Press "Enter" to skip to content

(Dark) Tourism and Emotions in Places of Turmoil | Dorina-Maria Buda | TEDxUniversityofGroningen


[Applause]
good evening everyone today I will take
you on a journey to visit some places of
social and political turmoil and
conflict I grew up in communist Romania
of the 1980s in a small Transylvanian
town at the border with Hungary and at
the time the Soviet Union during those
times food was scarce food was portioned
in ratios per family communication with
the world outside Romania was severely
limited and controlled international
travel and tourism into Romania was
equally severely limited and heavily
surveilled it was also prohibited for
Romanians to travel abroad now here on
the slide you can see a picture of my
father as a border patrol military
officer during those times both of my
parents were working for the border
patrol so for me growing up in these
times of turmoil unrest and revolutions
such as the 1989 revolution in Romania
living in a border town with parents
patrolling the border fueled my dreams
and desires to break free of the
confines of Romanian communist borders
so
in psychoanalytic theories
it is said broadly speaking that we
desire what we do not have we desire
what we lack
but this core desire does not pursue its
own satisfaction of having what we lack
this core desire pursues its own
furtherance its own continuation that is
more desire greater desire so my desires
have led me to work live and study in
about eight countries on four continents
since 2001 I have become a social
sciences researcher with keen interests
in travel and tourism in dark tourism in
social and political conflicts in
emotions and effects now from all these
concepts that I have just enumerated
dark tourism almost always acts as a
hook for most audiences now please put
your hand up if you have ever heard the
term dark tourism or if you have engaged
in dark tourism perhaps perhaps you
visited places such as the former
transit camp investor board here in the
province of drain day than the
Netherlands and you can see on the slide
a picture of the wagon in Westerbork or
perhaps you visited more known places
such as Ground Zero in New York or
perhaps you visited tombs or graveyards
of famous people and you can see here a
tourist visiting the tomb of Yasser
Arafat in Ramallah so have you heard of
dark tourism how many of you have you
heard of dark tourism or engaged in dark
tourism
quite a lot of hands up all right now
what is dark tourism the term was
introduced in the late 1990s by two
British researchers John Lennon and not
the famous death singer but the British
tourism researcher John Lennon and
Malcolm Foley they define dark tourism
as visitation of places connected to
death disaster and atrocity for mass
media dark tourism has become an
incredible buzzword to get people
interested in news about disasters and
atrocities and here on the slide you can
see a collage of such news items we
don’t ISM researchers have been
exploring this phenomenon for the last
three decades to understand how it
really works one of the angles that I
use to explore dark tourism in
particular but also the wider phenomenon
of travel tourism and mobility is via
emotions and effects emotions I consider
are those states that can easily be
labelled as fun fear or joy amazement
and the like
whereas effects cannot easily be labeled
cannot easily be brought to the surface
of representation to the surface of our
consciousness and awareness effects are
like those drives residing at other than
conscious levels inside of us moving
inside of us and making us move outwards
as well so tourism in most its forms and
niches is about emotions and effects
something that sounds so simple and
common-sense right
yet as tourism researchers we are just
beginning to confidently vocalize this
and to explore this aspect in more depth
beyond tourism emotion as tourist
satisfaction that encourages repeat
visits so to reflect this idea that
emotions emotions and effects are the
drivers behind travel and tourism I put
forth this concept of effective tourism
in my book with the same title by
effective tourism I mean the circulation
projection transference
countertransference of emotions and
effects in most tourism transactions now
this circulation of emotions and effects
contributes to shaping identity of
places especially in areas of ongoing
turmoil and conflict where multiple
contested and conflicting stories about
a place who exists so to explore this
process of identity formation of places
I conduct tourism ethnography now what
is tourism ethnography and what does a
tourism ethnographer do as a tourism
ethnographer I immerse myself in the
tourism life of a place such as this
marketplace in Jerusalem or alkyds
as the tourism ethnographer I conduct
interviews with locals with tourists
with tourism industry representatives I
commission Diaries from participants in
my projects written Diaries photographic
Diaries video diaries I also record my
own observations which I later analyzed
so from analyzing this wealth of
information generated from these sources
it is amazing to see the power of
tourism and emotion to bring people
together as tourism allows us the space
gives us the space and emotional impetus
to think through to reflect on important
issues such as death personal traumas
collective traumas international
conflicts peace world and and so on now
in my projects I explore tourism
dynamics in the wider area of Jordan
Israel and Palestine I have always
wanted to understand the deep
connections and disconnections in this
region and here on the slide you can see
a map of the region just to remind you
of the geopolitical positioning of the
area since 2009
I have spent accumulated of one year in
the region I have conducted more than
100 interviews with tourists locals and
so on I have taken a group of 25
students to Jordan for a fieldwork and
it is amazing to see the increased
emotional awareness cultural
understanding and compassion with which
most tourists leave such places it is
equally amazing to see locals somewhat
content that their realities on the
ground have been witnessed by people
from abroad the tourism in its potential
for emotional engagements is a powerful
tool to make the world a better place if
and only if it is handled it is
practiced with care compassion good
morals and ethics tourism is equally a
powerful tool to make us better people
as tourism again allow allows us to
space and gives us the emotional impact
us to think through unravel and
dismantle some of our prejudices some of
our personal and collective traumas
and in the following you will hear an
interview an excerpt from an interview
that I had with a tourist from France
now the excerpt is the rope is the rough
cut so please pay attention to the
interview and also follow the reading of
the transcript on the slide
so for these stories from France
traveling in these areas of turmoil such
as Jordan Israel and Palestine made him
think of his father fighting the
Algerian war made him made him think
through his family memories and
vocalized this in a discussion with me
and this is an example of how tourism
can make us better people as this
tourist pledged not to ever fight a war
and made him reflect on what world does
to humanity now as a tourist and tourism
researcher in the region I also
encountered tourists who somewhat easily
cross opposing binaries of emotions such
as joy and anger fun and fear let’s take
the example of Josie a tourist from
China and in an interview with me as she
was visiting the region she said and I
quote I took pictures with the soldiers
I even touched them I touched their guns
it’s very cool I remember her having
said that while laughing while at the
same time we were afraid someone’s
shooting us so you can see how easily
she she she crosses this emotional
binaries of fun and fear we were afraid
someone shooting us but it was cool
right and on the slide you can see a
picture we can you can see two pictures
of soldiers and armed soldiers at
tourist sites themselves having fun
while pictures of them were taken now
tourism is not only about tourists right
is also about locals and in these
regions of turmoil tourism is a chance
for locals to tell their side of the
story
tourism becomes a platform to make their
voices heard take for example the case
of this Jordanian tour guide who in an
interview with me said
and I quote I swear one of the reasons
why I work as a tour guide is to change
your that is our tourists own
perceptions opinions about Arabs about
Islam to show you we are something else
we are not what you hear about us in
your country so for me as a tourist and
tourism researcher having grown up in
communist Romania traveling in these
places makes me confront my own
childhood memories and growing up with
certain limitations and insufficiencies
and I want to remind you of the words of
the British actress Emma Thompson when
she visited the anne frank house and she
said all her would haves are our real
possibilities our opportunities so I
want to make well if there is one
message that I would like you to take
I’m sorry that I would like you to take
from my talk today is that emotions and
effects are the drivers behind tourism
they create disconnections as well as
connections when we visit places and
when we are the visited locals I also
want to make one aspect really clear as
far as I’m concerned
tourism is a privilege is not a right to
roam freely tourism is performed is
practiced by about twelve to fourteen
percent of the world’s population
usually by those with enough money with
enough disposable income to spend
traveling usually originating from
countries with developed economies in
Europe North America and some English
and Australasian countries this further
increases our responsibility
to use the power of tourism to tap into
our compassionate and caring emotions to
build bridges of peace to build
connections and to turn and Frank and
Frank’s would have into realities so my
plea to you is this next time when you
travel open not only your eyes and your
cameras open your hearts as well take
time to talk to as many people as
possible to listen to people’s stories
take time to engage with a place next
time when you travel let your heart be
impressed by what it feels let your
actions be driven by care and compassion
take time to reflect on issues important
to you that are brought to the surface
of your consciousness and awareness by
engaging with that place next time when
we travel perhaps keep a diary talk to
as many locals as the place allows you
next time when you travel bring home
messages of peace become the one who
speaks out for the dispossessed become
the one who has the courage to unravel
and dismantle your own prejudice and the
prejudice of others become the one who
contributes to dismantling the
disconnections that keep us in conflict
and this ladies and gentlemen is my
humble bid for world peace through
tourism and emotions thank you very much
you
Please follow and like us: