Press "Enter" to skip to content

Décisions anti-constitutionnelles dans une démocratie? | Frédéric Bérard | TEDxMontreal


[Music]
the rule of law what the state
Right and right so that
distinguishes a democracy from a
dictatorship is the history of mankind
ever you do find a
democracy a true democracy
is not quite a true and straight
still in 2016
we have examples around the world
the state should primarily c-53 thing
there is one law for all are
equivalent in the law are all
equal before the law
the second point the government by
such public authority must
respect the law must respect the laws
which are adopted
the third point and the forgiveness
Courts act as bulwark
the state should the courts will punish
government when the government
violates the rule of law are the three
basic foundations in Canada in theory
and hopefully in practice we live in a
rule of law
quebec also but there are slippages
Fraikin being discussed to know more
when not total we discussed
facebook we discuss for 24 to 48
hours and then we move on
remember you are the Montreal
Last week all the stories
SPVM police spy is
that on journalists for ten
minute for a day or two
sometimes for months or even
years we will see what will come out a
Later but still and that’s what
kind of alarming skid more
major fire say I think I can
wrong but it’s a skid which
little has been said enough reasons
you understand yourself is the
sphere Khadr
everyone now knows omar
khadr at least some citizens saw these
Canadian
teenager 15 years in Afghanistan in a
fight with US troops
there was an ambush nearly all
two in fact almost all are
Kader died except his side and
on the other side you have a citizen
or US actually is
died in the ambush
khadr is trapped and sent to
guantanamo cuba
one would question namely yes
but that the international convention
of child rights should not
apply here on child soldiers
was 15
that the Canadian government
Harper government said later
well no it is not applicable it is
terrorist in Guantanamo but he
What happens there happens what happens
usually guantanamo
ie systematic torture
Kader on which 15 years 16 years 17 years
perhaps more serious in this
history ecsc the lady did not know if the
belly know is that when green
where that parent is not even accused
nothing why he is not accused is
simply because we have no evidence
against him is none what is the
Canadian government to help
Americans
he sends two agents scrs Service
Canadian secret information
kader will ask for several
hours for several days
obtain confessions under sub Tortul
term torture is important is to top
Kader on and to make her admit
he was responsible for the murder
US soldiers in right law
Canada but right now
International Torture is not
admissible in evidence why
proof because a flourish
suture confession know nothing
why you laugh I know about
you but to me you have snatched me
angle the state of a certain level of
believe it holds are not held
and thereafter if melun
entered into evidence the ladies years I
cooked but the view was obtained
understand it
Tomorrow lawyers who khadr
Canadian learned ploy
ask the Federal Court of
Canada to repatriate khadr saying
that violated his rights since
long but even more since
Obviously involvement
Canadian government
Federal Court if indeed you
have violated the rights of Omar in khadr
Under the Canadian Charter and
requests that khadr be repatriated
in fact it orders the repatriation
khadr federal government go to
appeal to the Federal Court of Appeal
who says the same thing as the aco
Federal repatriate 16 khadr I
violated his rights and not any
law the rights and freedom must
Security is potentially must
life and serious all this is what
heard either in the media
call a small paragraph here and there
the best reason but because for
that time you have someone
having a Conservative Prime Minister
who repeated systematically is
serious what is happening is a khadr
terrorist but whether someone
is guilty of terrorism I would
that a court decision
on it that never happened
during that time he passes
something else
the united states is finally decides based
Evidence we have obtained in torso
we decided to finally hold a trial
Kader listen that the trial took place
court
Normal serious pro before the
US military commission which is
a compound of which will have it within
a judge
US military a lawyer
khadr his lawyer that his own lawyer
confided some US military is
also quite attorney lawyer
the crown is open in the middle of
Pirate is a US military will
and sells all the jurors what they
Kader had to decide whether or not
was guilty of killing
US military
were US military if
you see no problem with
the court’s impartiality
you stress a little dog she is
Fortunately for good ironically kader
his lawyer has the second day
faded ottoman faint in
full in some courtrooms
and the trial we had an abortion
perhaps not a bad thing
you and me because I think
After the trial is already clear to
early in this one you imagine the
poor lawyer who is forced to plead
khadr defend before his sworn friends
US military judge
established brief return to canada
Federal government lost in court
Federal is under appeal
take federal court in thing
Court of Canada
and there happened something
enough etc and start adding email
auditions
Minister of Foreign Affairs
which is somewhat in charge of the file
Queen this case do not know the room
common effect that chromium by
media and the question is
Minister
listen to it what are you going
do what your government
will do if the Supreme Court
the highest court in the land if the court
Supreme command you to repatriate khadr
the rods Answer two points on
will
I began to be sure
everyone understood me because
even that fact several times that
tells this story
the cbs channel I tell
tells stories nonsense strong
Unfortunately this is the real story
one asks a man what
what you are going to do
if the judiciary of the rampart
OPTT the right order you to
government because you have violated
the rights of a Canadian citizen
Under the constitution commands you to
repatriate what are you going
or to meet heroes and
journalists therapies so thank you
to do other things that will
discomfort hypothesis I do not know if it
stands the Supreme Court of Canada
probably aware that if their
gave repatriation remember a
constitutional crisis in Sicily are
Justice of the Supreme Court Order you
repatriation and the government
refuses to follow your prescription
what do you make seven points
it is zet before a crisis
major constitutional and want
not judge it like when the government
refuses to follow the decisions of more
high court
it is a breach of trust and I
will go further and that’s
a breach of trust that binds or
on which you want the
toques right is what
really live in a democracy when
may violate state or cinema
Right frankly I can certainly is
while knowing that the Supreme Court
crisis work they were
dissipates potential to do the thing
Next it splits the two esi
Government clearly violate
Rights khadr his right of freedom
his right safeties it makes no
them but given the prévert
traveling in Business
Foreign and Thaksin is a lsm
little to the front by one step back
is located it relieves a
prior jurisprudence short stuff
a little curious in there and it ends
per say but I will not order the
repatriation
because I do not have any on hand
information but I’m still going
say you have to choose your government
punishment is punished for it
but chooses not support you nition
are convicted of murder and the court
from school
it’s serious but chooses not punishment
we will try something
roll 140 on the highway at the time
leaving actually take you to true
say one goal is that of the
do and told police they
stop the coast I know I
I wanted to 140-150 know I
violated the Loire is a clear one do
the case Reims choose my punishment
a few passages rec solar is
not hurry with it and then after that
Please send me video
the reaction of the cop
da I’ll put it on youtube
How is what I mean
Obviously all this is was received
as a number for each
Lawyers khadr
one imagines his lawyers asked for
Following the Federal Court did not
meaning what happens when why
it is meaningless because he is Jewish
So with the Supreme Court before the
government you have to choose your own
Punishment services a government
Canadian in fact he sent a beautiful
letter to the Department of Defense
American saying know what else
the same Thursday that it was not nice
get the press under torture while
it can not use this evidence
there and then the united states that had
pay a ton dollars never have
answered
they used the evidence they
not found with this end their brief
back in federal court attorneys
khadr request to this hand
federal
Hence the government to not respect the
Supreme court did
not united enough we are helpful
in eure and confederation
actually we agree with you
they are given to new government
find a new repair in
seven days
what the government is doing
Conservative doubt doing homework
in the task once again call
during that time the youngest in
guantanamo
it may well be that Cuba is not as
joyous as basement there is torture
since the age of 15 years
systematically lawyers
Ghadames recounted the tortures
khadr suffered is things that
not told about an appellate court video
Federal court zuber when there is a
one judge who was appointed by the
preservatives
is a former minister of justice
Tory
I mean his name is called stone
blais I told myself I see no urgency
the not appreciate my money will
later tso make their report
I analyze the balance of convenience
can not the government sent
to do something that’s fair ball
six years of torture Maps
guantanamo
so obviously is probably not
too important drawback here brief
all that to say that after these
decisions of the Federal Court of Appeal
which swinging a hearing on the bottom
indefinitely so much
far lawyers khadr and Kader
especially had he enough I want
press it out of here
and there they agreed with the
US government and the ambassador
canada in the United States to sign
the agreement as what he calls
guilty he had served eight years
jail
the next year in Guantanamo and
castles would be repatriated to Canada
spend a year lawyers khadr
asking the Conservative government
good well we shrivels customers or
big canada how prison
Which province and the Government of
answer what how why it was a
agreement
we had a year that Guantanamo
repatriated to the country
the postman is tied but if your
Ambassador by then Ambassador
Canada in Washington that is written there is
is not bound by our embassy in
even you have not already seen it you
Ambassador of a country that does not read her
country still another formula
original
short after some pressure we end
when even repatriate khadr on
Later we see her in a prison in
Maximum security in alberta
and whenever wanted khadr
to reduce the security level
the prison you can be sure that
the federal government was going ahead
the courts to fight against this
same query
you can be sure, but also that
each kader asked where his
Conditional liberation
we must be sure that the government
would oppose him
today is systematically khadr
released controllably life
change his lawyer began
studying to become paramedic
remains of other problems that
that subjected him to the government
during this ten dozen years
is the story of my losing arrives
tomorrow to say yes but it is far from
me that I speak not touch
Afghanistan – will launch bombs is
true you know what I do not know if I
khadr is a terrorist or not can
be that it is possible but it is not
that the question
because if he was, but that he
make a proper trial form
before a real judge and condemn but
never did and why it was
never did because you have
Government has decided that it
were terrorists even if we did
never any evidence to that effect the
company got this torture that’s
is serious and it could you
happen to you it could happen to me
me an election in the United States
in repeat heard
This week there is a candidate who is
became president who promised to
deport immigrants file
a Muslim said cuff as
has done in the 30s
there was still reading it will piette
up today is that I will
to close with and montesquieu
I think this draw should resonate
Beyond the sphere should this khadr
Once our lives as individuals
montesquiou was an injustice
committed 1 is a committed injustice
thank you all
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: