Press "Enter" to skip to content

Fairness Epidemic: Color Discrimination in India | Kishor Bharadwaj | TEDxDeerfield


good evening Deerfield

I’m Kishore bhardwaj and I’m the last

scheduled TEDx speaker for tonight so

before I get started with my talk I just

like to congratulate all my fellow

speakers on phenomenal talks and as well

thank that TEDx team for helping put

together this wonderful performance and

help us with preparing her talk so could

so with that I’d like to get started if

you were to go to any drug store in

America you’re bound to find products

that will help you get 10 there are

bronzers tanning lotions and even

melanin boosting serums and all sorts of

crazy stuff but instead let’s take a

little bit of a trip about halfway

across the world to a land where over

time various races and ethnicities have

ethnically bonded or amalgamated to

create a naturally tan population and

with that namaste and welcome to India

this enchanting land of over 1 billion

people is also home to 22 major world

languages as well as many different

ethnicities and cultures and throughout

history different world powers of

conquered different parts of the

peninsula over time for instance the

Mughal Empire in the north constructed

world wonders that the world knows such

as the Taj Mahal and the Kutub Minar and

the Dravidians in the South who are the

native people to the South constructed

beautiful Indian temples as this

hundreds of them the one pictured here

is called Mahabalipuram it’s a religious

site and the Portuguese and British

conquerors also left behind their

cultures and religion and although each

state has its own different cuisines

cultures day to day customs and

languages there are also plenty of

unifying factors Indian patriotism and

national sports are two of the main glue

sticking the myriads of these micro

cultures together except it’s my painful

duty to inform you that there’s one

terrible cultural aspect tearing apart

the Indian people and that is their

obsession with light-skinned remember

the tanning lotion from the first slide

imagine the opposite of that but to an

extreme extent imagine your mother

scolding you for getting a Sports ten

genuinely worried that you will not be

able to get you married

imagine being rejected by a potential

spouse by the love of your life

the only reason being that you are too

dark

imagine being an overqualified candidate

for a job and your interview goes

flawlessly you nail it but you don’t get

called back why because the candidate

who walked in five minutes after you was

just a few shades lighter imagine you’re

the darkest sibling in your family and

you grow up knowing every single day of

your life that you’ll never be the

favorite child no matter how successful

accomplished or philanthropic you may be

imagine the culture around you forces

you to bleach your skin and dye your

hair just so you have a fair shot at

success now you all are imagining right

now but this nightmare this nightmare is

a reality for the beautiful but darker

boys girls women and men of the Indian

subcontinent if you don’t believe me and

there’s reason for you not to because

I’ve just given you hypotheticals

imagine this imagine that I want you to

pay attention to the screen in a few

minutes a few moments and watch a video

of world famous Bollywood actor and for

those of you who do not know what

Bollywood is it’s the Indian version of

Hollywood a video of Shahrukh Khan who’s

a critically acclaimed actor endorsing a

skin bleaching product and in this

advertisement he tells a darker man in

search for love in search for a soulmate

to bleach his skin in order for him not

to look like a lowly domestic to his

female counterparts and although this ad

is in Hindi which is the national

language of India

the degenerate and twisted logic that it

is based off of simply speaks for itself

please

[Music]

suppose morrow gay and havin territory

and someone mandoline a fair and

handsome friend scream more donkey

sucked to a chocolate risk of five

action fairness system they’d

long-lasting Dora but they are very

that’s not an anomaly there are plenty

of ads like that if I wanted to I could

fill up this whole TEDx talk with ads

similar to that one and worse than that

one well that’s for another time keep in

mind that Shahrukh Khan the actor that

you saw a role model for youth and young

men my role model as a child growing up

told the man in that video to bleach his

skin and endorse this terrible practice

of skin bleaching that’s pretty blunt

and blatantly color discriminatory or

the shorter-term colorist

but the bluntness does not stop there in

India where arranged marriage is still

fairly common prospective husbands and

wives give resumes and a list of

prerequisites for a potential spouse in

the matrimonial section of a newspaper

so similar to in the States we have the

sports section business session etc in

India they also have a matrimonial

section just for these ads so I’ve kind

of pulled together a few newspaper

clippings from different parts of India

and let’s just look at a few so this is

a matrimonial section from The Sunday

Times and next to words like likes

traveling and you know business major

and likes kids likes to cook is a word

that’s from I’ve taken newspapers from

all different parts of India and there’s

one word that’s in common between all of

them and I’m gonna ask the audience does

anybody want to guess what that word is

these newspaper clippings as I said are

from different parts of India and give a

diverse sample of how these matrimonial

sections are and this explicitly shows

how a parent this fairness epidemic has

become and unfortunately demanding fair

spouse’s has become the norm now let me

show you some statistics this graph is

from part matrimony calm in addition to

newspaper is in matrimonial sections

they’re also dating websites so in the

u.s. we have a harmony and match calm

but in India they have both matrimony

which is a dating site for arranged

marriages so I’d like you to take a look

at the South Indian graph right here and

with a little bit of addition you can

figure out that over fifty percent of

South Indians identify as fair or very

fair when South Indians are of the

Dravidian ethnicity the same ethnicity

that

built the temples that I showed you

earlier and Dravidians are naturally

dark and have curly hair and me being a

South Indian most South Indians do not

look like me they’re dark and have curly

hair resemble more African than white so

when pigs fly that statistic is real so

why is there such a stigma why are these

South Indians embellishing their actual

skin color acting like they’re lighter

and more Caucasian looking than they

actually are so I decided to research

this question why is there such a stigma

blame for colorism or color

discrimination in India is attributed to

different conquering powers in archaic

principles throughout history and also

immigrants immigrants are blamed for

everything these days

but Indo Orient’s who were immigrants

from North India who were lighter than

the native indigenous Indians there

could have been a conflict there the

Mughal Empire same people who built the

Taj Mahal hailed from the Caucasus so

there could have been some conflict and

color discrimination there the British

who were white there could have been

some discrimination there and these all

these different powers have received

their fair share no pun intended of

blame so I decided to research this

little bit further so the caste system

or the Varna system in Sanskrit has

always been blamed for discrimination in

India of all sorts and what the Varna

system or caste system basically is it’s

a system that attributes different jobs

to different people in a community or

originally based on merit but now it’s

based on hierarchy so if I’m of a

certain caste

my kids will be of a certain caste my

grandkids will be able to certain caste

etc and this system was separating

people into groups and the first

recorded incidents of this in Hindu

history was in the Rig Veda which was

discovered about 3,500 years ago written

3,500 years ago and it is a highly

revered Indian text and I looked through

the Rig Veda in my free time and look

chanced upon the poorest rakta which is

a verse that analogizes the caste system

of Varna system to an eternal being and

I’ve written it here the brahmanas were

as mouths the CRA’s were as arms the

vices worst eyes the shooters were his

feet and as you can see with this

pyramid here the Brahmins referred to

the members of the priests or academic

caste they were responsible for passing

on knowledge they held the power the

truth Ria’s were the Warriors the kings

and the legislative groups of India

the vices were the merchants or

landowners and the sudras

were the vocational caste of India and

made sure that garbage wasn’t rotting on

the streets as the civilization

progressed and this beautiful metaphor

explains that without all castes present

society would cease to function imagine

it an eternal being without a mouth or

without arms it’s very hard to imagine

and many professors from universities

have conjectured that the oral

recitation method used to convey the

Vedas and other important texts like

this from mouth to mouth have maybe led

to the misinterpretation of such

metaphors eventually evolving into caste

and color discrimination but I

personally don’t believe in this and

I’ll give some more evidence so throw it

Hindu history many dark and non Brahman

which are everyone above the priests

class figures have been extremely

revered and are venerated on a daily

basis so two examples are Lord Krishna

and Lord

both incarnations of our God and they’re

portrayed in blue in order to to

describe detail otherwise if they were

portrayed in black it would be very hard

to show the intricacy of their faces and

this even goes so far to say that

Krishna which is the figure on the right

even means black in Sanskrit and as for

women

the maiden Draupadi from the epic

Mahabharata which is one of our ancient

texts was very dark and was also very

beautiful

so if Hindu texts categorized people but

did not discriminate by any means then

when did this deviation from mutual

respect to loathing dark-skinned happen

turns out that the British were

notorious for imposing their archaic

Victorian ideals upon the Indian people

and constantly reminded their subjects

of the relative significance to their

European rulers and there’s one sign

outside of a European Club in India and

a European club is like a Country Club

in the states in India that the only

prerequisite to get in is that you have

to be white signs like this no dogs or

Indians allowed to make matters worse

there were black towns there were white

towns the British segregated townships

as they did in South Africa and many

other nations probably the worst crime

that they did to Indians amongst the

realm of colorism said they gave lighter

skin the Indians more power and chances

to succeed within the British government

and this led to a disparity but I

revolutionaries like Mahatma Gandhi

toiled day and night to remove caste

discrimination and allowed for an equal

playing field meaning that anybody from

any caste can pursue any profession that

they like but for some reason India

decided to do like a selective rebellion

and did not rebel against all archaic

and wrong principles but for some reason

decided to cling on to color

discrimination and colorism and let’s

see how this color of sentiment has

stayed within the Indian people years

after the British left

so this simple random sample is of men

and women who were asked if they had the

choice to go on a date with a date a

lighter skinned person or not and as you

can clearly see even taking margin of

error into consideration the numbers are

both above 50% showing how instinctively

Indian the majority of the Indian people

think in that having light skin and

being beautiful are synonymous here’s

another graph that shows the same random

sample from before was asked to define

the word beauty and the frequency shown

are the percentages of people who use

the word fair or light-skinned in their

definition and as you can see both men

and women are even taking margin of

error into consideration are both above

the 50% mark and keep in mind how males

are slightly more receptive to having a

light skinned woman then females are two

men just keep that in mind for now I’ll

get to that in this graph here and this

is a very sad and interesting graph um

the person surveying this random sample

marked each survey e on a scale of 1 to

5 in terms of how dark or how light they

were one being very dark five being very

light now they were also asked if Fair

is beautiful and the percentages shown

are the people who say yes and almost

disregarding your color over 50% in each

survey responded that Fair is beautiful

meaning that the people who were dark

skinned

sadly accepted the fact that Fair was

beautiful and could this insinuate that

dark is not beautiful to them possibly

and this is females who know what we’re

asked were they aware of the harms of

bleaching their skin and as you can see

84% are aware and 16% are unaware but

the majority of females did know the

harmful effects of using bleach to

artificially lighten their skin and skin

lightening is a very common practice in

India I showed you this ad I carried

this word no I don’t carry this wherever

I go um I brought this for this

obviously but

I got this from my local Indian grocery

store in the Greater Boston area showing

how it’s even spread around so if we

could just pass that around please

showing that this epidemic is real now

you’ve seen the data you I’ve showed you

some reasons behind colorism in some

examples through the matrimonial ads and

the color discrimination in Indian

culture through that advertisement but

now comes the question how do we fix

this if you’ve been toning out my whole

talk just listen to these few words

colorism is a prejudice and it is deeply

rooted deeply ingrained in the indian

culture it’s like a phyllo pastry has

mouths it’s a multi-layered problem it’s

a result of many other issues that I

didn’t even mention in this talk such as

the education disparity between the rich

and the poor the cultural competency

disparity between metropolitan cities

and backwards villages and even the

rigid roles men and women are supposed

to play in Indian society are all to

blame and I could even give another TED

talk just listing the factors that are

attributed to color discrimination in

India right now again colorism is a

prejudice the Indian people do not need

to learn cultural competency and accept

that fair does not necessarily insinuate

beautiful or that dark is beautiful

because as you can see with this

statistic over here um a lot of people

know what they’re doing is wrong that

bleaching their skin is wrong that

conforming to this white ideal is wrong

but for some reason still decide to do

it it’s an addiction so instead of

learning to accept the Indian people

need to unlearn the years of

institutionalized colorism and the

promotion of falsehood that they have

been under and as you can imagine

unlearning something is much harder than

learning something for instance

anybody who’s tried to quit a bad habit

smoking drinking drugs even biting nails

it’s so hard to stop this almost

instinctive task so we can solve this

but it’s like a tree it’s very deeply

rooted we have to get it it obliquely so

how can we help how can you help

there are many small solutions that need

to be coupled together in order to

defeat colors and color discrimination

and I’ve listed a few of the problems

just before and here I present to you my

small solution and it is one small

solution that needs to be kind of

marched together with plenty of other

solutions to defeat this monumental

problem so let me go back to arranged

marriages for a second

so traditionally in many other cultures

as well the woman does the domestic work

takes care of the kids cleans the house

cooks the food while the man makes the

money and this means that being

beautiful to men has become more

important and to maintain socioeconomic

status because the woman is completely

financially dependent on the man and

keep in mind how men were more receptive

to having light-skinned brides so this

puts a burden on the woman to become as

light-skinned as possible to conform to

beauty standards as much as they can so

how do I say we solve this issue empower

women short answer it make them

financially independent it has worked

beautifully in cities and more and more

women joined the indian workforce and

powers and numbers over 1 billion people

the workforce is growing day by day so

how can you help sitting at Deerfield

Academy we can donate or volunteer to

organizations such as care called vidi

ala and c1 which is the self employment

Women’s Association and these are all

organizations that toil day and night to

increase education in India increase

awareness in India and also provide

infrastructure for women to operate

businesses in India and what this will

do especially in the rural parts is help

women become financially independent and

by you know donating volunteering and

even perhaps even working at

organizations like these we can

hopefully one day make it such that an

Indian woman’s socioeconomic status has

no correlation at all to the color of

her skin and literally a call Videla can

support what one Indian child’s

education for literally a dollar a day

so next time you want to buy a coffee at

Cumberland Farms redirect that dollar to

a call vidi ala one more day of

education for a child one step closer to

defeating colorism

such a deeply rooted issue we should get

started out now before it gets worse so

now that you know how to solve it

slightly I’m gonna end this on a

personal note so I have a big family

and what big families comes a lot of

births and about two years ago my I

guess she’s the toddler now cousin Lila

was born about six months ago my baby

cousin Annika was born and look they’re

so cute Annika is on there on your left

and Lila’s on the right and about two

weeks ago my baby cousin Amara was born

so you know I have so many new cousins

now and Amara was named after my

great-grandmother who’s unfortunately no

longer with us today but she was loving

independent driven feisty and she was

also very dark and regardless of how

dark these babies these my beautiful

baby cousins turn out to be I want to

guarantee their fair shot at success and

to a certain extent make the color of

their skin irrelevant relative to their

siblings relative to the rest of the

people and hopefully one day my cousins

will not only be able to appreciate

their true skin color but the Greater

Indian population will be able to

realize that the in will be able to

realize that they should be able to see

through the insignificant pigment of the

membrane covering our bodies and instead

appreciate what truly is on the inside

and with that thank you for your time [Applause]

Please follow and like us: