up the Sunday
papers these days the problem is that if
you look at the numbers what’s quite
clear is that things started to change
around 2001 I don’t need to remind any
of want to hear what happened in that
year that was 9/11 the man that changed
the dynamic was a guy called George W
Bush what happened was in the Wars of
the past there generally are the
tangible things like land water and
ethnicity in those kinds of conflicts
journalists were considered as observers
to the conflict rather than participants
in it it was dangerous of course working
on frontlines as it always is going to
be when you’re in a place with plenty of
bits of metal flying around at
supersonic speeds
but as I said journalists weren’t
targets but george w bush changed the
dynamic when he said when he stood up in
front of a joint session of congress and
he said you are either with us or you’re
with the terrorists
with that single statement what George
Bush did was that he made the conflict a
binary choice now for journalists that
was incredibly challenging because it
meant that if you were doing your job
and reporting in line with your
professional standards of balance
accuracy and fairness then by definition
you had to go and report from the other
side you needed to get information from
across the spectrum of the conflict that
meant that by definition you became part
of the enemy in the eyes of the American
government now this is not an abstract
idea it’s an idea that’s had some very
serious real-world consequences I was a
correspondent in Afghanistan back in
1995 for the BBC and back then we used
to routinely cross the front lines to
speak to what was then the most potent
military and political force in the
country and that was the Taliban now the
Taliban didn’t necessarily agree with us
they didn’t necessarily like my theology
or my politics but they understood that
we were legitimate parts of the
battlefield that we had a role to play
and they accepted us and at the same
time plenty of governments also
encourages because they also recognized
that there was a value in our reporting
that was able to help them understand
what was taking place with the Taliban
where they were coming from what they
were thinking if we go forward then to
2001 I went back to Afghanistan and I
was watching the American bombardment of
Kabul as they were trying to ask the
Taliban from power and what happened
then were a few things that really made
me appreciate that something fundamental
had changed for journalists one of the
bombs that fell during the bombing
campaign landed squarely on the Al
Jazeera Bureau now the Americans at the
time
said that it was a mistake it was an
accident one of these things that
happens then they later wrote to
al-jazeera and acknowledged that in fact
they had targeted a building that they
thought was harboring al-qaeda
terrorists now al-jazeera had of course
been running interviews with al-qaeda
and the Taliban but as one of the
editors pointed out these organizations
were parties to the conflict and as a
news organization they had a moral and
ethical responsibility to go and find
out what it was that they were saying a
few weeks later the Taliban intercepted
a convoy that was driving from a place
called Jalalabad in the east of car of
Afghanistan up to Kabul and they pulled
just four people out of that convoy all
of them were journalists one of them was
an Australian camera man called Harry
Burton the other was a wonderful
attending journalist it was it also
happens to be a very good friend of mine
called Maria gratia Bertolli the Taliban
dragged them off into the desert away
from the road and they emptied the
magazines of their Kalashnikovs into
them solely the following year a few
months later al-qaeda kidnapped and
beheaded The Wall Street Journal
reporter Daniel Pearl again because he
happened to be a journalist now each of
these reporters were targeted not
because of anything that they any
particular military secrets that they
are about to expose they were murdered
simply because they were journalists who
are doing their jobs and reporting from
across the spectrum of the conflict one
of the problems with the war on terror
is it’s in define ability a good friend
of mine once joked that George W Bush
had declared war on an abstract now it
means whatever anybody wants it to mean
and since then governments around the
world have massaged and stretched the
term to include anybody that they all
sorts of people they consider to be
enemies and often that’s included
journalists now let’s go back to those
journalists under arrest
the figures tell us that the vast bulk
of them
but rather just a small fraction of them
are there for what we might call
journalistic infractions journalistic
misdemeanors things like defamation and
slander not exactly the kinds of things
that you’d expect to wind up in prison
for but there you go the vast majority
of them more than two-thirds are in
prison for crimes against the state
things like sedition and treason and
guess what that’s exactly what we were
facing when we were arrested in Egypt
now I went to Egypt in December of 2013
to cover the on pole in political crisis
that was going on in Egypt at the time
and on the night of the 28th of December
the security agents raided my hotel room
in the room of my colleague Mohammed
fami and the house of my other colleague
Baha Mohammed they rested us hauled us
in took us down to the State Security
buildings for interrogation he’s what we
were charged with aiding a terrorist
organization being members of a
terrorist organization financing a
terrorist organization broadcasting
false news to undermine national
security now at the time made no sense
to me I simply couldn’t understand what
was going on here what we’d been doing
was what I consider to be fairly common
journalism fairly basic journalism the
government makes a statement you go and
speak to the opposition to find out what
they think and then you’d find an
analyst to make sense of it all vanilla
reporting the gap between what we’re
accused of doing and what we actually
did was so vast that I really couldn’t
see how it wound up in that situation
until it finally dawned on me the
opposition of course in the classic
model of democracy is the party that
lasts form government and in Egypt at
the time that happened to be the Muslim
Brotherhood they’d formed the first
democratically elected government in
Egypt’s history until they were ousted
in a coup about six months before we
arrived and what the government was
trying to do what the government wanted
to do
what the reason they came after us was
not because of anything we had done not
because of our reporting per se it was
because of what we had come to represent
the government wanted to shut down
freedom of the press they wanted to
attack one of the most fundamental
elements of any democracy and that’s the
capacity for people to have a complete
range of political views since then the
government has introduced a whole raft
of legislation dealing with terrorism so
that even if you’da simply disrupt a
civil servant from his duties you can be
hauled in as a terrorist now Egypt isn’t
the world’s greatest jailer of
journalists that honor goes to Turkey
there the crackdown began after the
attempted coup last year since then the
government has gone after anybody that
they consider to be either connected
with the party that was that they’ve
accused of being behind the coup or
anybody who indeed has been overly
critical of the government it’s often
included academics lawyers and of course
journalists at the moment there are
about a hundred reporters who are behind
bars and a hundred news organizations
more than 100 news organizations have
been shut down closer to home Burma has
convicted five people on terrorism
charges simply because they published a
calendar that described their a hinga
community which happens to be Islamic as
an ethnic minority so what about the
world’s greatest bastion of free speech
the United States that was that the
founding fathers there saw that freedom
of speech freedom of the press was so
important that they passed the First
Amendment to the Constitution which
guarantees that the government can never
pass any piece of legislation but limits
press freedom now it turns out that the
u.s. also has the Espionage Act that was
passed in 1918 to help the government
deal with spies who are sending national
secrets to the enemy from 1918 until
2008 the government used the Espionage
Act a total of five times and then came
Barrack Obama his government used the
Espionage Act more than twice as often
as all of his predecessors
combined now that would be perfectly
understandable if the people that they
were going after were selling military
secrets to the Russians or giving away
CIA counterterrorism strategies to
al-qaeda but that simply didn’t happen
in every case the government prosecuted
either journalists or more often their
sources because they were revealing
stories that were politically
embarrassing to the government for
example someone who was revealing
alleged allegations of corruption around
the sale of surveillance equipment what
Barack Obama began
Donald Trump has weaponized he’s accused
the New York Times CNN The Washington
Post of being enemies of the state
he has blocked several of the world’s
leading news organizations from White
House briefings and most recently
they’ve opened up investigations into
the sources of leaks of information
relating to the Trump campaigns
connections to the Russians using guess
what yep the Espionage Act now I’m not
suggesting that the United States is
about to become Egypt anytime soon but
it really concerns me that we’re seeing
governments around the world using the
war on terror and national security as
an excuse to chip away at one of the
most fundamental elements of our
democracy and it’s happening here in
Australia too since 9/11 we’ve seen a
whole raft of pieces of legislation or
dealing with national security but there
are a few that I want to give you some
examples of the section 35p of the Azio
Act 35p makes that a criminal offense to
reveal any information about what’s
known as a special intelligence
operation and sio the problem is that
that designation the SAO designation is
itself a secret so journal is simply
picking up the telephone and starting to
ask questions about the work of the
security services which is something I
as a journalist would consider to be
perfectly legitimate piece of our work
can unwittingly make themselves in
violation of the law and find the
selves in prison for up to five years
then there’s metadata legislation which
gives a whole host of government
agencies the power to go into anybody’s
metadata without a warrant the only
exception to this rule is journalists
and that’s a good thing except that we
know the AFP the federal police has
already gone into a journalist data
accidentally but here’s what’s crucial
it doesn’t protect a journalist sources
so any government official who believes
they have important information about a
wrongdoing in governments if they again
picking up the telephone and talking to
a journalist makes themselves vulnerable
now the government said that this was
for national security well enough except
that metadata has already been used to
investigate the sources of leaks about
the conditions on Manus Island and
narrow in the detention centers it’s
also been used to prosecute a leaker who
exposed serious security breaches at
Sydney Airport then a journalist who
wants to really understand what’s going
on what makes a young Muslim perhaps go
and fight for Islamic state can find
themselves in breach of the foreign
fighters Act which forbids the
advocating of terrorist ideology now
this is not just an issue for me as a
journalist what concerns me is the way
that this is chipping away again at one
of them at some of the most fundamental
elements or the way our democracy works
it’s eroding what one organisation has
called the gray zone and but what by
that they mean that space which allows
us to have nuanced subtle complex to
base it’s the space that allows us to
live in a multicultural pluralist
society alongside all sorts of people of
different races ethnicities religious
beliefs politics and so on without
ending up in acrimony without falling
into into open combat it’s a space that
allows us to have vibrant public
discussions about policy without turning
without winding up in prison in short
it’s the space
that’s allowed Australia to become one
of the most prosperous stable and
peaceable democracies on the planet for
the past 200 years now guess which
organization uses the term the grey zone
it’s not amnesty international it’s not
some liberal think tank it is Islamic
state is has an online magazine they
called dabiq and a few years ago they
published a cover story in which they
said they called it the extinction of
the grey zone in this article one
Islamic state did was that they
explained that one of their key
strategies is to erode the capacity for
us to live side by side with all sorts
of different ethnic communities and in
particular the Muslim community they
want to destroy our capacity to have
these kinds of open subtle debates they
want to make the conflict of binary
choice and in this article there’s one
man that they quote very prominently as
supporting their argument supporting
their case the man they quote is George
W Bush and the line they use is yep that
line from the joint session of Congress
you’re either with us or you’re with the
terrorists now in my work in some of the
more authoritarian places around the
world I’ve noticed that there seems to
be a kind of sliding scale where you’ve
got press freedom at one end along with
a whole host of other democratic rights
and you have a police state at the other
and in this current environment it’s
really tempting for governments to drag
the slider to the right trading off
press freedom in the name of national
security but the problem is that we know
from history that a police state can
never really deal with terrorism we know
that it’s very easy for one man to drive
a truck into a crowd and perversely the
best way to deal with extremist ideology
is to have vibrant public debate with a
press that is free to go and interrogate
not just governments but anybody whose
views drift off to political extremes
Islamic state knows this which is why
they want to stop this
ladies and gentlemen there is one man
who I think sums us up very well his
name is Albert Camus who was a French
philosopher and he said a free press can
of course be both good and bad but a
press that is not free can never be
anything but bad thank you
[Applause]
[Music]
Please follow and like us: