
in 2009 Quinnipiac University asked me
to teach the most unpopular course in
their graduate interactive program the
writing course the web students rejected
writing because they believed at the
time that books and bibliographies and
literature were obsolete this was a
particular moment in the evolution of us
in the internet because the financial
collapse had just occurred the Amazon
Kindle had just appeared and appeared to
threaten the entire entire publishing
industry just the focus on stem science
technology engineering math suggested to
many people that the humanities were
dying now as a good writer I stuck to my
convictions but I also listened to my
audience and I tried to speak in their
language I took the course online and I
used the metaphors and the forms of the
web to convince them that writing was
still essential in for an example I used
Twitter to teach them better sentence
writing now I know how we all feel about
Twitter right now but this was in the
beginning and at its most basic it’s a
limitation two hundred and eighty
characters per tweet back then it was
140 characters and it would force the
students to edit and if I reminded them
that they had to remain articulate for
their classmates and for the wider
audience they would learn to write and
they would learn to communicate better
online now taking the course online also
introduced it to a whole other hostile
audience my former colleagues
reporters and producers who were coming
back to school to learn about the web
that had halted many of their careers
and then I realized all I had to do was
turn the course on its head again and
use the web metaphors the writing
metaphors that they understood to teach
them about the web metaphors I could use
their love of a good sentence and a good
journalistic lead to help them
understand the possibilities of Twitter
and also help them get past the idea
that the web was their enemy and soon we
had this great online conversation
cross-generational cross skill level
cross different types of skills and this
was all in writing online and many of
the students who didn’t like the course
from both audiences now loved it let me
give you a larger example in the fourth
week of what I call the interactive
voice I asked students to pick out an
argument that they feel passionate about
and then I tell them to pick the
opposite side and play devil’s advocate
with themselves now the devil’s advocate
if you don’t know was an actual job
position in the Vatican in Rome someone
would speak against the candidates for
sainthood it’s a it’s a job position
that I think disappeared in the last
century and I hear the canonization
process is moving along quite nicely but
the phrase is stuck the phrase is stuck
the the lawyer the devil’s advocate at
the Vatican was a lawyer and all lawyers
use the devil’s advocate process to
prepare their arguments prosecutors
defense attorneys corporation counsel
they use the devil’s advocate to prepare
their witnesses and their clients for
the stand to think about what’s in the
mind of the opposite bench to imagine
the counter arguments that they will
face
in their next battle for the truth I use
the devil’s advocate as a writing
assignment because all writing is
argument whether you’re writing an op-ed
that’s packed that you’re passionate
about whether you’re submitting a
scientific paper whether you are
creating a piece of fiction and have to
convince the audience that it’s a
relevant reflection of reality it’s all
argument and if you really want to write
well you have to anticipate the many
ways in which the audience is going to
counter your ability to reach them now
and and that’s that’s really what I did
with the class I recreated it for each
new audience and and that’s what made it
successful now the devil’s advocate is
my favorite assignment a lot of the
assignments are teaching to form you
know how do you write a good resume how
do you write a good a good tweet but but
this assignment is about how to write if
it’s it’s open-ended so it’s really up
to the student to realize through their
imagination what they can do with it the
most basic thing I get from students are
the disclaimers even though we’re
working behind pseudonyms digital
avatars pen names that protect all of
their privacy
we still I still get these warnings from
from each of them these elaborate
italicized paragraphs at the beginning
of their blog posts to whom it may
concern do not associate any of the
following ideas or words with me this is
just a college course assignment for a
strange professor who wants us to take
the voice of people who were against all
that is good relevant and/or holy
clearly I’d hit a nerve and but the the
assignment doesn’t just work in that way
many other students will approach their
own empathy they will actually try to
put themselves in the shoes of an
other person I always get a debate team
captain or two who do the assignments so
well they put themselves in the minds of
the enemy so well that the rest of the
class thinks they didn’t understand the
assignment and then if I’m lucky
every second semester I get the example
the kid who will put themselves will
identify that passionate issue who will
research the opposition and really try
and get into that mindset and then they
it’s these are the students that I teach
for if they can get into that mindset
they can sometimes they will even try
and and navigate a third way through
that polarization and this is really
what good writing does it always
discovers not just in the research but
in the process of writing and in
connecting those words and connecting
those ideas it’s it’s that kind of
writing that they will that a good
writer will preserve in the writing
process so that we go through that
discovery too and then and then writing
becomes the preservation of knowledge
there’s one student that I had that she
I was just so surprised by her frankness
that she was learning and that she had
changed her mind and she said at one
point I’ve never challenged myself in
this way before and you have to ask how
often are we asked to challenge
ourselves in that way how often do we
take the opportunity when we get it it’s
the it’s the rare student who takes the
assignment all the way and it’s the rare
individual amongst all of us who will
admit to changing rather than wanting to
create change and everyone else now
since I started teaching the course
the online discussion has not improved
and many of the people who could
probably use the devil’s advocate
assignment would benefit from the many
people who would benefit from the
devil’s advocate assignment could have
have exploited and damaged how we think
about the social media formats that I’ve
used to teach good communication
internet trolls are actually not named
for the monster under the bridge they
are named for the phishing process where
you troll the bottom of the ocean trying
to catch something the moniker troll was
actually very much like the word hacker
originally a term amongst the early
internet culture that was positive and
it became negative in the mouths of the
internet skeptical a good internet troll
would do exactly what my assignment does
according to their definition a good
internet troll would try to go out into
the general public and catch the person
who needs to be who needs who needs to
be awake from the one way to see things
the internet troll is the gesture to the
king in the medieval times the the the
clown of the court would speak to
royalty and say things that would get
anyone else killed through the art of
comedy in King Lear we have the we have
the wise fool who bounces out the blind
literally and figuratively the blind
King and I you know as I
I make these comparisons in classes I
think about the devil’s advocate and I
think about trolling I realize it’s
American to troll the the checks and
balances system that the founders
created was meant to take the polarized
individuals and bring them to compromise
and it end and also to give voice to
those marginal ideas the marginal ideas
that founded the country we should be as
Americans more conscious of the the how
easy it is to get wrapped up in us
versus them the the idea that you should
wake the self when you want to wake
everyone else around you is as old as
Plato’s know thyself and to question
authority
you really have to begin with
questioning your own authority troll thy
self it’s the there was a student that I
had a few months ago it was a workshop
with retirees and he was a 70 year old
modern artist guy who had worked in the
mid last century with some of the greats
and he said to me you’re just talking
about the artistic process you’re
talking about the internal editor right
on the nose I don’t teach counter
arguments and trolling and comedy
because they’re the the things we see on
the web I teach them because they are
the oldest lesson of writing in art the
great writers the great authors they
they are relentless in the judgment of
themselves and their ideas and their
work that’s who creates the great work
the the writing the writers who approach
the paradoxes of our lives are the ones
who write the fiction and nonfiction and
art that grasps and occasionally changes
the world in other words
if you know thine enemy then you you still have some homework to do thank you
to teach the most unpopular course in
their graduate interactive program the
writing course the web students rejected
writing because they believed at the
time that books and bibliographies and
literature were obsolete this was a
particular moment in the evolution of us
in the internet because the financial
collapse had just occurred the Amazon
Kindle had just appeared and appeared to
threaten the entire entire publishing
industry just the focus on stem science
technology engineering math suggested to
many people that the humanities were
dying now as a good writer I stuck to my
convictions but I also listened to my
audience and I tried to speak in their
language I took the course online and I
used the metaphors and the forms of the
web to convince them that writing was
still essential in for an example I used
Twitter to teach them better sentence
writing now I know how we all feel about
Twitter right now but this was in the
beginning and at its most basic it’s a
limitation two hundred and eighty
characters per tweet back then it was
140 characters and it would force the
students to edit and if I reminded them
that they had to remain articulate for
their classmates and for the wider
audience they would learn to write and
they would learn to communicate better
online now taking the course online also
introduced it to a whole other hostile
audience my former colleagues
reporters and producers who were coming
back to school to learn about the web
that had halted many of their careers
and then I realized all I had to do was
turn the course on its head again and
use the web metaphors the writing
metaphors that they understood to teach
them about the web metaphors I could use
their love of a good sentence and a good
journalistic lead to help them
understand the possibilities of Twitter
and also help them get past the idea
that the web was their enemy and soon we
had this great online conversation
cross-generational cross skill level
cross different types of skills and this
was all in writing online and many of
the students who didn’t like the course
from both audiences now loved it let me
give you a larger example in the fourth
week of what I call the interactive
voice I asked students to pick out an
argument that they feel passionate about
and then I tell them to pick the
opposite side and play devil’s advocate
with themselves now the devil’s advocate
if you don’t know was an actual job
position in the Vatican in Rome someone
would speak against the candidates for
sainthood it’s a it’s a job position
that I think disappeared in the last
century and I hear the canonization
process is moving along quite nicely but
the phrase is stuck the phrase is stuck
the the lawyer the devil’s advocate at
the Vatican was a lawyer and all lawyers
use the devil’s advocate process to
prepare their arguments prosecutors
defense attorneys corporation counsel
they use the devil’s advocate to prepare
their witnesses and their clients for
the stand to think about what’s in the
mind of the opposite bench to imagine
the counter arguments that they will
face
in their next battle for the truth I use
the devil’s advocate as a writing
assignment because all writing is
argument whether you’re writing an op-ed
that’s packed that you’re passionate
about whether you’re submitting a
scientific paper whether you are
creating a piece of fiction and have to
convince the audience that it’s a
relevant reflection of reality it’s all
argument and if you really want to write
well you have to anticipate the many
ways in which the audience is going to
counter your ability to reach them now
and and that’s that’s really what I did
with the class I recreated it for each
new audience and and that’s what made it
successful now the devil’s advocate is
my favorite assignment a lot of the
assignments are teaching to form you
know how do you write a good resume how
do you write a good a good tweet but but
this assignment is about how to write if
it’s it’s open-ended so it’s really up
to the student to realize through their
imagination what they can do with it the
most basic thing I get from students are
the disclaimers even though we’re
working behind pseudonyms digital
avatars pen names that protect all of
their privacy
we still I still get these warnings from
from each of them these elaborate
italicized paragraphs at the beginning
of their blog posts to whom it may
concern do not associate any of the
following ideas or words with me this is
just a college course assignment for a
strange professor who wants us to take
the voice of people who were against all
that is good relevant and/or holy
clearly I’d hit a nerve and but the the
assignment doesn’t just work in that way
many other students will approach their
own empathy they will actually try to
put themselves in the shoes of an
other person I always get a debate team
captain or two who do the assignments so
well they put themselves in the minds of
the enemy so well that the rest of the
class thinks they didn’t understand the
assignment and then if I’m lucky
every second semester I get the example
the kid who will put themselves will
identify that passionate issue who will
research the opposition and really try
and get into that mindset and then they
it’s these are the students that I teach
for if they can get into that mindset
they can sometimes they will even try
and and navigate a third way through
that polarization and this is really
what good writing does it always
discovers not just in the research but
in the process of writing and in
connecting those words and connecting
those ideas it’s it’s that kind of
writing that they will that a good
writer will preserve in the writing
process so that we go through that
discovery too and then and then writing
becomes the preservation of knowledge
there’s one student that I had that she
I was just so surprised by her frankness
that she was learning and that she had
changed her mind and she said at one
point I’ve never challenged myself in
this way before and you have to ask how
often are we asked to challenge
ourselves in that way how often do we
take the opportunity when we get it it’s
the it’s the rare student who takes the
assignment all the way and it’s the rare
individual amongst all of us who will
admit to changing rather than wanting to
create change and everyone else now
since I started teaching the course
the online discussion has not improved
and many of the people who could
probably use the devil’s advocate
assignment would benefit from the many
people who would benefit from the
devil’s advocate assignment could have
have exploited and damaged how we think
about the social media formats that I’ve
used to teach good communication
internet trolls are actually not named
for the monster under the bridge they
are named for the phishing process where
you troll the bottom of the ocean trying
to catch something the moniker troll was
actually very much like the word hacker
originally a term amongst the early
internet culture that was positive and
it became negative in the mouths of the
internet skeptical a good internet troll
would do exactly what my assignment does
according to their definition a good
internet troll would try to go out into
the general public and catch the person
who needs to be who needs who needs to
be awake from the one way to see things
the internet troll is the gesture to the
king in the medieval times the the the
clown of the court would speak to
royalty and say things that would get
anyone else killed through the art of
comedy in King Lear we have the we have
the wise fool who bounces out the blind
literally and figuratively the blind
King and I you know as I
I make these comparisons in classes I
think about the devil’s advocate and I
think about trolling I realize it’s
American to troll the the checks and
balances system that the founders
created was meant to take the polarized
individuals and bring them to compromise
and it end and also to give voice to
those marginal ideas the marginal ideas
that founded the country we should be as
Americans more conscious of the the how
easy it is to get wrapped up in us
versus them the the idea that you should
wake the self when you want to wake
everyone else around you is as old as
Plato’s know thyself and to question
authority
you really have to begin with
questioning your own authority troll thy
self it’s the there was a student that I
had a few months ago it was a workshop
with retirees and he was a 70 year old
modern artist guy who had worked in the
mid last century with some of the greats
and he said to me you’re just talking
about the artistic process you’re
talking about the internal editor right
on the nose I don’t teach counter
arguments and trolling and comedy
because they’re the the things we see on
the web I teach them because they are
the oldest lesson of writing in art the
great writers the great authors they
they are relentless in the judgment of
themselves and their ideas and their
work that’s who creates the great work
the the writing the writers who approach
the paradoxes of our lives are the ones
who write the fiction and nonfiction and
art that grasps and occasionally changes
the world in other words
if you know thine enemy then you you still have some homework to do thank you
Please follow and like us: