Press "Enter" to skip to content

Electoral Dysfunction and Reform | Elizabeth May | TEDxStanleyPark


I want to start by acknowledging with
gratitude I stand here on the
traditional unceded territory of in la
scream Squamish and slay with his
amid all the fun exciting and emotional
talks you’re going to hear today I get
to tell you about voting systems how
they work how they sometimes don’t work
the perennial Canadian problem of
electoral dysfunction there someday will
be a drug in the meantime we have it in
our hands to fix our broken voting
system but first we need to understand
it so one of the things I want to share
with you is that it’s really easy to
vote using almost any voting system you
can think of but people who use that
voting system often find it hard to
explain the system they’re used to I
discovered this when I was on the
special parliamentary committee on
electoral reform and forum research came
to us to tell us that they had polled
Canadians to find out if we even knew
the name of the system we’re using now
they made it easy they actually created
a multiple choice list and went out to
find out could Canadians pick from a
list you know you’ve got to let your
preferential voting proportion
representation or first-past-the-post I
was actually quite surprised to find
that most Canadians couldn’t properly
name the system we’re using from a
multiple choice question only 40 percent
could and 40 percent saw that it was
first-past-the-post also probably
couldn’t explain how it worked exactly
because any voting system can be
complicated to explain even if it’s easy
to use for instance I hear news media
people all the time during an election
talking about the campaign to elect a
new prime minister news flash to news
media we don’t elect prime ministers in
Canada we do not hold an election to
choose a new Prime Minister the only
voters in Canada who ever saw Justin
Trudeau’s name on a ballot in 2015 were
the voters in Papineau in his riding in
Quebec we elect members of parliament in
a Westminster parliamentary system
want to shed a bit of light on that but
I want to give us three easy how to
things you think about when you design a
voting system okay and I’ll walk them a
walk you through them but here they are
three things one design a voting system
for people not horses it’s more
important than you think this one to
avoid the problem of having the wrong
I think you already are ahead of me on
this but three come up with a voting
system that’s designed for voters not
for political parties so let me start
with the first one what about horses why
do we have so much horsey stuff in our
voting system we talk about the ridings
we have ridings across Canada each
riding a Lexington P and then we have
the electoral system we use
first-past-the-post bull riding is about
how much of a district in the olden days
you could ride around on horseback I
guess to either collect the votes or go
back to tell your constituents what
you’ve been doing at first-past-the-post
is a term from horse racing horse racing
term so all of these these strange
things that were going on we’re
involving horses now first-past-the-post
is actually a rule that was the the
first horse that got its nose over the
line would win all the money even if
that horse was later disqualified I
found this from a book published in 1880
called racehorses in training you could
probably find it too and it referred to
this rule and said fortunately it was
stopped
according it was stopped in its infancy
thanks to the vigilance of the jockey
club right the system we used to vote is
named for something they used to do in
horse racing that the jockey club got
rid of in 1880 just just say it must be
a wonderful system now all of these
horses and all of these riders where
were they all riding around not in
Canada all of this terminology and all
the system came from Rule Britannia
Britannia rule the waves the great
British Empire developed the system of
voting that we have and only those
countries
that were ever part of the British
Empire use this system that’s something
else the Canadians don’t really know
about our system of voting
first-past-the-post most modern
democracies don’t use it they don’t go
near it there are many reasons why not
and I’ll get into some of those but it’s
a it’s a hand-me-down now in 1867 which
we all know because it is now yay 150th
birthday of Canada recognizing that
there were other people here first I
just like to remind us of that when we
celebrate the 150th birthday but our
Constitution the British North America
Act 1867 said Canada’s Parliament shall
be elected using the system we’re using
now at Westminster until such time as
the Canadian Parliament decides on its
own system 150 years and Counting we are
essentially still wearing Queen
Victoria’s old hand-me-downs we have not
improved on it and it’s not as though
Parliament’s haven’t tried I was again
something I learned from being on the
special parliamentary committee on
electoral reform the first time the
Canadian Parliament studied our voting
system was in 1921 and they concluded
that in any democracy with more than two
parties which Canada had three four or
five parties since the early part of the
20th century that in any system with
more than two parties
first-past-the-post did not work it was
a bad system for Canada but we didn’t
take it forward to figure out what would
be a good system well let me take you to
the second problem the problem of the
wrong winner now it’s been on our minds
a lot lately I know you’re all thinking
of it and best picture goes to lala land
oh I got the consternation you saw the
cast accrue of Long Islander on stage
giving their thank-yous and then there’s
people with headsets and they’re running
around behind it’s like it’s a mistake
it’s a mistake they’re not the real
winner don’t you just wish that when
commenced to take the oath of office of
present United States someone hadn’t
just Robinson sorry mistake Wow we were
tweeting we missed the Hillary Clinton
got three million more phones than you
I’m so sorry mr. Trump wrong winner now
the wrong winner problem amazingly
enough yes the United States of America
threw off the British Empire had a whole
revolution about it got rid of King
George the third but what the heck they
kept first-past-the-post and they made
it even weirder by creating the
Electoral College so some of you and I
think a lot of Canadians often think as
we look at other countries we can feel a
bit smug we can say to ourselves well
that couldn’t happen here not we could
have happen here it has happened here
the wrong winner problem happens because
under first-past-the-post the way we
vote separates the seat count from the
popular vote
so if 1957 john diefenbaker by popular
vote lost the election that he won the
Liberals under lewis alcohol had more
votes than john diefenbaker
but and literally we could say in the
rest is history diefenbaker became prime
minister in 1979 the Progressive
Conservatives under shell Clark had
fewer votes than the Liberals under
Pierre Trudeau but it was one of those
wrong winter problems and the Liberals
lost the election even though they won
the popular vote the wrong winter
problem is really quite confusing it’s
happened a lot it’s happened in the
and if you wonder why it is that New
Zealand a Commonwealth country with a
constitutional monarchy just like us Her
Majesty is their head of state and a
Westminster system of electing members
of parliament if you wonder why New
Zealand has proportional representation
fair voting under the system they picked
because member proportional probably
because in the late 70s and early 80’s
they got two wrong winner elections in a
row two times in a row the people of New
Zealand voted for a party and gave more
votes to the party than lost it can
happen here it has happened here we
really need to be concerned about having
a system that can deliver to us a
government with the wrong winner and
even in some ways an almost bigger
problem is the problem hopefully wrong
big winner when a minority of the voters
vote for a party that manages to
accumulate the majority of the seats and
that’s when you have a majority
government that doesn’t have the support
of the majority of voters it’s easy to
see how it happens if you’re going
riding by riding a lot of those votes
disappear now give you an example in
2015 one there’s a group of MPs who were
elected in their own writings with less
than 29 percent of the popular vote 28.6
28.8 they were competitive I’m not
saying we are all equal as members of
parliament doesn’t matter how much we
carried our own riding I were equals but
when you’re in Quebec with a strong
campaign for bloc a strong campaign for
liberals a strong campaign for truth way
you can see how it happens you can win
your seat
leaving 72 percent of the voters in your
riding with their votes
Carrie that’s how you accumulate this
big distance between the seat count and
the popular vote so 0.3 you’re designed
in a voting system
you ought to design it to work for the
voters and not for political parties now
political parties want one thing and I
think you know what it is they want
power and they will manipulate any
voting system you give them to figure
out how to play the odds to get that
power
so under first-past-the-post since it’s
the seat count that matters and not the
popular vote increasingly in recent
years the big parties know you don’t
need to go forward to the Canadian
public and try to get the majority to
agree with you and you don’t need to
necessarily listen to the majority of
Canadians when they tell you what they
want you to do because you’re playing
the odds and you’re slicing and dicing a
targeted message you’re using
dog-whistle politics you’re using voter
suppression political parties and the
big ones like first-past-the-post
because they’ve got this sense that even
if they lose one election or two
elections eventually it’ll be their turn
again all right
people talk about politics encounter all
the time if a phenomenon isn’t about
people getting excited and voting for
what they want
it’s about this overwhelming and
incentive to throw the bums out and then
you get a big sweep the other direction
and everything the last government does
the new government tries to change
that’s what parties like what do voters
like voters like knowing that when you
put your little X next to a name on the
ballot your vote has clout you want to
know that your vote will mean something
and when you vote for a person in your
writing to be your MP or a party whose
beliefs you have aligned with your own
and that person represents that you want
to know that your vote is going to count
and if you live in a riding and you know
the stories you know you can run a goat
with a red sweater and he’d win in this
riding because the Liberals always win
or you can run a dog in a blue sweater
if you are living in a place like that
where the outcome seems certain before
you go to the polls you have less reason
to go voters want to know that their
votes going to count and have Club
second thing voters really want in a
democracy to be absolutely obvious that
every system should let people vote for
what they want vote for what you believe
in vote to send a message vote to use
your voice but in first-past-the-post so
often people say well I know what I want
I want to vote for them party eggs but
if I vote for party eggs I’m terribly
afraid party Y like get in so I’m going
to have to hold my nose and vote for
parties in now I don’t know about you
but I think what you can’t breathe as
you vote
it’s actually not very healthy I think
it induces nausea it makes it less
likely you’re going to vote again next
time
so voting for what you want should be
something we build into a voting system
is something that’s meaningful you have
your vote has clout you know you can
vote for what you want without getting
what you most fear the third thing the
Canadians really want in a voting system
is knowing that the way the
collectivities of Canadians are voted is
reflected in the seat count in the House
of Commons you want to know that the
popular vote is reflected in the
Parliament you get it’s a democracy that
should be considered so basic that we
should still be talking about it
so don’t you think in the hundred and
fiftieth birthday since we were first
told as soon as Parliament can get
around to it you can pick a voting
system works for Canada we ought to have
a look at the voting systems that could
work for Canada the we should look at
the systems that allow us to keep an MP
representing us locally so just so you
know our committee set its name on
anything like the system use it is real
wages vote the political party we do
want to have I love that I represent a
constituency people who tell me what
they want and I work for them and my
constituents want to know who is their
MP who’s their go-to a person for
everything now that can be protected
with mixed-member proportional like they
use in germany in new zealand with
single transferable vote clustering the
ridings and begin
pick a number of candidates every time
you go to vote electing a number of MPs
for a clustered running these systems
can be tweaked they will work great for
Canada what we do know is the
first-past-the-post is a system that
doesn’t work well for anyone so in 2017
for a 150th birthday party what do you
say should we have rules that are at
least as fair as what the jockey club
insisted on in 1880 and shouldn’t we
and should we have elections that are
even fairer than the Oscars the envelope
please thank you [Applause]
Please follow and like us: