Press "Enter" to skip to content

Fun & Games: Reflecting on Societies Biggest Problems | Alan Grant | TEDxKU


I’ve been thinking a lot about M&Ms
do you like M&Ms I brought a big batch
of them today and I’d like to share some
of them with you if I could if if you’d
be willing to play a little game with me
I know that teryn told you to turn off
your phones but if I could get you to
turn them back on just for a moment we
can play a little bit of game little
game together with M&Ms as the reward
here’s the game that I’d like you to
play today I’d like you to choose a
signature color one of two colors you
can choose red or you can choose green
and a number of M&Ms that you’re going
to receive depends on your choice of
signature color after everybody has sent
in by telephone their signature color
I’m simply going to add up the number of
people who chose red and everybody who
chose red will get exactly that number
of M&Ms
so if 20 of the people in the 100 member
audience choose red those 20 Reds will
receive 20 M&Ms what about the greens if
you choose green I’m going to give you
exactly the same number of M&Ms as I
gave the Reds but then I’m going to give
you an extra 20 M&Ms
so if 20 of you in the audience choose
red and 80 choose green the Reds will
receive 20 M&Ms and the greens will
receive 40 have you given some thought
to your choice of signature color once
you have there’s a number on the screen
you can simply text the word red or the
word green to the number on the screen
and I’ve got a friend who’s gonna
tabulate these and will report back on
how you did a little bit later in the
presentation
I like M&Ms too I stopped on my way here
and bought a package of M&Ms peanut M&Ms
my favorite the best kind I think they
cost me a dollar I walked into the store
I found the M&Ms I gave the clerk gave
my dollar I walked away happy I valued
the M&Ms more than the dollar
the clerk valued the dollar more than
the M&Ms we know that we both materially
benefited from this transaction because
at the end of it
we both said thank you transactions like
these happen millions of times every day
they’re commonplace they’re completely
non-controversial we don’t give them a
second thought and yet there are other
times when the pursuit of material
self-interest causes outcomes that many
people view as problematic these
controversial outcomes or their
controversial solutions actually present
some of society’s biggest and most
vexing problems climate change
overfishing depletion of the rainforests
fracking basic income healthcare clean
energy gun control segregation epidemics
these problems are some of the biggest
problems that we face they are problems
that we have been unable to find clean
workable solutions to in many instances
sometimes for decades or hundreds of
years and yet they all share a similar
feature they are all examples of what
economists call collective action
problems collective action problems are
problems that are going to require the
coordinated efforts of large numbers of
people to solve I know that many of us
have worked in groups as small as two or
three or four and found that group
workings aspirating it’s really hard to
get three people to work together for a
common purpose these problems are going
to require not two or three or four P
to work together but two or three or
four hundred million people to work
together it’s no wonder we haven’t come
to a solution for these these issues are
also heavily politicized I worked once
at a university that had a dedicated
recycling coordinator this was his job
to make sure everybody recycled and late
at night once a week he would use his
passkey and enter faculty and staff
offices long after everybody had gone
home and he’d start searching through
trash cans and when he came to the first
trash can that didn’t have any
recyclable materials in it the owner of
that trash can
would receive a recycler of the Week
award and they’d be written up in the
faculty and a staff newsletter along
with a little blurb why they recycled
and the most common answer was because
recycling is the right thing to do but
I’d like to point out that choosing
whether to use a piece of paper over
again is really fundamentally an
economic question not really a moral
question that putting your paper in the
black bin doesn’t make you bad or evil
and putting it in the blue bin doesn’t
make you a saint or a savior this really
is just an economic question and it’s
not the only economic question that is
somehow become imbued with all kinds of
moral content that has been politicized
in some way shape or form many most all
of the issues that we looked at just a
few minutes ago have been heavily
politicized well what’s the problem with
politicizing an issue politics matter I
think the problem is that when we
politicize an issue we lose completely
our ability to think rationally and
objectively about the nature of the
problem or the nature of that problem
solution instead we tend to cling to our
political anchor and we refuse to
objectively look at all points of view
one way in which this happens
is what psychologists call confirmation
bias this simply means that we will take
in information that agrees with our own
moral philosophy and will simply refuse
to take in information that does not in
a recent study participants were
presented with biographies of real
scientists along with summaries of their
public published research and then they
were asked whether the scientists were
experts in their field or not and
unwaveringly individuals with strong
political inclinations would qualify as
experts those scientists whose research
agreed with their own political priors
but they would refuse to endorse as
expert scientists whose published
research peer reviewed research
disagreed with their own political
beliefs so when we look at information
we will take an information that agrees
with our own inner expert but we will
reject information we’ll simply refuse
to think about it
if it doesn’t agree with us but what
happens if we actually force people to
take in information that is counter to
their own political priors in the
election of 2004 researchers strapped
study participants into functional
magnetic resonance imaging machinery and
this is a machine that simply Maps
brainwave activity in different parts of
the brain and these participants were
diehard party loyalists was the clear
favorite candidate and while they were
strapped to this machine they were fed
information that was potentially
damaging to their candidates chances of
winning the election and what the
researchers running the study found was
really pretty compelling because when
presented with this potentially damaging
information the part of the brain that
was devoted to emotion lit up like the
fourth of July and the part of the brain
that was devoted to reason showed
virtually no response at all in other
words when we’re presented with
information that doesn’t agree with our
political priors we will simply refuse
to take it in but if somebody forces you
to take in that information your brain
will leap to your defense and simply
used to process it but what happens if
we force your brain to process this
information recently a group of study
participants were tested for
mathematical ability by being asked to
evaluate the effectiveness of a new rash
cream later those very same participants
were presented with exactly the same
numbers exactly the same mathematical
problem but instead of looking at a rash
cream this problem was dressed up in
different packaging instead of
evaluating the effectiveness of a rash
cream they were asked to evaluate the
effectiveness of a gun control program
on reducing crime and here the answers
the mathematical answers that our
participants generated depended
critically on the respondents political
inclinations self-identified liberals
were very quick and accurate in
computing the effectiveness of a program
when it showed that gun control reduced
crime and yet they made frequent errors
when presented with an alternative
version of the problem that showed that
gun control had no impact on crime
conservatives made exactly the same
mistake but they made it in Reverse and
oddly enough ironically the better
people were at solving the rash cream
version of the problem the worse they
were at solving the gun control problem
when the answer was one that disagreed
with their own political priors
in other words politics makes us stupid
three times over the theme of this TEDx
conference is reflection how perceptions
evolve and unfortunately I’ve got bad
news for you when it comes to
politicized issues our perceptions do
not evolve they remain chained to the
foundations my job is to teach college
freshmen about big-ticket social
problems my students are bright they’re
disciplined they’re very impassioned but
I worry sometimes that the passion that
inspires them is also
interfering with their ability to think
critically about real-world hard to
solve politicized social problems so how
can we get college freshmen and how can
we get our friends and our neighbors to
think critically about social problems
to think objectively about them to see
that there’s more than one side to every
issue and the answer I think is to strip
away all of the political packaging
around a problem and really just look at
the core of the problem itself you can
think about this process as kind of rash
cream for college students the tool that
economists used to do this to analyze
these big-ticket collective action
problems is called game theory game
theory is the science of individual
strategic interactions with one another
game theory is particularly useful
because it lets us look at individuals
motivations and yet we get the chance to
add individuals up and look at the
collective outcome they produce
economists and mathematician can bend
more writes that the more deeply we feel
about issues the more we need to avoid
being misled by wishful thinking game
theory lets us discuss the logic of
strategic action dispassionately it then
becomes possible to follow the logic
wherever it leads us without throwing up
our hands and denial when it takes us
somewhere we’d rather not go I’d like to
talk to you for just a moment about the
collective action game you’ve played at
the beginning of my talk you were asked
remember to choose a signature color and
you can choose red and receive just as
many Reds as all the other Reds in the
room or you could choose green and
receive 20 more mm than all your red
counterparts I now have results from
that 14 of you in the audience chose red
everybody else chose green I want to
point out but this is a really bad
outcome for ever
buddy those of you that chose red are
gonna walk away with 14 M&Ms those of
you that choose green are going to walk
away with 34 M&Ms and if only you could
have coordinated with one another and
work together all 100 of you could have
chosen red and everybody could have
walked away with a hundred M&Ms this is
a collective action problem that has
been stripped of all political context
red is not good Green is not evil the
Reds and the greens all want the same
thing they all want more mmm and what
looking at a problem like the red-green
problem does for us it’s it lets us
focus on the core structure of the
problem the fact that we have an
individual incentive to choose green and
get the 20 extra M&Ms but we have a
collective interest in choosing red and
building a big foundation of M&Ms that
everybody can enjoy because M&Ms
are happiness and instead of focusing on
all of these issues on power on ideology
on left/right distinctions Republicans
and Democrats or even moral and immoral
we need to focus on the true nature of
the problem the tension in so many of
our economic decisions between what’s
good for the individual and what’s good
for all the people around that
individual right it’s the structure of
that kind of problem that is at the
heart of all of these collective action
problems it’s just that a lot of us
don’t know it so I wanted to talk now
about how we can take this red green
simulation this red green game and make
it useful to shed new light on some of
our big-ticket social problems in my
classes we start by taking the red green
problem and playing it over and over and
over again and I have to tell you you
guys actually did a much better job than
my students usually out of every 100
students I’ll get 7 who choose red and
93 who choose green but it’s still a
really lousy outcome and practice
doesn’t make perfect they play this game
over
over and over and they rarely do any
better so by the time we get ready to
study real issues they have some
background about collective action
problems and then once they understand
this tension between individual and
collective interest then the fun begins
because we get to unwrap the red/green
problem and take away the M&Ms and then
rewrap it into things that students
really do care about
we simply repackage the problem with
context add the context back keeping a
small fish green is good for a fisherman
returning it to the lakes in the oceans
red helps rebuild the sustainability of
the fishery carrying a gun for personal
protection may help an individual that’s
green leaving it locked at home in a
cabinet may prevent potential gun
violence that’s read tariffs on imported
sugar are really good for American sugar
producers Green free trade in sugar is
good for consumers red burning coal
ironically is good for power companies
this is ironically green alternative
energy is good for the atmosphere in the
air that we breathe red I got my flu
shot yesterday avoiding a painful
vaccination is good for the individual
receiving a vaccination is good for
everybody that individual comes in
contact with red green can help us shed
some light on these big-ticket social
problems less really can be more can
bend more rights that the crucial step
in solving a real-life problem nearly
always consists of locating a toy game
that lies at its heart only when that
toy game has been solved does it make
sense to worry about how its solution
needs to be modified to take account of
all the bells and whistles that
complicate the real world the real-life
problems that we have
looked at today are not going to be easy
to solve but they’ll be easier to solve
if we can strip away the political
packaging and understand the core of
that problem toy games like the
red-green game let us set about finding
solutions instead of simply casting
stones and that’s how a little fun and
games a little understanding of game
theory can make us both better thinkers
and better citizens thank you
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: