Press "Enter" to skip to content

Green-Light Revolution: Your Creative Life on Your Terms | Brooke Warner | TEDxTraverseCity


[Music]
imagine if Ted and TEDx only invited
people who were already famous to
deliver TED Talks imagine the limited
talent pool from which they would draw
if this were the case imagine the people
and the big ideas they would say no to
having been in the publishing industry
for the last nearly 20 years I’ve seen a
shift in the way my industry says no to
people today I’m going to talk about
three traditional creative industries
book publishing film and music and a
shift we’re seeing in the arts to
greenlight only those artists who are
already famous or who have celebrity
connections sure you might argue it’s
always been this way but never before
has there been so much pressure on
creative people to have star quality and
never before has celebrity been so
arbitrary
it’s as if reality TV we’re taking over
our actual reality oh wait never mind
but you don’t have to look too far to
find examples of breakout books movies
and songs that no gatekeeper wanted to
take a risk on that are known to us
today only because the artist
green-lighted themselves perhaps you’ve
heard of some of these projects a
Christmas Carol the joy of cooking Good
Will Hunting
this year’s breakout film success get
out and fan funded music is such a thing
that the topic even has its own
Wikipedia page I call these people green
lighters green lighters are not sitting
around waiting for someone else to say
yes to their dreams they’re artists and
creators and makers who determined that
their sense of worth comes from within
and not from someplace out there and
there are more green lighters today than
ever before
perhaps because our traditional creative
industries are taking fewer risks than
ever before and the rejection artists
face stems from lack of vision and
sweeping generalizations about what
sells and what doesn’t people are
rejected for lack of celebrity yes but
also for their projects being too
similar in concept to something else
that’s already out there or for
appealing to too narrow an audience such
narrow audiences as all African
Americans for instance or all LGBTQ
people or for their work being too dark
I can’t tell you how many times my sales
force has told me grief doesn’t sell and
yet green lighters are seeing more
success than ever
perhaps because their version of success
isn’t only about the bottom line and
because there’s flexibility and freedom
in being independent
the reason
I care about green lighters is because I
believe they’re the shapers of our
cultural values in a way that our
traditional creative industries used to
be I care about them so much that I
wanted to come out here today to appeal
to them directly maybe you’re one of
them the reason green lighters need to
be appealed to is because there’s a
perception in our culture that the only
people who get to call themselves
artists are those who are ordained by
the powers that be but it’s time to put
an end to that myth green lighters are
not second best as evidenced by the fact
that the moment someone makes it they’re
brought into the fold and it takes a lot
more courage to greenlight yourself than
it does to wait for someone else’s yes
I’ve been doing my own field research on
this topic for some time I’ve seen in
book publishing the way authors get
rejected not for the merit of their work
but for their lack of connections my own
story is one of disillusion and
reinvention and I’m going to share with
you how I became a green light or two
sometimes it takes bumping up against
disappointment or rejection to embrace
the idea that you may in fact be a green
lighter sometimes it takes walking
through fire to see the path you thought
you wanted to be on wasn’t meant to be
your path so often our creative pursuits
are tied up with a desire for external
validation which then somehow confers
legitimacy but legitimacy cannot be
bestowed you have to take it especially
today when our gatekeepers are thinking
too small and our culture is rewarding
the wrong things let me show you what I
mean
I was 23 when I started working in book
publishing I was smitten with this
industry I loved everything about it
making books reading books for a living
deciding what gets to be published when
I got my first job in publishing I was
so filled with gratitude for the amazing
privilege to get to do this work every
single day my second job in publishing
was my dream job I was hired to be an
acquiring editor for a women’s press I
was doing interesting and important work
this job was like falling in love I was
right where I wanted to be and
everything was right with the universe
fast forward seven years and the women’s
press where I was working where I was
now an executive editor was acquired by
a corporate parent company suddenly
books that I would have been able to
acquire in the past were being
scrutinized as not commercial enough a
new emphasis was being placed on the
author’s physical attractiveness I was
uncomfortable with these changes my
dream job was morphing into something
else my true love had changed and this
was not the relationship I thought I was
in this all came to a head for me in
2011 when I wanted to acquire a book
about transgender families I had been
hard at work cultivating trans authors
and trans books transgender issues were
entering into the mainstream lexicon in
a bigger way at that point and this was
part of the important work that we were
doing at the press little did I know our
parent company had decided we’d done
enough of those kinds of books but I was
blissfully unaware of this when I got a
book proposal from s Barry Bergman about
redefining what family is and can be
I knew of Barre he was an up-and-coming
voice
trans man with a book I thought really
mattered so I did what editors do I took
the project to my editorial board I was
excited I thought it was a shoo-in it
wasn’t until after the meeting that my
boss the publisher called me into her
office and there I was surrounded by the
countless books we’d Midwife together
over the years I don’t know what I was
expecting confirmation that she liked
the project validation that it was a
good fit for our list but instead she
had a troubled look on her face she told
me that our parent company did not want
me to acquire this book maybe I could
have pressed it even won the battle but
I didn’t have it in me truth be told I
hadn’t felt this way since the fifth
grade when I was cast to be the lead
role in a school play only to find out
the next day that I’d been pulled off
completely because my teacher found out
that I already had a part in the after
school production of Mary Poppins as a
penguin oh no I had a penguin slide it’s
not they’re a very cute little penguin
oh well
imagine a penguin if you will maybe I
could have fought for it then too but
sometimes you face those moments in life
when you know you’ve already lost and
this moment with my publisher was one of
those moments and truth be told I was
devastated and not just because I
couldn’t acquire this one single project
but because of what not acquiring it
represented the writing was on the wall
I was still nursing my wounds a few
weeks later when I got an email in my
inbox from a big deal New York agent
this project had all the right bells and
whistles the author was attractive
she was well-connected and she had a
bona fide celebrity attached to her
project who was going to write her
forward and throw her launch party this
book was about makeup
corporate was excited of course and I
was given permission to pay quite a lot
of money for this book I should have
been happy but I wasn’t I was upset in
fact I was angry I saw these two authors
and these two projects is symbolic of
something much bigger it spoke to me of
everything I’d come to dislike about
publishing his decision-making
a value of fluff over substance and
rejection of marginalized audiences and
acceptance based on celebrity and image
things sucked for a while after that and
I started looking for a way out it took
another year but I did leave to co-found
she writes press with my colleague cami
white cough we came up with a
non-traditional business model that
celebrates green lighters with a mission
to publish work based on the merit of
the writing alone we can do this because
our authors invest in themselves so our
focus is on the books content and not
the author’s brand
she writes press is just one of many
players and a rising greenlight
revolution a revolution that’s being
necessitated by the extremely high
barriers to entry in our traditional
creative industries where gatekeepers
are being trained to scout for fame over
talent
unfortunately this echoes a larger
cultural message that we’re fed that
Fame and celebrity and brand are the
highest measures of a person’s worth all
the artists I know create for so many
reasons beyond a desire to be famous and
because art always signs away green
lighters are circumventing those
barriers to entry and claiming their
legitimacy as artists green lighters
inspire me they have the kind of grit
and determining
that would inspire almost anyone let me
tell you about one such greenlighter my
friend director producer Sean Hanna
Sean has made two successful films
outside of traditional Hollywood what I
love about Sean is that he’s not caught
up in the scene
he wears t-shirts and tennis shoes to
work in a drives a 2007 Prius Sean’s
first movie returned to zero was about
the loss he and his wife endured when
their first child was stillborn
Sean faced an uphill battle on nearly
every front with this film the content
was dark people told him no one would
want to see it people told him grief
doesn’t sell but Sean persevered and
almost went broke self-financing a lot
of return-to-zero that needed a
Kickstarter campaign and he brought on
investors it was because of Sean’s
amazing script and not his big budget
that he secured mini driver to play the
lead after that lifetime bought rights
to the film and Emmys performance won
her an Emmy nomination
Mini’s performance excuse me who won her
an Emmy nomination when I asked Sean who
his film idols were he told me that
they’re the people who just don’t care
they’re the people who find a way to
make their movie he said those people
are green lighters and they do care just
not about what other people think they
should care about take Amanda Palmer
lead singer of The Dresden Dolls another
green lighter and someone in the music
business who embodies this indie spirit
Amanda tells the story in her TED talk
of a record label she was signed to who
that considered 25,000 copies of her
album soul to be a failure at the same
time people were coming up to her at her
shows and they were giving her money
confessing to downloading her songs for
free on the internet this inspired
Amanda to start giving away her music
for free everywhere
and she started asking for help Amanda
launched a Kickstarter campaign with the
goal of raising a hundred thousand
dollars and fans backed her to the tune
of 1 million one hundred and ninety two
thousand dollars huge remember espera
Bergman well let me tell you what ended
up happening to him he got a book deal
for that book that I did not acquire
it’s called blood marriage wine and
glitter his next book was a children’s
book featuring trans-identified children
the next part of this story will sound
familiar
while his fans were clamoring for this
book publishers were telling him there
was no market bear told me he had what
he calls a peak effet moment maybe
you’re familiar with this kind of moment
where you throw caution to the wind and
you take that open road for bear this
meant founding his own press flamingo
rampant which has published 13 books to
date on gender related topics for kids
and families bears a fit moment means
that he doesn’t have to justify that
there is a market for his books he is
appealing directly to his audience which
is exactly what Amanda did with her
music lots of artists are having these
kinds of effort moments when they
realize that they don’t want or need the
approval of the industries that they’ve
been seeking approval from for years and
it doesn’t matter who you are this is
never an easy moment it is tough to let
go of the dream of what you wanted your
creative future to look like but once
you do you make a new room for a new
dream that you manifest on your own
terms and I personally can’t think of
anything more freeing or empowering I
grew up in a family that supported my
creative dreams but I didn’t even make
it to adulthood before someone stomped
on my creative vision future thoughts
for myself as a writer
for me it was a high school teacher who
told me my creative writing wasn’t so
great maybe for you it was a parent or a
relative who told you to do something
practical with your life creativity in
this culture comes with baggage most of
us have raging inner critics telling us
we’re not good enough there is so much
one-upping and scarcity thinking in the
arts and then there are the misguided
values of our traditional creative
industries that I’ve been talking about
today my experience has shown me that we
worship at the wrong altars which is why
I’m excited about the green light
revolution for me it took opting out to
realize that there was another path
available to me it took helping other
green lighters to see that oh my gosh
I’d become a green lighter myself if
you’ve ever questioned your creative
worth take a deeper look at where that
message comes from if you’ve been
rejected or set your creative dreams
aside come back to that thing that you
loved not for fame or money or someone
else’s agenda but because it will make
you feel more alive the creative excuse
me green light revolution is available
to everyone and anyone if you’re not
already with us you’re invited thank you
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: