Press "Enter" to skip to content

Conversations That Matter | Mark Prain | TEDxDunedin


I’ll tell you a little about me later
but what I’m really interested in doing
tonight
in the spirit of making a difference is
to ask you all to do something now which
is experiment in improvisation and take
a deep breath because this is a huge
emotional challenge I want you to turn
to someone close to you and express
unabashedly the sign of peace where you
go
shut up
wonderful wonderful think about that how
comfortable that was how uncomfortable
that was whatever up here we have some
people and I’m going to be talking
tonight essentially about people and
journey these are all wonderful folks
they are part of my life in one way or
another
I however in terms of context I’m an
incurable optimist all take a side I
possess the optimist gene
those of us who possess the optimist
gene extraordinarily fortunate it’s not
that you walk through life naively but
you tend to bounce back a bit quicker
from some of the challenges that we all
have to confront I’ve had a few of those
I was born in Dunedin 60 years ago so
I’ve been around the block a few times
the thing about the optimism dream is
that what it gives you the gift is the
gift of agency the gift of having a
sense that you can participate that you
can enable that you can through doing so
affect change this is a gift which sadly
is in all too short supply
I believe our greatest single enemy is
not the existential challenges that we
all confront but people feeling it is
all too big or it is all too hard that
is the far greater challenge in my mind
then the problems themselves
speaking of context and the side of
peace which you’ve just engaged in let
me tell a little bit story about my dear
old mother my mother on one side of her
clan came from a long line of French
Jews
she and her sisters both married
Catholics I was raised pretty much
Catholic until my father long guide long
gone who died when I was 13 my mother
went on for another 31 or 32 years
during which time he became sanctified
he wasn’t a saint I can tell you but one
night at the tender age of about 80 she
stopped going to mess the reason was she
had all that time her Jewishness
notwithstanding been a Catholic and on
this particular night she went to Mass
and the mass was no longer in Latin it
was in English and the mask fell and at
communion she was asked if she would
turn around and give someone the side of
peace that was it she never went back
and for the last part of her life she
and her two sisters returned to their
Singer sewing machines like something
out of a Woody Allen movie and continues
to be the tailor’s the Jewish tailors
they always were we confront at the
moment in many parts of the world
geopolitically as you’re all aware
retreat of various kinds nativism
nationalism fake news the attack on
identity politics cap I come from not
only an optimistic perspective but I
have two very strong convictions and the
work I do which is one god protect us
from the zealots and I don’t care what
color creed or politics they are but I
also have an even stronger conviction
which is God protect us from the earnest
people who don’t have a sense of humor
are extremely difficult to work with so
these are the two contexts and the one
hand the positive that I believe in many
ways I’m fortunate to be able to
practice the optimism side of the
equation the other is I’m not an idiot I
am a pragmatist and one has to
acknowledge that we do confront some
fairly extraordinary challenge
be at local Vietnam be a global but I am
saying without any shadow of a doubt
that the way through these things is to
do with agency so what is the beginning
of agency to me it is people and it is
story and the beginning of conversations
that matter is the stories that we can
share that in many ways are still being
written the journey is far more
important than the destination and if we
can embrace our individual story first
and foremost and share that as we easily
do with our families that’s fabulous
with our friends in this day and age god
help us we can do that through tech in a
way that my generation certainly
couldn’t when I was growing up that’s
relatively straightforward sharing your
story passionately the strangers however
is a different problem it’s an
opportunity but it is a problem
particularly if that stranger you know
comes from an echo chamber a bubble a
political worldview which is utterly the
reverse of what you value of what you
believe matters but what I’m talking
about tonight is that fundamentally that
is the challenge that we need to
confront so if we begin with the idea of
story and the idea of sharing story what
is the middle what matters here what is
this about we just heard our friend from
the u.s. talking about the long term
versus the short term what I’m talking
about here is breaking the echo chambers
breaking the bubbles I’m talking about
bipartisan political processes multi
partisan political processes as opposed
to I’m a Republican you’re a Democrat
you’re a Trump voter I’ve got nothing to
say cultural respect what a story about
why do
we tell stories what is the aim of
telling stories what are we looking for
in telling stories
surely the opportunity is to look for
what binds us what is that that I am
hearing for the first time in your story
with which I resonate despite the fact
that I know you’re packing three visible
firearms and you probably have another
three and I know that you voted for
Trump
a month ago what is it that I can do –
listen acutely – find the cord where you
and I can have a conversation that
matters where we can lift we can elevate
the conversation amongst the easy bias
the easy prejudice which we all can
carry and I’m talking about the left as
well as the right I’m talking about the
kids and madrasahs in Pakistan as
readily as I’m talking about the Bible
Belt in America or the tall poppy
syndrome in our own beloved museum so
what are we after we’re looking for
cultural respect we’re looking for
common humanity we are definitely as a
system for hopefully engaging with humor
with what politicians who have this
naturally think of the Clintons bill had
it in spades Hillary’s unfortunately as
a bypass in terms of what’s called the
common touch and then fundamentally of
course we have to recognize that all of
us no matter where we come from no
matter what our stage of life no matter
what our situation we fundamentally are
concerned with whether there’s bread and
butter on the table and whether we feel
personally secure Bill Clinton’s famous
statement it’s the economy stupid echoed
recently by Steve Bannon when he was
finally a nun – happily booted out of
the White House he made the point rather
off handedly that he really hoped that
the left that the resistance in the US
would continue to focus on issues like
color on issues like climate because as
long as they did that it would
continually reinforce the Trump
who are primarily concerned with bread
and butter on the table we have to
acknowledge we have to recognize that we
all as human beings have fundamental
needs it’s not an either-or but if you
ignore those needs completely in favor
of some higher level of moral virtue
again it’s difficult so Who am I
my name is Mark crane I have the great
good fortune for the last decade of
being the founding director of the
Hillary Institute of International
leadership
this was established a year before it
died with his full support with the idea
of honoring his role as an exceptional
leader and as a global citizen
much as we revere him here his work
internationally is enormous ly
well-regarded what do we do we focus on
exceptional leaders in mid-career
exceptional changemakers in mid-career
people who are doing real and can
do more it’s an area which is often very
challenging as I’m sure many of you who
are mid-career will understand and so
that’s where we put our emphasis at
results and what’s called one Hillary
laureate per annum somewhere on the
planet we’ve been doing it for a decade
we have eight of them now ranging from
the president of Carabas to the founder
of Amazon watch an extraordinary woman
coup d’etat so sultani
to the current Hillary laureate 2017
Johan rocks from who many of you all
have heard her I’m sure he’s the man who
invented the planetary boundaries and is
a huge figure in the landscape of
climate change what are the topics we’re
talking about well the old adages you
should never talk about politics sex or
religion well basically I’m saying well
let’s turn that right on its head what
conversations that matter is about is
taking on those very uncomfortable
engagements those very uncomfortable
conversations as many of them were
mentioned today people have allocated
them far better than I some of them are
obviously there I won’t go through it
read it out you can see it and the point
in the brackets here
is that in our busy lives two things
happen one is we get distracted so very
easily and the other is as I said before
that we fundamentally use our busy lives
as an excuse for not participating for
not having agency for not engaging in a
way which actually confronts our comfort
which forces us to stretch which forces
us to go to those uncomfortable areas of
our lives which we would frankly rather
not so what is this for who is this for
as I said in terms of scale it’s
everyone it’s firstly the individual
challenge secondly agency community then
sector then nation then glow what are we
doing this for we are looking for
solution models which work across all
levels of society and to do that in my
mind we have to have the courage to try
and lift the conversation as I say above
our bias above our chauvinism above our
prejudice and we have to look for the
pathways where we can actually work
together and for some obvious examples
in the former slide in fact any one of
these issues here fundamentally is not
something which we’re ever going to
solve if we say the Democrats are gonna
do it or the Republicans are gonna do it
they ain’t we have to do it we have to
have those uncomfortable conversations a
friend of mine a former mayor of Seattle
20 years ago began a program which was
incredibly simple and it all I’m talking
about here is straightforward and simple
it’s not new what Herrmann did was he
challenged his community in Seattle to
say ray tonight you’re gonna have a
dinner and you’re going to invite ten
people to your home you’ve never met
before and I as the mayor I’m going to
guarantee you that those 10 people will
be all of different communities all of
different races
you’ll get a hosted dinner and there’s
only one ambition one outcome that
matters that is by the end of the night
somebody else is going to put their hand
up and say I’m going to do it next time
so again this is not rocket science
but it is looking for those
breakthroughs where we can actually
ultimately move from an uncomfortable
conversation to solution models that
actually work this young man here in the
middle in terms of my work last year we
were asked by the federal government
here in New Zealand great
Hilary Institute around for a decade
you’re well-known in Shanghai what would
you do if you came home what would it
look like so this year in fact in one
month’s time we are landing the first
cohort of what will be 100 a year what
are called Hilary fellows into New
Zealand 80 percent of them are coming
from everywhere on the planet the first
cohort we had 411 applications from 57
countries why are they coming to New
Zealand they’re coming to New Zealand to
spend three years developing a product a
good or a service which they can then
take back to scale and the service of
global solution modelling so in many
ways these people are by definition
entrepreneurs but they’re not in the
spirit of the talk we just heard just
tick entrepreneurs some of them do come
from Silicon Valley some of them like
this young man here come from and he’s
the chief executive of their fellowship
program in New Zealand he started his
life in a village in Ethiopia and he
wanted a first-class education so he
write to every Ivy League on the planet
he said give me an interview Cambridge
wrote back and said we’ll give you an
interview just as long as you can get
here so he also put the shekel out to
every goat in his village to get the
funds to get him to London he went from
Cambridge to Harvard
to Silicon Valley back to New Zealand
with two colleagues who were absolutely
convinced that this country this very
special out there or could be an
incubator nation for purpose impact
entrepreneurship so tied to this program
is a visa program this is election year
it represents one-and-a-half percent of
our national immigration profile at the
moment but in the next five years we
will have 500 fellows 400 will be
international 20% of each cohort of 100
at Kiwi and we’re hopeful that this will
re-energize if you will the kinds of
social progressiveness that this country
has sporadically been famous for so it’s
about the design what am I talking about
in conversations that matter I’m talking
about very intimate conversations I’m
not talking about castes of thousands
I’m talking about a very simple model
which is based on 10 participants very
importantly on three generally on three
generations
so I Ashley where are you there and my
good friend whose name is whistled
George I said to Ashley and George
before this I wanted to talk to them
after it it’s critical as both of these
wonderful young people so eloquently
said today that we have
intergenerational conversations that
actually matter and which are about
using these and are not about imposing
one generation upon another in yes
George we all suck you’re absolutely
right what a wonderful its position from
a young man of your age to be able to
the insight to see that but nonetheless
we have to have these conversations so
the model very simply there you can see
two facilitators highly skilled at doing
what encouraging everyone in the room to
feel empowered to have agency and
therefore be heard
and three provocateurs who strangely
enough whatever the subject matter is
actually know something about it I’m
sorry I do not accept that frankly I
will go to the airport and I know that
you’re the qualified pilot is going to
fly my plane but now I have an opinion
because I read it on Fox News that I
could probably fly the plane better than
you that what it you fifteen in the room
equal standing keep it simple so I’m
talking about very intimate groups at
whatever scale I won’t go into this in
detail it’s been a long day but you can
see it there this is an example this is
our current laureate mr. rock strim
extraordinary fellow the challenge to
you here in Dunedin for instance might
be to bring the whole global issue of
drawdown and climate change right down
to the local level and posit what does
Dunedin look like in a sustainable
decarbonized world what might that look
like that could be the basis of the
conversation therefore what do I need
from the other generations in the room
to make this happen what am i prepared
to contribute what is my actual
commitment what is the action I’m going
to take what is the behavior change
that’s involved in that not let’s have a
nice chat about it and then we’ll go
home feeling better having had a nice
chat if there’s not an action follow-up
in the spirit of doing real stuff we
haven’t got far what am I going to
challenge in my own life wonderful
friend before talking about clothing and
and and the the reality again and food
Finn was talking about this the
incredible waste which which we just
take for granted in in many of the
comfortable parts of the world so what
am I going to challenge in my own life
which means that my comfort is
challenged as part of this how do we
collectively D politicize the process
the greatest is respect to politicians
of all hues it is my experience over 60
years having worked on presidential
campaigns in the u.s. having worked and
a variety of campaigns around the planet
at the very highest of levels and and
also the grassroots that there are very
few genuinely gifted politicians who
leaved most of them follow what does
that mean it means that if we as
community are prepared to push to demand
to stand up then we have a better chance
of our politicians coming with us
Jurnee but they have to get past the
ideological debates the left/right
debates which so often are just there to
pay homage to stuff that doesn’t matter
what individual collective actions
starting now will get us to a
renaissance future I’m an optimist I
believe we are living in an incredibly
exciting moment in time this future that
we have in front of us is unbelievably
exciting we just have to have the
courage to make it happen
second example again with respect to our
young friends here this is the words of
my old friend Jane Goodall I’m sorry my
generation I get very terse when we talk
about sorry George
sorry actually we’re borrowing your
future we’ve stolen it and I
think that in many ways it is our
obligation therefore to stay and play
with you we have to be there with you we
can’t just retire the boomers contras
retire early in many ways we have not
met the bargain that we as in a youth
set out to to achieve so we have to stay
with you we have to work with you again
the same sort of model this by the way
for those of you don’t know is the
rather remarkable trust and well known
using and company working with 19 year
olds has been doing it for 14 15 years
all over New Zealand on these kinds of
issues
pilot outcomes reviewing the process
what works what doesn’t there’s no right
way here what we want to do in these
programs has identify some obvious wrong
ones there are some issues here to do
within this intensity of space how much
trust can you achieve if it’s Chatham
House versus if it’s streamed globally
right I don’t know the answer to that I
suspect the answer to that is probably
we need to have that find a middle
ground some refine distances within one
week we live in an ephemeral age you
have very little time to consolidate an
understanding and make sure people are
still feeling part of it invite comment
finalise distribute publicize and more
importantly ongoing outcomes build
momentum off these groups
so Herman former mayor of Seattle that
challenge she put in 1988 to his
community last year there were 18,000
dinners in Seattle just based on that
model build momentum share your impact
stories coming back what actually about
this wonderful resonant moment that
means that yes you’re a trunk vote a bit
my god we actually have something in
common let’s grab that can we share okay
celebrate the laughter celebrate the
laughter kia kaha stand tall but I’m
talking about not just standing tall in
terms of my personal totem in terms of
my personal value in terms of my
personal conviction but having the
courage also to find the wisdom to stand
tall above the fray to stand tall with
my brothers and sisters who at the
beginning of this conversation I thought
had nothing in common with so there’s
two layers involved with that I’m not
saying for a moment one gives up one’s
personal value is one gives up one’s
personal identity one gives up I am
saying you can’t still transcend that
and you can work with others who are
prepared to go on that journey and then
enable the process at scale scale what
do I mean by scale I mean billions
living on a planet we’re looking at nine
and a half billion by 2050 80 percent of
us will be living in cities this is not
hard to do we have the tools we need to
find the courage Emer a song for us
earlier today I said I would acknowledge
her I’ll do that now in closing it – OH
– Kumar Hanako Maha here total hoot RAAA
Mary a rota now Tom may take aha kita
fucka tikka Nara MA
or tongue qiyamat Oh Kia mama Oh kicking
uh ray-ray Kate on your motto here mama
hokey King ray ray Tatom
in English the serenity prayer
thank you
[Music]
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: