Press "Enter" to skip to content

Global World and Defence Systems | Richard Barrons | TEDxBedfordSchool


[Applause]

so ladies and gentleman call me Richard

I simply so I’m going to talk about

changing the norm and I’m going to talk

about the business of changing armed

forces I think specifically the Armed

Forces of the United Kingdom although in

its bones this is really no different to

changing other any other institution or

organization that you may now or in the

future be be part of its process you

have to understand the journey that

you’ve traveled in all its richness and

complexity and uncertainty you then have

to understand where you are now and

accept that it’s not frozen there are

the aspects of your current situation

which even now are changing and even

when you’ve done that then you have to

stretch yourself as far into the future

you can look to make sure you are

grasping the risks and opportunities of

the future or you’ll be designing

yourself into sustained obsolescence and

if you’re capable of doing all of those

things whether you’re changing armed

forces or anything else then you

absolutely then have to make change

happen it won’t happen without

leadership and effort unless you choose

simply to be a victim of an uncertain

future so let’s look at the journey

traveled by Western and specifically the

United Kingdom armed forces because it

it matters and it should provoke some

interesting questions about the future

so the history is clear and this is

history and imperial history then the

world wars of the last century first

world war Second World War streaming

seamlessly into the frozen conflict at

scale of the cold war and that finished

in 1989 and for many armed forces

including the British Armed Forces that

was a shock because that was the end of

a piece of history that was familiar

where armed forces exist is as large

conventional forces fielded on an

enduring basis

and then suddenly the requirement for

that had lapsed and some people declared

the end of history I was a bit

optimistic so there was that a process

of redefinition as expressly the

campaign’s that I and others have taken

part in the Balkans of Bosnia Kosovo and

then Iraq and Afghanistan and Libya now

Syria and the crucial thing for you to

remember there but those those

particular campaigns is that they were

all abroad so it was an away match they

were limited in scale and duration at no

time was your homeland at risk or indeed

your future prosperity or your prospects

and that’s bred a certain sense about

what the British and other European

armed forces should be like in the

future but now you have to ask yourself

can you be sure that the future going

forward is going to be as secure and

benign as the recent past and then we

need to look at some economics it is

very simple if over 25 years you reduce

your defence budgets from roughly four

percent of gross domestic product down

to two percent of gross domestic product

even if you maintain the size of your

defense budget in real terms the fact is

over 25 years if the cost of your people

your equipment your activity and your

logistics continue to inflate above

inflation year-on-year and they will and

for high-end in equipment somewhere

between seven and eleven percent then

over time inevitably no matter how

efficient you think you can be you will

buy less equipment you will hire fewer

people you will do less stuff and you

will hollow out your stocks and if you

do that for 25 years there is a risk

that you will boil your frog but you’ll

have something that thinks its Armed

Forces that looks like Armed Forces but

is so small and feeble that actually

it’s fine as long as you don’t need it

and that absolutely is a great place to

be if you feel safe and you’re sure the

future is going to be as benign going

forward as the reefs

past so let’s look at the world as it is

already changing your world the first

thing is there is no shortage of

conflict in our world today perhaps 42

globally we spend about 1742 billion

dollars a year on defense warfighting

capability there are now more than 60

million people in a world displaced by

conflict alone and there are something

like a hundred thousand united nations

peacekeepers serving on separate

operations in Africa alone so you may

think as a resident of safe and secure

Europe that you’ve reached the end of

history and war has left you alone that

is not the experience of billions of

people in our world today and then we

need to have a conversation about the

nature of war itself it is an aspect of

the human condition if you like part of

our biological baggage that remains

unaltered over the centuries it is

unreasonable irrational feral stupid

dangerous disruptive destructive almost

always disappointing and almost always

ends badly and almost always starts for

really bad reasons but it is absolutely

part of the human condition so just

because you’ve had the luxury of 25

years of our comfortable post-cold war

era does not mean that you should

benchmark your armed forces against your

preferred form of warfare maybe the

things you’ve done recently you have to

remember that for millions of people

wore the nature of war is like this and

it never changes and partly for those

reasons it’s not helpful to talk about

peace and war in the modern age there’s

not a switch that you throw except

perhaps in law where you say we were at

peace and now we’re at war any country

this happens to be the United Kingdom

any country exists with a spectrum of

relationships with the people that it

deals with in the world so we will

cooperate with some we will compete with

others we will confront or be confronted

by some states and will be locked in a

state

conflict with others and in the

particular case of our time Isis for

sure now and you have to manage that on

a daily business on a daily basis and

tune your armed forces to deal with the

world has its actually turned out day by

day not the world that you would have it

be and you would then have to recognize

but even if the nature of war doesn’t

change the way it’s conducted in terms

of ideas and equipment and capability in

the jargon changes all the time and

here’s some examples this first one here

is the evolution of terrorism and

extremism in our time so traditionally

terrorism for us would be small groups

of people armed with bombs and bullets

we tried to kill policemen and soldiers

will blow up public buildings if you

like the traditional model of the

Northern Irish terrorism that came out

of the of the troubles now sadly I

happily now well contained however

terrorism in our time is completely

different the terrorists of our time

don’t expect to go home so they come

with a gun and they come wearing a

suicide vest and they come in numbers

and they are an existential fit they

mean to terminate your way of life and

they don’t mind who they kill along the

way and they aspire to step into weapons

of mass destruction whether that’s

home-cooked chemical weapons or

biological weapons or to acquire other

people’s missiles so this has to be

dealt with because this is a problem

that has presented itself even if we

didn’t want it and then in our age

there’s the issue of the significance of

ballistic missiles now this will not

have troubled you at all but you will

have heard of nuclear missiles but in

the age we now live in a modern

conventional that is to say a missile

with a high-explosive warhead in the

hands of countries which we may not be

on best terms with is capable of

reaching your homeland and when it comes

if it comes it comes at Mac six to seven

it will bring an eight hundred kilogram

high-explosive warhead it’ll have an

accuracy of about two meters it’s very

precise

and it will carry onboard its own

defensive suite are really hard to shoot

down and it is of course as I say

traveling extremely quickly so none of

these things featured in the Balkans or

Afghanistan or Iraq but they are now

feature of the modern world and it’s not

just the stuff that might come our way

in the future there’s also the question

of in the jargon a2/ad aerial denial

anti-access have thoughtful investment

by many nations around the world in

advanced technology that is designed to

keep other people’s air forces navies

and submarines out of their territory so

for example the way I air forces have

operated over territory like Afghanistan

for a decade does not happen if you’re

confronted by the thing on the top right

there which is a an s 400 Russian

launcher shoots aircraft down at 400

miles a ship won’t get within 300 miles

of a coast defended by modern anti-ship

cruise missiles and in the area

particularly of autonomous systems

drones in the underwater space a

submarine becomes a much harder thing to

sneak about the world so you have to

consider the stuff that might be fired

at you and also consider how hard it is

to reach the heartland of people that

you may fall out with in the future and

there are couple of new things which may

not be a surprise you the business of

cyber it is a normal part of the daily

interaction between states and non-state

actors 2014 half of the crime in the

United Kingdom at six million events

were ascribed to cyber the global annual

cost of cybercrime alone is three

trillion dollars which happens to be the

same cost to the US of the campaigns in

Iraq and Afghanistan it’s just a normal

part of the way people steal information

commit criminal acts and cause harm and

disruption and in our age perhaps as it

was during the height of the Second

World War if you want to wage war you’re

not necessarily wage war by trying to

destroy someone’s armed forces or

destroy their civil population but you

will make their daily life hold by

taking down critical now

infrastructure so you’ve never had a day

in your life when you wake up and

there’s no power there are no atms than

those supermarket distribution systems

there’s no postal system there’s no

banking there’s no air traffic control

there’s no traffic control in the

streets and your daily life comes to

hole in the modern age modern armed

forces have to deal with that sort of

effect created by cyber but if necessary

also by those precision ballistic

missiles I referred to and all of that

is in the world we live in now and would

have to be factored into how you would

transform modern European armed forces

but let’s look at how the world is

actually going to change and and there

are a number of really important things

they’re going to shape all walks of life

over the next generation we live in the

Asian century wealth and power is

transitioning East the rules-based

international order which has protected

us and by which we have prospered is

being challenged the institutions we

have invested great confidence in our

being neutered weakened and in some

places displaced we now live for sure in

a generation where we as people of this

earth as we grow from seven billion to

nine point four billion by about twenty

forty five are going to outgrow the

capacity of our planet to absorb all the

terrible things that we do to it and to

satisfy all our expectations so

inequality migration deserta fication

climate change population growth and

aging population all of those things are

going to shape how conflict is started

and where it occurs in in particular

urbanization half the world’s population

now in cities 2045 two thirds of the

world population in cities mega cities

of more than 20 million people that is

where war will be fought not in the on

the North German plane or some

wilderness where armed forces would much

prefer to operate because it’s a simpler

environment and then there’s this the

fourth Industrial Revolution so how we

all live and work and play and fight

will be changed by combinations of data

processing connectivity autonomous

systems artificial intelligence robotics

new materials

use of space it started already and it

will only accelerate over the next

generation so of course if you’re

transforming Armed Forces you will look

for advantage by being on the front edge

of making combinations of this

technology you will not look simply to

have more of the stuff that got you

through the tricky years of the 1990s or

the noughties so now you have to make

change actually well a big important

make change actually happen and here we

get into the human dimension the first

thing that you must have our leaders who

are capable of not just running today’s

events but also looking to the horizon

and I know that sounds nothing like a

revelation but it’s actually very hard

so for our government today for example

very fixated on the problem of brexit it

also has to think about security and the

changing world that I’ve described and

then you need people who can think

rigorously so strong minds and more than

that you need great reserves of moral

courage because you are going to

challenge vested interest you’re going

to have to overcome institutions and

people who invested their lives in a

particular way of doing things and now

you’re going to have to decide you’re

going to sweep it away in order to

transform armed forces or whatever it is

that you’re doing and in doing that you

have to be so good at what you’re doing

that not only can you think brilliantly

and bring to that thing great moral

courage and conviction but you can argue

and many great ideas fail because

although they are great and brilliant

they just never well articulated so

advocacy this important is as important

as the idea and you’re going to have to

tinker with complicated issues like this

is at the UK public sector cake about

seven hundred and eighty billion pounds

a year taxpayers money and borrowing and

if you want to transform armed forces

you’re going to provoke really difficult

questions like okay so we need to spend

more money on defense

so so how many for your hospitals would

you like or more potholes in the roads

or lower pensions or less employment

protection there’s no free free right

here it is an exceptionally difficult

argue to my argument amount to people

who live comfortable lives and have

certain expectations that for their

future security or the security of their

children they may need have less of the

things that they like to spend money on

stuff they don’t like which are their

armed forces and then you’re going to

need a team and I hope many people

watching this will aspire to be members

of this sort of team so not just

military people who can think of

military ideas important though that is

you need the scientists and engineers to

develop that capability you need the

civil servants who can manage the

finances of it complicated as it will be

but over time you need industry and

others to produce these things and to

make them competitive and affordable and

you need technical skills which I know

it sounds dull that’s so important

people who can write good contracts and

some people maybe some of you in this

room will invest your lives in being

good at one or more of those disciplines

then you need time and money because if

there’s one thing you need to remember

in transforming armed forces which is

you may want to have all the time in the

world but you may find and this is the

new york times from august 1914

asserting that a general European war is

unthinkable and it broke out a month

later so if you take the world I’ve

describe to you how can you be sure that

you’ve got all the time in the world in

a leisurely way to think about

transforming your own forces for a world

that may just turn out to be more

threatening than the one that you have

lived in your lives so far thank you

very much you

Please follow and like us: