Press "Enter" to skip to content

Empathy, not MBAs | Jessica Graf | TEDxHSG


good morning everyone I like to start a

talk we’re telling you that one in three

people on this planet do not have decent

toilet this is not something you

probably think of when you wake up in

the morning which I can tell you it’s a

very very big deal because not having a

toilet means getting dairy away more

often and diarrhea kills it kills in

particular small children in fact half a

million small children die of diarrhea

every year the answer is never simple

the answer is like let’s get them

talking that’s right it’s so easy and

yet it doesn’t happen it doesn’t happen

at all so you’re wondering of yourself

like what is so difficult about it and

why don’t they buy toilets well last

time I asked this question he was in

Tajikistan a few weeks ago despite my

belly and this man his children his

grandchildren none of them had seen

running water or toilet and I asked him

imagine for a second you had all the

money you wanted to invest into a

bathroom what would you buy and guess

what the answer was

for sure he wasn’t toilet it was this I

like ba ba ba woo like with the dark and

the lady insider you know like and you

wondering what is wrong we did you know

with him you know like he needs a toilet

right that’s the answer has something to

do with these right this is what we’re

trying to sell him and the picture

doesn’t look pretty but I can tell you

that this is by development standard

considered as an improved sanitation and

guess what he says when we try to sell

him that stuff

he says oh it’s too expensive I don’t

have the money come home right and

you’re like whoa wait I just saw a

motorbike can you quarter and I saw TV

in the living room and I saw a couple of

mobile phones don’t tell me you don’t

have the money right and so you’re

wondering what what is he really trying

to tell me well it’s not so difficult to

imagine anyone in this room would just

think like these old men let me

challenge you imagine you don’t have

enough money to sell everything you want

to buy everything you want on this

planet I’m sure it concerns most of us

right so when was last time you saw that

little pretty dress or the last iPhone

whatever you dream of these days right

and you don’t have enough money to pay

you’re going to start saving something

on something when I was a student I

saved on food to pay my trips and I

could eat pasta we own weeks weeks weeks

of path cheapest I could find in me grow

right and my mom would go crazy she’s

like vegetables what’s wrong with you

you think I was you know disturbed but

where I was then not at all

did I ever regret these broccolis never

right would I do the same again probably

so what I’m what I’m trying to say is

that when people tell you it’s too

expensive

they probably tell you it’s something

else in my career I figured out that

probably what they tell you when they

tell you it’s too expensive Street

things I do not value the stuff you’re

trying to sell me I do not trust you or

I do not need what you say what you’re

selling me and let me give you a few

concrete examples about what I mean

first on value do you know that the

recycle clothes is sent to charity in

Europe or to Africa or wherever are not

appreciated at all in fact most of this

clothes end up to mop the floors

seriously you might find this shocking

thinking I’m like

these are poor people we sent him all

these clothes and they don’t appreciate

it well just a pack a second imagine

you’re in vest invited to a birthday a

good friend of yours and a new closet

you have this nice dress you never worn

it because not quite your size but it

would fit her perfectly would some of

you recycle that dress as a gift perhaps

some of you would fare that matter right

but you would not tell your friend this

is a recycle gift right I don’t need to

explain to nobody why your friend would

feel upset well why poor people should

feel any different just because you have

poor not really right and so let me give

you an exact very cool example of people

who crack this problem what they did is

they organized the lottery so they’re

organized these nice little event sold

the tickets not for free sold the

lottery tickets now everybody comes in

and one of the biggest prices is that

huge bundle of clothes right I can tell

you that the winner of this bundle feels

lucky when he wins it because first is

truly lucky you want it and nobody else

right

and he wants something that everybody

else in the room had paid for to try to

win right so the issue is not about how

cheap or free we make this close but

issue is whether people value or not

what we give them second problem trust

right this is a problem that comes again

again and to illustrate this point let

me bring you to Africa and to one of my

preferred entrepreneur who is trying to

commercialize efficient cookstoves for

those who don’t know efficient

cookstoves are you know cooking devices

that burn way less fuel and generate way

less smoke why is it important well

because we chopping trees like crazy and

millions of people are dying out of

respiratory diseases every year

including moms and kids right and this

is the story tells when you try to

first-time commercializes cook stove

he arrives in the first village makes

the bestseller speech in the universe

very African and then nobody wants to

buy and the answer is like too expensive

it’s three dollars more than that the

market and you know I just bought one it

doesn’t look so sexy it looks like the

stuff I have at home and what kind of

buying stuff is like okay ladies who is

the best to cooking ladies in the

village so big discussion picks up chief

gets them cooking the same recipe just

one you know two piles of charcoal

heathe cook stove they cooks down at the

end the result is very obvious you know

the food tastes the same everybody

enjoys but one pile of charcoal is high

one pile of charcoal is low it’s like no

now you see what I’m trying to tell you

who buys only one lady the one who

cooked them is cook stove okay I’m gonna

do your favor I’m gonna leave ten cook

stoves here right I come back in a month

only one condition all the money you

spend on charcoal you put into that you

know team guinea pig bank don’t touch it

I come back in a month

it comes back gathers everybody opens a

team is full of dollars right even the

ladies who had been saving us surprised

by how much money there is he’s asking

now who is buying my cook stove guess

what only the 10 ladies who could test

it stops nobody else and he was like oh

okay so let me give this deal to

everybody in the village you can keep

the cook stoves for one month on trial

right but it will be more expensive then

50 more percent more expensive guess who

went for that deal everybody there’s not

some crazy to you the same people who

were trying at the big selling at the

beginning oh it’s too expensive these

same people are now ready to pay even

more right and how do you explain that

well my grandparents who wear modest

people could very well explain that they

would say they are too poor to afford

something cheap what does that mean it

means that when you have little money

you cannot get it wrong because you know

if that product is not working you don’t

have money to buy the next one and this

is exactly what the ladies were thinking

they have been fooled over many times by

people coming and sell stuff to their

village and then disappearing in nature

right so when they say it’s too

expensive they don’t it’s not doesn’t

mean that your products too expensive it

just means they don’t trust you and this

is actually the picture of the cooking

exercise third problem a bit more

difficult but is like people tell you

that it’s not what they need but you

what you offering them is not solving

the problem and for these let me fly you

to Bogota city beautiful city thriving

but there is a lot of youth and

employment right a lot of people are

trying to fix the problem including the

state’s pumping billions into building

training centers and so on and you know

the answer you get from the parents and

the kids when you ask them why don’t you

send them for further training so they

can find a decent job oh we cannot

afford sending our kids to school no

more you know like and you’re wondering

what’s wrong with these parents right

ready to ready to screw the future of

the kids just for money and then I have

seen the solution though the solution is

another enterpreneur a Colombian doctor

who try who set up a series of training

centers and B’s work why did his work

because first he didn’t build them in

the center of Bogota City he built them

in the suburbs where these kids live so

they don’t have to do three hours of

commute into work or a city every day

second thing he acknowledged the fact

that they would never leave they you

know whatever day job or night job to

come and study so the study hours are

completely flexible 24/7 last thing he

did he made it bang not free like the

public safe system in many pain but you

know not six month of from tuition fee

rather say you pay me when you

have a bit of cash every week or so

everybody pays him on time or more less

right the kids find a job within three

months and the double the salary so the

solutions exist when the bottom line is

the solution exists but we keep doing

the wrong stuff even when we have the

solutions in front of our eyes

and for me one of the most striking

example of that is one we see you me

every day here I hope that everyone in

the room recognize that this picture is

known about American what about

cigarettes

hint hint and so I think this is about

the smartest advertising campaign ever

created last century it wicks old and

young you know richer richer poor it

makes you buy one of the most harmful

and use this product every day again and

again and it makes actually hard to quit

because quitting would mean to leave

behind a bit of that ideal right of

freedom of having it on its own terms

and this is a beautiful example of

something that works so my questions

like why can’t we do the same to sell

they’re useful and life-changing stuff

and when you think about it it’s like in

the empty smoke people I’m and one of

them the Andes mph you know even despite

having the right example in front of the

ants what what kind of campaign do they

design they put you you know lung cancer

pictures from the pockets and do a

cowboy here one picture you know lung

cancer pitch no should a cowboy care but

you know what why so accident he or she

will die off no that’s not what couples

do right so you’re not putting a picture

of lung cancer on a packet is something

similar as to trying to selling

cigarettes by saying our cigarettes are

ten cents cheaper they last longer in

the mouth there

made of organic tomato tobacco and they

kill a bit less right

would you sell a serum with such an

argument so my question is like what is

wrong with us when the answers are so

obvious and I think it’s good news

because the answer is very very simple

with all due respect we don’t need more

MBAs

we don’t need PhDs in engineering

what we need is actually just a bit of

empathy and imagination and recognize

oneself your friends your grandfather’s

your family into this old Paget man into

these African mama into these Colombian

student and also acknowledge that poor

people don’t need to be told or

explained or lectured about what is good

for them because nobody likes that right

but any am I thinking empty is the

easiest thing well I’m afraid it’s not I

struggled for a long long time and just

Eureka my life story

I was lying spending eight years looking

at the world

Santa’s problems working for developing

development institutions in very very

exotic places and trying very very hard

to save the world then I grew grew a bit

frustrated I went to private sector did

an MBA did Mackenzie did investment

finance and the day I decided I would

put my brains to work to solve the world

toughest problems I was thinking yeah

it’s easy come on I’ve done so many

things in my life

come on selling these beautiful products

you know selling the cookstove selling

toilet easy peasy

what not really I did all the mistakes I

was mentioning before and actually I

realized that the more I was trying to

learn to you know to apply what I

learned at b-school what McKinsey like

the perfect you know marketing framework

the perfect

market survey or whatever you name it

the more I was getting it wrong the more

was trying to apply precooked recipe the

more off I was right and it took me

actually 20 years to realize that I

should forget about all these and

instead do one thing which is imagine

this when you’re confronting such

problem and when you with these people

there’s just three things you need to do

take a white page stop look and listen

thank you [Applause]

Please follow and like us: