Press "Enter" to skip to content

Growing Talent for civic entrepreneurship. | Serob Khachatryan | TEDxYerevanSalon


I am working in the villages trying to

develop thinking skills of children a

couple of years ago and I was working in

the villages there was one girl in my

group she was a twelfth grade and I

noticed that every time I am giving

something which requires creative

approach reasoning skills

she was always shining so I was very

inspired and one day I went to her and

said what are your plans for the future

and she said I don’t know maybe I will

become a housewife like my mother and I

was very upset so I went to the teachers

and asked them what do you think about

her and they said you know there are

lots of problems with her bad memory

less diligence so on so on so on and I

decided to look at our educational

strategies what are they suggesting for

these kind of situations and I looked at

the document and in the documents I find

that we are implementing child-friendly

policies every child matters but I

didn’t find solutions for these types of

situations at the end she stopped her

education after graduating from school

and got married now the world in my

opinion lost a talent and it’s awful

when child cares the talent inside and

nobody cultivates this talent and there

is no interest industry which is

developing these talents growing this

talent and the worse thing in this world

is not the death the worst thing in this

world is killing talents inside children

after that I try to look to observe what

type of strategies we are using

to grow talents the first step approach

I found I will call the few are talented

this approach is based on conception

that some people few people are talented

so they know the truth they have good

education degrees they develop different

strategies documents and they are the

ones who should govern the world from

above imposing their ideas decisions to

the society and after developing these

strategies they give these documents to

people in the communities and say now go

and implement these ideas and because

these people are not considered as

talented they don’t know how to

implement it effectively and sometimes I

turn to them and say ok but do you have

opinion on this and they say yes of

course I have opinion but I don’t agree

with my opinion so that’s that I will

call a one-size-fits-all approach if you

fit our size you are ok if not you are

out and there is an old story which is

called Procrustes bed Procrustes was a

giant person awful person and he was

owning a small hostel in a crowded place

and people who were passing by sometimes

were staying at this hotel and what he

was doing he was asking people to lay on

the bed and if they were longer than the

bed

he was amputating and killing them if

they were shorter than the bed he was

stretching them so that’s that’s the

approach we are sometimes trying to

implement and by this we are neglecting

many many talents

the second approach I will call

incentive based approach in this case

we say okay let’s give people different

incentives and to meet these intensive

they will grow their talents and perform

better but here I see two main problems

one problem is that sometimes you have

good intentions but you get bad outcomes

let me tell you a story about India at

some point British people were in India

and they noticed that there are lots of

snakes around so in order to give

incentive these people they said we are

going to pay you for every killed Snape

and after five years ago five years they

found that now they have more snakes

around than before

why because Indians decided to breed

snakes and sell more so you have

fantastic intention but you got bad

outcome

the second approach with incentive based

policies is that sometimes appearance

appearance becomes priority meaning that

people only prioritize things for what

they are paid or for which they are

receiving incentives and this reminds me

a story when a person goes to a tailor

to to get his new suit so he gets on he

takes on new suit and he notices that

the sleeves are longer and he says you

know sleeves are longer and the tailor

says hold your hands like this and he

holds like decent says you know but the

colour is not OK for me and he says put

your head like this and then he says but

the trousers are not okay and he says

stay like this okay now you are

fantastic you can go and this person

goes out

the street and two people see him and

one of them says look at this poor man

and the other says what a nice sweet he

had a fantastic he had a fantastic

tailor who made a great suite for his

body so this is a case when we are

deforming body deforming body in order

to get some appearances and many in many

cases this I noticed this in different

reforms for example to do some to do

some change we we asked existing

institutions to do something this way

and then the other way and at the end we

see a nice appearance nice appearance

but body is essentially damaged so the

the third approach

I am favoring for I will call it Civic

entrepreneurship now there are two

important developments during last

year’s the first one is connected with

intelligence theory the older theory was

saying that talent is something which is

fixed and some people are talented

others are not the new theory says that

everyone can grow it doesn’t mean that

everyone can grow equally so different

people have different levels of growing

their talents in the different fields

and the second issue here development

here is diversity before we were living

in a society which was very homogeneous

but now we have more diverse society so

diversity is an important development

important change in current world last

year there was an article in Harvard

Business Review published by

a famous neuro leadership school leader

David Rock and this research was saying

that diverse teams work better perform

better they feel in the sense of comfort

they are not okay but in the sense of

performance they are better that Norm

diverse teams non-diverse teams feel

better but because they feel better

sometimes they think that they perform

better but the research shows that it’s

not the case so now that means that

diversity is the reality we should not

complain from diversity we should see it

as an opportunity to to change the world

and here comes civic interest ownership

Civic intervener ship is an approach

where you start from grassroots where

you start from working with people in

the communities and one of the first

changes you make is somehow giving these

people freedom giving these people

opportunities making them part of the

game and now the world now is so complex

that project managers who who write

different development programs cannot

deal effectively with this complexity

without people who work in the

communities who work who know local

problems face them and they have a good

relationships with people

now before before explaining the

importance of relationships I would like

to tell you a story and then explain why

relationships are important for civic

enterpreneurship once a young man goes

to a wise old man and asks him for an

advice he says you know I am tired

I am disappointed from life can you give

me some advice and the wise man says

please go and bring three bowls with

water put carrots in One Bowl heads in

the second and coffee in the third and

boiled them after boiling wise men asked

the student what happened to them and

the student says carrot after boiling

became weaker egg became harder and the

coffee is ready for drinking the wise

man says that’s ok but your explanation

is very simplistic carrot is like a

person who meets challenges adversaries

new people and resigns and becomes

weaker than before egg is like a person

who meets challenges and after that

starts to fighting with with the new

challenges trying to wind up the game ok

but what about the coffee now the coffee

is the most important thing because

coffee as carrot and egg also meets the

same challenge but instead of becoming

weak or heart it took the water and give

the taste to the water now civic

entertainers are people who should base

their work on I and you relationships

now the coffee made the best

relationships with the you with the

other person so this is this is an

important thing because theory says that

every person has inborn idea of you

others and sometimes we kill this idea

of you

or put it on a just competitive days and

stress very much on cognitive skills and

at the end we have a world where some

people are not ready to work with others

because we killed their social fabric

finishing this I would like to say the

following that when I started when I

started to work in development sector

everyone who was entering the training

room was telling this fish story which

are duck told and everybody was saying

instead of giving a person a fish we

shouldn’t we should teach them how to

fish and now I learned that there is a

new episode of this film which is

instead of teaching a person how to fish

we should establish fishing industry why

because sometimes we teach people how to

fish and we think that they learned and

after couple of months we go for a

monitoring and we see that even if they

know how to fish

they still use other ways they know

before which means that just learning

something is not enough you should

create some ecology some industry in

which people will have opportunities to

to implement this new skills new

knowledge so civic entertainers are

people who are not saying walk behind me

because maybe I am NOT the leader they

even don’t say walk in front of me

because maybe I am not the follower they

say walk beside me and inspire me

because when you inspire people they

give you more

then you want if you manipulate people

they give you exactly what you want and

sometimes less thank you [Applause]

Please follow and like us: