
so I want to take
back to the 80s big hair sappy love
songs and specifically 1987 so 1987 I
was a second-year medical student and I
was taken up to the patient floor to
meet mrs. Jones mrs. Jones was going to
be the first patient encounter I had my
first H&P what an H&P is as a history
and physical examination this isn’t just
a coffee discussion this is asking a
patient complex questions getting
information from the patient and
processing it in order to give the
patient a differential diagnosis of what
they have in a treatment plan it’s the
first step of developing a
doctor-patient relationship so I walk in
very nervous my first question was mrs.
Jones what brought you here today her
answer was a cab I wrote down a cab now
I had no idea what she was saying I saw
her mouth move I heard words come out I
had no knowledge base what so I read one
year medical school under my belt and I
had no idea what she was saying to me
when I went to do the physical exam I
listened to her heart
there was no heart so I was the first
student to examine a patient was alive
with no heart I’m convinced to that and
my diagnosis there I did what I wrote
down was difficult to auscultate heart
zones what that means is I can’t hear
the heart so Hippocrates and 400bc
talked about the importance of a strong
doctor-patient relationship that was the
that you needed that to improve care to
improve healthcare so I was convinced at
this point Hippocrates is spinning in
his grave because I have no idea what
I’m doing and I was convinced that mrs.
Jones thought I wasted get this two
hours of her time two hours of her time
when I went to shake her hand she looked
at me and she had a smile on her face
and I realized I didn’t waste two hours
of her time she had two hours of my time
and she was able to unload her burdens
on me mrs. Jones was twice my age
she was an african-american woman and we
were cultures apart and that
doctor-patient relationship was able to
transcend gender race and culture
and I started to get an inkling of how
important that relationship is in the
healing process so what does it take to
get to that point of having a strong
doctor-patient relationship well first
you need a strong doctor you have to be
able you have to train a physician you
have to give them a knowledge base you
have to download information into their
brain too so they understand what to ask
how to ask it and how to apply that to
medical information that’s available
then you need experiential learning you
need to do this over and over again so
now I’m an emergency physician and when
I hire young physicians who come and
practice what I find is after four years
of medical school and three or four
years of residency training it takes
them another three to five years which
in our world equates to 10 to 15,000
patient encounters before I actually
feel like they know what they’re doing
and before they will admit to me that I
think I get it now
that’s how much time it takes once you
establish that relationship everything
starts working great in fact studies
have shown that when you have a strong
doctor-patient relationship health care
improves management of chronic medical
conditions gets easier patients
adherence to taking medications as
prescribed gets better there their
perception of their pain improves they
have less pain believe it or not if they
get admitted to the hospital their
length of stay in the hospital shortens
this is huge on the doctors side factors
have more satisfaction in their jobs
they actually get sued less which in and
of itself is job satisfaction when
you’re not getting sued so you have the
patient happy of the doctor happy you
have health care improving and you have
cost decreasing so it’s a good thing so
I should just end my talk here and say
that’s it so why do I have the audacity
to stand in front of you and say we need
to fix this relationship the reason is
because I think from the time of
Hippocrates to now we’ve had wedges go
between doctors and patients and in the
last thirty years we’ve had an
exponential increase in the wedges that
get between the doctor and the patient
some of it is just the business of
Medicine
we have fewer doctors in in places where
we really need them we have more
patients
we have sicker patients we have an aging
population we get that that’s not what I
want to focus on many papers have been
written on that instead what I’m going
to talk to you about is data information
overload so we have enormous amounts of
data out there remember I talked about
what it takes to get a physician to the
point of being able to sit down with a
patient
and start that patient relation to that
doctor-patient relationship it takes
information download you almost it’s
almost impossible to download
information now because there’s so much
out there the the in fact in in studies
done we saw that in the decade between
75 1975 and 1985 on average every year
there was a quarter of a million new
research articles Currier put in the
National Library of Medicine a decade
later that went to 370 and a decade
later it went to 400 400,000 new
research articles so we have information
overload we also have something that I
call asymmetric development of
information technology we’ve done a
enormous job with growing equipment and
hardware technology and we’ve done a
poor job in developing data analytics
and management of the data that’s out
there so what you’re left with you’re
left with doctors that have a different
standard of care now that’s been
developed so we have access to us to the
best equipment ever and when you talk to
physicians from other parts of the world
they can’t believe what we have
available to us so you have this
enormous amount of technology your
standard of care now almost warrants
that you utilize that technology and
that technology is uncovering new
diseases when I trained there was no
such thing as hepatitis C it was non-a
non-b hepatitis we’ve already even
Churchill was infectious or
non-infectious we had autoimmune
diseases were there there were short
little chapters in the textbook but now
you’re starting to see a Reese you’re
starting to see more of these diseases
I’m not convinced that we’re seeing more
of it I think we can uncover it now with
the technology we have so we have more
technology we have apparently new
diseases out there
and that we have new treatments for
those diseases it’s almost impossible
for doctors to keep up now patients have
the same access to information they have
much more access to information than
they used to so they they can go online
and they look things up in fact when
they come and talk with a doctor they
tell you so I have stomach pain I looked
it up I’m sure it’s cancer I need this
cat scan these blood tests and and these
things done and a doctor says you sure
it’s not that bag of hot cheetos at you
ate last night at midnight they say
absolutely not I do that every night do
ya that’s the point that maybe that’s
what it is that’s not it doctor now we
don’t have time to have a discussion to
talk patients from that from their
perception from their from their
viewpoint so doctors succumb to ordering
more tests than they need to prescribing
medications when they don’t need to or
patients will dr. shop the other thing
the information overload does is it
becomes hard to become a specialist in
one area so you tend to refer patients
to other physicians so all this
increases help the cost of healthcare
and it deteriorates the doctor-patient
relationship so what we need to do is we
need we need to get everything back on
track I think one case that kind of
highlights where we were and we
understood this in medicine we knew in
medicine we had this chasm developing
and in the mid 90s we started
implementing electronic medical records
and and I think the case that I always
go back to and actually was the start of
my research was the 1995 heat disaster
so in Chicago we had in July one week
time period where it was hot well it’s
July but we had 700 people die in a week
700 people in a week think of the last
time you read the newspaper opened up in
is 700 people died in the city this week
it just doesn’t happen
I was working clinically at the time and
I tell you it took us almost two days to
figure out our patients were dying from
heat it’s a it’s it’s absurd to think oh
but that’s the truth and the reason why
is we had paper and pen we worked in our
silos and we didn’t see the forest
through the trees and so we knew we had
to get better and so what you saw over
the next five years was the the
implementation electron of an electronic
medical
records so Nietzsche is credited with
saying that that which does not kill us
makes us stronger we knew that the vast
amounts of data out there actually
created a wedge between patients but
we’re too far downstream to turn back
and say let’s not do this so we double
down we need more information
but we need to manage that information
differently I’m here to tell you that we
are at that point now so we’re at a
point where I’m convinced we’re in a new
revolution like the Industrial
Revolution we are in the healthcare data
analytics revolution you won’t see it
yet and like in the Industrial
Revolution historians will debate would
they to really start in 1760 or not
because it was agreed not really
revolution because it’s a gradual
increase it’s a gradual disruption of
what’s happening in society and that’s
what’s happening within healthcare with
data analytics we’re having a gradual
improvement in the end you will see
changes you’ll see decreased healthcare
costs you’ll see improvement and
outcomes just can’t see it yet so if you
fast forward 50 years from now guarantee
you you look up this TED talk 50 years
from now and and you’ll see what I’m
saying is correct so we’re going to
removing the dial on this so what you
have is you have traditional researchers
out there and when I say traditional
researchers I think of older physicians
like myself and white coats doing NIH
funded research looking at data
analytics and they’re in there and
they’re they’re moving the dial there
you have non traditional pseudo research
which is done by younger high tech
entrepreneurs who are implementing
disruptive healthcare technology I’ve
had the pleasure of working with both
teams and it’s really fascinating to
work with both and out of there you have
hybrid teams a little bit of each my
research team is actually more of a
hybrid team so we have clinicians who
are content experts about disease we
have statistics experts we have public
health experts we have informatics we
have interface experts and we have
programmers it’s a lot of fun guys
and we sit and we and we try and
problem-solve and what we’ve been able
to do is we’ve been able to look at all
the data that’s coming out of electronic
medical records and it’s not as easy as
you might think because all systems have
a different language so we’ve created a
system that’s agnostic to all the
systems out there and we’re able to look
at the information I tell you it’s like
looking under a microscope and seeing a
bacteria for the first time you start to
see trends unfold and and what we’ve
been able to do with that so we can we
can look at a patient’s medical record
in real time and I say that because
that’s important to get the doctor back
in front of the patient so we can our
system can look at a medical record and
read what the clinician whether it’s a
doctor or a nurse or a student what
they’ve entered into the medical record
whether it’s a button click or even if
it’s typewritten we spent a year on a
natural language processor that actually
now for the first time in history can
read doctors handwriting and what we’ve
been able to pull out of there is
fascinating we can now we’ve developed
algorithms what we call disease
fingerprinting we developed algorithms
around identification of rarely
occurring diseases that we know doctors
will not diagnose because they’re so
rarely occurring they want to be the one
to say the patient has that condition
and we can let a doctor know hey we
think it’s this condition have you
considered these tests to prove or
disprove this theory we we do that with
rarely occurring diseases we also do it
with annually occurring diseases like
influenza our system has been so
effective we can predict flu season one
to two weeks before CDC says hey we’re
in flu season so I’ve missed a lot of
been a good interview opportunities
because reporters will say doctor are we
and flu season I’ll say no it ended last
week so it keeps me out of the spotlight
but our system works works that good it
has that level of sensitivity we’ve also
expanded the definition of disease so if
you say that admitting somebody to a
hospital is a disease in and of itself
we’ve been able to identify the
variables to lead that lead to patients
being admitted to the hospital and so we
can let a doctor know this patient is
going to need to be admitted before the
doctor has even completed their work on
why is that important it gets the
patient where they need at the right
time get some care faster and it
decreases extraneous testing the doctor
may do to decide themselves if the
patient needs
we also have collaborated and
collaboration is a big part of being
ready for whatever is coming down our
way we’ve collaborated with a company
and get this we’re working on predicting
medical errors before medical errors
happen medical errors do not occur in
isolation they occur as a series of
unfortunate events we actually can put
values on that series of unfortunate
events and we can tell clinicians hey
something bad is going to happen here
and we know that here so do something to
stop it from happening this is a game
changer in healthcare and we’re actually
working on that right now so you might
say well aren’t you also predicting the
end of the role of a physician and I’m
here to tell you no so automation didn’t
get rid of factory workers it did reduce
the workforce but it also led to
efficiency ATMs that didn’t get rid of
bank tellers made them more efficient
doctors aren’t going anywhere but we
need to make them more efficient so I’ll
end with a story about 20 years ago I
was working on an inpatient unit and
there was a patient it would call it
Beatriz because I can’t use her real
name an elderly woman who was afflicted
with multiple strokes so she lived in a
nursing home she had beautiful long
white hair she would always end up in
the hospital nobody wanted to take care
of her because her care was so
complicated I took care of her and I
knew her from years of taking care of
her so it wasn’t that complicated for me
one morning I walk in and the nurse says
to me doctor Beatriz isn’t doing well
she had a rough night you might want to
go see her the family had made her a DNR
so do not resuscitate no life-sustaining
intervention but what we could do is
keep her comfortable I went in the room
and she was having a hard time breathing
she looked at me and I wanted I did draw
a blood test because I wanted to see if
there was something I could do in
addition to keeping her comfortable is
there something we were missing that we
could correct when I drew the blood I
held pressure where I drew the blood
from so where she was so she when
bleed and I held her hand she looked up
at me and and she had a little smile on
her face and she closed her eyes and she
took her last breath and she left and
I’d like to think that she waited for me
that morning because I’d spent years
working with her I’d also like to think
that the last minutes of her life on
earth was comforted by my presence being
there
that’s the doctor-patient relationship
debt will not go away we’re just going
to make it better thank you
[Applause]
back to the 80s big hair sappy love
songs and specifically 1987 so 1987 I
was a second-year medical student and I
was taken up to the patient floor to
meet mrs. Jones mrs. Jones was going to
be the first patient encounter I had my
first H&P what an H&P is as a history
and physical examination this isn’t just
a coffee discussion this is asking a
patient complex questions getting
information from the patient and
processing it in order to give the
patient a differential diagnosis of what
they have in a treatment plan it’s the
first step of developing a
doctor-patient relationship so I walk in
very nervous my first question was mrs.
Jones what brought you here today her
answer was a cab I wrote down a cab now
I had no idea what she was saying I saw
her mouth move I heard words come out I
had no knowledge base what so I read one
year medical school under my belt and I
had no idea what she was saying to me
when I went to do the physical exam I
listened to her heart
there was no heart so I was the first
student to examine a patient was alive
with no heart I’m convinced to that and
my diagnosis there I did what I wrote
down was difficult to auscultate heart
zones what that means is I can’t hear
the heart so Hippocrates and 400bc
talked about the importance of a strong
doctor-patient relationship that was the
that you needed that to improve care to
improve healthcare so I was convinced at
this point Hippocrates is spinning in
his grave because I have no idea what
I’m doing and I was convinced that mrs.
Jones thought I wasted get this two
hours of her time two hours of her time
when I went to shake her hand she looked
at me and she had a smile on her face
and I realized I didn’t waste two hours
of her time she had two hours of my time
and she was able to unload her burdens
on me mrs. Jones was twice my age
she was an african-american woman and we
were cultures apart and that
doctor-patient relationship was able to
transcend gender race and culture
and I started to get an inkling of how
important that relationship is in the
healing process so what does it take to
get to that point of having a strong
doctor-patient relationship well first
you need a strong doctor you have to be
able you have to train a physician you
have to give them a knowledge base you
have to download information into their
brain too so they understand what to ask
how to ask it and how to apply that to
medical information that’s available
then you need experiential learning you
need to do this over and over again so
now I’m an emergency physician and when
I hire young physicians who come and
practice what I find is after four years
of medical school and three or four
years of residency training it takes
them another three to five years which
in our world equates to 10 to 15,000
patient encounters before I actually
feel like they know what they’re doing
and before they will admit to me that I
think I get it now
that’s how much time it takes once you
establish that relationship everything
starts working great in fact studies
have shown that when you have a strong
doctor-patient relationship health care
improves management of chronic medical
conditions gets easier patients
adherence to taking medications as
prescribed gets better there their
perception of their pain improves they
have less pain believe it or not if they
get admitted to the hospital their
length of stay in the hospital shortens
this is huge on the doctors side factors
have more satisfaction in their jobs
they actually get sued less which in and
of itself is job satisfaction when
you’re not getting sued so you have the
patient happy of the doctor happy you
have health care improving and you have
cost decreasing so it’s a good thing so
I should just end my talk here and say
that’s it so why do I have the audacity
to stand in front of you and say we need
to fix this relationship the reason is
because I think from the time of
Hippocrates to now we’ve had wedges go
between doctors and patients and in the
last thirty years we’ve had an
exponential increase in the wedges that
get between the doctor and the patient
some of it is just the business of
Medicine
we have fewer doctors in in places where
we really need them we have more
patients
we have sicker patients we have an aging
population we get that that’s not what I
want to focus on many papers have been
written on that instead what I’m going
to talk to you about is data information
overload so we have enormous amounts of
data out there remember I talked about
what it takes to get a physician to the
point of being able to sit down with a
patient
and start that patient relation to that
doctor-patient relationship it takes
information download you almost it’s
almost impossible to download
information now because there’s so much
out there the the in fact in in studies
done we saw that in the decade between
75 1975 and 1985 on average every year
there was a quarter of a million new
research articles Currier put in the
National Library of Medicine a decade
later that went to 370 and a decade
later it went to 400 400,000 new
research articles so we have information
overload we also have something that I
call asymmetric development of
information technology we’ve done a
enormous job with growing equipment and
hardware technology and we’ve done a
poor job in developing data analytics
and management of the data that’s out
there so what you’re left with you’re
left with doctors that have a different
standard of care now that’s been
developed so we have access to us to the
best equipment ever and when you talk to
physicians from other parts of the world
they can’t believe what we have
available to us so you have this
enormous amount of technology your
standard of care now almost warrants
that you utilize that technology and
that technology is uncovering new
diseases when I trained there was no
such thing as hepatitis C it was non-a
non-b hepatitis we’ve already even
Churchill was infectious or
non-infectious we had autoimmune
diseases were there there were short
little chapters in the textbook but now
you’re starting to see a Reese you’re
starting to see more of these diseases
I’m not convinced that we’re seeing more
of it I think we can uncover it now with
the technology we have so we have more
technology we have apparently new
diseases out there
and that we have new treatments for
those diseases it’s almost impossible
for doctors to keep up now patients have
the same access to information they have
much more access to information than
they used to so they they can go online
and they look things up in fact when
they come and talk with a doctor they
tell you so I have stomach pain I looked
it up I’m sure it’s cancer I need this
cat scan these blood tests and and these
things done and a doctor says you sure
it’s not that bag of hot cheetos at you
ate last night at midnight they say
absolutely not I do that every night do
ya that’s the point that maybe that’s
what it is that’s not it doctor now we
don’t have time to have a discussion to
talk patients from that from their
perception from their from their
viewpoint so doctors succumb to ordering
more tests than they need to prescribing
medications when they don’t need to or
patients will dr. shop the other thing
the information overload does is it
becomes hard to become a specialist in
one area so you tend to refer patients
to other physicians so all this
increases help the cost of healthcare
and it deteriorates the doctor-patient
relationship so what we need to do is we
need we need to get everything back on
track I think one case that kind of
highlights where we were and we
understood this in medicine we knew in
medicine we had this chasm developing
and in the mid 90s we started
implementing electronic medical records
and and I think the case that I always
go back to and actually was the start of
my research was the 1995 heat disaster
so in Chicago we had in July one week
time period where it was hot well it’s
July but we had 700 people die in a week
700 people in a week think of the last
time you read the newspaper opened up in
is 700 people died in the city this week
it just doesn’t happen
I was working clinically at the time and
I tell you it took us almost two days to
figure out our patients were dying from
heat it’s a it’s it’s absurd to think oh
but that’s the truth and the reason why
is we had paper and pen we worked in our
silos and we didn’t see the forest
through the trees and so we knew we had
to get better and so what you saw over
the next five years was the the
implementation electron of an electronic
medical
records so Nietzsche is credited with
saying that that which does not kill us
makes us stronger we knew that the vast
amounts of data out there actually
created a wedge between patients but
we’re too far downstream to turn back
and say let’s not do this so we double
down we need more information
but we need to manage that information
differently I’m here to tell you that we
are at that point now so we’re at a
point where I’m convinced we’re in a new
revolution like the Industrial
Revolution we are in the healthcare data
analytics revolution you won’t see it
yet and like in the Industrial
Revolution historians will debate would
they to really start in 1760 or not
because it was agreed not really
revolution because it’s a gradual
increase it’s a gradual disruption of
what’s happening in society and that’s
what’s happening within healthcare with
data analytics we’re having a gradual
improvement in the end you will see
changes you’ll see decreased healthcare
costs you’ll see improvement and
outcomes just can’t see it yet so if you
fast forward 50 years from now guarantee
you you look up this TED talk 50 years
from now and and you’ll see what I’m
saying is correct so we’re going to
removing the dial on this so what you
have is you have traditional researchers
out there and when I say traditional
researchers I think of older physicians
like myself and white coats doing NIH
funded research looking at data
analytics and they’re in there and
they’re they’re moving the dial there
you have non traditional pseudo research
which is done by younger high tech
entrepreneurs who are implementing
disruptive healthcare technology I’ve
had the pleasure of working with both
teams and it’s really fascinating to
work with both and out of there you have
hybrid teams a little bit of each my
research team is actually more of a
hybrid team so we have clinicians who
are content experts about disease we
have statistics experts we have public
health experts we have informatics we
have interface experts and we have
programmers it’s a lot of fun guys
and we sit and we and we try and
problem-solve and what we’ve been able
to do is we’ve been able to look at all
the data that’s coming out of electronic
medical records and it’s not as easy as
you might think because all systems have
a different language so we’ve created a
system that’s agnostic to all the
systems out there and we’re able to look
at the information I tell you it’s like
looking under a microscope and seeing a
bacteria for the first time you start to
see trends unfold and and what we’ve
been able to do with that so we can we
can look at a patient’s medical record
in real time and I say that because
that’s important to get the doctor back
in front of the patient so we can our
system can look at a medical record and
read what the clinician whether it’s a
doctor or a nurse or a student what
they’ve entered into the medical record
whether it’s a button click or even if
it’s typewritten we spent a year on a
natural language processor that actually
now for the first time in history can
read doctors handwriting and what we’ve
been able to pull out of there is
fascinating we can now we’ve developed
algorithms what we call disease
fingerprinting we developed algorithms
around identification of rarely
occurring diseases that we know doctors
will not diagnose because they’re so
rarely occurring they want to be the one
to say the patient has that condition
and we can let a doctor know hey we
think it’s this condition have you
considered these tests to prove or
disprove this theory we we do that with
rarely occurring diseases we also do it
with annually occurring diseases like
influenza our system has been so
effective we can predict flu season one
to two weeks before CDC says hey we’re
in flu season so I’ve missed a lot of
been a good interview opportunities
because reporters will say doctor are we
and flu season I’ll say no it ended last
week so it keeps me out of the spotlight
but our system works works that good it
has that level of sensitivity we’ve also
expanded the definition of disease so if
you say that admitting somebody to a
hospital is a disease in and of itself
we’ve been able to identify the
variables to lead that lead to patients
being admitted to the hospital and so we
can let a doctor know this patient is
going to need to be admitted before the
doctor has even completed their work on
why is that important it gets the
patient where they need at the right
time get some care faster and it
decreases extraneous testing the doctor
may do to decide themselves if the
patient needs
we also have collaborated and
collaboration is a big part of being
ready for whatever is coming down our
way we’ve collaborated with a company
and get this we’re working on predicting
medical errors before medical errors
happen medical errors do not occur in
isolation they occur as a series of
unfortunate events we actually can put
values on that series of unfortunate
events and we can tell clinicians hey
something bad is going to happen here
and we know that here so do something to
stop it from happening this is a game
changer in healthcare and we’re actually
working on that right now so you might
say well aren’t you also predicting the
end of the role of a physician and I’m
here to tell you no so automation didn’t
get rid of factory workers it did reduce
the workforce but it also led to
efficiency ATMs that didn’t get rid of
bank tellers made them more efficient
doctors aren’t going anywhere but we
need to make them more efficient so I’ll
end with a story about 20 years ago I
was working on an inpatient unit and
there was a patient it would call it
Beatriz because I can’t use her real
name an elderly woman who was afflicted
with multiple strokes so she lived in a
nursing home she had beautiful long
white hair she would always end up in
the hospital nobody wanted to take care
of her because her care was so
complicated I took care of her and I
knew her from years of taking care of
her so it wasn’t that complicated for me
one morning I walk in and the nurse says
to me doctor Beatriz isn’t doing well
she had a rough night you might want to
go see her the family had made her a DNR
so do not resuscitate no life-sustaining
intervention but what we could do is
keep her comfortable I went in the room
and she was having a hard time breathing
she looked at me and I wanted I did draw
a blood test because I wanted to see if
there was something I could do in
addition to keeping her comfortable is
there something we were missing that we
could correct when I drew the blood I
held pressure where I drew the blood
from so where she was so she when
bleed and I held her hand she looked up
at me and and she had a little smile on
her face and she closed her eyes and she
took her last breath and she left and
I’d like to think that she waited for me
that morning because I’d spent years
working with her I’d also like to think
that the last minutes of her life on
earth was comforted by my presence being
there
that’s the doctor-patient relationship
debt will not go away we’re just going
to make it better thank you
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: