Press "Enter" to skip to content

Failing Upwards: Science Learns by Making Mistakes. | Phil Plait | TEDxBoulder


have you ever made a really dumb mistake
now I don’t mean like going to the store
and coming home and then realizing you
forgot to buy something I mean something
big something consequential something
that affected other people something
that was embarrassing
well did you admit it and did you
apologize and most importantly did you
change your way of thinking so you
wouldn’t make that same mistake again
well I have a secret for you that really
shouldn’t be a secret science does this
all the time it is the very essence of
science now people have a lot of
misconceptions about science about how
it works and what it is a big one is
that science is just a big old pile of
facts but that’s not true that’s not
even the goal of science science is a
process it’s a way of thinking gathering
facts is just a piece of it but it’s not
the goal the ultimate goal of science is
to understand objective reality the best
way we know how and that’s based on
evidence and the problem here is that
people are flawed we can be fooled we’re
really good at fooling ourselves and so
baked into this process is a way of
minimizing our own bias so sort of boil
down more than is probably useful here’s
how this works
if you want to do some science what you
want to do is you want to observe
something say the sky is blue hey I
wonder why you question it the next
thing you do is you come up with an idea
that may explain it a hypothesis well
you know what
oceans are blue maybe the sky is
reflecting the colors from the ocean
great but now you have to test it so you
predict what that might mean your
prediction would be well if the sky is
reflecting the ocean color it’ll be
bluer on the coasts than it will be in
the middle of the country okay
that’s fair enough but you got to test
that prediction so you get on a plane
you leave Denver on a nice gray day you
fly to LA you look up and the sky is
we blew hooray your thesis is proven but
is it really know you’ve made one
observation you need to think about your
hypothesis think about how to test it
and do more than just one maybe you
could go to a different part of the
country or a different part of the year
and see what the weather is like that
another good idea is to talk to other
people they have different ideas
different perspectives and they can help
you this is what we call peer review and
in fact that will probably also save you
a lot of money and a lot of time flying
coast to coast just to check the weather
now what happens if your hypothesis does
a decent job but not a perfect job well
that’s okay because what you can do is
you can modify a little bit and then go
through this whole process again make
predictions test them and do that and as
you do that over and over again you will
hone this idea and if it gets good
enough it may be accepted by the
scientific community at least
provisionally as a good explanation of
what’s going on at least until a better
idea or some contradictory evidence
comes along now part of this process is
admitting when you’re wrong and that can
be really really hard science has its
strengths and weaknesses and they depend
on this and one of the strengths of
science is that it’s done by people and
it’s proven itself to do a really good
job where we understand the universe
pretty well because of science one of
Sciences weaknesses is that it’s done by
people and we bring a lot of baggage
along with us when we investigate things
we are egotistical we are stubborn we’re
superstitious we’re tribal
we’re humans these are all human traits
and scientists are humans and so we have
to be aware of that when we’re studying
science and when we’re trying to develop
our theses but part of this whole thing
part of the scientific process part of
the scientific method is admitting when
you’re wrong and the thing is science
scientists are human we have all those
same traits as every other human and
when you have a cool idea giving it up
is really really hard
I know I’ve been there many years ago I
was working on Hubble Space Telescope
and a scientist I worked with came to me
with some data and he said I think there
may be a picture of a planet orbiting
another star in this data we have not
had any pictures taken of a planets
orbiting other stars yet so if this were
true then this would be the first one
and we would be the ones who found it
that’s a big deal I was very excited so
I just dug right into this data I spent
a long time trying to figure out if this
thing were planted or not the problem is
planets are faint and stars are bright
so trying to get the signal out of this
data was like trying to hear a whisper
in a in a heavy metal concert it was
really hard I tried everything I could
but after a month of working on this I
came to a realization couldn’t do it I
had to give up and I had to tell this
other scientist the date is too messy we
can’t say whether this is a planet or
not and that was hard
then later on we got follow-up
observations with Hubble and it showed
that it wasn’t a planet was a background
star a galaxies something like that well
let’s get too technical but that sucked
I was really unhappy about this but
that’s part of it you have to it you
have to say look you know we can’t do
this with the data we have and then I
had to face up to the fact that even the
follow-up data showed we were wrong
emotionally I was pretty unhappy but if
a scientist is doing their job correctly
being wrong is not so bad
because that means there’s still more
stuff out there more things to figure
out scientists don’t love being wrong
but we love puzzles and the universe is
the biggest puzzle of them all now
having said that if you have a piece and
it doesn’t fit no matter how you move it
jamming it in harder isn’t gonna help
there gonna be a time where you have to
let go of your idea if you want to
understand the bigger picture the price
of doing science is admitting when
you’re wrong
but the payoff is the best there is
knowledge and understanding and I can
give you a thousand examples of this in
science but there’s one I really like it
has to do with astronomy and it was a
question that had been plaguing
astronomers literally for centuries when
you look at the Sun it seems special it
is the brightest object in the sky but
having studied astronomy physics
chemistry thermodynamics for centuries
we learn something very important about
it it’s not that special it’s a star
just like millions of other stars but
that raises an interesting question if
the Sun is a star and the Sun has
planets do these other stars have
planets well like I said with my own
failure in the planet I was looking for
finding them is super hard but
scientists tend to be pretty clever
people and they used a lot of different
techniques and started observing stars
and over the decades they started
finding some things that were pretty
interesting very edge of what they were
able to detect but time and again it was
shown to be wrong that all changed in
1991 a couple of astronomers and rulin
and Matthew bales had a huge
announcement they had found a planet
orbiting another star and not just any
star but a pulsar and this is the
remnant of a star that has previously
exploded is blasting out radiation this
is the last place in the universe you
would expect to find a planet but they
had very methodically looked at this
pulsar and they’ve detected the
gravitational tug of this planet as it
orbited the Pulsar it looked really good
the first planet orbiting another star
had been found except not so much after
they made the announcement a bunch of
other astronomers commented on it and so
they went back and looked at their data
and realized they had made a very
embarrassing mistake they had not
accounted for some very subtle
characteristics of the Earth’s motion
around the Sun which affected how they
measured this planet going around the
Pulsar and it turns out that when they
did account for it correctly
poof their planet disappeared what in
real so Andrew Lyne had a very
formidable task he had to admit
so in 1992 at the American Astronomical
Society meeting which is one of the
largest gatherings of astronomers on the
planet he stood up and announced that he
had made a mistake and that the planet
did not exist and what happens next
oh I love this what happened next was
wonderful
he got an ovation the astronomers
weren’t angry at him didn’t want to
chastise him they praised him for his
honesty and his integrity scientists are
people it gets better
Lin steps off the podium the next guy to
come up as a man named Alexander
volscian he takes the microphone and
says yeah so Lin’s team didn’t find a
pulse our planet but my team found not
just one but two planets orbiting at
different pulsar we knew about the
problem that Lyn had we checked for it
and yeah ours are real and it turns out
he was right and in fact a few months
later they found a third planet orbiting
this pulsar and it was the first
exoplanet system ever found what we call
alien worlds exoplanets that to me is is
just wonderful at that point the
floodgates were opened in 1995 a planet
was found around a star more like the
Sun and then we found another and
another this is an image of an actual
planet orbiting an actual star we kept
getting better at it we started finding
them by the bucketload we started
finding thousands of them we built
Observatory specifically designed to
look for them and now we know a
thousands of them we even know of
planetary systems that is actual data
animated showing four planets orbiting
another star this is incredible think
about that for all of human history you
could count all the known planets in the
universe on two hands nine eight nine
but now we know they’re everywhere every
star for every star you’ve seen the sky
there could be three five ten planets
the sky is filled with them we think
that planets may outnumber stars in the
galaxy this is a profound statement and
it was made because of science and it
wasn’t made just because of science and
the observatories in the data it was
made because of the scientists who built
the observatories who took the data who
made the mistakes and admit admitted
them and then let other science
scientists build on their mistakes so
that they could do what they do and
figure out where are places in the
universe that is how you find the truth
science is at its best when it dares to
be human thank you [Applause]
Please follow and like us: