Press "Enter" to skip to content

Embracing Robots – How robot stories shape visions of technology | Jeanine Reutemann | TEDxLausanne


you think smart robots will one day
exterminate the human race
this is often one of the first questions
I ask my students when I teach about
media technology storytelling and robots
in movies often health of the group
raise their hands when I further ask why
they come to this conclusion they
immediately start to reference to movies
such as The Terminator or contemporary
series like like Mero some even refer to
the matrix scenario and suggest that the
apocalypse already happened and we are
unknowingly in the matrix while our
bodies are producing energy for smart
robots isn’t it sometime impressing that
stories about us which are impossible
that we can create energy i’ve even
thinkable for them well i think there
must be more to the effects of movies
and us than actually pure consumption as
a passionate and a critical researcher i
investigate the impact of technology on
our society at the lighten university
center for innovation and i’m also a
filmmaker myself so obviously all
everything at you is about moving images
and i love it
so and today today I want to explore
with you on how artificial intelligent
robots are shaping a vision of the
future and why this matters but first do
movies really influence on what we
believe or about be fear please have a
look at this historic clown it’s
fantastic isn’t it well when I run an
image search in 2018 about clowns this
is actually about Google through up
please definitely close look amazing
isn’t it
so our digital collective image of
clowns seems to have changed with
penalized from the movie it and probably
penny wise is not even the worst clown
here on the slide so yes we have
empirical evidence that movies can evoke
strong emotions and massive reactions in
US and today these geniuses of
filmmaking certainly ride on the
shoulder of amazing film science with
the fundamental knowledge and intuition
on how to tell immersive stories they
can make basically millions of people
afraid of robots but how did robots
became such a dominant part in science
fiction movies let us tell forbidden to
the palace furnace during the
industrialization there was big fear for
technological development the various
uprising against automatic weaving
machines most famously by the latest in
England so they initiated really big out
risings against them automatization and
robots will take our jobs yes sounds
familiar doesn’t it well the thing is
some say we are experiencing right at
this very moment the fourth Industrial
Revolution but if robots do all these
very terribly boring jobs for us why is
our vision of them in the future often
so dark and dystopian in storytelling
basically nothing gets the blood pumping
like fear and science fiction movies
draw on this emotion a lot and hand in
hand with fear we also have this deep
fascination of the unknown let me give
you an example for this the Jewish
character column can be seen as an
intercessor of robots it can be a
villain or a victim it can be a man or
woman or both at the same time the gun
can be activated by writing truth on its
forehead Emmet
and they can be deactivated again when
removing the in letter by changing the
inscription from truth to death the
various other characters in history like
the Greek tell us from Hephaestus or
Frankenstein or Maria from the movie
metropolis from 1927
so this cultural memory still influences
contemporary characters like the
Lawrence from vest world but cultural
memory is not just stories it also
influences us on how we see a real
robots in the real world so what exactly
do movies influenced us about let’s take
a look at this well in a majority of
narratives after a flourishing period of
peace and prosperity future societies
collapse into an end time dystopian
scenario rabbits initially magical
beings relieve us from redundant work
they’re here for our pleasures but as
soon as they reach a self-conscious
state they turn evil and rise against
humanity in this metamorphosis
filmmakers often make use of the so
called uncanny valley effect and show
them very terrifying
so the basic message is although we all
first believe that robots are here for
our own good in the near future devil
actually turn against us and kill us all
so I think there may be an underlying
problem there which has to do with the
power relation the word robot was first
coined in 1923 by Carl chap back in his
famous Blake are you are rust Sims
Universal robots the word rubber comes
from the Czech word robota
which means forced labor so this story
of our yard affects the classical power
relation between robots and humans where
robots are enslaved by the human masters
many examples in art and literature they
picked up our relation between robot and
human which are biased by the archaic
pattern we know from human to human
socio-economic
patterns the master/slave relationship
so our cruelty to each other is
projected unto a technology which
fundamentally differs from human
intelligence needs or motivation even
the fantastic and philosophically deep
movie ex machina ends in a fight and
spoiler alert sorry for that I’m Eva the
main character frees herself from
slavery but in this unique example we
feel that she has the right to do so so
while modern saris stretch this
narration over several episodes or even
seasons the main arc often stays the
same and if we believe in the stories
we’ve been told a clash between robot
and humans is inevitable but are we
really telling the stories of a future
we want to live in if we humans create
robots in our own image and enslave them
is it really so surprising that they
will rise against us but among us humans
who exactly are those creators maybe the
sample there are some in the room here I
don’t know interestingly movies also
show another conspicuous analogy to our
current tech world robots are often
created by hashtag evil corporations
today’s questionable power of
cooperation is reflected in the Society
of the future are really robots killing
us or is it maybe the hashtag late stage
capitalism well ok this negative
perception of robots is not a human
Universal historically the idea of
robots originated in various
methodologies around the world but today
only few of us appreciate the souls in
everything yet animism considered be one
of the proto religions of our species
would find in natural that robots are
actually capable of hosting their own
selves so maybe robots are intended as
well by the beauty of the world bitches
don’t know
the mechanical puppets are very close
relatives from robots for example the
category ninja category means in
Japanese Akane Tate’s as well trick to Z
for illusion as these puppets imitate to
be alive some of them were actually made
to take part in tea ceremonies so they
were rather seen as helpmates friends or
sometimes even equals the very famous
anime character the robot Tetsu vana
Domo had a clear impact on the real
development of Japanese robots when the
integration of the famous as in a robot
when they started the production they
asked wouldn’t we like to have a robot
like Tetsu and Tomo
so we have to keep in mind and science
fiction stories can be really an
inspiration for girls as well so vile
real robots are taking more
responsibility across our human
experience we need to really reflect on
how we gonna integrate approach and
somehow think about them
so should we really fear AI robots or
not this is the general question out
there everybody asks let me give an
answer from my own perspective the thing
is the following
well the debate of killer robots has
reached the United Nations level where
lethal autonomous weapon systems have
become a major negotiation stream and
this is crucial
yes but fear will not help us in
understanding and highly complex
technology rather it clouds our reunit
completely you should definitely fear
this animal very cute honey vector
because it’s very aggressive but in
contrast to what movies want us to
believe neither shooting with big guns
fighting with your bare hands or
plugging out the cable will be smart
strategies to deal with AI robots so we
should maybe try to avoid this what can
we do then well let’s start with this
movies communicate in a different
language we need to learn how these
movies
works that we can understand how what
can effect effect they have on us so we
need to learn to read movies the same
way as we need to learn to analyze texts
basically there is a subconscious
influence coming from the movies we
watch it is and our thoughts impact our
actions hand sense fiction not only
speculates about the future but also
shapes it and we can assume there will
be a day for coming pretty soon when we
need to collectively decide on what the
lawmakers called today electronic
persons understanding where our fears
concern and visions come from is
therefore crucial for us as citizens of
the world so maybe we can we can’t do
anything against the advancements of
robots it’s gonna happen one day yet we
may be able to stir it into another
direction then enslaved robots
controlled by their human masters under
the control of evil corporations are
often told in science-fiction movies
today AI is being the loft both behind
closed doors in corporations which
recently gave it up on not being evil
and out in the open as foundations
universities and github we need to start
spreading positive and scientific
positive and Otto pian stories about the
future as well
there evil corporations were really
overcome and decentralized so maybe one
way is really to tell more stories of a
future with robots in which we really
want to live in
[Applause]
you [Applause]
Please follow and like us: