Press "Enter" to skip to content

Demagoguery or democracy in action? | Katie Ghose | TEDxUCLWomen


first of all I’m going to say something

a little bit about the the title slide

any of you who’ve taken part in a

referendum will know that it’s it’s

interesting because it’s a vote that’s

given over to the entire public or the

entire voting public rather than a

decision that’s kept in the hands of a

small number of elected representatives

and the reason I’ve called my talk

demagoguery hard to say or democracy in

action is that demagoguery or some

definitions of that phrase kind of

summon up a sort of a political agitator

or a leader that relies purely on drug

drumming up strong strong emotions even

kind of mob rule if you like as opposed

to a more reason deliberation and what I

wanted to explore in about just 10

minutes I think it will be it’s that

idea of what a referendum is in our

democracy the place of emotion in it and

the place of Reason deliberation and

whether they can be a force for good or

a force for ill in our democracy well

our journey today begins in Scotland in

Glasgow and if we got any Glaswegians

here but several months before the

Scottish independence referendum in 2014

I was in Glasgow I guess it was a time

this was several months before the

referendum but already the world’s eyes

were on Scotland thinking is this

country going to become an independent

country or is it going to choose to stay

part of the UK and that the electoral

reform society which is the organization

that I run an organization that’s trying

to bring about a more healthy democracy

in the United Kingdom we wanted to get

underneath the stay leave decision that

Scots were being asked to make and we

wanted to explore a little bit more

deeply about democratic participation so

you’ve got some lovely images there of

just how seriously the Scots took the

vote and how sort of energetically they

got involved but the group that we

brought together we asked two companies

bring some some groups together had one

thing in common and this was their lack

of democratic participation these were

people who never vote ever no matter

what the issue no matter what the

election no matter if a candidate’s

bothered to knock on their door they

never vote some of them had voted some

of the older people had voted in the

past and then they’d given up couldn’t

see the point of it and most of the

younger people had never voted at all

and my colleague Willie Sullivan who’s

the director of the electoral reform

Society in Scotland calls these people

the missing millions and he’s written a

book about it which which you might want

to go away and read what I wanted to

tell you about this group of people is

that we basically just it was quite a

small group and we just went round the

table and we said so so you’re you know

you you don’t ever seem to vote but what

about this Scottish independence

referendum what about this are you going

to vote every single person said they

were going to vote why it’s the future

of my country and so in this they had

found something of meaning something

that was worthwhile and that was why

they wanted to have their say and then

on polling day when ninety-seven percent

of the Scots the Scottish people were

registered to vote and eighty-five

percent turned out I think we really saw

the sign of the truth of those groups

had told this was a decision that was

worth being part of it was a really

something they felt almost magnificently

important and and that it was worth

their time it was worth their while that

there was something extraordinary about

the the length and the breadth of the

participation that you saw in the

Scottish referendum it really showed

what a referendum can do that it will

energize people with those huge numbers

and there was something about the length

of time that people had their which I’ll

touch on as well for the debate so that

was that was the kind of an

extraordinary example if you like of the

kind of length and breadth and depth of

political participation that can happen

in a country well fast forward a couple

of years to this summer and the twins

third of June and Britain’s voted

52-percent to forty-eight percent to

leave the European Union well I was back

in my local gym that the weekend after

the vote and I haven’t been there for

some time because it had been an

intensely busy time at work and at my

local gym it’s very unusual to overhear

much political chat at maybe the sort of

heavy breathing and the heart FM don’t

know the kind of the loud sounds in the

gym or it might just be that there’s not

that much chat going on and in fact the

last time I’d had any kind of a

political conversation at the gym had

been a couple of days after the general

election in early May in 2015 and I was

lying on a mat doing my warm-up

exercises and a neighbor of mine and her

friend came over and they’d spotted me

on television talking about the 5

million people who voted for the United

Kingdom Independence Party and the green

party at the general election and had

only ended up with one member of

parliament apiece for all those folks

that had all had been all the

representation it had added up to anyway

they’d heard about that and they wanted

to talk to me about it but this time

round there were three men probably in

their twenties i would guess and they

were having an incredibly energetic talk

about the EU vote so this was a couple

of days after the referendum when we

decided as a country to leave the

european union and they were using

extremely colorful language that i won’t

repeat today but they were saying

jean-claude juncker norway that’s never

going to work here and so on and they

were demonstrating a concrete and

detailed grasp of the issues underlying

that important vote and then they

politely stepped aside to let me get to

the weights machine and then they

carried on with their debate about the

EU well this really got me thinking

about what is

it’s that brings politics into the

mainstream so the café’s to the gyms to

the bus stops what is it that that

brings us to that political table if you

like or brings politics into a load into

the places where we spend our lives and

I was struck by for me one of the

symbols of the other pictures I have in

my mind when I think about the Scottish

independence referendum which was the

women who were on hen night discussing

the future of the currency in Scotland

should Scotland decide to become an

independent country and for me this has

become one of the symbols of the extent

of the democratic participation that

took place in Scotland people seized the

agenda for themselves they became

knowledgeable they took the agenda if

you like from the formal campaigns and

from the elites and they made it

something for them and they dissected

the issues and they talked about the

issues for themselves so done well I

would argue that a referendum a public

vote that’s thrown open to every single

one of us on the register to take part

on can cut through to people and get

into the heart of their lives even in

this cynical error if the topic is right

a referendum can get an issue out there

and it can be something that people

really grapple with and of course in a

referendum in a vote that is thrown open

to all of us every single vote counts I

don’t know if any of you here were part

of the surge in membership that some

political parties found happened after

the EU referendum some of you might have

even join joined parties or rejoined

parties I don’t know but at the

electoral reform society my my

independent non-governmental

organization we had our own mini surge

in membership and hundreds of people

contacted us why were they joining the

electoral reform society they said my

vote has just counted in the referendum

it didn’t matter where I lived in the

country my vote had the same value as as

someone else’s vote

were no safe seats seats that always go

to the same party as they say you pin a

rose s on a donkey and the same party

gets in however you have cast your vote

there was none of that there were no

post code lotteries wherever you were in

the country your vote was of equal value

and so many more people have joined our

society in our cause because they want a

voting system that can give equal value

an equal voice now the result was of the

EU vote the the voter you leave the

European Union was clear and it was

decisive but many of us felt

dissatisfied and many people on both

sides of the debate felt too satisfied

about the the quality of the debate and

the the the information we wanted to

take a closer look at that and

understand that why was it that with a

really quite a good turnout seventy-two

percent more than in the general

election the parliamentary election why

was it that we felt so dissatisfied and

so many people after the four months

quite for quite intense months of the

formal campaign just felt that the

quality of the information and the

public debate wasn’t good enough and it

didn’t match up to the interest that

people had well we took a closer look at

this and my colleague will has collated

the information and it was a real team

effort and we just tried to do some

dissection we tried to get under that

understand understand that

dissatisfaction a little bit more we had

conducted surveys throughout the

campaign that really looked at how

people were feeling what was their

actual experience not just what we were

being told by the campaign’s but what

were the information sources they were

using who were they trusting or not

trusting how are they feeling about the

experience and what we discovered was

that time really matters it’s it’s an

incredible experience today here we all

are taking the time to hear from some

quite extraordinary and witnessed some

extraordinary people and interact with

each other and and that’s a wonderful

experience and journalists in this

campaign

were bored before the referendum

campaign had even started but for the

general public for all of us we needed

time and we didn’t have it we needed the

time and the space to really dissect and

get to grips with the issues for

ourselves let’s just look at this this

spike that’s the 24th of June that’s

Friday that polling day as we probably

appreciate is is Thursday in this

country this was on Friday the frequency

of the phrase what is the EU googled in

the UK people that this was a high

interest but low information referendum

people were really interested in anybody

tell you that people in this country

were not interested they had a high

level of interest so it was as though

people didn’t get the richness of

information the time and space to

breathe and to deliberate that their

interest really mattered they didn’t get

the campaign that they deserved what’s

the solution well the first thing we

have to do is to understand what kind of

a creature referendums our little bit ly

British star we’ve tapped referendums

public votes that have thrown open for a

direct say by anybody who wants to get

on the register and have that say took a

fairly traditional representative

democracy a democracy that is evolving

and bringing in more participation and

deliberation we need to think before we

have any more referendums about how what

sort of a creature this is and how does

it lit in with other elements of our

democracy don’t let’s wait until after

the vote to then consider how does

Parliament’s role reflect or knitting

with the say that the people have just

had second we need to do referendums

differently the public should be back in

control of referendums it not enough to

just say that everybody shall have a

vote that doesn’t in itself guarantee

meaningful public participation there

needs to be much more thought given to

the public

roll from the very beginning of citizens

panels to help shape the terms of the

debate of the referendum the framework

the lenses through which will be seeing

this important decision there need to be

proper resources and publicly funded

open forums and above all balanced facts

a fat book if you like or a minimum data

set that people can trust to be the

basis of their conversations and

deliberations the second bit of doing

referendums differently is about ground

rules we need a referendum rule book so

that everybody knows where they are the

campaigns and the public and we need

tough enforcement measures so that when

eva campaign site makes a wildly

misleading claim it’s called out at the

time and tough enforcement action is

taken and we saw in the european union

vote both that on both sides of a say

and the leave there were some vast

claims made about how much it would cost

the public and the public person

individual households on one side if the

decision was to be made and on the other

side there was a 350 million pounds that

were going to the NHS so both sides made

wildly exaggerated claims and we think

that they should be an official body

that could call those out during the

campaign and take action finally we want

referendums to be far more deliberative

we want that time and that breathing

space to be there so that by all means

we should have high emotion in a

discussion politics should be emotional

but there should also be the time in the

breathing space as well for people to

deliberate to discuss to debate among

themselves at their best referendums can

be an inspiration in public dialogue

they can actually give us a chance over

over the long term to become more

democratic citizens more involved in

politics but at their worst they make us

more divided they make us more

distrustful of each other’s ability to

make a good decision I feel that in the

UK we are really guinea pigs we’re

but these are valuable experiments in

Ireland where there was a referendum on

gay marriage the alternative vote

referendum on the referendum on the

voting system which crashed and burned

this was in 2011 but as a rich source of

learning about referendums on about how

to achieve electoral reform in the

future and the referendum experience

that we’ve just had in this country so

we do have a few more under our belts

and we know so much more than we did now

it’s up to us all to make sure that

future referendums are done better and

done differently thank you very much

[Applause]

you [Music]

Please follow and like us: