Press "Enter" to skip to content

Doctors in Distress: Saving the Lives of Those Who Save Lives | Dr. Ed Ellison | TEDxNaperville


[Music]
when I was five years old I was
diagnosed with rheumatic fever and
thanks to the steroids I had to take I
blew up like the Michelin Man it wasn’t
cute and believe me it wasn’t fine I was
put on bed rest I wasn’t allowed to run
and play with my friends and for a
five-year-old that’s tantamount to
torture so my my birthday rolled around
my parents were determined to make it
special now my big day my my dad hai
stood me up on his shoulders and he
carried me to the toy store to choose my
present well I don’t remember the toy
that I picked I absolutely remember that
act of love and while my illness was a
low point in my young life there were
actually some good things that came out
of it my pediatrician came to our home
to care for me
that’s right doctors made house calls
back in the day and he was kind and he
helped me and not only did he heal me
because clearly my illness did not stunt
my growth his compassion and his caring
they moved me and they made me realize I
wanted to be just like him a healer now
you better believe when I told my
parents I want to be a doctor they lit
up I mean this was 1960s America Marcus
Welby time doctors are heroes respected
looked up to it’s an honorable and noble
profession and my parents are so proud
that their little boy was going to be a
doctor what they didn’t know and what I
couldn’t know was that while Noble and
true and good that in medicine I would
find an enormous problem and yes there
is fantastic positivity there’s healing
and there’s cures and the advances the
last 50 years I mean they boggle the
mind they inspire the spirit
but there is an underside to medicine
that has been hidden for far too long
and obscuring it is just making it worse
it’s something that we don’t talk about
among ourselves in the medical
profession and certainly something we
don’t talk about with our patients but
the field of medicine is being strained
enormous lis strained by a number of
factors and so today I’d like to pull
the curtain back and share with you
what’s ailing our doctors and what you
can do to help to begin with the
qualities that make you a great
physician also are qualities that can
contribute to the potential misery of
that person that’s right I said misery
it’s sad but it’s true
it’s heartbreaking actually but this is
how it takes shape first of all
perfectionist make great physicians I
mean doctors pay incredible attention to
detail we tend to check and recheck and
then we we recheck again and while
that’s a quality that you absolutely
want in your physician it can make the
people in your personal life a little
bit crazy believe me I know and once
these perfectionists arrive in medical
school that hallowed ground where you’re
first taught the mystery of healing the
human body they’re discouraged in every
way possible
from asking for help people who are
drawn to medicine are devoted to taking
care of the needs of others and they
tend to put the needs of others above
their own nearly always so let me bring
this to life for you I had a colleague
of cardiologist who has severe back pain
he was in the hospital for surgery he
heard a code blue called down the hall
so he wrestled himself up out of bed and
he shuffled down the hall to save a life
then there’s the OBGYN colleague who is
admitted to the hospital in labor to
deliver her own baby but who leaves her
bed and goes next door to assist a
colleague with a difficult delivery to
bring a new life and
the world I mean these are incredible
people and they never stop so we have
devoted perfectionists who’ve been
conditioned to just suck it up to do
whatever it takes to get the job done
and they do all night shift check no
sleep fine junk food for dinner well hey
at least I got the shovel something down
my throat an exercise well the standing
on your feet for 24 hours count but they
learn more they also learn how to
swallow their pain how to swallow their
fear their fear of failing the earlier
their fear of letting someone down their
fear of letting someone die and doctors
are people who never give up until they
do so what does giving up look like well
it can look like losing energy and
engagement and the things that matter to
you they can become disengaged and
attached and the people you care about
your family your friends your patients
you feel ineffective and like you can’t
accomplish anything you feel like you
want to quit and and sometimes they do
and there’s actually a term for this
state of chronic stress and it’s called
burnout and the symptoms of burnout
include emotional and physical
exhaustion insomnia loss of appetite
loss of focus anxiety depression
detachment I mean you get the gist in
fact between 2011 and 2014 a Mayo Clinic
survey showed that the percentage of
physicians in this country who are
experiencing at least one symptom of
burnout rose from forty five point five
percent to fifty four point four percent
I mean that’s unacceptable that’s not
okay that’s not good for our patients
and it’s certainly not good for our
physicians and you’re probably wondering
what’s contributing to the spike in
burnout
we know that physicians work long hours
but increasingly they’re experiencing a
sense of loss of control over their work
they are measured on everything that
they do and while they’re dealing with
matters of life and death the complexity
of medical care is just exploding every
single day and then there is the
implementation of the electronic health
record which has brought many positive
attributes to care delivery but has
brought with it inefficient workflows
that are time consuming and ironically
take physicians away from the things
that brings in their greatest joy in
practice
spending time with patients so this can
feel like a gigantic pile on especially
for perfectionist and remember doctors
don’t ask for help they just sold you’re
on and do whatever it needs to be done
to take care of their patients so not
surprisingly if this isn’t addressed
matters get worse today many previously
well-adjusted engaged physicians are
being stressed to the breaking point
they are retiring early and they are
reducing their clinical practice or
they’re leaving medicine altogether but
it actually gets darker and the last two
years data shows that the rate of
suicide among male physicians is 40%
higher than that than the general public
forty percent now men tend to experience
burnout as detachment and disengagement
what about our women in medicine female
physicians rate of suicide is a hundred
and thirty percent greater than the
general public
a hundred and thirty percent now of that
is tragic and that is unacceptable
and women in medicine experiencing
burnout differently than men do because
of their gender and the greater
expectation for empathy they tend to
give and give and give until they have
nothing left to give but there’s even
more sobering
information the rate of suicide among
physicians is similar to that of combat
veterans actually it’s higher our combat
veterans heroic men and women who put
everything on the line for us who endure
untold suffering and hardship but did
you realize that many of your physicians
are suffering too and so you you you
wonder where did this all begin
and actually it begins in medical school
where we take these bright shining stars
and we often wear them down to a dull
nub studies show that students entering
medical school actually have a higher
incidence of wellness and resilience and
optimism than those entering any other
field of graduate study and yet by the
time they graduate medical students
sense of wellness and resilience and
optimism is worse than that of any other
graduate field so it makes us ask
ourselves right what are we doing to our
medical students we’ve talked a little
bit about that already right
perfectionists don’t ask for help suck
it up you’re a lone ranger you’re a
superhero
and your needs don’t matter but then
maybe when you get out of medical school
things get better right but actually
they don’t because your training
continues there’s residency and then
there’s fellowship for many until
eventually we have these newly minted
physicians mostly 20-somethings with a
burning desire to make a difference in
the world into to do well and good for
people’s lives but they’re finishing
their training broken down and beaten
down and this is the beginning and these
are our healers and I know because I’m
one of them I followed in the footsteps
to be a physician in lockstep I did the
training I went without sleep I ate junk
and I learned and I suffered but I was
also inspired by the gratitude of my
patients and the satisfaction of knowing
I was making a difference in people’s
lives and so I
did more and I asked for more and took
on more as my colleagues do I was called
to leadership and now I’m privileged to
stand before you as co-leader of one of
the largest groups of physicians in the
world 21,000 doctors taking care of
almost 12 million patients and I have
gained perspective I’ve heard the cries
I’ve attended the funerals I have felt
their pain our pain from my vantage
point I feel the weight of the
responsibility of my role and to me it
is profound and it is sacred I lost to
medical school classmates to suicide
before we had even finished our
internship and I have lost colleagues
from my Medical Group and that is
incredibly painful you know that the
cardinal rule of Medicine the oath that
we take as physicians is first do no
harm
first do no harm and how can that be
anything but good well let me break this
down for you the patient is why we are
here absolutely we are drawn to serve
but if we don’t also recognize and care
about the lives of those who save lives
those of us who design the systems in
which we work those of us who work
side-by-side those who receive care from
physicians if we don’t also care about
the lives of those who save lives if we
ignore the humanity of the community of
those who care for others then we are
doing harm and this epidemic it will not
stop now we intuitively know this in
other settings right you got on an
airplane they say before you help
someone else put on your own oxygen mask
but doctors aren’t doing that and they
are starving for oxygen and this is a
big problem and if we’re going to change
it we really have to change our thinking
our culture inside and outside of the
medical profession across society even
if it means going against the grain to
do it we have to declare our physicians
humanity we have a path forward we are
beginning at the beginning at Kaiser
Permanente we are opening a new medical
school and
few years we’ll be welcoming our first
class to our Kaiser Permanente’s School
of Medicine and these bright young minds
we’re going to absolutely teach them how
to be exceptional physicians because
that’s non-negotiable
we’re gonna teach them some other things
as well we’re going to teach them that
their wellness matters we’re gonna
provide support for them and connect
them with each other and resources we’re
gonna teach them how to set healthy
boundaries for their own wellness and
about how prevention and nutrition works
not just for them patients but for
themselves and really importantly we’re
gonna teach them how to work within
these systems to change these systems so
they’re not busted about by the system
but they can be advocates and agents for
change to transform and now this is
really exciting stuff I mean it almost
makes me want to go back to medical
school almost and this is exciting for
our medical students but what about my
colleagues who’ve been practicing for 10
or 20 or 30 even 40 years what about
them we must affirm their humanity too
in the medical group that I lead we are
applying these same learnings first and
foremost declaring their wellness is
essential for themselves and the
Wellness of our patients and our
communities and we’re working on those
systems that need to be improved and
we’re providing greater opportunity for
flexible schedules that can make their
lives work and we’re teaching them about
support for themselves in that love is
medicine and exercises medicine and food
as medicine and sleep as medicine for
themselves as well as their patients
importantly that their wellness matters
now we have a lot more to do we have
doubt of the shows we’re making some
progress moving in the right direction
but this is a complex problem there’s a
lot more that we are committed to doing
and that end I was privileged to be
invited to join a consortium sponsored
by the American Medical Association last
year I joined esteemed colleagues from
the Mayo Clinic and the Cleveland Clinic
Duke Vanderbilt Stanford Johns Hopkins
and we sat down to talk because the
title the consortium was the joy in
medicine
we couldn’t get to the joy in medicine
because we were all focused on this
epidemic of burnout that we’re all
seeing and so we committed that we were
going to make a difference that we would
share what we’ve learned with each other
as broadly as we can and we continue to
do that work but we also know that
that’s not enough if we’re going to stem
the tide of burnout the epidemic of
suicide then all of us have a role to
play those of us who design the systems
those of us who take part in the systems
those of us who receive care we should
tell this story
the doctors are people too and that may
sound trite but it’s not if we want our
physicians to shine with resilience and
with joy we have to consistently affirm
their humanity and the critical role
that they play in caring for all of us
we need them but you know what they need
us we need them to recognize that in
order to fulfill this noble calling to
heal and save lives
they must first learn to heal and save
their own for the sake of their patients
for the sake of their families for the
sake of themselves they must know this
they must believe this now it might
surprise you to hear me say this but in
spite of everything that I’ve shared
with you today or maybe even because of
it I still love my profession and I want
those bright shining stars to seek it
out because we need them we need these
healers these coaches and champions of
health these brilliant minds were
dedicated to the Wellness of their
patients and their communities but if
we’re to help them succeed we have to
help care for the lives of those who
save lives and this is a powerful way
that we can do it all of us together can
think about the humanity of our
physicians and how we affirm their
humanity so the next time
see your doctor go up to him or her look
them in the eye and say hello and say
thank you now they’re not good at
accepting it say it anyway the fact that
you are aware and that you care it
matters more than you know and the
impact of affirming the humanity of our
physicians to support those who care for
us the impact of one makes a difference
for many and that that can make all the
difference in the world thank you
[Applause]
[Music]
Please follow and like us: