Press "Enter" to skip to content

Dragons and Dragonslayers | David Sweanor | TEDxHongKong


hi it’s it’s great to be here and and
challenge a few assumptions and then
this session we’re talking about it’s
not what you think so I want to to push
some thinking here
my goal is convinced you that we can do
something it’s actually pretty simple
that can prevent hundreds of millions of
premature deaths now but the other thing
about is not what you think is that the
solution to the problem involves dragons
now I’ve spent over a third of a century
as a lawyer doing public policy work on
public health I think I’ve had a lot of
successes there are a lot of things that
seem to get in the way and as much as I
learned about law and politics and
advocacy and how to deal with the media
and politicians and I realized there was
something missing and it only came to me
late in my career which I think will
surprise a lot of you I didn’t
understand very much about dragons and
Dragons were clearly the solution to the
problem so I had to put my entire career
on hold to learn a lot about dragons and
that five minutes on Wikipedia was time
well spent because what I learned is
that there’s lots of different types of
dragons you know there’s the dragons
that have literally shaped the
architecture of the city there’s the
Dragons of power the Dragons of luck you
know the the Dragons of wisdom the
Dragons that literally impact our
destiny by controlling things like water
and weather but those aren’t the sort of
dragons I’ve had to deal with in my
career what I’m talking about are the
bad guy dragons the evil dragons the
dragons that would burn down villages
they would destroy the crops they would
kidnap princesses
these are irredeemably bad dragons and
when you get
in irredeemably bad dragon you need a
dragon slayer because that’s all you can
do you can’t negotiate with the dragon
when they’re like that you just have to
slay them well this is really critical
in various ways and we’ve heard from
other people here are talking about how
our brains work that we see danger very
very quickly even if it’s not their
evolution prepared us to do that because
if we were wrong and there really was
danger and we guess there wasn’t then
you know nobody would have lived long
enough to breed and we wouldn’t be here
so our brains are set up to do that so
there’s this tendency to make these gut
reactions the the fighter flight the
good guy or bad guy you know seeing a
witch seeing a dissident finding a
dragon and when you find a dragon it’s
just like any form of evil you end up
finding more because nobody ever finds a
little bit of evil you know if you’re
having a purge you don’t find just one
dissident if you’re viewing a witch hunt
it isn’t a single witch if you want a
decent Inquisition you don’t stop at one
heretic you find lots more so this ends
up affecting a whole lot because you get
into the area that that I’ve tried to
work in through my career when I haven’t
put it on hold to read Wikipedia that
you get public health taking a really
rational approach towards things you try
to meet people where they are rationally
deal with the problem be really
pragmatic so with any cause of death
injury or disease what we try to do for
different things what whatever is
causing the problem you say what can we
do to dissuade people from ever starting
to do that what can we do to get the
people who are doing it to stop what can
we do to protect third parties from what
they’re doing you know things like
drinking and driving laws and what can
we do to reduce the risk for the people
are still going to engage in the
activity that’s it the problem is
when dragons get involved because once
you’ve got an enemy
once you’ve stimulated that deep part of
our brain you’re no longer seeing a
problem to be solved
you’re seeing an evil to fight and if
you look at the history of public health
that comes up again and again and again
so even with with really straightforward
things like immunization you know we’ve
eradicated some amazing diseases but it
wasn’t easy because when you try to do
that logical Public Health thing stuff
gets in the way people see Dragons so
you talk about immunization what happens
when somebody says you’re interfering
with the will of God or you’re going to
cause autism they see a dragon they’re
fighting the dragon it’s no longer about
solving a problem it’s fighting an enemy
what happens when Public Health takes on
the role of a dragon for things like
during smallpox inoculation campaigns
some public health agencies manage to
get police power they could force people
to be immunized against their will
because this is how we’re gonna solve a
problem the difficulty is the people
started finding out that some of those
vaccines were contaminated they were
causing death or injury and the
immunization programs are being run in
ways that were clearly racist or
class-based so what happened dragon
people saw a dragon there were riots
against being immunized against smallpox
dragons there’s other times where we
look at a major health issue and obesity
is a good classic example we see a
problem and we have a choice you know we
can use that rational part of our brain
to say let’s think it through what do we
really know what can we question what
more do we need to know let’s keep keep
judging this and deciding are we doing
the most efficient thing or we can spot
a dragon thought was the dragon we
decided to slay thought and when you’re
in a dragon fight you don’t have time to
do other things like listen to people or
look at the research you’ve got to fight
a dragon you’re slaying a drag
and they were so busy slaying the fat
dragon get it fat dragon that there was
no time to pay attention to sugar sugar
got a free ride the obesity problem got
larger so you turn that to an area where
I spent most of my career and trying to
deal with smoking cause disease and you
know it’s background cigarette smoking
will have killed about six million
people worldwide this year by 2030 it’ll
be about eight million a year at current
trends in consumption the World Health
Organization is estimating it’ll be
somewhere around a billion people in
next hundred years huge cause of death
but an interesting thing happened and
you know what it’s going to involve so
starting about sixty years ago as all
this research started coming out of but
just how deadly cigarette smoking was
thousands of papers coming out over a
period of decades and the cigarette
companies did an interesting thing they
decided well rather than logically deal
with this and try to look at what we can
do to reduce the risk for the people who
are using the sort of products that
we’re using why don’t we hire lawyers
and public relations consultants and
deny at all and we’ll say we don’t think
it really does cause lung cancer or
emphysema or esophageal cancer or oral
cancer or heart disease we don’t believe
it causes stroke we don’t think it’s
really addictive our advertising hey
that doesn’t affect consumption us
wanting young person to start smoking
you’ve got to be kidding of course and
what was the public reaction what was
the reaction of health advocates it’s
simple dragons they saw evil and when
you get into a dragon fight of course it
is a fight to the death with evil so
anything that looked like a dragon had
to be taken on so it wasn’t just
cigarettes it was the company’s it was
anything they sold any other form of
tobacco product they sold any nicotine
product anybody else sold because they
were all dragons and if you couldn’t
slay the right dragon well you could
slay some other dragon so you might not
be able to get rid of cigarettes but you
get rid of smokeless tobacco or
electronic cigarettes or you can over
regulate
replacement products to make them hard
for people to use because darn it
they’re all dragons but while this is
going on and it’s tremendous fun to be
slaying dragons there was this other
thing happening which is called science
and the science was telling us that the
real problem here is a smoke the reason
that cigarettes cause all those diseases
just people are inhaling smoke our
bodies aren’t equipped to do that you
know if we got our caffeine by smoking
rather than brewing tea leaves same
diseases you know the reason half a
million women in India will have died
this year from respiratory illnesses
caused by cooking is that they’re doing
it over an open fire it isn’t the
cooking that kills you it’s the smoke
that kills you and we knew that there
are ways that you could get your
nicotine with very little risk
you know the Swedes have been doing it
for a long time with a form of oral
tobacco they are called snus the
Americans have their forms of moist
snuff there’s now things like electronic
cigarettes at the Royal College of
Physicians in the UK after major report
earlier this year said these products
appear to be at least 95 percent less
hazardous and cigarettes and probably
even less hazardous than that there’s
things like heat not burn products that
have gone over very big in Japan just in
the last year and it looks like about a
million smokers it switch to these sorts
of products they get rid of the smoke so
what would happen if we do this amazing
thing that does not come naturally to
our species what if we could banish the
Dragons from the room and say how could
we deal with this logically well we’ve
got one and a half billion people on the
planet we’re currently getting nicotine
by sucking smoke into their lungs
primarily cigarettes but also cities and
Crete X and on cigarettes alone they’re
spending 800 billion US dollars
equivalent per year most of them are
already saying I don’t really like doing
this you know there’s something about
early death that doesn’t appeal to me
and stinking and being a social pariah
doesn’t help so they’re interested and
what we’re seeing is orden
people doing ordinary things ordinary
people saying All Things Considered I’d
rather not die prematurely and I’m going
to look for something else so we’ve seen
millions of users of cigarettes moving
to other products trying to find other
products a reason why we now have a
multi-billion dollar market for things
like electronic cigarettes the reason
why Sweden now has the lowest rate of
tobacco related deaths and disease in
the Western world because of things like
snus
well what if we supercharged that idea
to say ordinary people doing ordinary
things let’s empower them well look what
we’ve done in the past with things like
pharmaceutical regulation 1938 FDA in
the United States how do you get rid of
all the snake oil products at dr. grambs
peak pills for pale people sort of
things
well supercharge science-based
pharmaceutical products give people
truthful information about products that
are actually safe and effective given
encouragement to industry to bring
forward ever new products encourage the
research and development and the
investment to get those products to
consumers because ordinary people want
to do ordinary things like have things
that make them better rather than sick
and within 12 years 90% of all the
pharmaceutical products sold in the
United States did not exist when that
law was passed that law transformed the
market just like ordinary people didn’t
like ordinarily having to eat
contaminated spoiled food or highly
salted smoked pickled food and that’s
why in the 1940s stomach cancers leading
cause of cancer death in North America
but somebody had an intervention they
didn’t have to worry about Dragons they
got refrigeration it allowed ordinary
people who do the sorts of things they
wanted to do and it supercharged the
idea because they get the refrigeration
they changed their dietary habits in
ways they wanted to do and consumption
of those sorts as the spoiled the stuff
that was causing stomach cancer declined
dramatically stomach cancer became
really rare so what could we do if we
decided to supercharge the idea of
alternative nicotine acknowledged
there’s a lot of people who are not
gonna be able to totally quit anytime
soon just like any other sort of drug
just about any other human behavior but
if we gave an encouragement through
regulatory interventions so that the
less hazardous products the less
addictive products became more readily
available we use differential taxation
so it became less expensive to buy the
products there aren’t going to kill you
what if we allow that to happen
encourage the innovation of ever better
products so we got the scientists of
researchers the entrepreneurs the
investors behind the idea of let’s
replace an eight hundred billion dollar
market for things that don’t kill people
the things that allow them to end their
addiction if that’s what they want to do
imagine if we could start that happening
and then have the help of people like
product liability lawyers that sue the
pants off anybody continuing to sell
cigarettes because they’re now
unreasonably hazardous and you have all
those new businesses those new entities
that want to see further restrictions on
cigarettes so you get this virtual cycle
and imagine if we did that what we’d be
able to accomplish would we be able to
do like happen with pharmaceutical
products that within 12 years we get rid
of 90% of our cigarettes you know maybe
more could we possibly justify not even
trying
I mean clearly we have an opportunity
that can change human destiny that could
prevent hundreds of millions of deaths
simply supercharging ordinary ideas that
people are already starting to do and if
we did that by having the dragons kicked
out of the room it’s time to bring other
dragons back into the room not the bad
guy dragons but the ones I talked about
at the beginning of the talk the Dragons
of power of luck the dragons that
changed human destiny because that’s
what we’d be doing and it would be
amazing thank you
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: