Press "Enter" to skip to content

“Engineering Diversity” | Ellen Simmons | TEDxUniversityofGlasgow


so last year around about this time some

members of femen’s decided to plant some

small little facts around about the

engineering buildings on campus one of

these particular facts noted that only

9% of the UK workforce in engineering

were females and I came across this

again quite recently there’s still not

been taken down but I found a small

piece of vandalism and this person had

written this and I don’t feel that it’s

something meaningless because it

actually portrays a frustration that I

have felt by a number of my peers in

engineering because they see these facts

and they understand that people are

bothered but they don’t feel it

themselves they don’t experience sexism

in their everyday lives as engineering

students and especially the girls they

don’t feel as if they’re being

disempowered by any sort of system or by

their male student friends so this is a

problem because there is obviously an

issue but people don’t see it for

themselves and they don’t really

understand why it’s an issue for the

world so today I really don’t want to

dismantle this particular discussion

because it’s quite complicated it’s

quite sensitive but what I would really

like to discuss is ways that we can work

towards making a more diverse workforce

and why I believe that’s really

important especially in engineering a

lot of companies right now are working

on initiatives that enable them to have

more women coming into their workforces

some of you may know the term positive

discrimination a positive action and in

some cases this is heralded as a great

way to get women into companies but this

isn’t always the best way to do this and

I’ll illustrate this with a little story

about myself so this year well last year

I won my first ever trophy and this is a

really big deal as a big shiny trophy

and I had got that because I had applied

myself I had told them about the things

I had done and that I was passionate

about and I felt so proud of myself when

I got that award and it was a big

ceremony and I remember standing up in

front of all those people and they were

all clapping and then just before we

left the person who was speaking on the

microphone said as you can see all the

award winners today were women so no one

can say we’re not doing our bit and so

that really changed the nature of what

that award meant for me because it went

from being something I had earned

because I deserved it to being something

that these this organization had decided

to give me as a sort of pat on the back

there you go isn’t that nice of us to

give you that and so this isn’t a very

helpful thing I find that so upsetting

so how can we look at different ways to

try and address the issues that women

are saying hold them back but do it in a

way that’s not going to cause them to be

devalued in their workplaces so if we

think about what engineers do their

designers their creators they make

everything from the tray that you’re

sitting on the phone that you’re

pretending you’re not looking at and

maybe the instilling pen that you had to

use at lunchtime okay so who does that

cover you can’t limit that to one

particular demographic we have such a

diverse world population you know it’s

Half Men half women 10% lgbtq+ and why

is that not represented in the people

that are making all these objects that

we use every day so not even just this

aspect of it is important because

there’s statistics to back this up this

economic data for instance if you look

through the Harvard Business Review

there’s so many studies done into the

effects of gender and racial diversity

in the workplace and one particular

study that

stood out for me was from Credit Suisse

and they found that when they assessed

over 2000 companies the ones that had

one woman on the board as opposed to

none and more women always had higher

financial returns they had higher net

growth and if you think about it

non-homogeneous teams should be smarter

and there’s so much interesting facts

about this that I really encourage you

to go and look at and so reading them it

really did make sense for me that this

is a good thing that diversity is

important so how can we apply that what

can we do to create more diverse

workplaces so I’ll tell you about myself

and how I got into engineering

so from quite a young age I was quite

interested in biology I was like very

into medicine and I thought that’s the

route I’m gonna take and you know I

thought I was smart enough I could get

in no problem but then at age 13 I was

fit with a devastating blow where I

couldn’t take biology from my standard

grades and the only option I could take

was physics and I was very upset about

this and made very big fuss but as you

can imagine a 13 year old making a big

fuss about having to take biology

standard grade isn’t going to make much

of a change to the school so I ended up

having to take physics however this

turned out to be a very impactful

turning point in my life because it

turned out that actually I was quite

good at physics and I quite liked

physics I had an extremely encouraging

teacher who made sure that everyone in

that class felt very valued and

encouraged all of them even the ones

that clearly were struggling and

probably wouldn’t progress with it so

then I suddenly had to incorporate

physics into my idea of what I was

interested in and then you come to your

fifth year which in Scotland is the most

important year for getting into

University and I ended up being one of

the best in the class for our math and

that really surprised me I never thought

I fit into the very very top category of

maths so then I was having a lot of

turmoil because I really really loved

physics and math suddenly and I realized

that I didn’t really want to leave them

behind

but how could I still pursue my

interests in medicine and human biology

with that in mind so spent a long time

thinking about it trying to talk to

people and it wasn’t until one day my

dad got an email from his university

about this mysterious new subject called

biomedical engineering and the minute I

heard it I just thought that’s it that’s

exactly what I need to do I didn’t

really know what it was but I just knew

that fit what I was interested in and

sure enough it did and I’m so thankful

that that email came at that time and

that I was forced to take that physics

class but isn’t it just so sad that

that’s what my future was depending on

my future was depending on an awkward

timetable and a difficult guidance

teacher and eventually dependent on a

random email my dad’s very very full

inbox so really there’s an issue here

because my entire life after that point

would have been very very different had

those things not fallen into place and

I’m not an exception here because this

is very true for so many of my friends

who are girls and engineering they came

into it because either their dad was an

engineer or because they stumbled upon

it when they were looking for the other

subject that they thought they were

supposed to do and it’s not necessarily

that if I had done medicine I would

never have achieved something good but

maybe it wasn’t the best thing for me

and I didn’t know what else I could have

found so this is something that is

really important and we need to make

sure that this isn’t going to happen to

any other girls in the future or boys so

the FEMEN Society was started in 2013 a

bunch of naive first-years all gathered

together and we just thought we want to

do something girly for the girls

we’ll have bake sales and I don’t know

make a calendar or something and just

bring all the all the sort of lone women

in the different engineering courses

together and we thought that’s what they

need it we thought that will help them

that will make them feel happy and will

encourage more people to come to

engineering because they see that they

can still have a great social life with

women in engine

but actually we ended up getting a bit

more interest from school teachers than

we did from other female students and it

turned out that the teachers also

recognized that there was a gap in their

education in terms of the careers

guidance they really wanted to have

women in engineering coming to their

school because they felt that we could

offer something very valuable as being

role models so this became quite a

common theme we would go to school

events we would round up different

disciplines and we would go and

demonstrate something or just talk to

school children but then as ferment

evolved we realized that actually it

wasn’t just school children that needed

role models that actually university

students really wanted role models as

well and it doesn’t stop the minute that

you come to university so we started

holding events where we got alumni in

and we would have recent graduates come

and they would just talk about their

experience at Glasgow uni and then how

they got into the career that they are

in and maybe the issues they had along

the way or the fact that they had no

issues which was very common and that

was great to hear other women say

actually I had no problem I didn’t

experience any discrimination and that

means that maybe for you this won’t be

an issue either and that in itself was

quite empowering and then again this

year we recently launched a mentoring

scheme because we realized that there’s

such a plethora of information held in

the people who are in the higher levels

of these degrees so we linked out 4th

and 5th years with first and second

years and their discipline and this is

something that we’ve got the guys in our

course to engage with as well so it’s

not just women are like talking to women

it’s boys talking to women and all these

different mixtures of personalities and

people but the whole point is we’re

saying there needs to be more

information exchange from the upper

levels at every stage of your career so

another issue that you may have heard

about about why women feel that they

can’t really progress in engineering

industry is because they’re not given

challenging enough jobs they’re not

given the opportunity to really

demonstrate their skill

and sure what they can do so my salt a

couple of years ago how could we make a

really big high-profile project that

just showed off what women in

engineering could do on their own

hence famines in Rwanda okay so

basically what this was the idea is that

we were going to collaborate with the

University of Rwanda and we were going

to try and help them to see where they

could use some of what fermenters done

in the University of Glasgow and could

that be helpful for them and hopefully

learn something interesting along the

way as well

what this turned into was three weeks

spent in the capital city of Rwanda we

worked with a group of students all

female students from the College of

Science and Technology in the University

of Rwanda and we also worked with eight

high school graduates from various high

schools around Rwanda as well and what

we did was we split into groups we made

eight different workshops demonstrating

engineering concepts everything from

low-cost Diagnostics to water control to

renewable energy and what we did was we

we then went to schools or we had

schools come and visit us at the

University and then we showed them what

engineering really was we would give

them a small presentation and we would

tell them this is aerospace engineering

and these are the subjects you need to

study in order to go there and this is

the career that you could have

afterwards and that information in

itself is something that they all really

wanted to tell but then we also gave

them the chance to experience that

engineering mind for themselves we gave

them design problems we showed them a

blind person going around a supermarket

trying to figure out the prices of the

foods and we asked them to design

something out of cardboard and foil and

it was incredible what these outputs

were and we were all blown away by the

enthusiasm and the confidence that these

girls had and it was really reassuring

because we thought maybe this is it

maybe this is all that you need

do all you need to do is just show them

what engineering is give them some

information and then let them get on

with it and if that’s what they want to

do then they will have nothing in their

past stopping them from doing it and

that was achieved bear in mind we saw

only we saw over five hundred

schoolgirls in those three weeks that

was with only two hours maximum with

each group of skilled children and one

week of preparation and we managed to

make almost all of them say afterwards

that they wanted to be engineers okay

and whether that was just to make us

feel happy or not we don’t know

but the point is that that wasn’t so

much effort to just give them that

little bit of insight into their future

and that could be life-changing for some

of them and in terms of the students who

were involved in this they gained a

really valuable life experience as well

because not only are they planning a

project raising money talking to

companies talking at the Scottish

Parliament about this but they’re also

getting to demonstrate that they’re

experts in something that they are

valued and they’re disciplined enough

that they can talk to children from

another country about it and have an

impact and that’s so important

especially for girls who are maybe in

the earlier stages of their career to

really feel that ownership over their

work and their skills so what this leads

to I believe is that we’re just gonna

eliminate that obstacle that obstacle of

women feeling like there is nothing

holding them back just because they’re

women and ultimately I think that’s the

key thing we need to do just show them

that they can do it show them that we

doing it show them that other people

have done it and I think that will

really solve a lot of the issues that we

have so just thinking about what I’m

saying today first of all in terms of

your workplace the societies you’re a

part of your project teams at work I

know things that are potentially holding

it back from being as diverse a

workplace as it could be do you have

unconscious biases that are potentially

getting in the way of you having a more

diverse team

and I myself have unconscious biases oh

I will maybe initially prefer to have

someone on a team with me because I feel

that they relate to me more but that’s

not actually the key to progression I

don’t believe so maybe think about that

for yourself and in terms of your

children I know that maybe right now the

little girls in your life might all want

to be princesses okay but that does not

mean that that is it and that does not

mean that she’s not capable of doing

something completely at the other end of

the scale in her later life I still want

to be a princess but I’m very very happy

that I’m an engineer so just think about

changing these attitudes and giving this

education in the earliest stages what

this could do for the world thank you [Applause]

Please follow and like us: