Press "Enter" to skip to content

From care spaces to caring systems | Thilo Kroll | TEDxQMU


I think the essence of this slide and

this talk is how we actually move from

care spaces to caring systems we have a

lot of discourse around how we improve

our hospitals our practices our caring

institutions but how do we move on to

caring systems we already when you think

about that you already notice a slight

difference in emphasis in preparation of

this talk I came across a quote in a

newspaper about a young couple that

moved to New York City from Dublin this

was around the time I moved to Ireland

to moving to a new country allows you to

reinvent yourself and I passed a little

bit to think what that means in terms of

our topic today the transgenerational

world I’ve moved several times and you

saw an illustration from Dundee to

Dublin recently but I’ve used several

times before and had to reinvent or

readjust readapt had to change I’m

thinking about our generations a

transgenerational world when you think

about it and reflect about it a moment

when your parents were born your

grandparents were born what that world

looked like when you were born and what

has happened the last maybe 20 30 years

how life around you has changed how

people around you have changed people

who might still be here others might be

gone and new people like our youngest

TED talk member today have entered this

world so this requires a lot of

adaptation a lot of flexibility but our

our caring systems our healthcare and

social care systems our systems that we

are interacting with are they prepared

to match this diversity this dynamic so

we’re living in changing worlds and have

changing lives one of the those changes

manifests themselves in the way

we think of families still in policy

documents and strategies we speak of

family-centered family-friendly policies

but rarely do we pause about and think

about you know what family actually

means nowadays we’ve great awareness of

more diverse families than ever before

I saw a while back in a little Metro

free newspaper a clip of I think was

around the time when and Elton John and

his partner adopting a child is seeking

to adopt a child forty five permutations

family we have single-parent families we

have same-sex families we have

multi-generational families we have

childless families with nuclear families

extended families and so on this little

illustration here just shows you a

patchwork of these different notions of

family again if we pause and think how

well our systems geared up to match the

needs of these diverse families another

notion of change relates to community we

can think about how communities now live

together work together the spaces they

inhabit and I’m thinking about my mom

who lives in a suburban community in

Germany has lived there about 40 years

he’s 85 years old now and a lot of

things have changed in that community

when she moved in there were a lot of

families of probably the same age there

were a lot of traditional farm farmers

still in the community active and she

was welcomed she was become became

quickly a part of the family of their

community now in the last 10 years

families older family members have moved

out of the community or have died

children like me have moved all have

moved abroad and the neighbors are new

their social support structures and

social environments that she is

confronted with

is completely different now than was

thirty years ago but now she needs those

social connections now she needs those

links but they’re hard to find people

drive into the city to do their shopping

the local shop that used to cater for

immediate needs like milk potatoes and

so on

slows down it was not sustainable

anymore that is the shop she could reach

she doesn’t use the internet she doesn’t

believe the Internet she is not a

digital immigrant or digital native as

we call it but she predates the internet

technology the way we communicate the

way we access information the way we buy

things shop for things get get connected

with each other has strange dramatically

in the last 20 years or so

smartphone density is now higher in some

East African countries than in parts of

Germany so it’s a global phenomenon that

the way we communicate has changed

people under 20 or 25 I would say have

seen now more places in this world then

the older generation could ever dream of

so we’re highly mobile our workforce is

highly mobile and yet our older

population but not only them becomes

increasingly socially isolated and

lonely so loneliness is a real

phenomenon we communicate a real-time

more than ever before instantly through

Twitter Facebook and so on but

loneliness is increasing so what do we

see we see a huge fragmentation of the

way we live the way we communicate and

also the way our services are arranged

and organized we need to find a way to

overcome this fragmentation and to

reconnect the dots that are currently

isolated we operate in these silos

we try to create efficiencies in

hospitals through Lean Six Sigma or

whatever

managerial mechanisms we try to

implement but even connecting

information from the hospital to the GP

becomes difficult with all the

technology in the world but cannot have

electronic records that follow the

patient Social Care

supposedly integrated completely

different ways of capturing data for

instance in Scotland several initiatives

are underway to rectify that but the

huge challenging effort and then the

communities that develop that change

constantly and the families within those

communities the ways they live the ways

that communicate the ways they support

each other who is the caregiver I’m a

caregiver for my mum but I live about

2,000 kilometres away so that’s a new

reality that we communicate that we need

to communicate and work with so as I

said we are focusing very much on our

structures on making our hospitals

efficient on improving discharge and all

the data that we have so we are the

length of stay for many conditions have

has decreased at the same time we lack

GPS a massive lack of GPS and under

utilization of public health nurses for

instance in in Ireland so we desperately

need to reconnect the systems because at

the moment they are fragmented we’re

talking about clinical pathways and

that’s fine we’re talking about stroke

pathways dementia pathways but people

are not just conditions and more often

than not when you’re 65 and older you

just have more than one condition to

manage you might have dementia and a

stroke and a learning disability or

something else that need to come into

the picture I think it’s time to think

about people pathways relationship

pathways rather than clinical pathways

we need to move the power back from the

professions into the public

decision-making back into people and

together with the professions not in

isolation it’s about relationships

it’s about people centeredness community

centeredness family centeredness this

these are the assets that people bring

to the table then don’t live in

isolation tank have hobby friends their

relatives their colleagues they engage

in work spaces and so on they have

places of worship supermarkets they

engage with and so on we need to think

out of the box we need to harness the

complexity of these systems in order to

create something that I call a

flourishing system a flourishing caring

system and I’m drawing here on this

ecosystem notion but also on concepts

that come from positive psychology in

terms of how people flourish and it’s

not rocket science it’s five components

that Seligman and colleagues have worked

up there are positive emotions it’s

about engagement it’s about

relationships it’s about meaning and

it’s about achievement if you think

about those we lift these systems from

individual a individual component up to

a system level I think we can do it we

need to enhance connectivity engagement

and there’s lots of emphasis in Scotland

in Ireland and other places about civic

engagement public involvement but we

also need to be mindful that it doesn’t

become tokenism that people are excluded

from this engagement practice we’re

talking with the diverse population we

need to adapt the methodologies the

methods how we engage with people

whether it’s using sign language for

deaf population whether it’s providing

accessible venues for people to come to

to engage and transportation support

whether it’s a supply supplying

alternative formats for reading and

understanding the information for people

with learning disabilities and so on so

we need to think in terms of diversity

not only the easy to reach or easy to

easy to engage people and it’s about

happiness it’s about hope it’s about

positivity when I went to Brazil a few

years back and I visited a hospital one

thing that struck me immediately is how

the caring professions interacted with

each other and with the patients there

were a lot of smiles people pause the

liqueur it was to hug each other asked

about their day and there was a lot of

laughter on the bedside there was a lot

of painting drawing a lot of creative

activity if you wear student nurse you

were encouraged if you were a good

singer to sing with the patients and

they did that so they embrace this

positive holistic understanding of well

create a good environment a positive

environment and positive relationships

and create a hopeful environment create

an environment that provides nourishment

a while back we wrote a paper about

dementia and trying to shift the notion

away from decline to development things

that you can discover there are armed

people that constantly evolve and change

if you adopt a notion of change rather

than defect decline deficiency if you

embrace a social model or a relational

model rather than a deficit model of

functional model finally I think really

important meaning what matters to people

we did some work on stroke a while back

and asked really what kind of outcomes

are really picked up by therapists who

work in the community and we found

actually they use the same measures the

same standardized functional measures

that they would use in the hospital

whether someone can walk a certain

distance or can pick up certain things

but does that really matter when we

people yeah it is maybe it means to an

end but what ultimately matters is being

down the down the pub with a friends

being back in dance hall to do ballroom

dancing to meet the grandchildren to

lift them up so those things matter but

we need to ask them we also need to

understand the biographies of

individuals of families how people live

how they want to live how the desire to

live how they’ve lived in the past no

need to bang on about being physically

active if you never been physically

active in your life you know it’s you

need to understand where it’s coming

from

well sit if you have an athletic family

yeah it might be a no-brainer to do this

after you had a stroke to encourage that

physical activity and from a health

perspective I’m not arguing from that it

might be functional but is it meaningful

and people need to have a sense of

belonging as well and experience that

again a while back we had a little

project looking at the difference

between housing and making a home I

think it relates very much to place

making as well as home making home is

not a notion of a physicality per se

home is something that has an emotional

connotation as a social relational

connotation it’s where people are happy

where they connected where they feel

well and this well-being this feeling

feeling well I think is essential and

lastly we need to enable people to gain

the sense of achievement not necessarily

it sounds almost patronizing to say

enable because they bring a lot of

assets people bring assets people have

assets but we need to recognize them we

need to encourage aides agency in people

we need to harness that agency to create

the systems that will ultimately help us

flourish thank you

you [Applause]

Please follow and like us: