Press "Enter" to skip to content

Conversation Stoppers | John Corvino | TEDxWayneStateU


we are a divided people who knows we’re

divided politically into red states and

blue states we’re divided on social

media and to our own little echo

chambers where we can belong the people

we disagree and most of us recognize

that this is a bad situation it’s bad

because it’s unpleasant but it’s also

bad because it makes it harder for us to

solve the practical problems that face

us problems about climate change or

religious liberty or economic policy

these all require some kind of solution

from us and unless we can come together

at the table to discuss them it’s harder

to solve them I know something about

this the last several decades I have

traveled the country participating in

the culture wars specifically on the

issue of same-sex marriage when I

started doing this in the early nineties

most Americans were opposed to same-sex

marriage in fact in 1996 the first year

that Gallup started polling on the issue

68 percent of Americans said they were

opposed only 27 percent in favor as

opposed to today where we have 61

percent in favor and 37 percent against

so there’s been a real change here and

during my time engaged in those culture

wars I built some interesting

relationships even friendships with

people on the other side of the issue

people like Glenn snaffle to Focus on

the Family

Maggie Gallagher of the National

Organization for Marriage and people

would sometimes ask me John how can you

as a gay rights advocate and a gay man

in yourself be friends with people who

are fighting against your rights and the

answer to that question is very simple

I drink know the answer to my question

is that I recognize that we all have to

share the world together and if we’re

going to do that successfully it’s

better for us to be able to come to the

table and enter in a respectful dialogue

but you know sometimes that’s not easy

to do and one of the reasons it’s not

easy to do

this because what we say we want a

better dialogue we often end up saying

things that function as conversation

stuff there’s their way of stopping the

conversation and making that dialogue

partner and today I want to talk about

five of those some of them are coming on

the right side of the culture wars some

of the more common on the left side of

the cultural wars all of them take our

challenges more difficult to confront

the first one comes from the right side

is the Klamath I’m not interested in

being more politically correct what does

that charge mean when we say that

something is being politically correct

it suggests that there’s a kind of

orthodoxy being imposed on the

conversation stifling free speech saying

there are certain things that you cannot

say what things well usually people

bring this up when they feel like

they’re not allowed to say certain

things that hurting people who are

marginalizing people behaviors and

actions that actually hurt others and

when they’re talking about they’re

saying well you’re just being all

politically correct the irony is that

this charge functions as a kind of

political correctness itself it says

there are certain things you can say you

can’t tell me when my words and my

actions hurt and marginalizing see

that’s not how free speech works free

speech means that I get to say what I

believe and you get to tell me when I’m

being a jerk it’s true now there may be

threats to free speech that you want to

speak up against and that’s great but

when you do that don’t just label them

as politically correct that’s a easy way

out it’s lazy and also functions as a

conversation stuff now

while the right tends to use this charge

of Louisville correctness the left

sometimes uses the charge of imagery to

stop the conversation what does this

mean well the Webster’s tells us the

bigot is a person who is obstinately or

intolerant ly devoted to his or her own

opinions

how many of you have beliefs that you

are stubbornly devoted to raise your

hand

Lisa R stubbornly most all of us do and

if I disagree with them in a certain way

I may call them bigotry in what way well

what I call of yoohoo bigoted I’m not

just saying that it’s wrong

I’m saying that it doesn’t even belong

at the table

it doesn’t even belong as part of polite

conversation it’s beyond the pale well

that claim is a conversation stopper if

anything is now granted sometimes this

is the appropriate stance to take there

are some views that are so bad that the

only appropriate response is shunning

not engaging but we obviously use that

stance sparingly if we dial every

conflict up to the outrage level that’s

not just going to get us all worked up

it’s also going to make it harder for us

to have productive dialogue with the

movable bill it’s a conversation stuff

now back over on the right we sometimes

hear people say well look these are not

my claims they’re God’s claims that is

people hide their fallible prejudices

behind claims about an infallible God

this also functions as a kind of

conversation stuff I used to get this a

lot of marriage debate sometimes I would

be invited to debate local pastors I

have nothing against pastors but it’s

too easy for some of them the frame the

things and frame things in the following

way they say here’s what John Corbino

says about homosexuality and here’s what

God says about us as well how am I going

to win

think about this for just a second John

Corbino has a PhD in philosophy God is

omniscient I can’t write I cannot learn

that and of course I have to explain to

people not what John burrito says versus

what God says it’s two human beings of

the state on the stage each trying to

get to the truth

believing in them fallible God does not

make us available and any honest look at

mysteries all those we should be careful

but you can become too confident that

they speak directly for God that’s why

I’m kind of opting out of responsibility

for the conversation it’s a conversation

stuff now what’s interesting is that on

the Left people do almost the opposite

instead of trying to make their planning

infallible they want to avoid making

plans about children all physically

about the earth and I sometimes hear

people say things like morality is a

private matter you shouldn’t judge other

people you shouldn’t judge other people

what does that mean so a we should go

around wagging my finger equals face as

well of course nobody likes a

know-it-all but does it mean we should

never make judgments about what other

people are doing this is that part of

being a morally responsible adult in the

world will give it other people’s

successes and failures adjusting our own

lives and response to that isn’t it part

of our responsibility to figure out what

kinds of things we want to encourage

what kinds of things will be nearly tore

it and what kinds of things we must

absolutely forbid and I sometimes hear

well-meaning fellow liberals and I think

as well it comes from a place of

humility twist themselves into pretzels

trying to be non-judgmental I once had a

student do this he kept talking about

what’s true for you and true for me and

that’s right for you what’s right for

being so you can’t really get any more

plans because it was right for me may

not be right for you and you look at a

paper on this and I gave it

and he was kind of upset about this he

came into my office he’s like I look

really hard on this paper why did you

give it a neck

I said well migrated this paper the way

I read all my fingers sat at the top of

the staircase and I throw the papers

down the stairs first few stairs get

AIDS and these internal heavy papers

down to the bottom of the stairs it gets

that and he said but but that’s not

right and I said that’s not right for

okay I didn’t really do that but if I

had tenure I would ever I have tenure

now so watch out then what does this

story teach us it teaches us probably

about just a private matter it’s about

how we treat one another so things like

fairness things like justice and we make

small claims were making claims about

how things ought to be out there in the

world and if you say oh you can’t make

those plans you shouldn’t judge people

it’s a private matter it stops the

conversation now many of the

conversation stopper as I looked at and

then on one side or the other but

there’s one conversation stopper that I

think of as an all-purpose conversation

stuff but people all over the political

spectrum use it they say that’s just

your opinion now my first inclination

when I hear this as a philosophy

professor is to want to give a very

technical philosophical response to this

land that’s just your opinion which is

my opinion I’m the one talking does it

think it would have be that doesn’t say

anything about whether it’s a reasonable

opinion or an unreasonable one whether

it’s one that you want to adopt or one

that you want to reject not opinions are

created equal some of our thoughtful

backed up by the different evidence some

are unreasonable biased even silly and I

think part of the problem that we face

here is that there are a number of

different distinctions in the

neighborhood and people tend to jumble

them together and then they get all

confused and let’s just Europe in one of

those distinctions it’s a very important

distinction it’s the fact value

distinction and what we’re talking about

moral issues of course that distinction

come up factual and

plans without the way the world is value

claims claims about the way the world

all to me the therapists people are

doing this fact value distinction it’s

somehow it gets more into a opinion

distinction which is a lot more money I

think and then that can somehow demoted

into a fact mirror in distinction it’s a

mirror opinion it’s like a matter of

taste and yet often the things we’re

talking about the things that divide us

are not your matters of taste there are

urgent matters of how we are going to

live together in the world here’s a

useful analogy think about it this way

some only you’d like to keep your

thermostat at seventy five degrees and I

like to keep my thermostat at sixty-five

degrees

okay that’s something we can agree to

disagree about you’ve got your house

I’ve got my house now suppose we live in

the same house the moral issues that

divide us these controversial things

we’re talking about often involve our

house the world we share together and

when we try to respond the claims within

that sphere by saying well that’s just

your opinion it makes it much harder for

us to figure out how to do that together

it’s a conversation so now I want to

conclude with one final point that is

important something I learned in my

peers spending time in the culture wars

because I often be involved in

situations with people to say yeah I

believe in dialogue I think it’s

important for us all to come together in

fact they pat themselves on the back

because they’re so proud of themselves

how open-minded they were for sitting

down with people on the other side and

then when it came time for it actually

engage into the conversation they would

just repeat their talking points

that’s not dialogue that’s not

conversation where dialogue is

challenging will dialogue involves

listening to other people not just

listening so you can figure out where

the flaws are so you can pounce on them

but listening soon can understand

and we’re not well most of all requires

us to exercise our moral imagination to

put ourselves in other people’s shoes

it’s important for us to do that it’s

important for us to do that because it

helps us confront the practical problems

that face us as we try to change the

world and it’s also important because

when it comes to our fellow human beings

and the world we share it’s the right

thing to do please keep the conversation

going

I’m John Correa

[Applause]

you [Music]

Please follow and like us: