Press "Enter" to skip to content

Conversations with the Past | Narayani Gupta | TEDxNIITUniversity


good afternoon everybody you must be
you’ve sat through a number of talks
which have been extremely inspiring I’m
going to talk about something which is
very dear to my heart and this girl who
introduced me said just now I begin with
the Conservation Society of Delhi
because when they asked me for a topic
for the lecture I scribbled down
conversations with the past and I
remembered how very often when we were
typing things those were the days of
typewriters the conservation society is
1982 we is too often by mistake that
conversation society then I have to
clean it but it struck me it’s not a bad
word that conservation is something
serious it’s about seeing that old
buildings are kept in good shape and to
create public awareness about them but
thing with them talking to the monuments
is something that I think we really have
to learn to do just think for a moment
when you go to a monument you are taken
around if you have a guide or you have a
guidebook I mean the classic stories of
English tourists who walk around with a
guide book and read it all the way and
never even look at the monument so there
are situations like that when you’re
learning about it but you don’t have
time to appreciate it and usually these
things are done rather quickly and
you’re through with it and you’ve ticked
it off as seen and usually being
photographed with it
can’t we go beyond this a bit and I
would like to link this with the fact
that most children get very bored and
they don’t have any hesitation in saying
so a very bored with history you must
have been through it or your children
have and this boredom aches extends
itself to museums and
two monuments you go through it
wondering when it’ll end and you hear
the tinkle of teacups in the distance
you know there’s a cafe there and you
wonder how much longer so there’s
something seriously wrong in the fact
that the country like ours with a long
history with large gaps in it admittedly
but still an extra extraordinarily long
history has no sense of excitement about
the past
incidentally children particularly
little children often say they love
archaeology now give this a thought they
like archaeology but they dislike
history that’s because a key ology they
visualize doing digging finding
something finding that pot of gold or
finding a skeleton or whatever that is
discovery they want to do that but they
don’t want to be taken round and shown
things in glass cases or at a site and
being told at X or Y billeted in this in
the seer so they don’t want to be – what
they want to discover so can we change
things about a bit so that we are less
patronizing to children now what are the
questions we are asked or address when
we go to a monument the usual when who
where and of course what what name is
given who the name of the king who our
order whichever aristocrat who
patronized it who wanted it built or
paid for it
where’s the location and when the date
so it’s little wonder the children say
history is boring it’s full of facts and
dates now instead of being embarrassed
about your child you should pay serious
attention to this remark and realize
this is not important this is a given
but the more information you give them
you’re moving further and further off
run into boredom
TS Eliot one said this enough is very
beautiful line where is the wisdom we
have lost knowledge where is the
knowledge we have lost in information so
we have quantities of information you
can go to it you can always check
anything you want the magic of the world
wide net and there are books there are
illustrated books aplenty there’s plenty
to read but I don’t think that is what I
want to talk about because that is a
resource we all have I want to think of
which question we do not think of apart
from the one way how what and whichever
who there were two other questions
how and why how meaning how was it built
and why was it built in this particular
form and that is one thing that we don’t
really bother to talk about and that is
what we opened the doors to discovery
which will make people interested in it
see it as see old buildings with its
forts or temples or places of worship or
palaces such as they are or even what is
called vernacular buildings that is the
Hadees of people who which have got
deserted or some of them have become
gentrified and made really beautiful how
do we address them how do we look at
them so the need is for time and
attention the patron who’s building this
is looking down from the great height
not falling over oppressor pace or
looking over a precipice perhaps but
from a mountaintop he’s a powerful man
but the person who’s building it is
looking upwards
he’s the humble man none of these
architects very very seldom do you have
the architects or artisans leaving their
names in the Kutub inside the stones I
mean the stones which you do from inside
the cube you often have what are called
artisans
that is the use little signatures for
themselves you get this in many places
or whether you know in a kind of
shorthand fashion they would write their
names or their initials but they were
doing that just for convenience they
were not doing it to say look I built
this sometimes there are places where
ever particularly with painting where
the artist puts in a little picture of
himself in the general crowd of pictures
you see a man standing with an easel and
with the paintbrush oh that’s him but he
doesn’t give his name so we’re still not
sure so we’ll never know where in Europe
you can point to buildings from the 12th
century and know who the architects were
not so in India so we fall back on the
king who’s commissioned it now the point
is to come here to get to a point when
you talk to the architect and to the
various we blue helping you might be
knowing this but the tradition in India
was that you have what is called the
Panchala that is the five Smith’s
the Goldsmith the stone brave maker
person Overton stone the metal worker
the bricklayer and always forget one so
there you have these different
categories of specialists working in
harmony they work together they discuss
things they change things they adapt
their designs so it is a great work of
creative art done with the cooperation
of a lot of people it’s not one person
laying down a blueprint and saying
follow this so then you come on to
seeing what the things are that they’re
sculpting what is the stone they’re
using how many young people can tell us
what the stone is that is used in North
India what is the stone used in
Rajasthan what where ideas of sandstone
and not limestone sandstone and granite
and quad site and when you get to Bangor
for instance you get brick temples
because there’s hardly any strong stone
there so you have the made and break or
in terracotta which is mud you get to
South India to Kerala you have
small-scale buildings because that fits
in with the landscape and in Tamil Nadu
which is flat country you get tall
gopuram so that the pilgrim coming from
very far off can recognize it and it
that way so think artists playing it not
being God but creating with a sense of
purpose ended dedication not for the
money that he’s receiving but because he
wants to do the best there is a story
which I’ve heard repeated in various
places come very far from each other
it’s a parable rather than a story about
an architect to this I first heard and
Konark
that he builds this tall structure the
Chikara and at the end he says no that
something’s gone wrong and I can’t
figure it out and a young man comes
along and says will you permit me to
help and he says yes but who are you is
the matter let me see and if it isn’t
then he finds out it is his own son he’s
been away from home for so long I’ve
forgotten what the Sun look like now the
same story is repeated else with the
whole idea to tell you that the father
skill continues in the chair because
these were all family traditions and
that it’s only his old son who could
correct him which also is another
Sanskrit shloka so it says that you
should be proud of being defeated by
your son because your son should be
better than you so there’s all these
stories of groups of artisans who are
the vishwakarma the Vishwakarma is a now
a caste but essentially if you read the
Mahabharat there are two people in it
there is Maya and there is Vishwakarma
Maya helps her to build in the Rasta and
he comes up and says very humbly I am
the Vishnu karma of the Asura the asuras
word this is another debate so I won’t
won’t go into it in great length the
inhabitants of South India
inhabitants and we show Karma’s of the
Aryans so these are symbolic figures
what I’m trying to tell you is that
architects had a very major place in
society I mean they were the traditional
thing to do is to say we are as near the
Brahmins as possible which is what they
bid but not today today you still have
the difference between the architect
whose name is known for having designed
the building which is more than we had
in earlier times but you’ll never know
about all the workers you’ll never know
how many workers died in the building
the skyscraper so but at least let us go
back to the past that’s a human story
but in for the past let us get to know
of the skills they had and this was the
time when you had a kind of tandem
working of mind and heart of hand and
heart today alas I think we use our
fingers chiefly for tapping very gently
on our smartphones but just think of the
limbs we were given and how they were
used I mean I don’t know but I think
it’s very important to learn a craft
which you have to do and do badly and
get frustrated and then learn to improve
on it it makes all the difference to
your self-esteem it’s much better than
passing exams or getting medals at that
level that’s a sidetrack so that’s one
thing the other thing is to understand
the beauty of the things because
aesthetics is something we forget we
talk of buildings as though they are
just anything you know a factory or
something like that which is efficient
these buildings were most of them done a
scientifically and B with a great sense
of beauty you know and it is so inbuilt
that you have to experience it you have
to see it at different times of day is
it more beautiful look at the direction
of our buildings the orientation facing
east opening to the east working on the
west and see what it means in terms of
the morning light see what it means in
terms
the sunset I we were told yesterday that
the sunset from the roof of this
building is very spectacular and the
sunrise from the grounds behind us so
these are things one should think of
think of the Stars the sky which was
full of stars which people could see
which were also figured in their
calculations so our architecture
something that young people should learn
to understand and become friends with
and see it in terms of crafts of art and
I mean you remember the kind of paints
they used if you’re talking abou alot
these were all natural dyes and not they
artificial ones we use today and in
terms of Gardens laying out of gardens
the kind of trees and flowers they used
no just do orders it is not something
that you have to do for a degree it is
simply to make your life more full and
enjoy it and here you are best placed
for this Indian Brahma where where you
have the Gateway to or Rajasthan
architecture open to you please I hope
you will be able to take this further
and see how you can you don’t have to
build the same things again don’t copy
old art that is a sacrilege but at least
you can come to appreciate them and see
how at different terms of our history
these things were hungry and I mean
these were dumb and with no sense of
time or money but simply that of the joy
of creation and so well you should think
of yourselves as citizens not just
citizens of the Republic of India but as
belonging to the Republic of beauty that
is our country thank you [Applause]
Please follow and like us: